OMG. This place. Swung by before the beach to get good sammies and this place went above and beyond- a deli with an attached butchery and Italian grocer. Went for a 'small' sandwich and got the attached honking feast. Freshly made rolls and subs, all the best meats and cheeses lovingly made. The packed cases of alll the in-house meats, salads, dishes and favs. I'm hoping they ship! Easily accessible parking, super organized, clean, attentive staff and the big sniff when you walk in is Heaven. read more

Fratelli's Pork Store - Roast beef and sharp provolone! - Meat Shops Near Me - Centereach, New York

Overly satisfied for 12 years. Everything sold here is top shelf. I'm anxious to have a bbq that's catered by them . read more

Terrific Italian butcher and market. Our family in the area gets all of our meats and pork products from this shop for special events and family get togethers. They also sell pastas and assorted sandwiches along with party platters. Terrific quality foods and great service. read more

See all

I came to Fratelli's hungry and have been craving a chicken parm sandwich for the last few days. It was my first time here and I was expecting, at the very least, a solid chicken parm meal from a legitimate Italian market. Whenever I walk into my local pork store I'm always greeted with a solid, sincere hello! acknowledgment, anything. Aligning with prior issues that have been reviewed on here, I was met with the young guy, leaning over the display counter, thumbing away On his phone.. eyes met , then nothing, not even an head nod. At least when I walk into an unknown deli on parts unknown Long Island I'll get the, "what's up boss, what can I make ya?" No big deal though, I knew what I wanted. I ask The kid to make me a chicken parm sandwich. With the personality of a wet paper bag he acknowledges it by writing it down on the dupe and heads in the back. The "adult" of the store walks out onto the floor, tasked, but managed To gave me a solid hello..... fantastic , all is well now, my feelings have been lifted. Fast forward, I get my sandwich, go sit in my car to dig in and I hate to give bad press to a mom and pop shop, but it was bad. Ice cold, cutlets overtly thick for that type of sandwich, and just basic flour breading, zero flavor.... Hats off to The bread guy though because the bread was great. Overall a very disappointing sandwich, couldn't even finish it , certainly not what I was expecting ... I hope this review reaches the people in charge and the above issues are dealt with appropriately and specific people are squared away. it's a tough business to make every customer happy but attention to the little details make a big difference. read more

I've been going here for years! Best local pork store in town. Everything's fresh and made on premises ,Eddie is the best!!!

Brings me back to my childhood, everything is top notch from a to z. Everything a pork store should be. I would pay to walk in and smell the air. read more

Like the selection and authentic Italian atmosphere you their meats are of good quality and the service is very good and helpful very happy cutomer read more

Very disappointed with the fresh mozzarella. I was told it is made fresh daily but the mozzarella was extremely dry just like the packaged mozzarella you purchase from the food store. Please stop telling your customers it is made fresh daily when obviously that is not happening. This is not the first time this has happened to me!!! read more

Good selection of great sausage. Just ate a parsley and cheese coil. Full flavored, porky, juicy, unguent. Nice selection of fresh antipasti, pastas( fresh and dried) and all Italian ingredients. Not the selection that Uncle Guiseppi has but the sausage is better. Give them a try! read more

I have gone to this store since it was Aiello's Pork Store for the best soppressada around. The last few times I have been there the young guys behind the counter are nothing like the other owners who would greet you and be friendly and eager to help. Today there were 2 kids behind the counter one helping a customer and one standing there. He passed in front of me 3 times and never made eye contact. He was leaning on a counter behind the olives looking down (maybe on his phone). 3 times I said, "excuse me" and he still didn't look up. FINALLY I said loud enough "For Gods sake am I invisible can't someone even help me!!" That is when he came over. They need to hire better help there it stinks! read more

Premade fell short of my excitement and expectations. Stopped in to grab some pre-made food for dinner..... Penne Ala vodka pre-made was dry, not good flavor and sell by was yesterday, (which i missed). Eggplant parm no good, kids refused everything. Usually like this store for the cuts of meats, however won't be buying the pre-made entees anymore. Not to mention, I stood on line for 25 min with only 2 patrons ahead of me, with most people working in the back. Hope this was just a hiccup! read more

This is has the ambiance of an an old style pork store. They offered all the Italian specialties you could ask for! The service exceeded my expectations. I highly recommend Fratelli's Pork Store. read more

Great service and prices and prepared food . I meal prep all week but go here to keep my sanity often on a Friday when I need a break . It doesn't break the bank and it is just amazing !!! read more

Fratelli's Pork Store - a hand holding a sandwich - Meat Shops Near Me - Centereach, New York

I was looking for a real good Italian hero and boy did I strike gold!!! Delicious hero with 5 meats including prosciutto which many places tend to omit!!! Seasoned perfectly with the works as they call it which is lettuce, tomato red onion in their dressing!! I definitely will be back!! I also picked up some fresh made fennel sausage which l haven't tried yet! read more

Fratelli's Pork Store - Italian Hero with the works! - Meat Shops Near Me - Centereach, New York

Absolutely love this store from the moment you walk in until you leave the food smell is delicious I want to eat everything the displays are neat and Sensational read more

Absolutely beautiful store. Top quality meet and cheese with a very helpful staff. Do yourself a favor and check this place out. Real deal.

We come to Fratelli's all the way from Wading River. It's that good. Everything is fresh and of the best quality. The staff is great. We love everything from their homemade Italian sausage to all their antipasti. They also have fantastic meats. We've been a customer for over 15 years and highly recommend them. read more

Awesome place! Reminds me of pork stores in Brooklyn. Meat,pasta,salads,this place has everything! Friendly staff! You won't be disappointed. read more

What happened to the sausages, driest things ever!! Come on, you always had the best !!!

Fratelli.. I'm feeling kinda generous so the 3.5 is rounded up to a 4. It's a pretty solid pork store here on this strip of Jericho/25/Middle Country. FYI it's Jericho to me. Anyway... service is always good and on the more friendly side. They have your typical Italian fare and then some. They also have a little market to get some of your favorite Italian staples. I did notice they had a bit of a larger olive assortment which next time when I can control myself I will be trying the lemon olives. Some prices are a little steep compared to the Ronkonkoma Pork Store but I blame the Fratelli name added to it. No harm no foul though because when it comes to good eats I'm willing to give it out. My biggest complaint was the Stuffed Artichoke we got. It was bland and the leaves were rather tough. I think as much as I like a good Stuffed Artichoke I think I will stop trying to find the perfect one. Though I had a delicious one in Oyster Bay after Oyster Fest with Roy and Lana at Oyster Bay Fish & Clam. That bad boy was stuffed with bread crumbs and lobster meat. Ooooh baby that was GOOD. Will I be back? Yeah of course just not as often as I visit the Ronkonkoma Pork Store. read more

I have been a customer for a few years now...I love this place! They have the best sirloin burgers...tastes like a steak and never any grizzle or bone chips! I also love their grilled artichoke hearts. I also always purchase a fresh turkey(24 lbs.) every year...the best fresh turkeys. Very friendly service. read more

Fratelli's Pork Store - Perfect sirloin burgers! - Meat Shops Near Me - Centereach, New York

I've been coming to this place for 7 years ordering sandwiches and buying prepared salads etc. the food has always been good, and the staff is always nice, that's why they have two stars. Today I went to pick up a sandwich that cost about $14 a month ago and about $10 5 years back. Today the sandwich was $20.83. I know inflation is real but even at 10% that would've made the sandwich $16. I paid and mentioned this price change and the staff said their prices went up. I get it, I do but I'll never buy another thing from them. A 25% increase in price is ridiculous even by todays inflation standards. Again I bought it because I don't want to be the jerk that wastes food, but that's truly the last dollar I'll spend here. If you want good food and friendly service AND you want to be ridiculously overcharged then by all means shop there. It's a shame because it's really the only real nyc style Italian deli nearby. read more

I recently popped into Fratelli's pork store in Centereach to pick up a few steaks to bbq for a family gathering. Once I was inside I couldn't resist stocking my freezer for the month. There were just so many amazing choices, from chicken kabobs, and specialty burgers to their mouth watering marinated skirt steaks. The sides... I could go on for days. I ended up getting all the fixings to make an amazing charcuteriebourd, that my mother in law raved about(takes a lot for that one). At checkout I had to add the fresh mozzarella and a huge loaf of Italian bread. From the second, I walked into the busy shop I was blown away by the friendly team, the customer service was just amazing and they made me feel like I was at home. One of the owners introduced himself and told me if I ever need anything to just give them a ring, I have kids, so sometimes it's hard to make it in the shop. He suggested calling ahead, so the order would be ready for me and one of the guys would bring it out to the car for me! How's that for service? I'm giving five stars because I can't give more.!!!! read more

I ran in tonight for a few things, which I was surprised it was open and not limited to how many people in the store. It was good to see the staff had masks on but the cold cuts were not covered , just sitting out and the customers in there did not have a mask,so those cold cuts were exposed. I purchased a few things , one being a fresh mozzarella. It was disgusting. And i was very disappointed because its always good there. Well when I got home and took the items out of the bag I found the glove that the guy must have had on. I was so grossed out. Guess i won't be going back there any time soon read more

First time here. Great service by the boys behind the counter. Great steaks! Great pre-made deli products. Will return!

Great store! Well stocked, fantastic selection of meats and salads. Friendly staff. Definitely worth a visit.

Uhm - this is without any question the best quality pork store in Suffolk county. I absolutely never feel bad about spending my money here. My recommendations for life are the broccoli Rabe - deli meats- rustic breads - and other proteins - are amazing !! Enjoy and thank me later. read more

I wish I could leave zero stars. We used Fratelli's to cater our BBQ. I am Celiac and they totally disregarded this fact and cook only food I am unable to eat. I basically overpaid paid for professionals to not be professional. When we pointed out to them at the party that a mistake was made, they made no allowance and were not apologetic at all. So if you are stuck with any type of food allergy like I am and you gamble in using these guys good luck. My family will never use them again. If I saw them at a party I attended, I would leave. read more

Best food but went there for second time in 2 weeks and again 3 people in line and 6 behind counter plus 3 in back room and I waited 25 minutes for someone to help me. The lack of sense of urgency was almost disturbing. Great food but a shame service appears to be struggling read more

We used Fratelli's for the bbq service for my daughters graduation. I can't even say enough good about their service! The food was excellent, fresh and delicious! Everyone was raving about how good the food was! The grilled were excellent!! If you are looking for someone to cater an event...look no further! read more

This is a great place to get meats, cheeses, and salads. I came here to make a charcuterie platter for a party. I got 1/2 pound of three different cheeses, in addition to sopressata, pepperoni, and salame. They are not cheap, but they are not expensive either. It was approximately the same price for the meats and the cheeses as I would have gotten at a grocery store (maybe a little cheaper for some items, and a little more expensive for others), but at Fratelli's it's all fresh. This makes all the difference. I will be going back for my cured meats and cheese needs in the future. read more

Fratelli's Pork Store - Charcuterie platter I made from meats and cheeses I bought at fratellis - Meat Shops Near Me - Centereach, New York

Very strange. Everything looks great, but weird spices used in Stromboli. Almost as if a middle-easterner tried to make Italian specialties. House made mozzarella very bland. Stuffed artichokes over-stuffed with tasteless bread crumbs and very dry. On a good note, the grilled vegetables were expertly done and very tasty. The rustic foccaccia was also very good. Opt instead to go to A&S pork store. Much more authentic. read more

All of the sandwiches here are amazing... particularly the chicken with mozz and tomato. The seasonings are just right on everything that I order. Yum! Though the first experience I had at Fratelli's was because I was passing it on the way to a friend's house.. I now find myself making the special trip just to indulge in my favorite lunches. 5 stars! read more

I have never had a bad visit to this store. The choices you have are endless with sausages or meats, including chicken. Always fresh. Friendly staff, clean store and decent prices. Try it for yourself. read more

This is a little late coming but it has to be done. We used the catering for my daughter's graduation party. They were wonderful. Food was fresh and delicious. They threw some extras in because we ordered a lot. You are not going to Stop and Shop. You are getting quality food and the service has always been amazing. We received many compliments from the guests and I am so glad we used them. Sylvia C. read more

quality meats. amazing cheese sausage. my family in Pennsylvania always wants their sausage when we visit or when they visit me they go there. all their products are wonderful. Just make sure they give you the fresh meat in the front of the glass showcase. sometimes the lines tend to be long but that is what happens when you sell good stuff read more

Spent $24.99 per person + 15% gratuity for their catered BBQ. 50 people = large bill. All sorts of meats and veggies grilled over charcoal for a 3 hour duration as well as salads, cookies and watermelon. Food was great, but was disappointed in the method of serving the food. First off, they said there would be a 6 foot grill. It was 3 foot. The problem with that was they cooked all the inexpensive foods, hot dogs, hamburgers and sausages and chicken wings first. Then they announced the food was ready, There were no steaks, ribs, chicken kabobs, steak kabobs, etc. prepared. The 3 foot grill couldn't handle the quantity of food. During the setup, here I am bragging about the skirt steaks, filet mignon, beef/pork/chicken kabobs...and by the time they were ready, everyone was fairly full on the basics. Like I said, everything was good, and we were given all the leftovers, cooked and uncooked. Their setup and presentation was excellent, 2 tents, serving tables, hot chafing dishes, etc. Their method of serving was hampered by a too small a grill. Then the coals started getting cooler, and the food cooked slower, etc. They never refreshed the coals and over time, that "sizzle" and "char broil" vanished to just "cooked". Just a heads up to the owners. Something that could have made the catering excellent.....larger grill to get ALL selections of the food on the line at the same time, and adding charcoal to keep the heat up. read more

I agree with Yelp F. They forget the customer pays the bills

I had fratellies pork store BBQ at my daughters engagement party this August of 2016 and people are still talking about the food!! All the food was delicious and more than plentiful!! And the guys That did the grilling were very helpful in setting up and very polite to my guest. I would recommend Fratellies for any occasion your having or just want to get dinner for the night!! read more

Love this place, great butcher shop, great cold cuts , great authentic Italian specialties. Not the most friendly but the product is great.