I like Goldberg's but the lines are unbearable. Call ahead always. The young man who works the cashier at the East Hampton location is the best. Overall good food but not worth the wait if you don't call ahead. read more

Goldberg's - Hobo on Plain Bagel - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Goldberg great breakfast place, foods good and fast but the problem is it takes so long. There is always a line out the door, but overall it's fine. Good ambiance. read more

Goldberg's - Hobo - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Delicious, fresh bagels. We came in as a group of 11 and they got through us easily with no mess ups. That can be hard to come by! They also got through us fast as well as the people behind us. No long waits for everyone! read more

Goldberg's - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

A fantastic deli in East Hampton. Two lines, one for bagels only and the other for everything else. Limited space for eating there. So takeouts it is for me. On top of the deli meats, lox, salads, and, sweets that I take home; for years now, with breakfast, I choose their egg, bacon, and hash brown "Hobo" on an everything bagel; and for lunch, I choose their pastrami, turkey with slaw and Russian on rye specialty sandwich, "East Hampton"! (and, not to be missed on winter weather days, their amazing "Lentil" soup) CHEERS! read more

Goldberg's - Love Goldberg's! - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Great bagels I love how they are well done. I went Monday for a tuna on a bagel with lettuce and tomato was $12.95 came with a pickle. Went Wednesday for same exact or received also coleslaw was $13.95. Same thing! read more

Great coffee here and fresh bagels and baked goods as well as sandwiches. Fast service, casual ambiance. Tables to eat outside in the warmer weather. read more

Rip off. $20 for a bagel cream cheese with scallion and salmon. They forgot to toast the bagel and barely a trace of cream cheese no scallion and one slice of salmon. Bagel was hard and needed a chainsaw to get into it. The texture was just awful. No soft chewiness just stale hard bagel Seriously?!? It was 10am. There was no line, no rush how can a bagel place be so bad? read more

See all

Stopped by on our way home from montauk to grab a bagel. There's a sign that says, essentially, "This line is for bagels and spreads sold individually. If you don't know where to go, order at the far left register." So I go there and the woman directs me back to the register I was at with that sign. She comes from across the store to take orders at the register she told me to go to then tells me to go to a third register. I tell her that SHE'S the one who told me to go here. I walked out. Overly complicated business model just to order a bagel with cream cheese. read more

Goldbergs is known for great food and has the crowds to prove it! Some days you can call ahead, but during busy times it's not allowed. The line moves fast, though, and the Spicy Hobo is worth it! read more

Goldberg's - Weekend crowd - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

The service is absolutely disgraceful...I was told to wait in a line and then was told that it was the wrong line and I had to get back inline after waiting 25min. I then waited another 20mins and my order was wrong. Never again! read more

Goldbergs is the go-to bagel place out in the Hamptons, and that is very apparent with the crazy crowds and long lines. The bagels themselves are okay, but it was $15 for a bagel with whitefish and a coffee, crazy expensive for an average bagel. Also, no place to sit inside. One weird table near the garbage. They should invest in more tables outside or inside, and refill coffee if you stay in. Sub par, and it sucks there is no other choices for bagels out east. read more

My favorite Goldberg's is WESTHAMPTON BEACH. Always friendly, fresh and delicious. So many great traditional and new choices. Great menu. Love the healthy choices offered too! read more

Fire bagels. I had a flat bagel with strawberry cream cheese but forgot to take a picture. I'd never had a flat bagel before so that was fun and the cream cheese was amazing and seemed so fresh (had real strawberries in it) read more

Goldberg's - Bacon egg and cheese on plain bagel with scallion cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Outrageous prices. Sandwiches can be pretty mid. Most of the times when you call to place a pickup order they'll have the phone off the hook or won't pickup. read more

Just grab a blueberry donut and make it two. Toast one with butter or low fat cream cheese, and go with no heating on the other blueberry bagel with either option. Close eyes, mouthgasm, thank me later by dropping a vote on this review. Because this location is out of sight on the main road, it isn't as crowded as some of the other locales. Service is a bit dry, but luckily they're bagels are not. Solid coffee too. read more

See all

I stopped by this place since for a quick lunch since I was in the area for a doctors appointment, and I was blown away! I could tell this was a local favorite by the amount of people that were here at 11 am on a Saturday. The line was out the door, but the wait wasn't too bad. When I went (10/2021), there was no indoor seating, but there were some tables outside, which was nice. I got the, I believe it's called the Hungry Man, on a roll, and it was amazing! It was a bacon egg and cheese with sausage and ham and it was so filling. You will definitely be full for a while after eating this! Coffee is also a must! This is definitely a go to deli; I would definitely come here often if I lived in the area. read more

Goldberg's - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Furious is an understatement. Ordered a bagel and cream cheese and after waiting patiently for 15 minutes and watching person and after person that came in up to 10 minutes after me get their orders. I finally asked the young woman who took my order what was taking so long and she asked me if I ordered from her and I said yes. She asked what I ordered, I told her and she looked at me like a deer in headlights. I then told her never mind and I'd just get a refund because I had to go and she walked away. I spoke with one of the two women at the register and told her I needed a refund because the woman who I ordered from forgot it and she motions around to the room and said, "we're very busy" and I explained again what happened and that I needed to leave so I just wanted my money back. She tells the other woman and she asked what I ordered and I told her assuming she was asking so I could be refunded. Nope. She tells me she's going to have them make it and I again told her I just wanted my money back to which she responded very dismissively, "Mami, I'm busy" while waving me away so I just walked out without my order or my money. read more

At 7:30 on Saturday we beat the rush. Servers attentive and kept my coffee topped off. Spanish omelette has a delicious homemade sauce over it. Good thick bagels. read more

This is the worst Goldberg location. Like other reviews have stated, the customer service just isn't it. They hear what they want to hear instead of what you said. On 3 different occasions I've asked for BEC with scrambled eggs... not once were the eggs scrambled. You could see the yolk had congealed.. why didn't they scramble the eggs like I asked? I stopped ordering that, ordered a toasted bagel with cream cheese thinking that would be easier. It wasn't. The bagel was extra toasted to where it tasted burnt many times! Okay so now I won't order it toasted. A plain bagel with little cream cheese. Simple enough right? Wrong! They REFUSE to put little cream cheese. I can't make this up. I've asked them to scrape some off and then they roll their eyes at you! Unbelievable. How am I in the wrong by wanting my food made the way I ordered it / purchased it? Today I made the bagel myself by asking for a little cream cheese on the side because when I asked the woman to take off some cream cheese, she took almost all of it off. the cream cheese on the side is after I used some for my bagel. Look how much is left. It's just so wasteful honestly. The woman told me to order my cream cheese on the side. lol ok. But yeah I'm so done with this place. It is not worth the hassle. read more

Goldberg's - Making my bagel at the counter bc they couldn't do it. Extra cc tossed after I used the "little bit" that I asked for. - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

I had the Hamptons Special and it was delicious! Lox and cream cheese was very generous. read more

See all

A bagel, dry...$1.75 - reasonable A bagel, dry and toasted....$3.50 - insane Cashier justified by saying its because the bagel used "electricity". Never again, Goldberg. read more

I live in New York City, and I'm very particular about my bagels. I usually won't even have a bagel unless it's from one of my three go-to places in the city. So when I saw Goldberg's, I was skeptical- but I really had a hankering for a good bagel to get the day started. I have to say, this place blew my mind. The plain bagel I got was delectable, perfectly toasted, a delightfully chewy and airy creation. Not only that, I tried their "flats", which look like a cross between a Turkish simit and a regular bagel, and it was unbelievably good. It was like nothing I've ever had before- a bit doughy like a bagel, but with the chew of a soft, pillowy Hawaiian roll. It's hard to explain, but easy to recommend- try it! If you like bagels, you've got to check this place out. read more

I LOVE Goldberg's! It's a must visit when staying out East! A few tips can go well before visiting: 1. Try calling ahead to place your order. Sometimes, when they are super busy, they stop taking phone orders, but it's worth a shot. The line can get pretty long, so it's better call ahead than wait in a 30 minute line! 2. If you can handle some heat, get the "Spicy Hobo" breakfast sandwich (Two eggs, bacon, pepper jack cheese, hash brown and hot sauce) - I think it's around $8.50. I get mine on a whole wheat everything bagel flat instead of a roll. 3. Lastly, their coffee is homemade, so be sure to try some of their original brew! I love the hazelnut roast. read more

Goldberg's - Spicy Hobo - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Goldberg's has the monopoly on Bagels across the East End. 10 years ago I would have given it a 5 star rating. Not anymore. The bagels are delicious BUT the service is below sub-par. They have been in business long enough to have improved their efficiency but nope. It is always extremely busy, especially in the summer months. The staff are generally friendly but 90% of the time hear what they want to hear versus what you order. I frequent it because it is close to my office but I cannot remember the last time I received a correct order. Example: today I ordered everything bagel, scooped and toasted with Honey Turkey, melted swiss and Caesar dressing. When I bite into it, they had put Russian dressing on it. They don't even sound similar. It's mistakes like this that happen every time. They need a "bar rescue" type situation to come in and help them get organized, or dedicate staff members to each station and make the food assembly line style- oh wait, they can't because they have the toaster on the complete opposite end from the grill and the salad station across from the grill. It makes zero sense. Goldberg's we love you but please so better. read more

Goldberg's - Turkey, swiss and what was supposed to be caesar dressing but it's Russian. - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Fantastic beautiful well-made put all the bagels in New York City to shame and affordable nova just wonderful hot and fresh out of the oven chewy moist the everything bagel my favorite all the way down to the plain bagel it's one of the reasons to come to the Hamptons and enjoy the summer year-round thank you Goldbergs for being here since 1947 enjoy read more

Goldberg's - Goldbergs bagel with Nova yummy - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Just a good, standard bagel place with everything you would expect, including chopped chicken livers. Excellent bagels, a lot of different cream cheeses too. You can get just about anything on a bagel here. read more

Want a tasty takeout breakfast or lunch without the hamptons price tag? Goldberg's! Walk in and get in line order and take a number... I think I only like a 5 min wait for my warm spicy powerhouse and blueberry bagel. Bagel was fresh and chewy with a tiny crisp. read more

Goldberg's - Spicy powerhouse - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

What a f**king joke. I go in here around 2:30pm on a Tuesday and there are 6 people working so you'd think the service would be good. I order egg salad on a toasted plain bagel with lettuce and pepper. After about 15 minutes of waiting (and other customers coming in, ordering, getting their food) I ask about my order. Everyone seems confused! Then ask me again what my order was --- Isn't that the point of WRITING IT DOWN?!?! I finally get a COLD toasted bagel with egg salad and NO LETTUCE and NO PEPPER. I will never go into this store again. What a joke. Just awful. read more

Hungry man breakfast sandwich was delicious and satisfying. Later we had the Corn beef/pastrami and the egg salad in a wrap on the beach later on- will be back, delicious! read more

Food is good and great variety but the service is so inconsistent and they are always so busy and if you order by phone you are usually disappointed when you pick up the food and it's not what you asked for. Always so crowded so I hate going in. The people on the lines are usually rude. Staff are nice but need to get their act together with the orders. Too m any mistakes. read more

Food was really good! Line was crazy long and confusing. Overall, was worth the wait in the line for the yummy bagels and sandwiches.

Simply thee best bagels/Flagels on the planet. All flavors. Soft delish fresh heavenly. Can't go anywhere without people asking us to bring a dozen! And we do! The service on pantigo is terrible. My order is rarely correct and long wait is common. Wainscott is cheerful and line moves fast. Order is almost always correct. Sag is great too although not as clean as Wainscott. Salads r pretty good. My fave CC is the lox spread. Egg sandwiches r off the charts delish. read more

Egg Salad is awful! Goldberg's is THE place for bagels in the Hamptons. Each town has one, and the lines every weekend in the summer at all locations are out the door. Given that, you'd expect the food to be great. Well, let me tell you, that's not the case with their egg salad. It is HORRIBLE!! I bought some today for my guests, and we couldn't decide if it was spoiled or was just terrible. I mean, how can you mess up egg salad?? If you're in the Hamptons and want a bagel, you don't have many options, but take my advice, skip the egg salad!! read more

Great bagels and BEC. Basically your only option in the hamptons. During the week, service is not bad, but on weekends, especially holiday weekends, it's a zoo! read more

I've been coming here for years - maybe more than a decade even. It took 30 minutes and $78 for a dozen bagels, 4 egg sandwiches, a quart of OJ and 8oz of cream cheese. Wasn't even busy but the server was yaking with another counterperson instead of filling the order with any urgency. He also didn't make one of the sandwiches right. Generally love the staff and know a lot of people come through with an attitude, but that love's gotta be a two-way street. Also, if you're going to charge an arm and a leg for this stuff, stop throwing freebies to local VIPs. Why am I paying for your largesse? read more

I have been here maybe 10 years ago And I am back wow the place is a 10 on my book A must visit for Authentic bagels Memories of days past read more

See all

The bagels here are fantastic! Up there with the best bagel shops in NYC. The line moves quickly. I ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a whole wheat bagel with an iced coffee today and everything was delicious. I've also ordered bagels by the dozen and they were all on point. The whole wheat everything bagel was especially good. read more

Goldberg's - Menu inside - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Heading out east, my girlfriend and I were on the prowl for a deli/sandwich shop to fit our "we-need-food-for-the-beach" needs. She's a smart gal, as she may not write reviews, but she uses Yelp to hunt down promising prospects. With four stars and in the direction we were headed, this place won out. Though after it all, we were left with something a little under four stars, but let me explain. It's not a large location, but most delis are squished in size and still find ways to roll out plenty of different types of food options. Goldberg's was no exception to this as there were bagels, breakfast sandwiches, lunch specials, and plenty of sandwich choices that would work well for what we wanted. We chose to split the Springs combination sandwich (breaded chicken cutlet, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and we added American cheese and mayo, all on a roll), but when ready to order, we stood by the counter for a few minutes with no signs of getting waited on despite several people roaming around behind it. I'm good at waiting/giving employees a moment to take an order, especially if a place is bustling, but no one else was there (besides one couple behind us) and it gave us a bit of a disconnect in the service department (part uno of the reason for three stars). As a drink, they carry a local Montauk beverage line and we went with a half and half (ice tea/lemonade). All items were devoured a little later on once at the beach. Working backwards, the drink was light, fresh, and full of sweet flavor. But more importantly is the sandwich. It was on the larger side and had a good helping of chicken. The breading was thick and along with the BLT portion and cheese created a good balance of flavor and a quality beach meal....though I can't say it was worth the price. Okay, I know we were getting lunch from East Hampton so it's almost to be expected as prices can be on the higher end, but $11 for the sandwich we purchased was definitely not worth the price (part dos of the reason for three stars). I do feel like we missed out on an important part of Goldberg's by not having bagels/breakfast sandwiches so it is possible we could return someday to give those a whirl. But overall, for this experience, I'd chalk it up to around three stars (maybe add a half) with a nice sandwich, but a price and service that wasn't anything to bring us back for more. read more

See all

My first NY bagel in East Hampton was a treat! Got a plain toasted bagel with butter to keep things simple and really taste the bagel. So yummy! My son got the Hampton special - cream cheese, lox, onion, lettuce on a plain bagel, which was amazing as well. They cut the salmon in front of us. Got crumb cake to go. read more

Goldberg's - Hampton special - so great! - Bagels Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Great for bagels my favorite one is the one with lax cream cheese tomato onion :-) Now they have locations also in EH. Sag Harbor read more