A true borderline review where a half star could possibly be tacked on to those three, though it's tough to tell as my recent trip out east with my wife to Bonfire was definitely middling. Now we don't venture all the way to Amagansett often, but we like to head out to Montauk once a year, and social media presented a cute coffee shop to stop at on the way, Bonfire. Cute could definitely be the word, especially the exterior of the place with some shaded seats on their deck and the small grassy courtyard that encompassed them and the neighboring storefronts. The vibes worked, though many other factors were more iffy. I'll try to focus on the other good options in that the menu of Bonfire is intriguing from their coffee and food options as well as gelato. I'll also say the staff, despite a small snafu (more on that in a sec), were able to take orders and keep things going. I'll even say that on first sip of my coffee I was wowed, but that's just what you see on the surface level. Underneath those positives was a pricier coffee spot with my wife's blueberry whip latte coming in at $11. Between that, a chocolate croissant, and my own latte we spent $27 which is a little much for what we got. Yes, eastern Long Island can be pricy, but dang. As for my aforementioned coffee, I got the Bonfire Latte which combined vanilla, hazelnut, and cardamom flavors to create what started as a truly delicious taste, but after a few sips once the flavor punch wore off, I would've at least expected a coffee kick in there. Honestly, there wasn't much. The real sign this was true was my wife who prefers a little more sweetness than coffee taste in her drinks saying that she couldn't taste any coffee in hers either. Oh and that croissant while soft and flaky, definitely felt like the chocolate could've been a little more melted in to it as I pulled out a whole piece when trying to tear it for my wife. One last item about the croissant was the fact that we ordered it and no one gave it to us. Our coffees came out relatively quickly despite the place being somewhat busy, but we stood and watched a few people who ordered after us get their stuff before I had to ask about the croissant which seemed to have been forgotten about. Oy. Overall, Bonfire Coffeehouse presents itself as a lovely eastern location to get some morning brews and then some, but perhaps it's not as fantastic as the facade it showcases. I'd like to try them one more time in the future, but that'll be a long time off (probably not til next summer) and that's if I feel like it's worth the price and I'm willing to believe the lack of coffee flavor was a fluke. Head out on the south fork and you be the judge. read more

See all

Went there for breakfast with sister, got 1 bacon/egg & cheese we split, 2 iced mocha drinks and 1 crossant. Total= 43.00 ! They charged me 1.25 xtra for the milk and 50 cents for the ice! Not to mention the sign said $8 for the drink when in fact they charge $9.75 because of the xtra charges, why not just say it's $9.75? And the sandwich could have been better, it used to be. I don't think I'll be back there any time soon, I'm not a wealthy person on Vay-cay who can spend like that, it was shocking! I'm sorry but the prices are getting sinful around here and it's sad because I love to eat out and have done so often but lately, not so much. :-( read more

we loved this shop. The gelato is delicious. There are so many more things to get in here besides coffee. The staff is awesome. We were able to try almost all of the flavors of gelato they had before selecting our choices. Both me and my fella got Affogato with two flavors of gelato and a double shot of espresso. We each got a biscotti. There's plenty of places to sit inside and outside. You're getting a very high quality product for very reasonable price. Whenever I'm in this area again, I will definitely be stopping by here. read more

See all

Love this cafe/coffehouse! The best part is that they're open year round. Whenever anyone comes for a visit it's a no brainer to go here! Best cold brew on LI! read more

Ladies and gentlemen this is "cappuccino" Absolutely terrible and it was $7. How is this a "coffeehouse" when they can't tell the difference between types of coffee?! This is definitely the worst coffee I had in Hamptons. read more

Bonfire Coffeehouse - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amagansett, New York

Yum! From a lifelong Starbucks drinker I can tell you I had the best latte ever here. Lunch specials are great! Soup and sandwich for $12. Toasted cheese and split pea on a cold day hits the spot. The Linzer Tarts are fresh and just perfect. Staff is so friendly and welcoming read more

Bonfire Coffeehouse - Toasted Cheese Sandwich Split pea and ham soup - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amagansett, New York

great , alil bit of a wait tho ..... sandwiches were bomb , all the food are pre made . the matchas and iced coffee are great !! also there's a lot of outdoor seating read more

This place has somehow reinvented the meaning of "order ahead." I ordered online, waited over 30 minutes for a large cold brew, and had to ask six times before anyone acted like my order existed. Impressive commitment to doing literally everything except making the coffee. Save yourself the time and go somewhere that understands the revolutionary concept of serving customers. read more

The coffee is quite so with every type of milk you can imagine including nondairy; I went with the pistachio! you can bring your own cup . The service is excellent. The baked goods are lovely.. it's not overrun by tourists, they have a nice bathroom. And you can fill your water bottle water on an urn ready for the thirsty. They are in a small village square so you'll park elsewhere and stroll over. Once you arrive, you can also sit outside in the good old summer time. Enjoy! read more

Best drip coffee I've had on the East End in a long time. Ill be back to try the many other items they offer. And they have a clean restroom! read more

As I was walked down Amagansett's Main Street, I saw their sign for Gelato and immediately knew what I had to do. As I followed the sidewalk path, I noticed the abundance of outdoor seating as well as the beautiful flowers all along the way. Walking in, the interior was bright and airy. As I approached the gelato station, the young gentleman behind the counter immediately offered me a sample. After tasting the coffee gelato, I ordered one on an old school sugar cone. I'm about to embark on a fast so this was the "perfect" way to satisfy my cravings before hand. The gelato really hit the mark, absolutely delicious and perfect on a hot summer day! And honestly, at $6, it was cheaper than I anticipated, given the location. read more

Absolutely incredible, with the best pastries, cakes, donuts, breakfast sandwiches, and platters. I literally bought out the store. 10/10 highly recommended, I would however get there early. we showed up at 9 AM, it was packed by 9:30 AM. The employees were great, they were sweet and so informative. This was one of the best places to eat in East Hamptons. I will be going back for sure. I got a BEC on a croissant, it was delicious. Then followed by a donut and banana chocolate chip pudding. Everything was so good, we left no crumbles LOL. read more

This coffeehouse has great selection of snacks, gelato, candy, coffee and sandwiches. There are plenty of tables to sit inside and outdoors. I tasted a few samples before choosing strawberry and my husband chose something nutella-coffee like. Super tasty and the staff is friendly. Will definitely stop by again when I'm in town! read more

Bonfire Coffeehouse - Bonfire latte, strawberry gelato, nutella-like gelato - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amagansett, New York

We had great breakfast sandwiches from this place. But the chai latte was the star of the show! It was the best one I ever had. The woman behind the counter was so sweet and welcoming too read more

Bonfire Coffeehouse - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amagansett, New York

New place with new possibilities of getting food in the Hamptons. Epic fail. Coffee- ordered a latte extra hot no foam. My cup was light as a feather. Clearly the barista doesn't know how to heat the milk without creating foam. The espresso was light and just a hint of coffee flavor. Food: got a croissant, a Bella Donna veg panini and a veg and Gruyère cheese frittata. Croissant was served ice cold and it was dense with no layers of buttery goodness. Frittata had potential but it was underwhelming. Veg panini according to the menu: Panini made on Rosemary Focaccia Bread Marinated Portobello, Vegan Cheese Roasted Red Peppers, Roasted Tomatoes, Micro Greens, Basil, Vegan Calabrian Chili Aioli, Vegan Pesto What I got was grilled veg, shredded cheese on a brioche style bread with rosemary bits sprinkled on top. barely saw a panini press despite being warm when I received it. Again the flavor was there but it just fell short. Seriously. If you say foccacia, I'm looking forward to a pillowy soft olive oil bread with rosemary. Look, maybe u guys were having an off day. I'll try again but won't go outta my way. read more

See all

1st time at this new spot. Enjoyed my coffee & avocado toast. The staff was friendly, bilingual & prompt with my order. The music & decor was relaxing, as well as the cozy seating. I will say that it was very hard to find. There is no visible sign off the street or even after pulling into the huge parking lot. It's in the back to the right. You have to walk in between the building to see it. Worth the stop. It was tasty. read more

Excellent coffee. Nice atmosphere. Outside seating. Breakfast sandwiches and baked goods. One of the only coffee places open on a Saturday evening. read more

I believe that Bonfire has the best product in Gansett. The coffee, food, Gelato ect is outstanding. A very welcoming atmosphere!

This place is great! Really delicious food and drinks. I like the fritattas and matcha, also the cappuccino is very good. Friendly staff and comfy seating. This cafe is a fantastic addition to Amagansett!! read more

Rainy day, after the Am O'gansett parade I stopped in with a friend. They weren't very busy, guess everyone stopped in to the full service restaurants on Main Street. This place is a gem, lots of choices for light meals, I personally had the Soup and Sandwich special, just $12 for a wonderful grilled cheese and a cup of Broccoli Cheddar Soup; filling and warm on a chilly, rainy day. Lots of choices for sandwiches, goodies, beverages, etc. Definitely worth it to stop in here! read more

Really cute little place. Got a speciality coffee that was divine. There was gluten free options and baked treats that were good. I loved the outside area. Overall 5/5 read more

Got a latte and a frittata and both were excellent and service was on point. My kids were in heaven with the large selection of drinks and treats. Great vibe, will definitely be back! read more

Great latte, great chia latte, great atmosphere. A hidden gem off of Main Street in Amagansett. Extensive menu for breakfast and lunch. read more

Love this place. Great coffee, impressive variety of grill items, and outstanding atmosphere. Plenty of room to sit inside and outside, and staff is friendly and accommodating, in contrast to Jack's Coffee on Main Street. read more

Super cute spot! Even during the off season they have tasty prepared food and yummy drinks. Looking forward to going back and trying a few more things from the menu! read more

Amazing food and sweet atmosphere! The staff was so kind and hospitable to our large group too.

Had the BLT with duck bacon and it was incredible! Very cute shop and the owners are awesome. Absolutely love this place!

honestly just writing this because I'm pissed... my cold brew cost 7. DOLLARS. COLD BREW!!!!!and it was mediocre... I also had the worst bacon egg and cheese in my life. it was 4 hard boiled eggs on a barely toasted ROLL..... hello?? Fine vibes in the store just exponentially overpriced :/ read more

Great addition to Amagansett- awesome fresh food, coffee and Gelato. Great outdoor area to hang and chill. Highly recommended!