Sunrise Bagel

This bagel shop is very affordable compared to others. I got a simple plain bagel with a little…read morebutter and jelly toasted. I appreciate when I request a little butter and I actually do get it. Owner is nice and works hard. It is more if a take out spot.

Nice little place. You can enjoy bagel or snack in cozy chairs. Great place to have a talk with…read morefriends or read the papers.

Outside

See all

Wally's Bagels

4.0(278 reviews)

4.9 mi

the best bagels, egg sandwiches and service on Long Island. Been going for years. I love the online…read moreordering

This bagel spot is next to my house and we couldn't be happier! There is a large selection of cream…read morecheese, like their new Dubai Chocolate and they are constantly filling the hot fresh bagels. I really enjoy their breakfast platters, like the western omelette and home fries. Their French toast platter is phenomenal as well, a must try. They do get busy, but don't let that scare you away. They have parking in the front and back plus, make an online order to skip the line THEN pick it up to the left door...they have an extension now that was built specifically for online orders.

Cream Cheese Bagel (on a Egg Bagel)

See all

August 2025

Bagel Boss - Bayshore

2.2(236 reviews)

0.6 mi

This place is going in my oh yeah "I'll come by here again" list. The bagels are so delicious…read moreespecially this tomato bagel. There's no big line which I'm surprised because the food is amazing. Customer service is good they are very nice people and I usually don't have to wait that's long for my order. Overall, if you were ever in Bay Shore montauk do stop by

People very unprofessional and racist I waiti for like 10 minutes wouldn't help me then people walk…read morein and got help right away don't eat there

The eggs sold at $2.99 (price marked), but the guy was charging an extra dollar for it bc the egg prices went up.

Cheese danish

See all

TGTG Mixed Bag. Thank you Bagel Boss! 9-8-2024

West Islip Hot Bagels

3.8(26 reviews)

3.9 mi

Honestly love this place more than the other bagel spots in town. Their bagels are the freshest…read more Pretty busy but def worth it And Tina is amazing!!!

Food and service was great. It's always busy so if you can call ahead for pick up. The staff is…read morevery nice and the bagels are fresh.

Everything egg, June 2024

August 2024

See all

November 2024

M & M Bagels

4.8(4 reviews)

3.3 mi

Friendly staff. They were accommodating with my order. The bagel was soft and delicious! I didn't…read moreeven mind hearing Stevie B on the speaker .

The new owner did his big one with this location update. He's so sweet, nice, gives you that…read moreSouthern Hospitality vibe. Also black-owned which is nice to see being that CI just up the road is a diverse place. Definitely try them. The bagels were fresh, creamy cheese so good! Hot Sandwiches bomb!

Wide array

Catering

See all

French toast

Bay Shore Deli & Grocery

4.7(20 reviews)

0.9 mi

Since writing my first review, my intrigue turned into a weekly visit! The food is unreal!…read moreAbsolutely delicious and I keep trying these new foods I would never eat. I wish I ate bell peppers, because a lot of their dishes have them. So even on a limited selection for me, they always have Plenty of fresh variety. If you are lucky enough to be there when the fried, butterfly shrimp tray comes out, be prepared for a "Wall Street like" experience to erupt! Lol. I have had amazing Yucca, beef patties, fried shrimp, pulled chicken and 12 things I can't pronounce! They don't have signage and if you speak Spanish you can order in Spanish also. Best hot food you can buy and you get charged by the container load, so you get nice portions for the money. If they were going to fix anything, they would have better signage that explains what everything is. But it gives it a mystery appeal I guess that makes it desirable. Definitely eat here for the ultimate bodega hot food experience.

This is a local bodega serving Dominican food. It's clearly a neighborhood staple, with a steady…read moreflow of customers coming in on their lunch break. I stopped in to grab something quick. They offer a large plate for $14.99 and a small starting at $9, which comes with rice, beans, and a choice of meat. There are also fried empanadas and a cold salad section available. I ordered arroz con gandules, beans, and half of a small roasted chicken. The food wasn't as hot as I expected for items sitting on the line. Flavor-wise, it was decent but nothing that stood out. Pricing felt a little high--my large meal and a Coke came out to just under $19 with tax. I'd probably stop by again if I was in a rush and craving Spanish food, but overall it was a lackluster experience.

Bacon egg and cheese on a roll

See all

Seafood platter Fried shrimp, fried whiting , salmon and rice

Maple Street Deli

4.5(50 reviews)

1.3 mi

Recently changed owners. The new owner had one of the best bagel places on Long Island ,Bagelicious…read morein East Meadow. They catered the party I attended. Heroes were amazing, and literaly the best potato salad I have had , since 1999. The year I moved. Thinly sliced and just delicious. My wife and I stopped in on our way to McCarther Airport. We were greeted by 2 very nice counter workers. We both ordered different roast beef subs. And potatoe salad with bacon. My sandwich was the munchie. A staple at Bagelicious. Plenty of meat on both . We ate half our sandwiches at the outside table, and finished the other half at the airport. If we move back to Long Island, I would get a sandwich , every weekend.

This is the second I tired out the deli before reviewing. I'm really not sure how a deli does not…read morehave grilled chicken, that seems like something standard to offer for sandwiches and wraps. I had thought maybe they just ran out the first time I went, so when I went back a month later, to my surprise, they still didn't have that. I was able to get fried chicken cutlet instead, which isn't what I truly wanted as I am trying to eat better, but it was good, just not what I had wanted. They did not have whole wheat wraps, the did not have avocado and they did not have chipotle mayo. I really struck out on this deli. I had also ordered a sausage egg and cheese which was good, but the bagel was just ok. It's truly been an issue finding a good deli around Bay Shore.

See all

Owner received recognition of new name change

Railroad Bagel Express

4.5(77 reviews)

5.8 mi

This spot never misses! Quick and friendly service . Such a wide variety of menu items . One stop…read moreshop. Really really fresh and delicious . Pro tip: they are also on the TooGoodToGo app. I am able to get a dozen variety bagels for at most $6!

I've been going here for about a year now for my morning coffee and occasional bagels/muffins…read more However, since my husband "discovered" them through searching for a good bagel shop it has become our Sunday morning spot for his bacon, egg and cheese sandwiches. Sometimes we try something different but always go back to the original. Even when it's extremely busy the staff is always friendly and try to be as fast as possible. Enough seats for a quick bite with some of the best coffee shop coffee I've had in a long time.

Another bagel pick up from TooGoodToGo. Literally over a dozen bagels

See all

Bagel bag from TooGoodToGo app

Grace Deli And Bagel

3.7(47 reviews)

1.9 mi

Bagels are stale and hard as a rock. Had to throw it out. Maybe a sandwich or something would be…read morebetter, I'm not sure. The cream cheese was good, just very limited.

Spent 70 bucks on wings and they didn't give a single dipping sauce. No blue cheese, no ranch,…read morenothing. For that price I could've bought frozen wings and my own ranch and been happier. Will never re order from them.

See all

Higbie Bagels

3.4(58 reviews)

4.6 mi

Good bagels. The Grubhub menu should allow you to order how much cream cheese you need. I ordered…read morethe "specialty cream cheese" for a dozen bagels and received 1/4 lb containers. Ordered Poppy, Everything, and Egg Everything bagels- received plain egg instead of Egg Everything. Ordered a Baker's Dozen, but only received 12 bagels.

Disappointed and Misled I was sold "vegan cream cheese"…read moreafter being assured multiple times it was vegan, only to later learn it wasn't. My daughter, who is dairy-sensitive, had a severe reaction. Though they refunded my money, this is a serious issue. This place used to run like a Swiss clock, but sadly, that's no longer the case.