I would give this 3.5 stars if I could, because I love the charm of this place and do think there's a lot they get right here. This place has been here for so many decades, it almost feels like stepping back in time with the big wooden booths and pastry counter. It's giving old school diner. When you walk in you'll notice the bakery portion of the store to your right, where you can order any freshly baked breads, pastries, cookies and the like. Straight back is where you go to place food and coffee orders. You place your order on a kiosk. Options include a variety of egg dishes, omelets and frittatas, as well as waffles, pancakes and avocado toast. There's a full coffee bar as well with iced coffees, lattes and other espresso drinks to choose from. We went with a bunch of iced coffees, a "build your own" omelet, breakfast burrito and mushroom omelet. Despite the crazy line here on a Saturday afternoon our food came out very quickly. Coffees took another 20 minutes or so until we were able to ask someone about it (we felt bad, they were so busy), and they handed them over to us. The food here was good and fresh, but also very no frills and portions are small. The prices here are so high though that when we were walking by Donahue's on our way out we realized we could've had a fancy brunch there for just about the same price as we paid for a few small dishes. read more

Tables were dirty (as others have mentioned).... Food was okay but very expensive. It's nice they have that back lot for parking. Pastries were very good. read more

I got the apple turnover and a hot chocolate on an early morning and it was so nice. The service was very delightful and quick. I savored every bite of apple crispness as it melted in my mouth. The powder in the outside of the turnover was a little messy but it made it a fun eating experience. The hot chocolate was perfect for an early June morning alongside my turnover, I loved it. With whipped cream it made my day. I loved this place I highly recommend, underrated spot! read more

Beach Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

See all

This is a real bakery with pasties that are expensive but well worth it. You will not be disapointed

Came here for breakfast and had a decent experience. This place was super busy so I figured it was worth a visit. There was a large selection of baked goods, so I got a black and white cookie, omelette and latte. Everything was just ok in terms of taste. I didn't realize the place was kosher either, so no meat. The place is nice but the outside seating could be cleaned more frequently. read more

My granddaughter's high school graduation cake was perfection! College logo beautiful, cake delicious and delivered to our party venue at appropriate time! read more

Wow. Hadn't been here in QUITE a long time. It's undergone a giant expansion, from a small counter and a few tables, to much more space with many more tables. The menu is bigger, too. I remember a case filled with just bread, and I think that they did cakes and some desserts, too. Now there's many more desserts as well as bread. Alas, the only gluten-free item is coconut macaroons. Hopefully they will add some gluten-free items in the future. Coffee selection was great. You pay at the counter and pour your own. It was later in the day, so I did half decaf and half hazelnut. Yum! We didn't get any food, because we had already had lunch. Service was good. We just ordered coffee cups and I asked about gluten-free items. The man who answered did seem regretful. I'm guessing that he's been asked many times before. I have a wheat allergy, and other people have gluten sensitivity, so perhaps some day they'll expand their offerings. In the meantime, I'll keep baking my own protein cookies and flatbread. I've found commercial gluten-free bagels and English muffins, woohoo! read more

See all

Beach bakery is filthy and dirty the tables are sticky and full of crumbs as well as the booths are full of crumbs!the eclair sucked ! A lot of chocolate very little filling inside ! What happened to this place everything used to be nice and clean and good. read more

I've been loving the Beach Bakery for the past 25 years. Black and white cookies, jelly donuts, delicious cakes. Mmmmmmm...... Ever since Simon sold a few years back, the new owner does not refresh his baked goods as often. Many times their signature black and whites and other products (elephant ears) are stale and hard. I keep on giving it another try in the hope to have another delicious Black and White, but usually end up dissapointed. read more

Ordered Christmas cookie Platters that were made up completely wrong. After a few go arounds it was clear they did not make up the platters based on the order and just took whatever they had and threw it together. This is the second time it happened. I have been going to the bakery for 30 years. Since the new management took over it's poorly run and dirty. New management does care about customer service. There are different people working there every week. I'm a resident in the town and I am done with the place. The uncaring attitude and poor customer service is just ridiculous. read more

Love the food here especially for breakfast although they didn't have almond milk at that time and oat milk was running out as well.. it's self service.. very casual ambiance.. great location.. has outdoor seating and it's nice for a summer day.. we love it and will definitely come back.. has vegan options read more

See all

Ever since Simon's Beach Bakery was sold, everything changed! They don't stay open late, the floors and counters are often dirty, and I have had stale pastries. For those of you who were regulars, I am sure you know what I'm talking about. The prices are high for the lack of food quality. read more

The food is not good. It's super chaotic inside and the layout is awful. Do not recommend.

Loved this place....NOT anymore!!!! No jelly in donuts croissants ugh! Don't even taste the same . Grilled cheese was sooooooo good not now 2 pieces of cheese. Whoever u are you've done Simon "wrong" Even the PINK boxes are gone! Find another bakery soooo sad! read more

they don't advertise that they are a kosher restaurant so there is no meat. the food is massively overpriced for the quality and the portions. the wait time is half your lifespan and the coffee is terrible. TERRIBLE! there also is a WASP PROBLEM. if you are forced to go here stick to the bakery side. don't even think about ordering real food!!!!!!! read more

Best sourdough bread every. Sadly, I had to throw out my jelly croissant. They charged the jelly and it tastes synthetic..yuck. I should have bought the Boston croissant.. Very polite staff even though he did not offer me something else. read more

Beach Bakery in village of Westhampton Beach. More of a grab and go coffee tea baker with some food options. Not the same bakery quality. Hanging hands has impacted quality on baked items. Location and convenience are still there. The owner came out to help the line and ignored me and took the man behind me first. I said I'm on line and he ignored me. Insult to women? Never experienced that before. The weird guy I with a pony tale in from the city likely, didn't say pardon me. Seemed to want to be rung up first. Two weird guys. Glad I don't live in the 3rd world. Could you imagine? Out of there and back to our great Island where that's the exception. I asked why all the donuts were half sized. The owner said we'll find you the bigger ones. They all looked like minis but the concern is are they proofed? A woman working there kept insisting her husband has been the baker here for 30 years but the jelly and Boston creme donuts are half sized not proofed. I've seen this since t bakery was sold. They did admit there are two other bakers also. So yeah something changed and the head baker is somewhere but not in charge of some or any of the baking. Lol. We have eyes. Croissants are not layered and flakey and chocolate croissants look like frozen from a restaurant supply. Quality is fresh just not superior as it was. Still glad to have them open and to have a late night place to pick something up. Will come in but will venture into Southampton for Tate's. Old Ye Bakery or a French place that is rocking it. read more

See all

Coffee machine always closed early even on the weekends. Staff always seem frustrated to be working.

Very good Kosher Dairy restaurant. Big menu with lots of options the baked goods are amazing.

I miss the old Simon's. It was really special. Food is decent, but it's hard not to compare it to what once was. I can appreciate how challenging this business really is, and I wish them well...just hope they can get it together. read more

The first breakfast spot we hit while in the area. The bakery/restaurant was ok. The bakery portion looked amazing with lots of baked goods. We really liked the look of the bakery, it was quite large. We chose to eat in, so we ordered at the kiosk which is a bit confusing but we got it done. I ordered a stack of berry pancakes and my girlfriend ordered the Spinach frittata. I also ordered a 16oz. Latte which I only realized after I had my breakfast that I was only served a 12oz cup. My girlfriend ordered the fresh squeezed orange juice which was at about $6 a glass but they did not have any so she had to get a bottle of juice which I had to go back and get the difference in amount we paid for. We told the young lady who was taking care of us that we intended to dine in but we were served in to go containers, not a plate. The food was good but the service was lackluster. It almost felt like they preferred we would take our food and go. The place was really nice and we really wanted to enjoy it but unfortunately we left feeling a bit disappointed. I would suggest the staff take the time to welcome and take care of their customers to ensure they come back. read more

See all

One of the worst cups of coffee I've had recently. I could taste the grounds. Plus the screens you need to use to order are really inconvenient. It's a miss. read more

Beach Bakery - Coffee with grounds in it - Bakeries Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

Me & my husband travel a distance to come here to get some raspberry croissants, it's the donut this bakery is known for. But we also like the pecan bars, Neapolitans & custard croissant's - they're ridiculously delicious too! The Jelly have the sugar topping & the custard has the powder sugar on top. We call it a "treat" coming here for obvious reason's but also it's expensive! bring your wallet they take credit cards too. The problem is don't have their prices listed anywhere!! so you really don't know how much your gonna spend unless your always asking how much is this or that.? It's always a surprise at the end but we usually end up spending $30-$50 a visit - it adds up quick. If your in the area give it a try the staff is friendly. Bring read more

Beach Bakery - $50 to go box - Bakeries Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

The portions are HUGE and taste great nonetheless! Got late so missed their breakfast time but this is a great halal/kosher spot! Service was great and the ambiance was perfect just as you'd imagine for a cafe in the hamptons read more

Beach Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

After a nice lunch at our favorite seafood place at Hampton Bays, we drove to West Hampton to explore the town. It was a nice drive along the beach. This is a lovely dessert place with enough seats inside and outside. We got Napoleon, a blueberry coffee cake and a fruit tart. Everything was perfect, but we could only have a little of everything and took home the rest. It seems the bakery got a lot of clientele. I did like our desserts, but I had Napoleon better someplace else. The blueberry coffee cake was probably the best of all three. read more

See all

We had a cake delivered to the beach for my husbands birthday and cannot express how wonderful the service and cake was. Everyone thought it was delicious and complimented on how good it was. I also gave them a Pinterest pic of what I wanted and it was perfect. Thank you so much! I would recommend to anyone read more

Beach Bakery - Pics don't do it justice... - Bakeries Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

The place to go in the morning and afternoon for coffee and amazing pastry, homemade breads, or a custom sandwich. All our birthdays out east get celebrated with a cake from Beach. Wouldn't be a trip to WHB without a stop at Beach Bakery. Much love - JGD read more

Establishment offered a very safe environment to enjoy wonderful food i highly recommend to eat here!

Came here for breakfast. Ordered on the kiosk, very easy ordering process. I ordered the breakfast quesadilla and my husband ordered the breakfast burrito. Everything was delicious and served hot! We were stuffed; very large portions. Next time I will order some of the bakery items! read more

Beach Bakery - Breakfast burrito - Bakeries Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

See all

This was our first visit to Simon's Beach Bakery. We were graciously greeted by Simon the owner and once I told him that this was our first trip..... her bright is a small tasting plate with a macaroon and an Italian rainbow cookie.... just delicious. He then made us mimosas which just got us nice and relaxed. For breakfast, we had the mozzarella and spinach frittata and the pancakes. Both dishes were delicious and well presented on the plate. Now it's time for some fried raspberry croissants! read more

See all

Excellent food and pastries great service an asset to Westhampton A+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

A local stable in Westhampton Beach! Def a go to if you are visting! tons of options of pastries, cakes and more! Lots of indoor and outdoor seating with live music some nights in the summer! Quality definitely took a big hit after simon the original owner left a few years ago but still a gem! read more

See all

We flew in from California to Eastport NY for a 60th Birthday celebration weekend. Javid, Ruben(bakery and master creator), Jelson(manager), were very polite yet professional. Thank you very much for all your help and cooperation! The Cake was beautiful, Simple and Very Elegant! It was absolutely what we had imagined and designed, delightfully tasty too! The Cupcakes and the Vegan Cupcakes were also great. You helped make our occasion special, and we appreciate that! We drowned ourselves in the Coffee and Sweet Treats while we waited. Kiran read more

I was a long time customer and I gave this place a chance but never again! This place was sold about 4-5 years ago and has new owners. Each year the establishment has deteriorated. The place is dingy and dirty. The bathroom is filthy. The counter is dirty, menus are dirty, Kiosks are dirty. The utensils are sticky. The pastries are stale and not fresh. I can only imagine how dirty the kitchen must be. There is no way this would pass a Kosher kitchen inspection. A kosher kitchen has a high standard. This would fail any health department inspection. If you look over the counter into the back kitchen... you would run... What a shame! Its embarrassing to have this type of establishment in this great town. Im so sad. read more

I love this place so much. Every time I'm in West Hampton, I have to come here. I definitely think this is one of the best bakeries on Long Island. Everything just looks so unbelievable good. Everything always tastes so warm and fresh-baked. They also make a lot of their baked goods in different sizes which is nice if you just want to try it and not buy an entire pie or cake. They have a whole ice cream section that I wish we had tried but didn't really have the stomach room for after our lunch. We did take home a lot of pastries though to try. The Napoleon was awesome. Needed a bit more thawing out because the cream was very cold, but still outstanding. The tarts were all really good as well. I loved the Key Lime tart so much. The eclair and cream puff were also pretty great. Well-made choux pastry. Light and airy. Great cream filling too. My award for best cream filled dessert though goes to the cream-filled croissant. That thing was just out of this world amazing. A must-try if you go here. The chocolate mousse tart was also another one of my favorites. That, and the Jelly doughnuts. The doughnuts are so perfectly baked. A bit on the doughy side, but really worth the carbs. They also have a nice lunch menu here that I need to try when I'm back in town. This place is pretty much the sole reason I will be coming back to the town of West Hampton. What a great spot! read more

See all

Online reviews are more impressive than the actual bakery . Confusion as soon as you enter . Where to order ? No ample signage for directions . Is it a bakery , a deli or a restaurant ? No one greeting or giving directions No waiter service. Self service for napkins, utensils and condiments all in different areas . Dirty floors in the outdoor seating area off to the side . If you don't clean the tables at least clean your floors for your guests. French toast was hard and portions were poor . Hash browns overcooked. Never again read more

Food was fine but service was terrible. After we ordered (and paid) at the counter, they told us they were out of one of the entrees we ordered. Then they made us wait in line over again to choose a different entree. The line moved slowly, so the rest of our party ate while we stood in line waiting to reorder. read more

We stopped in for lunch after a visit to Cupsogue. The staff were friendly and helpful, and the food tasty and prepared to order. The bakery seems to be the highlight of the restaurant, but the meal offerings are also expansive. We had a frittata and tuna salad wrap, along with a chai latte. read more

Frankly I have NEVER yet found a bad bakery!!! This place is no exception! All the pastries that I have bought there have been wonderful!! The spiderman gingerbread cookie was great. The elephant ears were amazing !! Very big ones!! This place is worth a visit.. read more

Beach Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

Update (1/1/2020): My birthday cake was amazing! On my last review I posted that the quality of their cakes had gone down and I probably wouldn't be ordering from them anymore. Luckily, my father doesn't have yelp and bought my birthday cake from them and it was amazing! It wasn't exactly like the good ole' days under the fabulous Simon, but it was close. I'm thinking (fingers crossed) that they are ironing out the kinks involved with switching owners and finding their groove. I will make a point to visit the bakery within the next few months for breakfast or lunch and do a more in depth updated review. read more