We love this local bagel store - hot fresh bagels & fantastic bagel sandwiches. Eggs are prepared fresh for each sandwich - I get my eggs scrambled and hubby gets his over medium so the yolk can soak into everything. Delicious! I also had their vanilla yogurt (not on the menu but it's in the case) - they don't make it but it was sweet and tangy and it's a large serving. They do make the rice pudding (also in the case) so we'll have to come back for that. Parking - there is a tiny lot (4 spaces?) behind the store and on the street in front and on the side. Entrance is accessible. There are a few tables inside, but we always get everything to go. Staff are friendly and efficient. Love this place! read more

See all

First time going there. Bagel egg and sausage and cheese was delicious and fresh. Actually couldn't finish it being was so.packed. Definitely this is my place for bagels since moving in the area. The young lady at the counter was extremely cute and friendly read more

Bagels at Wills are amazing! Always so fresh. Staff is so nice and helpful. Good prices. Love coming here for my bagels. Highly recommend!

Welcome to Oceanside, Will's! Probably the best bagels in town compared to LIBC and Cino's. My husband comes here regularly. I've grown to be a huge fan of the egg wraps. Food is fresh, love the whitefish, service is friendly, and prices are good. read more

See all

Stopped in here out bc it's by the train, very pleasantly surprised- super fun bagels, jalapeño, French toast, pumpernickel everything (tons of everything varieties), their bagels are LOADED with topping for everything bagels, you get 2 free for every dozen. They're light, chewy inside and crusty outside (got mine toasted), they put a lot of cream cheese but not so much it just falls out and is annoying. New Oceanside go to bagel spot! read more

Will’s Bagel Cafe - Pumpernickel everything, veg cream cheese, LTO & capers - Bagels Near Me - Oceanside, New York

Very good bagel. Potentially confusing selection, I wanted pumpernickel but got an everything. Generous vegetable cream cheese portion, decent lox portion. I'll try them again read more

Went to Will's twice on both a weekend and weekday. Great service, fresh delicious bagels and baked goods. Staff were friendly and service was quick. Highly recommend! read more

Love the bagels here! They are so fresh and delicious. I would definitely go back! Friendly staff too! read more

Easily a neighborhood staple! This place is awesome ! Best sausage, egg, and cheese in town!

Nice little bagel shop by Oceanside LIRR station. Friendly service. Quick lines. Delicious bagels, bialys, and coffee. Eat in. Parking in the back, on the side, and across the street in the train lot. read more

Will’s Bagel Cafe - Rainbow bagel - Bagels Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Will's bagels is always fresh and delicious. The staff is super friendly and it's located in a very convenient location by the Oceanside LIRR. I love a well-priced and yummy breakfast spot! read more

Best Bagels in Oceanside. Hand rolled Crispy and tasty. We highly recommend Will's Bagel Cafe. read more

To begin with was a long time dedicated 24 hr bagel patron. Will's completely and utterly smashes their bagels away. Wills bagels is platinum level bagels. They make small batches with a large variety of types so they are always super fresh and absolutely delicious. The bagels frankly are huge for the price as well. They also take phone orders if you want to make sure you get them out of the oven hot bagels. These can't be beat anywhere! Talk about the toppings, such as poppy, sesame, salt and everything bagels, they give you a ton of toppings on your bagel. No skimping here. They also have a bacon egg and cheese bagel which is over the top scrumptious. Wills has a huge variety of always fresh cream cheese spreads as well, such as lox, cheddar and bacon, chive and a bunch of others. I also see people ordering their lunch specialty sandwiches on a bagel and they look loaded and when I ordered them, they taste spectacular. The place appears to be family owned and operated so the Service is quick, friendly and five star concierge level! They have a bakery section and that is also 5 star, fresh and delicious when I need that little extra sugar kick. Store is always clean and it is just a great way to get your day started. Even the customers who come in are in good moods and it sets your day up by having a conversation while you wait briefly for your custom made sandwich. When you order ready made with your choice of cream cheese, be prepared to receive more than an adequate amount to satisfy your hunger. I Have been going there two to three times a week since a couple of weeks after they opened. If you haven't been there yet, you have to go or you are missing out on just a home town great place; a diamond in the ruff of wanna be bagel stores! You could not ask for more if you tried here, but if you did, their great staff would be accommodating. All in all, this is one of the best bagel stores ever and I have lived in Oceanside for over 60 years! We even have relatives in Canada and when we go there, fairly regularly, requests for a couple of dozen bagels are always fulfilled and brought to them. Seems when the family came in for a visit and had Wills Bagels, they now can't get enough of them either! read more

I'm so glad that this bagel store opened in Oceanside. I think the bagels are delicious especially the everything which is my family's favorite. I love to see a new business thrive. Their prices are better than other bagel stores. read more

Just the service needs improvement for the workers. Maybe bad day for me to stop by but I wasn't not enjoying what I saw and how they handled a mistake from a customer read more

Best bagels!! I've tried so many bagels in Nassau county over the years and Wills bagels are the absolute best!

Bagels are really good but waiting 10 minutes to order and another 30 minutes to get that order is insane.

Bagels are good, service is awful. Girl at the register with glasses is miserable and rude. There's one girl in there that actually smiles and friendly.. everyone else in there looks miserable to be there barely looks at you or says anything. There's a ton of good bagel places on Long Island you should try being friendly, fake it if you have to read more

So happy to find out they offer gluten free bagels. I got the everything bagel. It was everything but good. The worst gf bagel I ever had. No taste, hard has a brick, absolutely gross. I was so disappointed. read more

The bagels are great here. They have everything that you would want in a bagel and it all looks fresh. The people that work here are so pleasant and friendly. I live in Malverne and travel to this shop because it's nice to go into a store that has quality food and happy employees. You get greeted as you come into the store. There is a little parking close buy well worth the walk if you have to park further. read more

Great hand rolled bagels, which is hard to find. Great egg sandwiches, and great iced coffee. Potential to be better if their customer service enhances. I understand they just opened, but waited 30min for an egg sandwich. The registrar seems overwhelmed, stressed, and could not handle the influx of orders. With a little more structure and support, this place will be an Oceanside staple read more

Bagels are great, however the staff is the absolute worst. It's by far the worst customer service I have ever experienced. They are so rude it's unbelievable. You should only go here if you have at least an hour to kill because that's how long it takes to get your food. Be prepared to be served uncooked home fries and have to cook them yourself at home. Absolute worst place ever. There are PLENTY of other great bagel stores in the area. I am only giving 2 stars because the bagels are actually good so if they keep whoever makes the bagels and replaced all the other staff they would deserve a better rating. read more

Best bagels in Oceanside, actually Long Island. They are so fresh. The staff is so nice and cheerful. One of the bakers used to work at the original and nostalgic Stuff and bagels, which was also amazing. Will's jalapeño bagel is Outstanding, and so is the everything bagels that's loaded with seeds. Yummy read more

The plain bagel with veggie cream cheese and coffee i bought were good. I enjoyed the bagel and price is not bad. Service was good and friendly staff. The place is nice and clean. read more

Ordered the same sandwich 3 separate times. First time it was delicious. Second time it was missing 2 of the ingredients. 3rd time it was terrible. read more

Best bagels on Long Island! The bagels are always so fresh no matter what time I go in.

The best bagel place on long island!!! So much better than 24 hour Long Island Bagel Cafe. The bagels at Wills are always fresh and the staff is so nice. Never going to another bagel place!!! read more

The sandwiches and the service are great , we had the egg sandwiches on a bagel and.it was really tasty, love the decor