Hidden gem in Deer Park! Found this spot when I had to get fingerprints done for a new company I…read morework for (they are right next to each other). Ever since that day, I've been a happy customer! The shop has lots of seating, and it is very roomy. They also have a good selection of bottled drinks, house iced tea, coffee, tea. The bagels and rolls are delicious, and yes, soft!

A good bagel today and always. The staff is attentive and eager to please. The variety of add ons…read moreis enough for the average customer.

I went to Wally's Bagels, and it was great! I ordered a sausage, egg, and cheese on a sesame bagel,…read moreand it was excellent. The bagel was fresh with just the right amount of chew, and the sesame added great flavor. The sausage was well-seasoned, the eggs were fluffy, and everything was cooked fresh and served hot. The sandwich was generously sized and filling without feeling greasy. Service was quick, even though they were busy, and the staff kept the line moving efficiently.

This bagel spot is next to my house and we couldn't be happier! There is a large selection of cream…read morecheese, like their new Dubai Chocolate and they are constantly filling the hot fresh bagels. I really enjoy their breakfast platters, like the western omelette and home fries. Their French toast platter is phenomenal as well, a must try. They do get busy, but don't let that scare you away. They have parking in the front and back plus, make an online order to skip the line THEN pick it up to the left door...they have an extension now that was built specifically for online orders.

I'm a native NYCer, so I don't like these gigantic airy bagels that are all over Long Island. I'm…read moreused to Ess-A-Bagel, Zaro's at Grand Central Terminal, Bagel Nosh, Russ & Daughters, and many others. I went to Steve's bc I was dropping off a package at the store next door. Someone once told me the term "hot bagels" on a store meant they were "authentic" bagels. So when I saw Steve's, I was intrigued. I got six excellent bagels: two onion, two garlic, two egg-everything. They were not huge. They were normal size, perfectly baked and had plenty of seasoning on both sides but not too much. They were delicious. We liked them so much I sent my husband there on a Thursday a few weeks later and he came home with the same types of bagels. They were undercooked. They were overly large and they did not have much seasoning on them. Most of them had nothing on the bottom and a few barely had any seasoning on top. I understand that they use different bakers on different days, so whoever baked the bagels for Wednesday, April 8, 2026? He or she should get a raise and teach the others how to make bagels. The service was fine, btw. I wouldn't say "friendly," but it was attentive.

This place is really good. I ordered a sausage egg and cheese on an egg bagel. It was delicious and…read moresuper cheesy and gooey. Bagel was fluffy and crunchy! I also got an apple turnover. Very tasty! The ambience is very homey and personal! Highly recommend it.

You just know when you've found a truly great bagel shop. I dropped in this morning for a mini…read moreplain bagel with butter, and it was ridiculously fresh! Beyond how delicious the food is, the place has such a cozy, cute seating area where you can actually relax and enjoy your morning. Plus, having an in-house bakery makes it even better. Highly recommend giving this spot a try!

The bagels are good. The service is nice and I have always been met with a smile and warm greeting…read morefrom the people working there in the morning.

Small place. Nice guy that took my order. I ordered two…read morebagel sandwiches and stressed to scramble the eggs. I really don't like the consistency of egg whites. The sandwiches both had eggs that were NOT scrambled. I had big goops of egg whites. I really hate that. It really ruined the sandwich for me. One of the sandwiches had ham. one had bacon, tomato and onion. I also ordered 3 pastries. They looked better than they tasted. The bill came out to $29 and change. I gave this place a shot, but I don't think I would come back.

Awful, tasteless bagel. If I wasn't so hungry, and didn't need to eat quickly before an…read moreappointment, I would've walked out. Very unclean establishment.

Working in the area, and looking for a decent deli sandwich. Found this spot. It was highly rated,…read moreand people seem to be loving their cheesesteaks and sandwiches. So, I decided to head on over. It's a tiny spot. So, I waited a bit before going in since there was already 4 other people inside and that literally took up all the space inside. I ordered the "Stallone Cheesesteak" and the Papacino Italiano w/ no tomatoes. The Italiano was good, but could be better. Too much dressing, and the peppers made the hero super mushy. It tasted ok, nothing spectacular. Now the Stallone was sub par to say the least. I had high hopes for this one after reading all the great reviews about their sandwiches. The combo of hot Italian sausage and steak sounded pretty nice. However the execution was poor. The steak was over cooked and chewy & lacked flavor. The sausage was almost non existent in the sandwich & the pieces I had tasted bland. The tomato sauce made the sandwich a mess to eat & not in a good way. That hero was nothing close to garlicky. I didn't even finish it. It wasn't very appealing to eat. Too chewy and flavors were off. Maybe I'll give them another shot? But that's a huge maybe. Parking is available. Variety of drinks to choose from. If you pay with card they charge you more. Staff wasn't the most polite.

Long island is the land of great bagels and to be a true contender you need to stand out. Papacinos…read moreis probably the last local bagel joint I've yet to try so when a few errands conveniently put me in that area I gave it a go. I generally don't comment on atmosphere but papacinos overall is alittle generic. You walk in and there's nothing that makes you hungry. I want to see display cases full of bagels that scream "eat me!". Papa's maybe had 8 varieties in total hidden behind the counter and they just didn't scream appetizing. I asked for the darkest sesame they had with butter. A good bagel should have a slightly crunchy outside with a doughy inner. This bagel for the most part accomplished that but in a completely forgetable way. They were very light on the butter which I don't mind but I always lean on the side of "more is better" as you can always remove some but you can't conjure more. Overall papacinos is neither good or bad. It's a 90mph fastball down the middle no movement. This is a problem because in a world of SUPER STARS being just a STAR DOESNT CUT IT New York 2.5-3 Anywhere else in this country 4

It's a small little deli But the lady with the red hair takes good care of the customers. And the…read moreman in the back cooks some great food. It's clean well lit and organized the food is excellent and the crisp they are open on almost every holiday and will try to accommodate you in every way I want to shout out to the Red haired lady She rocks see yall on the weekend

You may be zipping by at 40mph but don't miss this hidden gem in a mini international food plaza at…read morethe side of the road. Currently breakfast sandwiches are half off until noon. So a meat, egg and cheese on a roll or bagel is just 3.99 before tax. Nothing satisfies better than a nice soft bagel with melt cheese with hot meat and an egg. They also have half off lunch sandwiches. Half off prices are in effect until January 1, 2024. Halal options also available. Besides this deli in the same parking lot is Chinese, Tex-Mex and kabobs so you can get a little bit of something for the whole family at one stop. Please support local small businesses.

Just stopped by for an iced coffee. Was passing it on my way and figured I'd check it out. Sweetest…read morewoman working the counter iced coffees already made in the fridge with all types of add-ons that you want. Also seem to be some international options as well like different types of juices that I definitely will check out at another point!

New to the area so I was really looking forward to having a bagel joint so close to me. The first…read moretime going the bacon was definitely undercooked. But bagels were fresh. So I understand that happens from time to time. Second time in was a not a great experience. I believe some of the staff need to be retrained on safe food handling. There was a young girl who took my order and handled my food. She was cleaning before taking my order and then grabbed my bagel with the same gloves. And while holding my bagel she used her other hand with the glove on and tucked her hair behind her ear. After she put my bagel into the toaster she came back over to the counter and rang me up with still the same gloves on! Then she walked to go back to get my bagel from the toaster. I had it and said could you please change your gloves you just handled cash! I'm not one to make a confrontation that is why I didn't not say anything the first time around as she handle it. Then she changed her gloves and continued to pull up her pants and play with her shirt. Unfortunately, I took my food and just threw it out afterwards. But I think this needed to be addressed in a review so everyone can understand the importance of food safety. As a new customer this was not a good impression to make. The business owner/managers need to pay better attention to this. I work in the food industry and as a manager I would call it out as soon as I seen an employee doing that and retrained. Hopefully this place speaks with their whole staff to ensure the food is being handled safely. That was very gross way to start off my morning.

Honestly love this place more than the other bagel spots in town. Their bagels are the freshest…read more Pretty busy but def worth it And Tina is amazing!!!

My niece used Emma's Deli to cater her son's birthday party and everything was fantastic! The…read moreheroes and salads were incredibly fresh and delicious -- everyone at the party raved about the food. Great portions, great quality, and made the event so much easier to host. Highly recommend Emma's Deli for your next catering needs!

Great classic neighborhood deli with fast, friendly service. Bagels are fresh and sandwiches are…read moremade to order. The BLT on an everything bagel with mayo and jalapeños. The BEC is fresh and delicious. Coffee is solid and ice teas are good as well. The deli serves Boars Head cold cuts, case full of pre sliced cakes and treats, as well as a small seating area.