This place is going in my oh yeah "I'll come by here again" list. The bagels are so delicious especially this tomato bagel. There's no big line which I'm surprised because the food is amazing. Customer service is good they are very nice people and I usually don't have to wait that's long for my order. Overall, if you were ever in Bay Shore montauk do stop by read more

See all

People very unprofessional and racist I waiti for like 10 minutes wouldn't help me then people walk in and got help right away don't eat there read more

Their bagels are the best on long island. The line was short and the staff very friendly. I will continue to go there.

I forgot photos on my journey to NY but we tried this place for breakfast. Unreal. I didn't even have the Bagels as the breakfast burrito was unbelievable. Egg, bacon, cheese and home fries on white tortilla. Soo good. Small plaza size shop. Super busy. Not the quickest but I wouldn't call them slow either. Kind of weird how the restaurant runs the stands, with 2 different areas to order and pay. Quality food. Overall 8.8 for the score. read more

I order 2 chicken cutlets sandwich on a roll $36 I think it's insane. Not only that it gave me and my husband the biggest stomach ache ever!!! Never again. So disappointed. read more

Tasted fine.. but for a $13 chicken caesar salad wrap .. I would've hoped there was at least more than a shred of lettuce in the wrap. Especially since there's a ton of dressing. Two stars bc the chicken tasted good but really lousy made wrap. read more

Bagel Boss - Bayshore - Caterers Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Everyone is so nice and the bagels are delicious. I moved out of New York 10 years ago and love to get bagels when I come back. These bagels are delicious and tasty. Crisp on the outside and soft and flavorful on the inside. It's a real cute shop too. I'm definitely coming back and recommend this store to all. read more

Omg the prices! I got an BEC on a roll. And it was $9.48!!!!!! Whatttttt. Never again. This was my first and last time here. It is gross the ceiling is brown and nasty from the oils. Do not come here if you're looking for a good Long Island bagel. read more

I am from Connecticut and one of the joys of my 25+ years of visiting my in-laws (they are awesome too) is the ambrosia of a Bagel Boss bagel. Specifically, and I'm not kidding, the Oat Bran Bagel Boss bagel is the very best bagel I have ever tasted (and I have tried tons of bagels, Ess a Bagel, Boston Bagels, etc). The Oat Bran Bagel is kind of "off the menu" and you need to ask for it as they tend to make smaller batches of these Oat Bran Bagels. Don't be fooled by the name "Oat Bran" ---- just try one of these and you imho will be blown away how good it is. Ok, and here is the reason for the 4 and not 5 stars....value. At Costco I can get about four or five bagels for the price of one Bagel Boss bagel. The Costco bagels are of course not as good, and are smaller. However, I just wish Bagle Boss brought back a little more value. (I'm willing to buy in bulk - as bagel lovers know, Bagels freeze very well). Having said all this, Bagel Boss rules, the staff is fine, the Bagels are wonderful and the veggie cream cheese is hands down the best cream cheese I have ever tasted. Yeah, I guess if you want the best, sometimes you need to pay a little more. Good place and I love that it exists. read more

I like the bagels but the service is way too slow. I watch all the goofing around of the young employees and wonder why management allows it. There will be a long line and the girls just take their sweet time, no concern at all. Must be a fun place to work but to its customer it's not funny. read more

Hot trash probably the worst bagel I had in New York Soy bacon "plant based menu" wait what!? Eggs seem microwaved The Cheddar cheese was basically craft American & bagel was stale read more

Well... Waited over 30 minutes as I didn't know there are TWO different lines depending on what you're ordering. The line to the left is just bagels and the line to the right is the grill...so breakfast sandwiches and what not. I don't understand why I can't order an egg sandwich on the bagel line as I'm getting a bagel. Makes NO sense. So after I waited on the wrong line the girl behind the counter said "the grill is full so you have to wait on that line." I understand the grill being "full" as it's a Saturday morning, but I don't understand why my order can't be taken . So I go over to the other line. A gentleman was nice enough to let me go in front of him as he saw that I waited on the wrong line. I noticed that eggs were being cooked ahead of time. No wonder the grill was full. Piles and piles of bacon and eggs just sitting there. Cheese added to order. I don't like the idea of eggs being premade like that and just sitting there. No wonder the grill was full! My sandwich wasn't even that good. Would have been better if it was made fresh. Bagel was good though, but the contents of the sandwich was blah and meh. It also cost $7.05!!! That's the most I've ever paid for an egg sandwich on Long Island. Also, when I was waiting on the line I heard an employee (blonde haired woman) yell and curse out a customer on the phone. That is so unprofessional. I won't return. read more

Bagel Boss - Bayshore - Inside of BEC - Caterers Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

In disbelief at the amount of cream cheese on this bagel no wonder its is so expensive. read more

Bagel Boss - Bayshore - 2 pounds of Plain Cream Cheese no wonder its so expensive! - Caterers Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Please, please, PLEASE do not handle money and then touch food. Change your gloves after working the register.

Several breakfast and lunch sandwiches, also bulk bagels were very good while I have been in the area for medical appointments. Oct.2024-Dec. 31st 2024. Many Staff on hand when busy , tip your server direct, dealt with several staff members, all were nice and attentive. Mike B. read more

This used to be my go to for bagels in LI for over 15 years. Recently I've noticed a lot of the employees are not changing their gloves in between making orders, changing full bags of trash out of the trash can, wiping down the display where the bagels are removing bagel debris, and taking money at the register. I literally watched 4 of the 5 employees behind the counter one day go through at least 3/4 customers each without anyone changing gloves in between taking money and making orders. There was 1 employee (young lady, short hair) who changed her gloves each time. If she's not there I won't get any food from this establishment. read more

I don't mind paying for good food. But when the price is outrageous and the quality is terrible i have a problem. I called in my order i go to pick it up. They just started to make it. Sloppiest sandwiches I've ever seen my egg sandwich had so much ketchup i couldn't even eat it. When she was ringing me up the lady was screaming at me bc she couldn't hear. Didn't put any utensils in the bag for the salad or napkins. read more

This place is always so busy and honestly not worth the price. It is great if you're in a pinch for a bagel but not my go-to. I do love the service and always feel welcomed but it can be so chaotic sometimes it isn't my favorite. read more

This place looks like it hasn't been cleaned since 1980, unorganized with the ordering process. After waiting to make an order someone just walks in and orders without waiting, I commented but the guy working there blew me off, so I walked out. read more

I don't know how this place stays in business! Probably because they are one of a kind in the area. You wait in line 15-20 minutes. No one acknowledges you. A large amount of staff works behind the counter in some kind of chaotic fashion, bumping into each other and fighting for grill time. When someone finally takes your order, they don't seem to know how to prepare your food or what comes with it. I have been here a dozen times and each experience is an exercise in frustration and aggravation. read more

My absolute go-to for simple, yet incorrect bagel orders and an incompetent staff. Be prepared to ask 3-4 times about the status of your order and to be met by confused looks. read more

I went there at 6am, and asked for a turkey egg and cheese on a bagel. She looked confused. Then she made a cold turkey and cheese sandwhich on a bagel and charged me the price of a hero. I was in a tush and didnt get to redo my order, but jf youre reading this you ruined my morning. read more

What a bunch of numbskulls. Went here a few weeks ago for an onion bagel at about 8 in the morning. Guy behind the counter looked confused then said they had none. Didn't ask anyone else, just told me "no". That early they were completely sold out? Biggest bagel shop around? Weird. So as I'm walking to my car he runs out to tell me he found some (and charges me full price for my trouble) Today I gave them another chance and I see they have a full basket of onion. I get home... she gave me a garlic which I hate. You had ONE JOB!! Don't you know bagels?!?! I gave you a second chance and you blew it. Bye! read more

Very overpriced. Subpar food. Egg sandwiches are ridiculously overpriced for what you get. The staff is incredibly slow and rude

These used to be the best bagels on Long Island. The perfect NY style: crisp on the outside, soft on the inside. At some point they changed ownership and now the bagels are awful. Soft and "bready" on the outside, bland on the inside. A massive disappointment. read more

Good bagels but have fun waiting 25 min for 2 bagels. Forget about ordering an egg sandwich, with the 20 employees behind the counter you think the line goes quick.. but nope read more

While the bagels & breakfast sandwiches are good, the service is awful. I have only lived in Bay shore for 5 days and already had 2 issues with this store. One time I ordered a bacon egg & cheese and a bagel with cream cheese, a very simple order. The young guy with longer hair brings my food to the counter, totally forgetting my bagel with cream cheese (not the biggest deal), but still taking additional time to complete my order as he had forgot. Because I know how long the lines are, the next time I ordered I called in ahead of time so I didn't have to wait. Bacon egg & cheese & a bagel with cream cheese, again a simple order, they said 25 mins. I get into the store 30 mins after I called and walk to the front to ask for my pick up order. They NEVER made it, so they proceed to try and tell me "sorry it was busy" which is an intolerable excuse as that's the whole reason why I had called to order ahead of time. The same young guy with longer hair proceeded to tell me he was going to make it now, and I was just over the situation and told him to please cancel my order & I walked out. It's sad that the level of service is so subpar bc the bagels are good. On top of the service not being great, they are also very slow. I think the owner needs to evaluate the people being hired bc their business could be run so much better. read more

-seems like they have a large selection of bagels -they don't seem like a gourmet deli for sandwiches -service was slow for the sandwich -worked forgot to get me my pasta salad and charged me for it -store looks run down and old read more

Bagel Boss - Bayshore - Selection of bagels - Caterers Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Just received my order and it was wrong. I can not have cheese or dressing . Both were on my sandwich after confirming twice they would not be on it. They forgot my ice tea and side that comes with it. Very disappointed. read more

So I go today to get a dozen bagels and a pound of cream cheese it cost me $31. I also asked if there was a Hospital discount and they said no there are discounts for Fireman policeman and teachers but not for Hospital employees. What a crock of crap. please Ban this place!!! local Hospital In Bayshore please protest!!!! and BOYCOTT hospital employees deserve a discount too! read more

Way too expensive.. does not take orders over the phone. Messed up my order. Very confusing cause people don't really know which line to get in. read more

The grown man behind the counter acts like a lunatic, and is rude to everyone. I walked out without ordering, and he was so mean to one of his young coworkers, and berating her in front and to of customers. read more

I'm not a big fan of the bagels here anymore, I only visit this store if I'm too lazy to drive a little further to a different bagel spot. It's just ok. read more

Foods subpar , prices are always different ,staff is rude . One star Subpar food , rude employees, prices are different every time .one star read more

I ordered a wrap that was supposed to have turkey, Swiss, lettuc and spicy mayo. No Swiss, no mayo, no lettuce and a few Measly slices of turkey. Is this a joke? For $12?!? I would not recommend this establishment. read more

Bagel Boss - Bayshore - Disappointing and WAY over priced for what you actually receive. - Caterers Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I just left Bagel Boss. I ordered an everything flagel with cream cheese and a small coffee..it was $11.45 ...Are you kidding me??? I will never go there again. That is insane for that. read more

Ordered the Homefries with bacon and cheese. Enjoyed every single bite. I highly recommend this joint for breakfast, lunch or dinner. The coffee is good too! read more

Way over priced because only bagel shop around. Staff very slow. Food was horrible bacon greasy and cold. Toasted bagel wasn't really toasted and so much butter couldn't eat it. Charged a $1.50 for a slice of tomato that was 1/6th of in inch. Will never go back or recommend. read more

Bagels are definitely the best in the area. However, the prices have recently gotten crazy out of control compared to their local competitors. Bagels and Cream Cheese are more than double the price of the joint down the road. Also, their service is famously confused and inefficient (particularly on the egg sandwich line) - that's been going on for 20 years. We just can't justify going there anymore. read more

This place always has a line and the people behind the counter never seem to pick up the pace, even at lunch time. The staff is unkempt and they lack customer service skills, and the place looks dirty front and back of the house. Bagel Boss used to be a reputable brand but the last few times I've been here it's been pretty awful. The place in Massapequa is equally disappointing. I don't think I'll be back to either location. The food doesn't taste the same either. I wish I could say something positive read more