Bagel Chalet is hands-down one of the best spots in Commack! I've been coming here for a while, and their quality and service are amazingly consistent. The bagels are phenomenal, but don't sleep on their lunch menu--the Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap is unbelievable. It comes with a side salad, and their cucumber salad is always fresh and delicious. The staff is consistently friendly, welcoming, and fast. I used to stop in years ago as a rep for Montauk Iced Tea, and while they don't carry that brand anymore, my love for this place hasn't changed a bit. If you're in the area, Bagel Chalet is absolutely worth checking out! read more

Bagel Chalet - My lunch - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

It's a no for me. I've been here several times. Typically I get one of their mediocre bagels or already assembled sandwiches. Today I built my own sandwich- the roll is beyond dry and crusty. I can hardly take a bite without it falling apart so I threw out the other half. Such a waste of money! read more

Here we go, So the hype was big about this Deli. I even passed by a couple of times while in the area and the line would be out the door. My BFF and I decided to check it out. We went after lunch crowd was over. It was about a few people sitting down in the dining area eating. Deli was very organized and clean. Customer service was OK. As we approached the counter of ordering I viewed the pastries which looked scrumptious. I decided to order the Apple Danish . My BFF ordered the chocolate muffin. Then we veiwed the sandwiches. I wasn't 100 percent sold on the sandwiches so I asked for my sandwich to be made fresh. However it wasnt . It was reheated. There is a big difference in taste from reheated to making it fresh. I just dealt with it. You would think after paying 46 dollars I would be satisfied, but to be honest with you I wasnt. After eating half of the sandwich I threw the other half away. Im thinking to myself ok maybe the Apple Danish would make up for it. No.. The Danish was very dry inside. Didn't really have any kind of kick to it. To be honest I was totally disappointed. Overall it was not the greatest but it wasnt the worst either. Im undecided if I would visit again. Happy Yelping. read more

See all

Solid bagel spot. Stopped for late breakfast during the work week, was busy but not crazy. Ordered an everything bagel with cheddar and 2 eggs scrambled, tasted good and came out hot. read more

Been coming here sinceforever Clean Bright Light Fresh selections of bagels and sandwiches Coffee selections plentiful BUT flavor pumps behind counter! Eggs fresh and affordable unless you start adding things Enjoy read more

Bagel Chalet - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Had a turkey on a bagel with tom(very cheap with tomato) and mayo. super bland sandwich , also had potato salad with it and it was the worst I have ever had. I had to throw the salad out. My friend had the macaroni salad and that too was terrible. Don't know how they are so busy. read more

Love that there are so many food options to choose from. Their bagels are so delicious but to be honest, my go to are the flagels & bialys. Their fresh salad bar is the best because you have so many unlimited options to choose from to be added into it & it also includes your choice of a bagel, flagel, pita or bagel chips. All of their other salads, veggie tuna, chicken, mac, potato, coleslaw & others that I've tried were all fresh & delicious. The employees behind the counter are quick to get orders processed since it gets packed with ppl. They also have a large area with many tables to sit at but as I've mentioned, they do get really crowded at times so you may have to wait for a table. Enjoy!!!! read more

See all

I wanted to share this for anyone buying the "low carb" bagels for health or blood sugar reasons. I wear a continuous glucose monitor and tried these on two separate days to rule out a fluke. Both times, my blood sugar spiked significantly, similar to what I'd expect from a regular bagel. At $2.25 each, I was happy to pay if they were truly low carb, but based on my real-world readings, they are not. I'm not trying to bash a local business, I just think people who are diabetic, pre-diabetic, or eating low carb should know before spending the money or making health decisions based on the label. Marketing these as low carb is misleading, especially for people managing blood sugar. I like supporting local businesses, but I also think accuracy matters when it comes to health claims. read more

Very interesting choice to give someone a chocolate chip cookie that is completely raw. All it takes is splitting them in half and you should see if it was raw or not. Not to mention i didn't even ask for a chocolate chip cookie i asked for a black and white. So not only was my order messed up but i was sent a raw replacement, cool ! At least the bagel was okay... read more

Happy to say that my egg sandwich is back to being delicious!!!! Bacon was delicious!!! Tasted and smelled like bacon! Woohoo!

Variety taste and business hours!..Don't people know ? I might want a bagel after 3:00 pm!!!! It's very disappointing to have a craving for a bagel with.... And they are all closed! Except BAGEL CHALET! And they offer so many amazing goodies! OMG! read more

Best bagels on Long Island. My daughter Nina orders from them all the time there so kind n fast in their service and her standing order only if they have fresh heroes(which they do) plain ham n mozzarella side of mac salad ready in 10mins n off to work she goes I always get a dozen on Sunday line is out the door for a reason but I've only waited 10-15mins tops..SO WORTH IT read more

This place is good.. I've ordered for delivery before but this place gets you in and out. There was a good amount of people ordering and the wait time was minimal. Food was great and service just as good. read more

Bagel Chalet - French toast bagel with strawberry cream cheese. - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

i get the eggplant special and junior special sometimes, and they have really good salads. the bread on the eggplant special with all the seeds and the type of mayonnaise they put is SO YUMMY. i been coming here for years! read more

Bagel Chalet - Eggplant Special Panini - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Best bagels on LI. There is absolutely nothing that compares to a fresh everything bagel from Bagel Chalet. Been coming here for years and always order a dozen to go. Although the prices have increased and the bagels have seemingly gotten smaller, I would still say that the satisfaction I get is worth every extra penny! read more

Bagel Chalet - everything - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

The bagels are great, not too much of a beverage selection but it's ok. You can sit and eat like a normal person which is good as a lot of stores don't have seating. But please do yourself a favor and order over the phone before you get there, sometimes the lines are just too long. read more

Bagel Chalet The staff at Bagel Chalet are nothing short of just spectacular. I mean these guys are SPECIAL. Day in and day out, the individuals that make up the Bagel Chalet team are putting in 110% to make your food perfect. They work effortlessly as a unit with their attention to detail and efficiency. The other day, I was at Bagel Chalet on the Friday after Thanksgiving. The place was packed and as I soon realized, this place is packed every day of the week because of the name brand and the reputation it has put out into the community. I was in line for less than 5 minutes and got my food within 10 minutes of getting there. This is not just a bagel place, this is a staple of the community. There was a certain energy that ran through the place. I tried their flagel with jalapeño cream cheese and it was nothing short of SPECTACULAR. I don't think I've ever had a schmear this good in a long time. The jalapeño cream cheese was flavorful and has a little bit of a kick to it that was refreshing. The flagel was surprisingly large and tasted very fresh. To go along with the flagel, I also got an iced coffee that paired very well it. I will definitely be back as I have also heard amazing things about the pasta and the other items at Bagel Chalet. Might have to be one of the best places on Long Island for bagels. read more

Bagel Chalet - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Good bagel spot with a lot of options on the menu and the salad bar looked good. I enjoyed my everything bagel with olive cream cheese (although kind of lacking on bagel size for the price) and the wait wasn't too bad in the early afternoon on a weekday. The counter line gets squishy so make sure you know what you want before you get to the register. Coffee creamers and sugar are self serve which I like but they are right in the way of people trying to get away from the register after paying (be warned - you need to move it). While tasty, their prices are really high - $5.75 for a bagel with olive cream cheese is wild. And $2.10 for just a plain bagel is twice the price of other places. I'll be going back to my usual spot. read more

Horrible overpriced food, rude workers. Saw a cockroach on floor after I ordered and sat and tried to eat the food. Brought to their attention and they just shrugged their shoulders. Never again. Disgusting read more

Monster INFLATION has hit this place hard: A soft drink is $3.65 and a small coffee is TOO! That's more than STARBUCKS small coffee !!!!!! WHAT ? Receipts are not ITEMIZED . Sketchy practice. Makes the customer Uneasy. Food is big and good. Take that as you like. read more

It was my favorite deli to pick up breakfast before going to work... until today. One of their STUPID cooks thought it was ok to leave eggshells in my breakfast. You guys need to do some firing and you have lost a customer . read more

The absolute worst sandwiches. We ordered a chicken cutlet on a hero and they literally split one cutlet in half and put that on the sandwich for $14. Also ordered a hungryman special that was lite on the meat as well.Unbelievable. This place is the worst and skimps on all toppings and meat for the sandwiches. So many other good bagel shops in the area. read more

I'm in the minority, but I don't come here for the sought after flagels. I just prefer a decent water boiled bagel when I crave a bagel sandwich whether that's bec, lox or real cream cheese. Bagel Chalet does it all in a simple and uncomplicated set up. From croissants and coffee to freshly made wraps and parfaits, you definitely can satisfy your appetite! I've never not seen them at least a little overwhelmed by the crowds, but I appreciate their professionalism and down to earth demeanor of the hardworking staff. It's a convenient stop when I go to church in Dix Hills, however It's nice they opened a second location on the south shore too which may be of greater convenience to the rest of us. Share the bagel love! read more

Bagel Chalet - Butter Croissant and Beach (the latter is highly recommended afterwards) - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Been going here for a while. It's a solid place, but they do get orders wrong a bit more than most places. The prices are also a bit high. An everything bagel with egg white, spinach, swiss cheese, and bacon was over $10. What prompted me to make this review is the $10 sandwich was missing one of the ingredients altogether: the bacon. Not the first time this has happened. Sadly considering to going to a further place from now on. read more

Bagel Chalet - Yummy bagel, but $10 and missing bacon - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

We ordered two breakfast sandwiches, two pieces of ham were added for three dollars. Two coffees. 21.00. Ridiculously overpriced was bad enough but the order was also wrong. I get they were crowded and everything is expensive but this seems excessive. I can get the same sandwich at bagel port for 6.00 with a free coffee. I will not be returning. read more

I'm incredibly disappointed by my food. I grew up coming here and they have to had changed their recipe because these tasted like grocery store bagels. They used to be large and heavily seasoned and now they are the opposite. I can't come here anymore. read more

My coworkers and I ordered on Uber eats. So cheap with the cream cheese. Bagels were burnt. For the price it was horrible. Never ordering again. read more

Bagel Chalet - Burnt lox bagel with almost no lox - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

I found it unbelievable that this place charged me $2.25 for a plain poppy seed roll. They make their own bread!!! I always thought their prices were high but food is usually good, but to charge this amount for a plain roll is insane. I will never shop there again. read more

Ever since we moved, we are going here so often. The long line is intimating but it moves! The bagels are always fresh and sandwiches always taste great. Hits the spot every time for breakfast or lunch. We have also ordered through Seamless before as well. They really make sure that you are not waiting for a long period of time. They have bagels, flavored bagels, and flagels. Just about anything you can think of- they have. Definitely recommend this place to anyone we know. read more

This place runs like a well oiled machine. The line can be practically going out the door and you'll still get through the line in a reasonable amount of time. I'm a huge fan of their everything flagel bacon, egg, and Swiss cheese. Sometimes I even opt for the turkey bacon and their equally delicious! read more

Bagel Chalet - Turkey bacon, Swiss cheese, everything flagel (BEC) - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

This place pumps out some serious business... they are always hustlin n bustlin! But it moves quick, so don't fret! The bagels here are always fresh and not burnt and they have a great variety. I'm more of a flagel girl and love their sesame and everything flagels! Also, their veggie cream cheese has nice chunks of veggies in it. They will pretty much make you whatever you want and it will taste good.. I've lived in a different town my whole life and moved closer near here but I was still coming here when I wasn't as close. Everyone knows about this place, obvi since it's always busy! Another fan favorite in my book is their everything flagel with veggie cc, lox, onion, and tomato! Fast paced, fairly priced, huge variety of bagels, cream cheeses, and homemade salads (love their pickle salad) will make anyone who pops in here happy they came. read more

When in the area, the Bagel Chalet is my go to place for lunch. It's no bullshit when I say it is well managed and the staff is of the highest caliber of in the business. World class food in a clean environment. You won't be disappointed. read more

All around amazing bagels! They have a huge variety of foods here, not just bagels. My go to order is an onion bagel with cream cheese, tomato, onion, & lox. I also order sunflower flagels quite often. They hold up great in the freezer. Price wise, this place is in range but on the higher end compared to other Long Island bagel stores. They also have delicious chopped salads which are quite popular. Huge parking lot in front. Right now, masks are required but social distancing wasn't strictly enforced while I was here. People were on top of each other while ordering and paying. Workers were also wearing masks and gloves. It gets EXTREMELY crowded here! Beware there might be a wait. They have also set up tables outside to eat. Overall, great fresh bagels! read more

See all

Very tasty! Bacon, egg, and cheese on an egg everything bagel. I'm from South Florida. Have not been to New York in over 20 years. NY has REAL bagels! So soft and delicious. Would recommend. read more

The food here is excellent. The bagels, sandwiches, salads & more. It is a bit pricey compared to other bagel shops. Portions can also be a little small for price (wraps etc). Always packed on the weekend. The offer low carb bagels that actually taste delicious. Extensive menu, deli & baked goods to choose from. Egg sandwiches are one of my favorite things to get! read more

I used to frequent this place but on my last visit I noticed the prices are out of control. Just lost my business. $2.25 for a plain bagel is just ridiculous and then they charge you a surcharge for using a credit card! The place was empty. I wonder why? read more

Do not eat here my bagel was not cooked, old and the cream cheese was not evenly distributed among the bagel. The person attending me didn't do what I asked and did not give me my ice tea. Also it's to expensive $30 for 2 bacon egg and cheese and 1 bagel like what. The tables were dirty. read more

Simple bagel turkey lettuce and tomato with mustard. Turkey was dry lettuce was wilted and turning brown and the whole thing was drowned in mustard. I was disappointed but maybe I'll give it another try on a different day. read more

Here at bagel chalet, the staff are all working as one. I was particularly impressed by their attention to detail. I observed most of the staff remembered many of the customers orders. I ordered a cinnamon raisin bagel lightly toasted with cream cheese. The bagel was most definitely fresh and delicious! There's almost always a line practically put the door, but don't fret, it will go quickly. I would also recommend the #6 hero for lunch. The garlic bread is almost always toasted to perfection, not too much and not too little garlic. I usually ask for extra cheese and hot sauce. Parking is quite convenient as it's bagel chalet is located in a giant shopping center. So while your at target or bjs take a ride over to bagel chalet and see for yourself! read more

Amazing food quick dielvery with great food Good selection of food .amazing staff and super friendly super quick line read more