Saturday morning, line of people waiting, bins filled with fresh bagels. All seems good…read more.. I just wanted two flagels, which if you are unaware are simply regular bagels that have been flattened a bit. I got a sesame & an everything. Mind you these were plain, no butter, no cream cheese PLAIN BAGELS, was charged $5 for TWO PLAIN BAGELS! I should have have refused but I was struck speechless. So if you want to be seriously overcharged for your bagels. Go to the BlueLine Deli

Staff is not friendly. I went in to get a bagel and they were working on a large order instead of…read moreservicing the customer in front of them. They seemed stressed and disorganized. They also were screaming and talking Badly about another employee saying why isn't she helping "she must be doing her makeup in the bathroom". The employees should be more mindful that the customers can hear them talking badly about their coworkers. My bagel wasn't also wrapped correctly and fell out of the paper into the brown bag.

After moving out of New York a few years ago, one of the things my husband and I look forward to…read morewhen we come back to visit family is having a delicious bagel (or two) while in town. My family and I spent several days trying to satisfy our craving for a good New York bagel and found our way to New York Bagel Company one morning. We may have come in on an off morning for them, but unfortunately we were extremely let down with the bagels that were used for our egg sandwiches. We ordered one sandwich with an everything bagel and the other sandwich on a garlic bagel. Unfortunately, both tasted extremely flavorless and the bagels themselves were an odd texture, almost as if they had been microwaved. My husband was so disappointed he went back to the cash register area to ask for a refund. Management stood by their product asserting that they did not put their sandwiches in the microwave. The manager remained extremely professional and offered a refund on the sandwiches. We were so surprised, but extremely grateful for the gesture. The service was the best part of our breakfast that morning. The bagels missed the marks for us and would be the main reason we would likely not return in the future.

Waited a full hour before they STARTED my order, then when I received it was missing items and…read morecoffee was without items ordered. Paid $80 for 1 sandwich 2 coffees (one that couldn't be enjoyed) and a small cup of watermelon. They credited me $10. What a joke. I had paid for uber so there was no getting it corrected.

Horrible customer service especially the two older ladies that work up in the front counter. They…read moredont know to speak to people.

Great sandwich options - the sun was honestly really good. I did order off of their prefixed menu…read moreso a sandwich with specific things on it - no one there seemed to know what the sandwich was except one lady behind the counter. They got it figured out but was strange. Awesome sandwich though! And huge size.

My family and I spent a few days in Islip and tried several bagel shops in the area. We came across…read moreBagels and More and had a positive first experience. It ended up becoming our go-to spot for egg sandwiches for the rest of our time in town. Fresh and tasty food with efficient service! They had a good variety of bagels each morning. My husband and I appreciated the taste and texture of each bagel we tried and the egg sandwiches were crafted well. My order was a bacon and egg (no cheese) on a garlic bagel and it hit home every time. It was also a nice touch to have a complimentary orange juice or coffee coupled with each sandwich to round out the breakfast experience. Overall, we had a positive experience during our trips to Bagels and More. We would definitely return the next time we're in the area and are so happy to have found a good bagel spot in town.

A dozen bagels with a bonus of 2 extra bagels- $16, 2 half-pound containers of specialty cream…read morecheeses- $5.50 each, not having to go to Bagel Boss ever again- priceless!!! This Mom and Pop shop has delicious bagels, fantastic prices, and courteous, kind people working behind the counter!!!

Decided to split a bagel with my daughter. One bagel with chicken salad and cheddar. One small…read morevitamin water. Are you ready? $18.15 Am I out of touch? I figured 11 or 12 dollars at the most. Insane. The price put me off but then we ate it. Tasted like they added simple syrup to it. There was nothing but celery and chic. No cranberries. Horrible! On the plus side,they were friendly.

Best bagels in town!! friendly owner and staff bacon egg and…read morecheese sandwiches were amazing also!!

Best jelly Donuts in the world ! Just the right amount of jelly soft and a decent size. Even though…read moreI think they used to be bigger.

Stanley's is the go to local bakery. They have a wide variety of baked items for sale, great…read moreprices, and friendly service. Their breakfast sandwich options are awesome - try one on a croissant if you can!

Harry's Bagels is a solid choice for an egg sandwich or just a bagel with some butter…read more The bagels are always fresh and I love the rough around the edges service. It's more inviting then the typical "going through the motions" customer service you get at a bagel shop. The guys here always give away the extra bagels if you're one of the last customers of the day and they make a good bagel. It is pricy but honestly everywhere is nowadays. The only fault of this place is the coffee is terrible. It's always burnt and to me never fresh. They say it's from the Babylon Bean which isn't my favorite place for coffee. You're better off getting Dunkin next door. If you're in the area and need some bagels, this place does the job.

I've been suffering with kidney stones for the past week and all I wanted was three eggs fried on a…read moreroll no bacon no cheese nothing. They had the audacity to charge me $14 if I hadn't been so sick I would've told him to shove it but I paid for it and left, but I will never go there again. I understand prices went up, but I could've got a bacon egg and cheese cheaper. They should be ashamed of themselves.

Great food and great people! Grilli's is a necessary stop every time I head back to the island…read more Perfect for breakfast and lunch sandwiches, plus the hot bar is always stacked with delicious foods.

Great deli close to my gym. I usually like to stop by after my workout cause I'm starving . Family…read moreowned and operated , friendly people . Always very sweet to me and my family. Never had the hot food but it looks delicious. Everything is fresh, deli is clean

I love bagels, and my ice coffee in the morning. Found this place when I had a meeting @ bank down…read morethe road for real estate agents. The place was clean and the service was quick.

The bagels are good, but I went in to order 2 dozen, she only gave me 22, where other places tend…read moreto give you more than a dozen when you order that much. She then told me the total was $33.xx, but apparently they add an extra $2 when you use a credit card because when I looked at the charge later it was $35.xx. It would have been nice if she mentioned that before charging me. Pay attention to what they're doing when you go here so you don't have the experience I did. Pretty upset with this place with the way I got ripped off.

Stopped here for a quick breakfast with my boyfriend before heading to Brooklyn for the day…read more Service was fast and effective. Bagels were fresh and yummy. I had an everything bagel with cream cheese. It was tasty and I didn't have a pound of cream cheese like most bagel places do. My boyfriend had a plain bagel with butter. No complaints from him either. For the two bagels it was just under $6, Employees were kind and provided service with a smile. I would definitely return for an egg sandwich.

We arrived to one of the servers smoking two storefronts down from the store. Not a good start…read more The bagels were soft, a different consistency than the usual Long Island Bagel, which my husband didn't like, but my son thought was OK because he had a "Godfather" sandwich piled high with meats and cheeses so the soft bagel was easier to eat. I had their eggsalad which was good - just the right amount of mayonnaise. The ambience is dark and the store felt cluttered. Loud television for a small place.