These bagels were fresh and delicious!!! real New York style kind of chewy on the outside soft on…read morethe inside and when they're toasted makes a perfect crunch. The service was excellent. I got my order fast, hot and fresh. I hope they keep this up a lot of bagel places around here anymore definitely try this place!

I mean the food is alright but every time I'm here I feel like I'm overcharged and quite honestly…read moreI'm not come back. I can't wrap my head for a BEC on an egg everything 1lb of chicken salad and a 99c arnie Palmer drink comes out to $27. This is the 3rd time I left feeling like I got robbed. Unfortunately I won't be coming back due to the prices. Growing up in centereach/selden there are cheaper and better bagels there that might be worth the drive. Edit: I just checked my bank account it was actually $29.10

I have to out them. Big fan of flat bagels and gave one a try. It was simply an regular bagel…read morethat pounded down a bit before baking. Exact density as a regular bagel, just flattened out a little bit. The final insult was the price, $2.50 EACH. However super friendly and helpful people that work there, that's the other star.

Best bagels in the area. And reasonably priced. The owner is very fair and doesn't overcharge…read morepeople which is why I continue to go there.

Great bagels, reasonably priced. It's my go to place, especially if I'm picking up a dozen or two…read more It can be busy in the mornings, so be prepared for a short wait. Amazing price for their weekday lunch special. $8.50 for a sandwich on a roll or bagel, 1/4 salad, and a can of soda. Roast beef w/ cheese lunch special available every weekday. The sandwich is plump, doesn't cheap out because of the price. Slicer closes by 2pm.

Rather you're on the run or just got done with a double and in need of some delicious sandwiches,…read moreBagel Gallery is your spot to head to for all those late night cravings. Just imagine your local deli but never closing. So that means you can get your BECs any time you want! That's right, they're 24 hours! Bagel Gallery offers some great breakfast, lunch or dinner options it all depends what you're in the mood for. Bagel with cream cheese, done... bacon egg and cheese, some... A little Mobster sandwich action going, DONE! Cappacola, salami, Italian dressing and all the fixing freshly cut bread on a Semolina? Fuggetaboutitttttttt! Stop on by for a Sandi or two! Oh yeah, they're 24 hours and the Lox is still fresh and Smokey !

Found a pubic hair in my bacon egg and cheesegood thing I don't swallow it. A black curly one…read moretoo... it was on my cold egg, this place is really gross.

We came here as a quick stop leaving families house from out of town. Very cute place lots of…read morepeople in and out that seem like regulars so we were excited to try it. We had a bagel egg and cheese sandwich and a bagel with cream cheese. We enjoyed them both! They had plenty of other treats too but we didn't have time to dry them sadly. Next time. Thanks Terry!

This bagel shop is so nice and clean. The bagels here are always consistent and fresh. They always…read morehave a nice variety of assorted bagels and cream cheese. The service varies from some days being very fast to some days being extremely slow. I'm not sure why. They have deals on the white board when you walk in. The staff is always friendly .

We love this bagel place. The owner is SO nice ! The bagels are huge and always fresh! Our weekend…read morestaple. The kids especially love the rainbow bagels.

This location is sold to New people...now it's under new ownership…read more Hope bagels will be batter now with some smile!

Very interesting choice to give someone a chocolate chip cookie that is completely raw. All it…read moretakes is splitting them in half and you should see if it was raw or not. Not to mention i didn't even ask for a chocolate chip cookie i asked for a black and white. So not only was my order messed up but i was sent a raw replacement, cool ! At least the bagel was okay...

I wanted to share this for anyone buying the "low carb" bagels for health or blood sugar reasons. I…read morewear a continuous glucose monitor and tried these on two separate days to rule out a fluke. Both times, my blood sugar spiked significantly, similar to what I'd expect from a regular bagel. At $2.25 each, I was happy to pay if they were truly low carb, but based on my real-world readings, they are not. I'm not trying to bash a local business, I just think people who are diabetic, pre-diabetic, or eating low carb should know before spending the money or making health decisions based on the label. Marketing these as low carb is misleading, especially for people managing blood sugar. I like supporting local businesses, but I also think accuracy matters when it comes to health claims.

Awesome bagels! There are lots of bagel places but this one truly makes a great bagel. They are…read morekettled the old fashioned way which shows in the texture and crispiness! My favorite bagel! Whether I visit my family in Germany or my in-laws in Florida, there's always a dozen bagels flying with me... Super friendly service and the owner is a gem! Great place.

Best bagels I've ever had in recent days and also growing up. Service is fast and easy and is a…read morenice in and out type of place with street parking or parking in the LIRR lot across the street. The breakfast sandwiches are perfect and the bagels are fresh, soft on the inside and perfect on the outside. The cream cheese is also very fresh and delicious. It's a great local spot to go to in the local town.

What an absolutely fantastic experience. Walked in and was immediately greeted by a guy that…read moreappeared to be in charge. Owner perhaps? Place is clean and well organized. A great spot if you are looking for a quiet bite to eat and maybe get a little work done. On to the bagels. I got an everything with scallion cream cheese and a chocolate chip with butter. I was hoping for a cheese bagel but no luck. The bagels were awesome. The service was fantastic. The 2 folks I interacted with were very friendly. Highly recommend!!

Not a very organized spot for what you expect on Long Island. There just isn't any flow in the…read moreorder process so it's a free for all to the counter wondering who has ordered and who hasn't with no employees directing customers. Bagels are big and pretty decent. Skimping a bit on the toppings. Very odd that the jalapeño used for their cream cheese is pickled so you get a sour vinegar flavor in every bite. Not good. Prices are a bit in the higher side. $8.50 for a cream cheese bagel and small coffee. Service just blah overall. Egg sandwiches I have had in the past were solid. Place gets crazy busy on the weekends so expect a wait with above mentioned lack of organization.

I just stopped in this morning to get a bagel and lox and I was so impressed with Kevin my server…read more he made the most beautiful little platter I couldn't get over how beautiful it was and I couldn't get over that it was $11. I usually pay $17 for bagels and lox in Commack With nothing extra but a salad a little baby salad.

Never had a issues with the food only for the price it's not enough. They are over priced !…read moreService takes forever very slow ! The store is always a mess. I ordered a omelette and it was 12 dollars and it came with just the omelette no potatoes or toast. I won't be back !