This bagel spot is next to my house and we couldn't be happier! There is a large selection of cream…read morecheese, like their new Dubai Chocolate and they are constantly filling the hot fresh bagels. I really enjoy their breakfast platters, like the western omelette and home fries. Their French toast platter is phenomenal as well, a must try. They do get busy, but don't let that scare you away. They have parking in the front and back plus, make an online order to skip the line THEN pick it up to the left door...they have an extension now that was built specifically for online orders.

Wally's Bagels in Long Island was hands down the best bagel I have ever had. Coming from Syracuse,…read morewhere *I THOUGHT* we had some top tier bagels, this completely elevated my expectations. These bagels were so fresh, soft, and perfectly chewy. Not crunchy at all, just exactly how a bagel should be. I ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a rainbow bagel with salt, pepper, and ketchup. I had never done the salt and pepper with ketchup combo before, but my friend recommended it and I am so glad she did. It was incredible. I could not stop thinking about these bagels the entire weekend. We literally ended up going both days. The ambience was chill, exactly what you would want from a bagel spot. The customers were kind and friendly and the service matched that same energy. I am so grateful my friend brought me here and introduced me to what real, fresh bagels are supposed to taste like. This place is unforgettable.

This place is going in my oh yeah "I'll come by here again" list. The bagels are so delicious…read moreespecially this tomato bagel. There's no big line which I'm surprised because the food is amazing. Customer service is good they are very nice people and I usually don't have to wait that's long for my order. Overall, if you were ever in Bay Shore montauk do stop by

Went in on a weekday morning, waited for 15 minutes as the 10 people behind the counter did…read moremiscellaneous tasks other than help the people on line. But remember now there are two different lines, which I don't think any of the customers even realize, nor did I for the first 10 minutes. One line is for bagels the other is for the grill. That didn't matter though because neither line was moving. Finally after 15 minutes I ordered an everything bagel with plain cream cheese. The price? $5. Actually it was $5 and change but I paid with cash so I guess I got a deal!! Customers and staff all seemed confused. Skip this place next time you're looking for a bagel.

Decided to split a bagel with my daughter. One bagel with chicken salad and cheddar. One small…read morevitamin water. Are you ready? $18.15 Am I out of touch? I figured 11 or 12 dollars at the most. Insane. The price put me off but then we ate it. Tasted like they added simple syrup to it. There was nothing but celery and chic. No cranberries. Horrible! On the plus side,they were friendly.

Best bagels in town!! friendly owner and staff bacon egg and…read morecheese sandwiches were amazing also!!

Once in a rare while I venture over to West Islip for the bagels in which I have set my standards…read moreby since I was a teenager. Turns out this place was not even on the yelp map yet!! I am astonished by this. It is so befitting and such an honor to be the one to add them.. Know what I think? West Islip is protecting their little hidden diamond where the bagels are so gooey and warm that all is right in the world with a bite. Its just not fair, we all should have these sexy simple classic bagels. Fancy cream cheeses and salads they are not- this place is old school. They do however do egg sandwiches, which I cant even think of right now or I will stop writing and head back in for one and Im way to full already. My buttered bagel was 2.67 with coffee- There are no tables but your bagel will not make it out if the parking lot alive I assure you. If you come in here tell em I sent you- they wont know who you are talking about but the shy 14 year old inside me who has adored this place since the doors opened back in the early 90s will feel honored.

Honestly love this place more than the other bagel spots in town. Their bagels are the freshest…read more Pretty busy but def worth it And Tina is amazing!!!

Friendly staff. They were accommodating with my order. The bagel was soft and delicious! I didn't…read moreeven mind hearing Stevie B on the speaker .

The new owner did his big one with this location update. He's so sweet, nice, gives you that…read moreSouthern Hospitality vibe. Also black-owned which is nice to see being that CI just up the road is a diverse place. Definitely try them. The bagels were fresh, creamy cheese so good! Hot Sandwiches bomb!

This is a local bodega serving Dominican food. It's clearly a neighborhood staple, with a steady…read moreflow of customers coming in on their lunch break. I stopped in to grab something quick. They offer a large plate for $14.99 and a small starting at $9, which comes with rice, beans, and a choice of meat. There are also fried empanadas and a cold salad section available. I ordered arroz con gandules, beans, and half of a small roasted chicken. The food wasn't as hot as I expected for items sitting on the line. Flavor-wise, it was decent but nothing that stood out. Pricing felt a little high--my large meal and a Coke came out to just under $19 with tax. I'd probably stop by again if I was in a rush and craving Spanish food, but overall it was a lackluster experience.

Here we go, This is a follow up review from the prior…read morereview. Great deli. Good food. Go on Friday when the shrimp special happens. Shrimps are so delicious. Nice and crunchy ,great taste seasoned very well. In order to get some of these shrimps go early before 12pm. Store is always stocked with drinks variety of snacks but most of all great food. Workers which are related to one another . They are always friendly and smiling. Portions of food are reasonable for the money . Check this deli out. Happy yelping.

Chicken noodle soup is goood the place looks cute inside a small little deli located in a townread more

Recently changed owners. The new owner had one of the best bagel places on Long Island ,Bagelicious…read morein East Meadow. They catered the party I attended. Heroes were amazing, and literaly the best potato salad I have had , since 1999. The year I moved. Thinly sliced and just delicious. My wife and I stopped in on our way to McCarther Airport. We were greeted by 2 very nice counter workers. We both ordered different roast beef subs. And potatoe salad with bacon. My sandwich was the munchie. A staple at Bagelicious. Plenty of meat on both . We ate half our sandwiches at the outside table, and finished the other half at the airport. If we move back to Long Island, I would get a sandwich , every weekend.

This spot never misses! Quick and friendly service . Such a wide variety of menu items . One stop…read moreshop. Really really fresh and delicious . Pro tip: they are also on the TooGoodToGo app. I am able to get a dozen variety bagels for at most $6!

I've been going here for about a year now for my morning coffee and occasional bagels/muffins…read more However, since my husband "discovered" them through searching for a good bagel shop it has become our Sunday morning spot for his bacon, egg and cheese sandwiches. Sometimes we try something different but always go back to the original. Even when it's extremely busy the staff is always friendly and try to be as fast as possible. Enough seats for a quick bite with some of the best coffee shop coffee I've had in a long time.