I would definitely eat here every single day if I lived in this area. The bagels are amazing.the lox bagel - perfect!!! The cream cheese tastes like homemade and the lox - not too salty! This is a gem!!! The owner and staff were so welcoming. I can't wait to go back. Listen, if you live in Baldwin or near by, do support this business. read more

See all

12/6/25. Cinnamon bagel didn't have much cinnamon flavor, tasted more like a plain bagel. Lox seemed fresh and was given ample amount of onions. Scallion cream cheese was average. The chocolate rugelach ($15.99/pd) was average as well. I liked the sugar crystals on top but it was a bit mushy, and oily on the bottom. Service was quick and friendly. read more

Bagel Boss - Oceanside - 12/6/25 - Bagels Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Before I begin my review, please note that somebody below decided not to learn kosher laws and believes they were being discriminated against for being visibly lgbtq, but wasn't themselves culturally sensitive enough to learn that kosher dairy establishments do not serve chicken. Shame on them, Jews are some of the most supportive people of lgbtq people and rights. Bagel boss is usually a great place for a morning bagel with generous portions. However once in a while the staff isn't paying attention and messes up the order. Today a brunette woman behind the counter mixed up my order and gave much less than the usual amount of lox on the albeit wrong bagel. Today's visit was the second time they ruined my order since I've been going and they charge too much for their lox to be messing up orders. Very difficult to decide if I will be coming back here for my bagels. If management considered removing incompetent staff I will return. read more

Bagel Boss is a casual, local place that has great bagels and so they make great bagel sandwiches. You can sit down alone and relax or with friends here. Have to disagree with Stacy a bit. Their cinnamon raisin is on point. It's one of my favs But then again, I don't put lox and onions on it. It's either butter or cream cheese They always have a variety of fresh bagels on hand from oat bagels , everything, pumpernickel and even rainbow. As for the rugelach, go next door to the bakery. That's what I do. If u r lucky they will be hot out of the oven. And they usually have raspberry cinnamon or chocolate. read more

Bagels always on point and tuna salad is the best! Also great people there who are so nice and always remember us.

Who tells a customer that you don't have chicken salad or egg salad because you're Kosher? Both of those things can be Kosher. And they're on display. Maybe try not telling a Jewish person what is and isn't Kosher next time. Couldn't even order here, I'm guilty of being LGBTQ+ in public. read more

This is a busy location although they need work to improve their workflow but who is taking orders they have a selection of approximate eight bagels and a deli area I asked for a quarter pound of chicken salad and they said they didn't have any but I'm pretty sure that I saw it. They had a multitude of prepared sides. They had cream cheese for purchase in the cooler which was 6.35 for .5 pound so if you're taking it home, just buy your own cream cheese. Not bad but better than grocery store. read more

Bagel Boss - Oceanside - Bagels Near Me - Oceanside, New York

When I called to place an order the lady who answered said she was busy two times very rude and unhelpful especially as a food service worker her accent was very harsh to understand not a place I would recommend! EVER read more

Bagels were fresh, coffee hot, service was great. Store was clean and orderly. Display cases were brightly lit and easy to make selections.

Craving Tuna on a bagel. Ordered scooped out toasted bagel. First they charge $9.47 for Tuna, another $1.50 to put it on a bagel and another $.75 for a slice of onion. Unbelievable. Take my order and leave and I get Tuna, untoasted, on a stale bagel. NEVER AGAIN read more

Bagels are stale, way too much cream cheese on the bagel even when you ask for light on the cream cheese/butter. Coffee sucks. Girl at the front has a terrible attitude. Very limited options for food being that it's a kosher establishment. read more

Grabbed a quick breakfast with my boyfriend on Sunday morning. He ordered an everything bagel with butter & I got a plain bagel with cream cheese + tomato. For both orders, it came out to less than $5.50, which is a really nice change from city prices. Overall, no complaints - it was a quick grab & go. My bagel was pretty good, but my boyfriend's would have benefitted with a nice pinch of salt. read more

The last few times I went to this location, my family & I were so disappointed with our order. Today's order was another and final disappointment. I ordered 1 egg everything & 2 poppyseed bagels with a little cream cheese... I got practically nothing on each. I happen to purchase a small cream cheese & 4 mini bagels (2 sesame & 2 poppy). We ended up adding cream cheese to our bagels. It was a waste of money, time & gas. read more

See all

I went in this morning to buy a few things including a medium coffee. They charge $4 for a medium, hot coffee!!!! Nothing special to it...just a run of the mill cup of coffee. I would expect to pay this price at Starbucks. I will not be returning due to this huge turnoff to this extraordinary price. read more

We loved these bagels and cream cheese. We had one bagel and a smear of schmear as we went through the TSA checkpoint at LGA. The agent said, "I really should take that away, but go ahead." Respect. read more

The better of the bagel shops in the area , they always taste warm, fresh and amazing on Sunday's, other days have been hit or miss.

Bagel Boss of Oside is pretty mediocre. Bagels tend to be really bland and dry! I swear there only 2 people working the counter at a time which makes for the long lines out the door, and sometimes you can be waiting 20 min on line. However I will credit that this place is Kosher friendly! read more

Terrible customer service, you try calling, they pick up and hang up on you with no words. They locked the door early before closing, and no one is helping read more

Bagel Boss - Oceanside - the reflection of a man in a store window - Bagels Near Me - Oceanside, New York

I wasn't able to eat my vegetable omelette. I told them I didn't care for carrots in the omelette and it was over cooked. I have to throw it out. The sesame bagel was ok. The people next to me eating French toast. That looks good. read more

Bagel Boss - Oceanside - Bagels Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

We needed a bagel place that could feed 10 of us. Hugo was so helpful and friendly and very patient taking our order even though it was busy and loud. He triple checked everything was right and even gave us a free coffee. He was awesome and I noticed he knew the names of a lot of people coming in. Great customer service. The bagels were delicious and fresh, I had the smoked salmon and cream cheese with tomatoes, onions and capers. It was divine. I highly recommend! read more

Okay, we have been here twice now. Each time, the food is good (maybe even great) and the service is just shy of dismal. FIRST VISIT: I discover they have "low carb" bagels, very cool. How low carb, and do I believe what they say? Not sure. But if they are a few grams less than standard bagels, great). We ordered two toasted bagels with lox and the works. And then waited what was at least 20 minutes. But, the sandwiches were totally delish. Plus, they included coleslaw (or optionally potato salad), and pickles. The slaw was actually amazing, almost (not quite) like grandma used to make. We were very impressed and enjoyed our meals. At around $11 each, with the sides, a reasonable price. SECOND VISIT: We are attended to by a guy in his early 20s. I say "two bagel and lox sandwiches" and then things go off the rails. He can't get that we want TWO, for some reason he think my GF wants 2 on her own, he can't get the order of what types we want correct, and this goes on a few minutes until another worker steps in to set him straight. We tell him, bagel #1 gets lox, cream cheese, tomato, onion." Bagel #2 gets the same, but no onion." And this goes back and forth a bit. Then he comes back to ask if we want them toasted, we say yes. And then we wait. Not as long as the first visit, but a while. Finally, he is done and we pay and leave. Once home we open the bag and find that: NEITHER BAGEL WAS TOASTED. NEITHER BAGEL HAD TOMATO SLICES. And the coleslaw was NOT the same as last time. This was nothing close to grandma's, rather, it was just very average commercial tripe that many of us would pass on. Same with the potato salad. So, there you go. read more

Perfectly served bagels, delicious as well. Add tip top service and I will most definitely be back!

Nothing special. I got the egg white and spinach tuna salad wrap. It was flavor less less like none. I asked for a croissant but when I started driving I realized they never put it in the bag. But by the looks of it send that they charged me for it. They were polite and had good customer service but they should really write Down there orders. I wad in a hurry so I couldn't even go back to ask for my croissant of money back. read more

I love bagels, though I rarely eat them, and I grew up with this Bagel Boss on the corner of my street. Whenever I go to visit my parents I look forward to the bagel & (scallion) cream cheese in the morning. The bagels are pretty uniformly very good, in my experience, and I would stick to those rather than being tempted by the plastic-containered palmiers, rainbow cookies and non-fat muffins that they offer too. Mario's next door is the place to go for sweets, for sure, so just go there after getting your bagel! Service is not the quickest, but that's okay, cause every visit here kinda feels like a relaxed Sunday. I couldn't recommend the coffee, per se - even the availability of flavored coffee knocks some points off your score, in my book - so just stick to the bagels and you'll be happier! read more

The absolute best bagels.... best variety bagels and toppings, and always fresh, and always served by an amazing counter crew that never fails to anticipate the customers' preferences. The home like ambience always makes the customers comfortable and special. Try the flageles.... they're the best! read more

As much as i love bagel boss and dont get me wrong, i really love them. The service at the oceanside location has been sub par. Several times my order isnt as i want it. I get it , you guys are up at the crack of dawn perhaps your tired or hungry yourselves and the last thing u want to do is carer to some annoying customers. Well, this customer rather travel to the bagel boss in hewlett to get the proper service. read more

Bagel Boss - Oceanside - Is this lightly toasted or burnt? - Bagels Near Me - Oceanside, New York

If you're looking for a great bagel shop, you found it! Enjoyed my everything bagel with butter. Yum! read more

Bagel Boss - Oceanside - Bagels Near Me - Oceanside, New York

I went to few different bagel boss & this one happen to be the one with worse service I ever received. I walked in, no one is there to take order. 2 person walked around & not even once bother to ask me if I want anything. Then I finally said good morning & then one person came up to me & asked me what I want to order? Then when I finally got the bagel, barely any cream cheese & my bagel was totally burned. It literally took more than 10 minutes to make that. I also asked for quarters pound egg white spinach & the guy literally asked me loudly "anything else"??? I kind of felt like he was feeling bothered. Then when he was bagging the bagel & egg spinach, he asked me do u need spoon? I said yes, he literally shoved one fork with piece of napkin. Come on guy, how am I suppose to eat the egg spinach??? With my barehand!!! One thing I definitely noticed that they are more friendly & respectful to customers who are from the town who comes regularly & I definitely felt like I'm a outsider don't belong there. read more

no sausage , no bacon , no eggs but they have fish ? this is bagel loss not bagel boss read more

Love this place! We come here at least once a week for pumpernickel bagels with cream cheese and oat bagels with eggwhite spinach salad. The bagels are always phenomenal. Toasted and crusty on the outside, dense and chewy on the inside. The coffee is good and the staff is always super nice! They have fresh B&W cookies and a great bakery case, as well as some gluten free options for when my sister comes along (fresh fruit, omelettes, gluten free linzer torte cookies, tuna salad, etc.) read more

Thank you so much for our bagel,spreads and muffin platter. It looked amazing, survived the trip to jersey and all was delicious. As Suggested we picked up early and bagels fresh. Again thanks read more

Best bagels and mac salad on LI. I come here at least 3x a week for my fix. Service is very friendly, even when its busy.

First and probably last time here. My coffee was good and got so that's good.... As for my poppy flat bagel with lox cream cheese there's literally almost nothing on it and for a grand total of $6.75 what a waste. read more

Bagel Boss - Oceanside - Poppy bagel with a weak amount of lox cream cheese. $4.25...... Dry AF - Bagels Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

The bagels are great. I usually get a lightly toasted bagel with lox, cream cheese, and sliced tomato. Knocking one star off because the service can be hit or miss. Sadly, it's due to one worker in particular. I don't know his name, but he can be described as the typical high school / college guy working there part time. He doesn't listen, has a bit of an attitude, and if your meal comes with anything (e.g. Free side salad), he will assume you don't want the item. Everyone else that works there is great. They listen and give you exactly what you order. read more

Friendly staff Delicious bagels, spreads, and cookies. The ultimate is a well done egg bagel with veg cream cheese on it. This sandwich will fill you for the entire day. Promise~ ALL GOOD THINGS!!! Good iced coffee too. I prefer my long island bagels to those in NYC. read more

A very nice, convenient and helpful place when you are in need of bagels and all the salads you can think of. Even when the Jewish holidays came and we needed to place a pretty big order almost at the last minute, they were able to accommodate us and supply us with everything we needed. I am a fan of their salads . . . they offer the standards, but dressed up or with a twist. The egg salad is egg white salad with spinach (although I am sure they have the regular egg salad as well), the smoked whitefish salad is soooo good -- it is smoky, creamy and just damn good. I've also ordered their lox as well which were fresh and cut very thin. And they have a nice seating area where you can enjoy your sandwich / salad. Keep in mind that while you can get an egg sandiwich here, it is a Kosher shop and therefore it is dairy only (no breakfast meat to be had). Also (for what it's worth), although the bagels are good, they don't rank as my favorite in the area -- these just are not as hearty as you get elsewhere as far as I am concerned -- but topped with your favorite shmear, and fish (or salad), it makes it all that much enjoyable. read more

If Bagel Boss Cafe wants to be the Bagel boss of me, they'll have to do better. Ordered a fried egg on oatmeal bagel, rice side dish and a cheese blintze. The bagel was fine, the rice was ok and the cheese blintze had cherries in it which made the whole thing much to sweet. (I made it clear to the server that I wanted just a 'cheese' blintze but she obviously didn't care.) If I happen to pass by this place again I'd go but I can guarantee I won't pass this place again. read more

Bagel Boss - Oceanside - Blintze and rice - Bagels Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Even when I lived in the area, like now, i usually visit the Bagel Boss in Merrick, 10 minutes east. It's not that I don't like it here, but a matter of convenience. That being said, I love the bagels here. The are a meal unto themselves. I like them even better with some veggie tuna fish. read more

No kidding I come here atleast 3 times a week! It never fails. Absolutely Delicious!!

The bagels, and lox are delicious ( just spent $30)... my order 6/28/17 was 1/2 Lb. lox.. 6 bagels, & 3/4. Plain Cream Cheese.. the young lady behind the counter was asked " is that 3/4 lb cream cheese " ( answer yes).. paid for my order came home...NOPE ..NOT 3/4 It was less than a smear. read more