Trust the reviews on this one. On Long Island we have some of the best bagels. Unfortunately they are not at this place. Bagels are subpar. Cream cheese is a little off and I ordered a toasted bagel with butter and as you can see by the picture it is barely toasted. The staff was very friendly and nice, but the processes of how they operate are not efficient. Not yo mention it took almost 15 minutes for a toasted bagel with butter and a bagel with cream cheese. To note, there was no one waiting ahead of me. Just 2 people who had ordered prior to me walking in. They offer many other sandwiches , smoothies and other things that might be good but this is not a good representation of bagels on the island. Maybe travel a little further down the road for a bagel. read more

Hampton Bays Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Hampton Bays Bagels might be the best bagel I've ever had! It's in a strip mall and doesn't look like much but don't be fooled! It's super tasty. They have mini bagels and normal sized ones. I couldn't resist and got a normal size everything bagel. The outside is crispy and inside is fluffy - just the way a bagel should be. There's just enough everything seasoning on both sides. My husband had an egg everything and he said it was delicious. Their plain cream cheese is thick and creamy. I didn't love the veggie cream cheese - lacked flavor. But the bagel made up for it! We will be back for sure next time we're in town. read more

This venue is a hidden gem..indoor seating, so many choices, all requests made to order. After a week of different bagel venues..this is the best! read more

One of our fave brekkie to go spots when we're out at our place for the Hamptons season! Orders are always on time and they take every special request added to an item seriously. The shopping center it is in is a bit desolate feeling but infusing this place, it has 2 great places to take out from during this pandemic and a decent Whole Food's knock off, albeit a bit over priced, but that's for another review. Their signature sandwiches, be it on a roll or their bagel, are huge, delicious and priced accordingly. Their waffles are huge and delicious and everything is packaged nicely to stay piping hot. Bagels themselves are both chewy and soft too. We'll definitely be back time and time again! read more

See all

Checked in and checked out fast. What is this Florida? Can't believe this place is in New York. Darkest, flattest omelette was on a diners plate seemingly being enjoyed. It looked like I'd not go for it. Kept walking. At the back is the counter and bagels are not heaped in the rows behind but instead a few below the counter. The palest bagels ever seen. They needed cooking. Despite this not possible to get a bagel experience.. the place had more sit down diners at there few tables than most places stopped in. Go figure! They all looked happy! So. Judge for yourself. read more

Hampton Bays Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Used to be good food but now that has changed and even the cashiers actitud is rude. Place is clean but i wont be bringing my family here again. The sausage in my wrap was not cooked thoroughly/not completely thawed out. I told the guy and he laughed, no apology, no acknowledge he just said i cut it ok. I threw the whole thing in the garbage. read more

This is my favorite bagel spot on the east end, mainly because of the sandwich in the picture, the Healthy Stacker! One egg, turkey bacon, cheddar, spinach & tomato on a whole grain bagel. Not too heavy & a nice combination of ingredients. Generally speaking it is like any other bagel deli around they just do a really nice job. FYI they also have Covid precautions in place, counter shield, mask, sanitizer available & a clean restroom. read more

Hampton Bays Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Nice bagels prepared by hard working guys and gals who get you on the road asap. Customize your breakfast selection any which way u want.

Great bagels - super fresh and yummy! It's basically a deli in a strip mall, but it had a huge menu and they seem to be able to do anything from wraps, sandwiches and burgers to smoothies and salads. The place was spick and span and had a seating area up front with cafe style tables and chairs. It's self service but they will bring your food to you at the table if you let them know you're waiting out front. Huge variety of pre-packaged snacks and drinks too. Recommend for a takeaway on-the-go breakfast for sure! read more

See all

Guy taking the orders must be deaf. Specifically asked for no ketchup and my sandwich is doused in it. And the bagels are beat. I've had better from 711. read more

Good good, just be ready for a line depending on the time. The bagels are nice and fresh.

The food and coffee were absolutely delicious (I'm still dreaming about that coconut cold brew), but the service was strange. We were in town for an event, and the moment we walked in the door, they were asking us what we wanted, before we had even had a chance to look at the menu. When we got our breakfast, we asked for silverware, and the employee said, "silverware?" and just stared at us, like it was a strange thing to request (luckily the employee behind him hooked us up). There weren't many seating options available when we went (there's a big room to the side of the main area, but it wasn't open), so we ended up sitting outside. But like I said, the food was so good, it'd be worth trying it again next time we're in the area. read more

Cold un-melted cheese on an egg sandwich? No thanks! Mediocre bagels not made in-house. I won't be back.

These bagels have to be the worst bagels I've had on Long Island. Went on a Sunday morning where you'd expect fresh bagels. These bagels were not fresh, skinny and bread like. read more

First time here at Hampton Bagels. As soon as I walked into the store, I was greeted by their friendly staff with a warm hello....nice. They have Side array of breakfasts that they offer along with a nice assortment of bagels. They are located in the planet fitness strip mall on Montauk highway. read more

See all

Most excellent breakfast sandwiches and fresh squeezed orange juice. They also have wonderful smoothies.

Big menu, very busy, lots of options. A few dine in tables available. We ordered, ate, then paid...unusual for a deli. Two of us had eggs and potatoes and two of us had pancakes and eggs. Ordered a dozen bagels for later. read more

Great smoothies. The Green Tea Smoothie is my favorite. Great coffee. Great Healthy options. The oatmeal is amazing. Always clean and love their wide range of healthy choices on their menu. read more

Great food, excellent quality, friendly staff. We frequent this establishment year round!

Very conveniently located on Montauk Highway, this bagel store has very good bagels and they're served fresh. I had a lox & cream cheese here and the serving size was generous for the price. The coffee is also very good, so I recommend this place if you're in the mood for a decent bagel while in the Hamptons. read more

I've gone here a few times to get my usual order of bacon and eggs on a plate. I've been mostly happy with the food, but sometimes the meal looks and tastes like it was prepared in a rush. The last time I went, I had to put a bit of effort into sawing through the scrambled eggs with the plastic utensils. The bacon has been hit or miss so far. When the bacon is done right, it's crispy (but not burnt) and delicious. On one occasion, however, it tasted as if it was pulled off of a shelf and tossed in the microwave. The interior is pretty nice; there's plenty of space between each table, and everything is always clean and orderly. There's not much space around where you place your order, but at least you can wait at one of the tables until your food is ready. The price for my food has been consistent across all three visits, which is extremely rare as far as my custom order goes. The staff has been very nice and helpful so far as well. I'm sure I'll be back sometime soon after another mediocre workout at the Planet Fitness next door. I want to give this place a higher rating, so I definitely want to try the bacon and eggs a few more times. read more

Hampton Bays Bagels - The bacon didn't come pre-chewed. I took a bite out of the middle piece before I took this shot. - Bagels Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

This place is an embarrassment to delis. They just take advantage of rich people on their way to the beach. I'm not one of the rich people but I have been taken advantage of. After waiting 20 minutes for my sandwich it was wrong of course. I wanted an Italian hero and he asked if I wanted it on a bagel or roll and I said roll. So of course he brings a round roll instead of a long roll. So now I'm pissed bc I have to share this sandwich with my fiancé and I know I'll still be starving after. And also it was 9 dollars for what as exactly: two slices of cappy, three slices of salami and two slices of provolone. Of but there was plenty of lettuce and onion and three slices of tomato to fatten up a stale round roll with store bought vinaigrette salad dressing. Avoid this place at all costs until he figures out how to make a decent sandwich read more

Hampton Bays Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Ordered the garden omelet and it was cooked well. Bagel was supposed to come with lite CC but they gave me butter instead. The bagel itself was okay. Not dry but just lacked some flavor. Perhaps light on the everything seasoning. Wife ordered a honey wheat bagel w bacon egg and cheese and she said it was amazing. Would go again if in the area. read more

This place has the best bagels in hamptons during season it has best tuna and white fish salads whoever makes the salads goes home after Labor Day lol. Big difference read more

We are still on the search for a great bagel place for breakfast sandwiches and a mean iced coffee. We were recommended this spot by someone and to be honest, we were disappointed. When we walked in, there wasn't really a system for ordering, paying, and picking up orders. It was disorganized and customers coming in didn't know if other customers were in line, ordering, etc. The staff weren't very friendly and seemed confused as well. We ordered 2 bagel sandwiches, 1 iced tea, and 1 iced coffee. Our bagels tasted like they could have been from Stop and Shop and the contents were extremely greasy. Nothing tasted fresh or home made. The iced coffee was okay, but definitely was not cold enough. Needless to say, we are still on the search for a spot that was like our former Bagel Palace in Hampton Bays. ;( read more

I came here with a group of friends for breakfast on a Sunday morning. There were so many great bagel options as well as breakfast sandwiches. The service was quick and the food was made fresh. The everything bagel is salted, which I love, and the ham and eggs I got on it were perfectly seasoned. Definitely recommend coming in for breakfast! read more

I love this place. Always have, always will. Every time I return home I have- emphasis on HAVE- to go to HB Bagels, even though bagel palace is much closer (too expensive, not a fan!). I've been going to hb bagel since high school and since then it has been owned by the same people. It's always consistent, has a great selection of bagels (mind you, if you go early enough!) and an extensive menu of other breakfast items, all of which are made to order. I always go for a lightly toasted bagel with a "lot" of olive- and/or cucumber dill- cream cheese. So tasty. It always comes out perfectly. The bagels are the perfect size, chewy and dense. read more

Always a great selection and variety of sandwiches. Could come here for a year and still not try everything.

I never write yelp reviews but I have never had a more offensive bagel. I spit out the first bite of a BEC and started dry heaving lol. The taste can only be described as wet dog combined w pennies. I feel like they haven't cleaned their stovetop in a year I don't know what could humanly create that taste. Run, far away!!!! read more

Came in toward the end of the day and were greeted. Had a rye bagel with 1/4 lb of tuna. Also a roll. Shared for (2) sandwiches and cost under $10. Centrally located in the Wild by nature lot. They had so many different types of soda, juice, tea etc. They have local artists work on the wall. The bathroom was clean . I will be back read more

See all

Best bagels in town. Grill is open all day who could ask for more? Oh wait they have flagels and twist style bagels that are awesome. Great service; eat in or call and place your order for pick up. read more

Special instructions were carried out perfectly. Nice service, tasty everything bagel. Ordering was a little misleading. I actually expected a platter of eggs, and a bagel on the side, but got all one one sandwich. Not a biggie, food was excellent. read more

The bagels were good but the whitefish salad had a tang to it and was mushy. Didn't enjoy that at all.

Delicious breakfast & coffee!! Egg sandwich was cooked to perfection and the vanilla sugar cookie coffee is sooooo good!!

Our regular bagel place is bagel palace in Hampton bay's but we were tired of the lines and long wait for food so we tried here. Hands down the winner in the area. Located in the wild oats shopping center on the way to quogue. Bagels are pretty much the same quality but the omelets are enormous and unlike their competitor not greasy. Large coffee and bagel is included so for 7.99 you eat quite well. They also bring your order right to the table. Added bonus... A Fresh squeeze orange juice machine. We'll be back for sure. read more

I have been trying to hard to stay healthy but I can't help but crave a nice Saturday morning breakfast. Hampton Bays Bagels has the best healthy choices around. Their garden omelet- egg whites, olives, mushrooms, swiss- on a low fat cc bagel and a coffee is my savior. The turkey wrap is yummy and healthy as well, but then again so is everything else I've tried at HB Bagels! read more

This place has absolutely amazing coffee. I worked down the road for 3 years and would rather stop here to get coffee than panera bread down the road. Also, they make good egg sandwiches and lunch sandwiches. It is not absolutely appalling. The people in there are really nice and the place is clean. And they have great customer service... read more