Ordered off door dash. 1 pound of ham , 3 rolls and a bacon,sausage and egg on bagel. It gets delivered and it has cheese. So can't be eaten. Has to be thrown out. And now I have to order from somewhere else since I can't drive. This is not the first time with this place. read more

Bagel Buzz - Cheese which should not be. - Bagels Near Me - West Islip, New York

You guys can't accept Door Dash orders if you are going to take 90 minutes to prepare a simple breakfast order. If a customer orders a couple of bagels with spreads at 9am, the prep time can't be 90 minutes. If you're busy great, just turn off Door Dash/Uber Eats. read more

Everything here is always delicious. The service is always friendly. Andres is no exception-it's nice to be greeted with a smile. Awesome bagels too! read more

Overall, a decent BEC. I ordered a Long Island staple. BEC. If you know...you know... I especially liked how the bacon was wrapped around the egg/cheese and just a "layer" on the sandwich like other places. The texture aspect was great due to this. The bagel was nice and fresh. I did ask for the bagel to be toasted...it had a very slight toast...and more of a toast was definitely needed. I also ordered a side of home fries. They had a good amount of flavor and seasoning. I would come back whenever I'm in the area. read more

Love this place, they're always busy but always quick and efficient. Their bagels are incredible and their food in general is fresh and great! read more

Bagels are very good, but not great. a little bit fluffy compared to a classic NY Bagel, but they come close. Staff is friendly and efficient. However they can get overwhelmed on a Saturday morning rush. Bagel and Cream cheese prices are around half of what they charge at Bagel Boss, where I used to be a regular. Nice simple place that, as of this writing, is still charging reasonable prices. read more

If I could recommend a Bagel place, this is the one to come to. Every single one of their staff is over-the-top friendly. They make you feel so important and willing to get you whatever you want, and it's QUICK. Their customer service was the first thing that stuck out to me when I started coming here. On top of the service they provide, the food is always delicious - and they give you SO much of it for such a decent price. If you come here for breakfast or lunch, they have a decent selection from breakfast to salads to wraps to paninis or even sides. I definitely love coming here and highly recommend it to you hungry Yelpers - you won't be disappointed. read more

See all

In a market saturated with bagel stores this place is below average. The bacon egg and cheese was decent but the bagel itself was very dry maybe even stale. Aside from the average food two things stood out. The nasty barking attitude from the older man/owner type character who I was afraid to order from in fear of being yelled at and the blasting rap music at 8:30am. If they just turn the lights down a little it could be a night club. I watched another guy walk in and look up at the ceiling wondering what the hell was going on. It's amazing how some people have no common sense. I won't be back here, I would rather eat a 7-11 bagel and blast music in my car. Here is a pic of the speakers and average egg sandwich. read more

Bagel Buzz - Average BEC with stale bagel - Bagels Near Me - West Islip, New York

See all

I tried with this place, service is so slow, and they never change their gloves, they handle money and register with the gloves on from previous customer and then use them to handle your food, they have a tantrum when kindly ask them to change their gloves. Its a shame to say good bye, but wish they were more conscious on their handling of food and money separately read more

Don't order Uber Eats from this place. They can't even read a simple order and the food is not tasty and not fresh. I order hash brown and omg it tasted a day old or even more like refrigerated and then heated up. I ordered a BLT bagel with a chicken cutlet. The chicken cutlet for an extra 3 dollar it was not fresh nor seasoned well. The tomato and lettuce were old. Who enjoyed old bitter tasting lettuce and old mushy tomato. I sure don't smh. I had 5 items ordered and only received 4. I ordered a side of bacon cause my daughter only eats bacon for a breakfast choice and never recieved it. Yes I'll get back my refund for the bacon but that's not the point. I had to pick out my bacon from my sandwich l. The only thing I enjoyed was my ice coffee and it was black smh I added my own creamer and sugar. Even the bottle juice was warm smh. Come on now this is ridiculous. Need to do better!!! I spent $40 to get bad food gtbkm for a fact I will never order or consider purchasing from this place ever again. read more

Bagel Buzz - a tray of food and a cup of coffee - Bagels Near Me - West Islip, New York

I absolutely love this bagel place ! Not only is it clean and inviting . The staff is so friendly and remember you by name ! Let's talk about the bagels ! My favorite are everything bagels , the seeds are perfectly proportional! Banging egg sandwich's and it's on the way to the beach , location, staff the food ! Must try ! Best bagel is west Islip ! read more

Do not order from this place!! Ordered New Year's Eve off of Grubhub / seamless. Ordered a hungry man hero, egg and cheese bagel, two small orange juices and a dozen bagels. Order came. No hungry man. Apple juice instead of orange juice. 10 bagels. Such a joke. Absolute joke. Tried calling the place and it doesn't even ring. Just some unprofessional voicemail "bagel buzz" sounds like the guy is high. Can't even contact the place. Such a joke. read more

Ordered a BLT today, this happened...enough said...usually they are very good. Mistakes can happen I guess but I was very sad today. read more

Bagel Buzz - a sandwich with lettuce and bacon - Bagels Near Me - West Islip, New York

Outstanding bagels. But I went in and found one of the men preparing food wasn't wearing a mask; he had on a plastic face shield instead. I'm a doctor and I informed him that the shield wouldn't do anything to protect the customers. He got angry and started arguing with me. Sorry, Bagel Buzz - there are plenty of good bagel places around. I'm sure they will be happy for my business. read more

Best bagels in town, worst chopped salads in town. Go for breakfast! Tons of bagels and cream cheese selections - they're awesome. Chopped salads are lacking - you never actually get what you asked for in it but some sort of random selection of veggies that they choose for you (why?). Takes forever to get as well. read more

Great service clean and curtious service and the monte cristo sandwich is awesome! So bagel buzz is the place to be! The bagels are great as well as the egg sandwiches and it's nice an air conditioned.They even have cereal and muffins too .Whether on the go or need a place to eat they tables to sit at.i highly recommend this store located in West Islip.A good place to stop and pick up something Service is fast for morning rush to work - coffee & muffins fresh read more

Epic fail for public safety! Looking for an open bagel store today and had a mask and gloves On. Walked in and none of the workers had masks on preparing food for the public. Needless to say, about face and left! Safety should be a food service number one priority!! read more

A little disappointed this morning. Got a plain with cream cheese. The guy put very little cream cheese on the bagel. I almost thought it was butter but it is cream cheese but hardly any in there. I don't know what this guy was thinking when he made my bagel. read more

This is my favorite bagel store in west Islip / Babylon area. The staff are all so friendly. The bagels are the best around for sure. The sandwiches are always delicious. There is plenty of parking. I remember when I first moved here I stopped in at the end of the day to get a few bagels and they sent me home with 2 dozen bagels!!! Nicest people. Quality food. read more

Ordered via Ubereats. Sandwiches delivered were completely wrong. Called and the person who took care of the order immediately took full responsibility. She made us new, perfect sandwiches and delivered them within 15 minutes. Will order again read more

Bagel was so so , read from previous posts that bagel had mildew taste. That's how the iced coffee tasted for me except it was more like a dirty sock was in it. Save your money read more

Great food! Very fresh! Also great service! I always get a whole wheat everything bagel toasted n scooped w lettuce, tomato, mayo salt n pepper and it never disappoints read more

Legit just left and had to come straight here. Went here for a quick breakfast for my gfs BDAY (yeah basic and quick bc we have a whole day ahead of us), they had to remake a BEC THREEEEEE times for the final time to be on an undercooked bagel. I just paid $18.xx for this mediocre breakfast that had to get done 3 times !!! I'm new to the neighborhood and I will go else where next time, somewhat feel like it was purposely done but ehh won't get into that . read more

This is got to be one of the nicest places ever came for A two week visit and we had the most wonderful time there best food I have ate on vacation in a long time!! Salad I had was absolutely fabulous our whole meal was delicious everything was perfect the staff so welcoming and sincere and very helpful. The atmosphere is wonderful I was very pleased with everything couldn't believe how excellent everything was. I will definitely be returning with my family to enjoy the hospitality and the great food again thank you for such an amazing time read more

Bagel Buzz - a salad with chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, and avocado - Bagels Near Me - West Islip, New York

New to the neighborhood. Was referred over here by my sister in law, she said they were great. The first time we went there it was ok. I figured give them 1 more chance. I ordered a rainbow bagel and plain bagel for the kids. Of course the man behind the counter heard cinnamon raisin (because that sounds almost the same as rainbow). My egg sandwich had a weird after taste and I found a few mushrooms in it. Which is weird because I didn't ask for those. Also when I ordered my wife sandwich I said fried eggs over hard and bacon on dry rye. He then asked me "so not juice in the eggs". Never heard that before. The woman then asked him if the rye bread was toasted. He said no. I said yes it is. He said you said dry. I said that means no butter. This place is a disaster. I will never eat here ever again. Horrible. read more

I find Yelp reviews cringey, but the bagel I got here this morning was absolutely leftover from yesterday or sitting out for an extended time to the point of being inedible. $5.62 for a bagel with flavored cream cheese that couldn't be eaten.... Just, no. read more

Bagel buzz has good prices and great egg sandwiches! The egg sandwich comes with an iced tea that's delicious or a coffee and even when ordering a large order they will make and label each coffee as requested. (From what I have seen most places just send black coffees for large orders so this is a nice extra.) The bagels are great not the best I have had but they are very good. read more

Bagel Buzz - #eggsammy - Bagels Near Me - West Islip, New York

Some of the best bagels on Long Island! Have been going here for over 10 years. Their egg sandwiches and bagels are amazing!

This is a solid bagel joint and has been a town staple for many years. While not the best in town anymore (since the return of a particular establishment that was destroyed by a speeding sports car), the bagels are still very good. The sandwiches always hit the spot and the staff is always so friendly. Prices aren't bad either. While it won't blow you away, it's hard to go wrong with Bagel Buzz. read more

I've grabbed a BEC from Bagel Buzz ~10 times in my life and it seems to get better every time. The everything bagels are big and fluffy and the portions are perfect. They load it up with bacon and add just the right amount of eggs and cheese. Not to mention, they are extremely quick. I would highly recommend this bagel shop to anyone looking for a quality BEC. read more

Will not be going back here. Went in on a Sunday morning and found multiple employees with no masks on or pulled down below their nose's & mouths. Also noticed while I was waiting for my sandwiches that they never change their gloves, I watched multiple employees handling money at the register then go prepare food without changing gloves, what's the point?!?. why not have one person at the register to avoid this? Also witnessed one older male employee staring at a young lady walking through the parking lot and then watched him strategically place himself by the counter to watch her walk out so he can check her out again, very creepy (he was also one of the guy's with his mask pulled down). read more

A colleague bought me lunch today, I ordered a salad. There were green peppers in there that I didnt ask for. The cherry tomatoes were cut in half, some of them were rotten, and tasted rotten! The avocado was either previously frozen, or also rotten. That was probably the worst "salad" I've ever eaten. You should be embarrassed. read more

I have been coming to bagel buzz for a few months now and I have to say their bagels are by far the best around. The staff is so friendly especially the new manager Tom who makes fresh soups daily that are out of this world! I am impressed all around! read more

hands down the best place for breakfast and lunch. service is excellent and so is the food! highly recommended.

Some of the kindest staff I have ever met! I go by another name and when I said I prefer that name, they called me that and apologized

By happenstance we got off the Robert Moses looking for coffee. Fell into the Bagel Buzz. Thank you Tina Marie for a great breakfast. Perfect bagel and egg sandwich. Coffee was delicious and fresh. Couldn't have gotten luckier read more

Gross. Used to love this place in 2013-2015, kind of didn't go in 2016 - although I am agreeing w the person below (Sam L?) I always thought the bagels had an odd taste...he described it as mildew - BINGO. Anyway, I went in maybe 3 weeks ago, employees high AF, def pill heads. Some short haired girl was high as hell, made the sandwiches I got. Kept gloves on, touched my money, swiped her nose w the back of her hand, kept on keeping on making that food tho. Fing foul. I started looking at all of the employees, all pill heads. And believe me, I have zero against pill heads (you do you) but I do if you're gross af making my food! Sick read more

Usually love the bagel sandwiches from here but I ordered a BEC on a whole wheat everything bagel and it had a fishy lox taste. I think whoever made the bagel sandwich did not wash the knife before cutting mine. It was disgusting and I was very disappointed. read more

good service, Store owners are friendly, The bagels and lemonade taste amazing and it's the best place to go for a bagel on Long Island!

Love this bagel shop! I go out of my way to come to this specific one because the staff is so kind and the egg everything bagels are amazing! Very family friendly and I recommend it to all my peers! The iced coffees are delicious too! read more