You just know when you've found a truly great bagel shop. I dropped in this morning for a mini plain bagel with butter, and it was ridiculously fresh! Beyond how delicious the food is, the place has such a cozy, cute seating area where you can actually relax and enjoy your morning. Plus, having an in-house bakery makes it even better. Highly recommend giving this spot a try! read more

First Class Bagels - Mini bagel - Bagels Near Me - Deer Park, New York

Brian is a great employee. He always treats the customer good and is very friendly and professional . Every store should have a Brian on their staff read more

The bagels are good. The service is nice and I have always been met with a smile and warm greeting from the people working there in the morning. read more

Excellent rainbow cookie cake. I have been buying it here since my children were small. It is the best.

This is our spot! The food is amazing. The staff is wonderful. The line is always long but worth it and a testament of how great it is.

Brian is an exceptional employee. Very friendly and great to deal with. Great service.

First class is an apt name for this place, because these bagels were delicious. From bacon egg and cheese to just simple cream cheese and butter, the portions have been generous and delicious, but most importantly the bagels have always tasted fresh even when showing up a little late. Coffee ain't half bad either, and a large iced is enough to fuel a jet plane! Service can be a little slow, but the quality is worth the extra wait. Parking lot right out front makes it a breeze to come and go too. read more

Fresh bagels, delicious deli and a very friendly staff. Seating is perfect but can be limited at times. They're busy but staff properly so you're never in line for what feels like forever. This is my go to bagel place in the area Their everything egg bagels are on point -- hits the sweet spot between a bagel and a pastry. Perfect with some scallion cream cheese + lox + lettuce + tomatoes + creamy onions + cucumbers + fresh squeezed lemon + small pinch of pepper.... delicious every single time. The whole wheat everything flagels are fresh always and also my go to flagel. This bagel shop seems to be the one place that doesn't skimp on toppings for bagels- plenty of seeds! Nice staff, and relaxed, laid-back atmosphere. Very clean. friendly hometown feel. Excellent workers. Great bagels and service. read more

This use to be my family's favorite bagel spot, however lately they have not been as good as they could be. The last few times we ordered bagel sandwiches they were extremely dry. I ordered a sandwich with turkey, mayo, and lettuce and the bagel had almost no mayo on it and very little turkey. They used to be so generous with their toppings. The bagels were not fresh either. Normally sandwiches come with side salad or pickle yet nothing here. In addition workers were mopping while people are eating (I get they have to clean however it made the place reek bc the water was dirty) and shaking out the dirty floor mats next to customers! We keep trying to give this place another chance but just end up disappointed. read more

I love this place when they get my order right. Today I ordered salami, turkey, and cheese on a roll with mustard. Instead I got salami, turkey and ham on a roll with mustard. It's really annoying because I work in Queens and look forward to having the lunch that I ordered. I also, do not like ham. It's always the girl with the black hair that gets my sandwhich order wrong. Their sweetened iced tea is amazing though. -- Update: Ordered an everything bagel toasted with butter and got an everything bagel toasted with cream cheese. -- Where can I go to get the correct food I order? This place isn't it. Besides the ice tea I can't recommend anything else. I'm over the whole incorrect order thing. read more

First Class Bagels - No cheese. But ham. - Bagels Near Me - Deer Park, New York

I ordered a sandwich from there was worst deli sandwich... when you get a deli sandwich you get alot of cold cut and its packed in there, this was clearly not the case.. got charged ton of money with a sandwich whith barley no meat.. staff needs be trained how to make a real deli sandwich... overall not happy what i got and what i had to pay for something like that.. horrible .. if you go there check your sandwich and make sure you get decent sandwich before you pay for it... read more

First Class Bagels - As you can see little turkey and like no ham... worst deli sandwich... staff needs be trained how make a real deli sandwich! - Bagels Near Me - Deer Park, New York

Updating my previous review to 4 stars, this bagel store has it all. They make great sandwiches, chopped salad bar to pick your own ingredients and have them chop away. Very large selection of bakery items, all very delicious and fresh. Great homemade salads and different flavored cream cheeses. Great customer service and very efficiently fast. read more

Since our favorite deli (Bagel Factory Farmingdale) closed decided to give this a try. Pleasantly surprised with the interior - large variety of goodies! Soups, sandwiches, bagels, sweets, etc. Rating was pulled down a bit because we felt the bagels were not traditional NY style that has a nice crust shell outside but nice chewy inside. Plus their "everything" bagel did not have salt outside (bummer). The spread we got was lite veggie tuna could've used just a bit more seasoning for that oomph. Another sandwich we shared was the grilled chxn/pesto/sundried tomato with cheese panini. Size was gigantic and flavors spot on for this creation but wished they used bread usually used in paninis (too doughy and did not hold together). Overall, good place but for now I guess the search for great bagels continues. read more

See all

They didn't have the supplies to make my sandwich, that was pretty disappointing also they were spraying fumes while I was in the restaurant that rubbed me the wrong way. Hopefully they improve on this. read more

The sandwiches here are mid to begin with. Against my better judgement, I stopped in to grab lunch and see A HUGE COCKROACH crawling around in the glass case next to open food in the middle of the afternoon. I alerted the staff and cancelled my order. Absolutely disgusting! Do not eat here. read more

A tad pricey but the bagels are worth it. The organization and service are also first class.

Disappointed - I called and ordered a panini- they were out of the bread so I got it on a wrap- it was ICE COLD and no balsamic dressing that I asked for. It was not busy so hard to understand why it was so wrong. Upsetting to spend $15 on a lunch that was not enjoyable. Do Better First Class! read more

I found First Class Bagels on a route that I travel often and I've been going there 4-5 days a week ever since. Everything that I've tried is fresh and delicious. Breakfast sandwiches,baked goods,salads,fruit salads, I've tried so many things and I've never been disappointed. The staff is very friendly and efficient. If you are in the area stop in and enjoy this gem as much as I do!!!!!!!!! read more

Very nice service and fluffy bagels. However barely any cheese on my egg + cheese, and no salt in their everything bagel seasoning

Minestrone soup and lobster bisque soup were both excellent and definitely hit the spot on a rainy day! read more

First Class Bagels - Minestrone Soup - Bagels Near Me - Deer Park, New York

Bagels, Deli Sandwiches, Pastries this place has an abundance of these delicious offerings, so many in fact that the store's counters, display cases and inventory consumes most of the restaurant's floor space leaving very little room for the few tables jammed in the tiny dining area. The quality is above board as well as the service, the line does move a little slow as others have stated but they get it right the first time and it's fresh and delicious. I came here after getting a recommendation from a associate that lives in the area and she was spot on. We loved everything we were served here and I definitely plan on returning. read more

See all

Update: came back after Kieth, the owner private messaged me. I must say, experience is MUCH different. They don't roll your eyes when you have a special request, staff is friendly and sandwiches are sooo good (but they always were) I'll have to come back for lunch and see what it's like bc that's were I get picky lol Glad I can come back here and have a great experience Old review: Customer service is horrible. I come here because its the closest by me... But when I do I make sure I have an extra 5 min because they can NEVER get My sandwich right. Employees always look miserable... Food is good when they get it right, place is really nice. I need to find a new local deli though because this place isn't worth the headache. read more

First Class Bagels - BEC on a toasted plain bagel. So good! - Bagels Near Me - Deer Park, New York

Decent bagels but beware of their sandwiches that you see when you first walk in. Bought one and it had mold. read more

First Class Bagels - Moldy buffalo chic salad sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Deer Park, New York

My favorite bagel shop but there's so much more at First Class Bagels. You'll have to see it to believe it: deli, bakery, sandwiches and salad bar. Staff is so friendly and it's a pleasure doing business there. read more

Great customer service and great bagels! I highly recommend the tuna salad on a chopped salad! The desserts are incredible as well!

My boyfriend recommended this place and I am glad he did. The breakfast Everything bagel with a slice of ham, one egg white, cheese, and cream cheese spread that I had was as delicious as high in calories! I love the fact that First Class Bagel Cafe offers a variety of bagels - from your typical Plain, Rye, and Sesame to oddballs like Strawberry, Spinach and even Bacon Egg. As well as having the run-of-the-mill display of cold, pasta side dishes. I also like the fact that the bagel cafe offers you the opportunity to build your own bagel to fit your personal palate. Will go again! read more

See all

I grew up going here and now that i love out of town it is always at least a one time stop if not multiple times for turkey egg and cheese sandwiches with hot sauce- my kids love their bagels with a smear of CC (love this option!) wish they shipped to florida! read more

Bagels were stale at 6 AM. Asked for an everything flagel with butter and they hardly put any butter on it. Threw 3/4 away. Was stale and crunchy. Didn't ask for it toasted thinking it would be fresh. Over priced. read more

First Class Bagels - a bagel with butter and a knife - Bagels Near Me - Deer Park, New York

I've been here a couple of times and the food and service have always been solid. I've never had a bad experience here so I don't get all the negative reviews. There's always a line but it goes pretty quickly. And as soon as my order is taken (cinnamon raisin bagel with cream cheese and an egg bagel with ham and egg), it was ready about 5 minutes later. They were very courteous and prompt. But what about the food itself? With NY bagels, how can you go wrong? The cream cheese tasted creamy and fresh, made on prem. The ham and eggs inside that egg bagel was delightful. If I weren't trying to cut my carb intake, I can easily see myself making this place my daily breakfast spot! read more

See all

It was my first time here for lunch with some co-workers the other day and my experience was half and half. They have a HUGE selection of bagels, cream cheeses, sandwhiches, paninis, and if you're looking for pasteries...this is your spot. They had tons of goodies all lined up behind the glass, and the best cheesecake from what I'm told. I ordered a chicken cutlet sandwhich on a roll with bacon and melted cheddar which was pretty sandard but tasty. Each sandwhich comes with a side salad (mac, potato, coleslaw) which for $7.95 was pretty good. I was only able to each half and saved the other half for the next days lunch. My only gripe was the service, not that it was bad at all...the line got to be a bit long and the manner in which they service guests is not the most organized. Before leaving I has asked for a to-go box from one of the young girls behind the counter to which I recieved not one, but two eye rolls from her....not the best end to my lunch break, but I'm sure I'll make my way back for lunch. The hot roast beef sandwhich is calling my name! read more

First Class Bagels - The Bagel Club. Chicken salad, bacon, lettuce, and tomato. - Bagels Near Me - Deer Park, New York

Ugh!!! Second visit here and first was okay this time will be my last time. I placed my order and the guy took too long and the one bagel I wanted was taken by another customer who came after me. All I wanted was an egg everything bagel! Someone placed their order long after I did and received the last one. After looking forward to it and getting then getting no sort of response when I mentioned I placed my order before the other customer did is just horrible customer service! So beware of this place! I hate establishments that don't care about their customers! They will never get another penny from me! read more

The hot sandwiches are cold... the cold sandwiches are hot.. the butter tastes like margarine this place is the opposite of 1st class

First time eating here and the last time I'll order a bagel with cream cheese. The bagel was soft on the inside but a bit hard on the outside. As for the cream cheese, the taste was average but there wasn't much on the bagel for the price I paid. I expect minimal cream cheese on a bagel from 7eleven, not a bagel shop. Service was extremely fast (11am). I placed my order and in less than 2 minutes the cashier was ringing me up. Pleasant guy with a smile to match. I may go back and try an egg or deli sandwich in the future. Its the service that put this at 3 stars. If I was rating on the food experience alone they'd end up with 2 stars. read more

First Class Bagels - Whole wheat bagel w/scallion cream cheese. Seriously lacking in the cream cheese department. - Bagels Near Me - Deer Park, New York

Usually good sandwiches but recent staff additions are definitely not up to par. I ordered a turkey and American on a roll with lettuce and mayo and what I got was a dry turkey sandwich on a roll. The worst part is I watched her write the order down. It's a shame because it makes me want to frequent there less. I work too far to drive back and get it corrected. read more

First visit here yesterday morning and the last. So disappointed because everything looked so good. I asked the girl at the counter if they had any french toast bagels and she said yes I will make you one (which I thought was odd but very sweet of her). I asked for very lightly buttered - which it was. I had $3.00 in hand and was shocked when she told me $4.00! Took my bagel to go in hopes this would be one of the best bagels for $4.00. I don't know what in the world she put on the outside of the bagel - tasted like oil with brown sugar - one greasy mess. I truly appreciate her effort and she was very pleasant but the bagel which I think was an egg bagel was beyond stale. Tried to salvage the bagel by wiping off the outside but it was useless. In the trash it went. read more

Best deli/ bagels around!! The owners know me by name, know my order, and are always so fast and friendly!!

I dont understand this place or people good reviews of their bagels....Literally the worst bagels ever. everytime Ive come here (about 5 times just based on proximity) the bagels are so friggin HARD! I got an egg bagel with creamcheese and its like a brick, this was at 9am, if your a bagel place with hard egg bagels in the morning you really need to consider a new profession. Its also very confusing bc everything they have LOOKS SO GOOD! the pastries, sandwiches etc. but nothing is fresh they def use it day after day whatever dosnt sell. yuck. read more

So, I've known these guys for almost 2 years now and I feel like I'm part of the family. I've been to a lot of delis across the island and these guys are top notch. Now, maybe I am a bit unique because I actually take time out of my day to ask how they are doing and treat the guys/gals behind the counter like real people, but I can tell you that I'm on a first name basis with everyone and they always say hi when I walk in the door. When you live on Long Island, it's easy to just go from one deli to another. What's hard is finding the deli that you like with food and people that keep you coming back. To me, First Class in Deer Park does just that and I'll keep coming back for a long time. Special thanks to Justin, Kieth, Joe and the rest of the gang. See you soon. read more

Whenever I am in the mood for a bagel this is my go to place. I have been going here for years and have always had good experiences.

I drove 30 minutes for the Rainbow cookie cake and it was worth the drive. I got there after the lunch rush and I felt very welcomed by all the employees. Keith gave me some extra cookies for the road. I also had an everything bagel for lunch and it was great! Will definitely be back! read more

First Class Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Deer Park, New York

See all