Their bagels are always fresh. Their eggs are always made perfectly to order. Sometimes they suffer the "teenager effect" with some of their younger less attentive staff members. (For example, Mayo instead of mustard) Outside of that, the line outside the door is worth the wait. They move the line pretty good too. They have one middle aged employee who can be a bit rude. She is always friendly to the regulars she recognizes and dismissive to others, including regulars I suppose she doesn't recognize. Sometimes if it busy and I see her working, I go to another place to avoid her. read more

first time, had a nice fresh poppy seeded roll, I think it was home made, regardless, it was fresh and delicious. the staff was friendly any the place was extremely clean. have not tried The bagels yet, so I can't give it 5 stars read more

Best spot to stop and get good quality food! Our favorite bagels are here! We buy dozens of bagels for our family for Thanksgiving and everybody has nothing but smiles on their face! From the minute, you walk into the deli till you leave, everybody is nice, caring and professional! The ambience is fun and chill! read more

Everything, quality, price, service and people, it's busy all the time. It's a morning must.

Came here for a BEC. Very lovely customer service and busy location. They have a wide array of bagels and muffins. I love my eggs over medium and many places fail to do it perfectly...except this deli! I wish they were heavier on the bacon like other delis on LI. Next time I'll order 3 eggs to make it a fuller sandwish read more

Pete's Bagels - BEC SPK EGGS OVER MED - Bagels Near Me - Eastport, New York

Easily the best bagel i've ever had ever! Super kind staff who know how to run a fantastic business! Will be back

Rude staff. Woman walks away from you when you order. Then gets aggravated when the sandwich isn't correct. Seems like you're bothering her. With the prices the way they are small businesses should be at the top of their game and at the very least offer good customer service. This has happened a few times with this same woman. I will take my business elsewhere. read more

I got Pete's beagles delivered today it was my first time trying Pete's bagels and I loved it my whole family got bagels and there wasn't to much cream cheese on my dads the bagels taste so good and fresh definitely eat here five stars. read more

Staff negativity. Bagels ok yet may not go again.. in this politically divided climate; the last thing we want from a business is to know ones political viewpoint. Cranky lady behind counter (typically cranky) complained about having to wear masks and Cuomo today. ( I get it's uncomfortable but science indicates it stops the spread). Does the owner feel the same way? ( I don't think he was around today around). KEEP POLITICS OUTTA BUSINESS PLEASE! Hubby pissed said we're not going ever again! read more

If you want the worlds best egg sandwich this is the spot. Bacon egg and cheese with salt pepper ketchup and a hash brown will rock your socks off. read more

Pete's Bagels - The remanence of a scrumptious egg Sammy - Bagels Near Me - Eastport, New York

Bagels are OK nothing special very crowded on a Saturday as it should be but at 8 am you don't just have 2 high school kids working the counter,need more staff on weekends. Bagels are all half plain because they only put sesame seeds poppy seeds onion etc on 1 side of the bagel bottom has nothing. Not a true NY Bagel. I have had better bagels in Florida read more

This is my go to breakfast place. I'm an Eastport resident now for over two years. I love trying new places but Petes definitely does a great breakfast. From the fresh homemade rolls to the crispy bacon, you won't be disappointed! read more

The bagels here are always good and the staff is so friendly. I was new to the neighborhood and stopped in a couple times on the way to work. It was so nice to be greeted by name after only a couple of times going there. Also, the prices are so much better than any other bagel store around that charges so much more! read more

I do not recommend. The staff is not friendly and the place looks dirty. They cut my bagel with a knife that had ketchup on it when I did not have ketchup on my sandwich. Another sandwich of mine was sooo small and and the lettuce was not good. They grabbed a bagel with their hand they handle cash with. Just a gross business overall. read more

Pete's has very good bagels. I like that I can call in my order and pick it up on my way to the train. One time my toasted bagel was over cooked. They made it again but acted like the burned bagel was normal- told me one toaster cooks darker than the other. Now I ask for " lightly toasted", and have had no issues. Service is always good. read more

First time there was waiting to be helped after customer was done. The employee ignores me standing there proceeds to talk to co worker then finally asks what I need. She then threw it in a bag and didn't even push the bag towards me or say thank you nothing. read more

I like how there's flagels here...they need to sell more of those in the city! I got the breakfast sandwich on a flagel and my boo got some meat on his. It was yummy and this place was pretty hoppin'. Oh, and the potato salad was pretty decent. read more

My first complaint is the customer service, most specifically an older woman, heavier set, with shoulder length brown hair who's been there ever since I can remember. This woman has such a miserable attitude, is extremely nasty to customers like she can't be bothered. If she doesn't like her job (which she's had for at least the past 20 years) she should find another. Secondly, the food. The bagels aren't bad but the cream cheese/butter is always carelessly spread. Just a big glop either in the center or on one side of the bagel. The egg sandwiches - don't even bother. One time my husband discovered half way through eating that his eggs had a grey color to them & later got sick. Aside from that your cheese will never be melted. Over all my advice to anyone looking on Yelp to try to find a bagel spot in the area is to take an extra 5 minutes out of their day, to either head east to Speonk or west to Manorville. read more

Way overcrowded for a mediocre at best bagel place. Bagel itself was good , but Bacon Egg and cheese sandwich was a pitiful mess. Didn't melt the cheese etc etc. Also had a bagel with cream cheese that barely had any cream cheese. Have given them a few chances now but too many other choices in the area to keep paying for this. read more

Pete's Bagels - Sad Bacon Egg and Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Eastport, New York

I love Pete's bagels. Food is good, staff is nice and service oriented, and prices are the fairest they can be. Pete's Bagels is a staple of our neighborhood. read more

The freshest, biggest bagels around these parts. The coffee doesn't bite you back & if you want to get a snapshot of what's on the Eastport/East Moriches community's mind, this is the place to go. If breakfast is the most important meal of the day, you MUST go to Pete's. read more

Pete's Bagels - a man and a woman behind the counter - Bagels Near Me - Eastport, New York

Local Bagel spot, food is always fresh and fast, call in to avoid the breakfast rush line. Owner is always present, the staff knows their customers and address them by name. What more can you ask for, friendly personalized service and an owner who cares. A+ read more

Kids working the counter too busy talking to take order. Food and atmosphere needs improvement. Go up the road a mile or so to Bagels and Brunch near Phillips Ave instead. read more

I can't say much about the food as I only ever get egg sandwiches here but they are always good. It's the service that I have a real problem with. I want to make it clear that not every employee is like this but a few are, in particular the older woman who's about in her 40s with brown hair and light brown highlights is extremely rude. Now I understand people have off days but she is consistently nasty whether it's answering the phone or taking my order in the store. I can tolerate a certain level of negativity but she makes me want to avoid Pete's all together. For that reason, I'm out. *Mark Cuban voice* read more

Bagels very good,. Had an egg wrap that was very good also. Terrible attitude however on the employees. No one smiles or is pleasant. I find this to be true of most bagel stores. Not sure why. Not getting paid enough? Over worked? Stressed? Bad managers? Who knows but this place makes me not want to come back just because of the u friendliness. Too bad because the food is good. read more

Sat and waited 5 minutes before getting helped with no one else in the store besides me getting ignored. Keep in mind I already called in my order so I can get in and out quickly. Got an egg sandwich which was below par, almost tasted like it was microwaved. Home fries was fine but it's hard to mess up home fries. All the staff seemed like they were brand new and didn't have a clue to seem like what was going on. read more

best bagles i've ever had. I come here all the time it's my favorite restaurant. the workers are so kind and welcoming. the food is even better! definitely recommended to anyone looking for a good breakfast/ lunch place!! read more

the absolute sweetest counter staff served me up the bangin-est breakfast sandwich... after hungover hot yoga on an empty stomach this sandwich saved my life. thank you!!!!!! read more

Just got home with my egg sandwiches! Ketchup all over both of them. Breakfast ruined like every single time i give this place a chance. When will they learn how to make a simple egg sandwhich correctly? Probably never. read more

I have lived in eastport my entire life a whole 20 years and for as long as i can remember pete's bagels was the spot to go in town because they had the best bagels and although they may have the best bagels in town good luck getting the right one when you order it. I have been going to pete's bagels my whole life and getting bagels and egg sandwiches but literally have never ever gotten the exact thing i ordered, everytime i order an egg sandwich from pete's bagels it is no where close to what i ordered and at first i figured it was a mistake but then it happened again and again and now everytime i order and egg sandwich from there it's just to see if they've changed at all and after today i've realized there is no hope for me and my sausage egg and cheese read more

They have the best bagels around! Plus I love fagel's and they have a variety. Coffee is amazing too! Love stopping here in the morning

I have been coming to the place for 7 years now!! I have always been totally satisfied with everything. The food is always fresh, and omg the egg sandwiches are amazing. I was in this past weekend, there are a lot of city people out. I have to give the manager Berna a shout out for keeping her cool with a rude customer. I would have told the lady to flip off! Like people give them a break, your fast to say they are nasty or rude but look what you give to them! People are so dramatic nowadays! PETE"S BAGELS YOU ROCK!!! PETE AND BERNA, keep doing what you do! read more

I will stand on line for as long as it takes ! Great bagels ! I brought some bagels into Manhattan where I work. My co-workers raved for days about how good the "Long Island" bagels were. Great job by the staff putting up with cranky customers ! I will remain a loyal customer ! read more

Staff were visibly annoyed that we ordered heroes and that we used our debit card. Telling other customers "sorry, I'll get to you when I'm done doing this complicated order" while working on our TWO heroes. Don't advertise lunch sandwiches then if they're "too complicated" to do. Sighing when we went to use our debit card. Won't be returning for a while!!! read more

I been coming here for lunch for the last 3 years now. Except for Pete the owner, his wife, a teenage girl (I believe is their daughter) and Ashley. All their counter staff are either stuck up, lazy, or just don't give a damn. The only reason I have been going back is because the food was good and it is close. Nevertheless, since the renovations recently done, the food has gone south and the service has gotten even worst. Today I came in at noon and the chairs were up on the tables. Furthermore, I had to tell the guy step by step how to compete my order. OMG so lazy! If he walked any slower and leaned back any further he would have been lying on the floor. I guess I am done Pete. Sorry! read more

A+++ for Petes Bagels! Their bagels are reliably fresh, soft, and just overall outrageously good. I typically order an egg white wrap with turkey and cheddar cheese and it's by far the best wrap of any place I've ever had that same order. The line can be long at times but if you have an easy order you're usually in and out in 10-15 minutes. They also let you call ahead which is very convenient if you're in a hurry. If you're in the area, GO, or if you're not in the area COME! read more

Don't even want to wait to try the food to post a review. Placed an order over the phone, went to pick it up, the line inside was around the store, walked up to the front and two of us asked two different people of there was a separate line for pick up, and were told we had to wait in line, until a different line formed of people walking up to the front and getting their order immediately. Thank you for wasting half of my morning read more

My favorite deli! I use to live right around the corner, but now I don't :((( They're bagels are great. Good consistency and they put a lot of seeds on them which I love. Their egg sandwiches are pretty inexpensive and comes with a small coffee during the week. I like their coffee as well- hot and iced. I was in there so often, that they know my name now. They know my friends and family. It feels good when you get to know the workers there. Pete is friendly and always says hello. Some of the workers should smile a little more, but what are ya gunna do? They hire a lot of younger kids too...I think they just need help. They keep posting about Help Wanted. They have a $5 card limit, but after awhile they don't even bother anymore. Not sure if it's because it's me and I'm always in there, or they just gave up. They don't really enforce it anymore. I recommend!! read more

Second time here, worst than the first. Don't know what the appeal is here. The bagels are gross the service is bad it's dark and dingy, stacks of water bitters and Gatorade are a potential fire hazard. What's making me post this today is just how dirty it is. The garbage is disgusting, tables not cleaned, condiments old and rancid and The best part when I was grabbing a drink from the refrigerator it was dirty and gross with dead flies. Not one person took a cloth to the tables between patrons. Needless to say we left and will never return. read more

Changed hands and hasn't been quite the same since. Can't say for sure now, but the food used to be excellent.