We love this local bagel store - hot fresh bagels & fantastic bagel sandwiches. Eggs are prepared…read morefresh for each sandwich - I get my eggs scrambled and hubby gets his over medium so the yolk can soak into everything. Delicious! I also had their vanilla yogurt (not on the menu but it's in the case) - they don't make it but it was sweet and tangy and it's a large serving. They do make the rice pudding (also in the case) so we'll have to come back for that. Parking - there is a tiny lot (4 spaces?) behind the store and on the street in front and on the side. Entrance is accessible. There are a few tables inside, but we always get everything to go. Staff are friendly and efficient. Love this place!

First time going there. Bagel egg and sausage and cheese was delicious and fresh…read more Actually couldn't finish it being was so.packed. Definitely this is my place for bagels since moving in the area. The young lady at the counter was extremely cute and friendly

Awesome 24-hour bagel deli. Great sandwiches and sides. Great bagels. Good iced teas.read more

One of the best local spots to get a delicious bagel anytime!!! My go-to here is the egg bagel with…read morebacon egg and cheese. I always love to get it toasted. You come up to the counter and say your order. Then you wait for the guy you ordered from to prepare your order. Today I had a pretty bulk order of about 4 bagels (all toasted) and wanted to try out the "lunch flat" specials. I picked the bacon chicken ranch one and the korean braised rib one. They probably are the ones that made the wait the longest because they turned out looking AMAZING!! Everything was delicious and filling. I love this spot so much! PS Had to remind about my gf's nut allergy and the staff said there's seeds everywhere but will do his best to keep things clean.. Happy to note that everything was great and she was able to enjoy the food here!!! - lots of variety to order: fresh brewed coffee, drinks, chips, sandwiches - open 24 hrs

Small restaurant but how much room do you need to eat a bagel…read more easy on street parking. For a quite run in for a bag of bagels. no need for toasting the bagels freshly made and delicious

Door Dash Date: September 9, 2020…read more My sister got a last week of watching my son in before he started pre-k. I'm a hot mess and am trying intuitive eating and have discovered I'm not one for eating breakfast right after I wake up. I forgot to grab egg bites or something from Starbucks when I got coffee for everyone so I made a door dash order for myself, my sister, my son and her son. I got an omelette which was seemed like a usual omelette but I wish they had included ketchup unless they did and I just grabbed the food in a hurry and it was in the paper bag. I'm not sure if my sister liked her eggs or my son or her son liked the pancakes she didn't tell me. I was impressed with how they packaged the food especially during this time of COVID when people are taking precautions. Overall I'd order or go there again, I wouldn't say it was mind blowing food but it wasn't bad either.

best bagels and sandwiches around! my favorite is a toasted French toast bagel with butter and a…read moreside of their chicken salad. Excellent customer service!!

Not a good place. Better places with the same food like Bagelville or Long Island Bagel Café…read more Service and ambiance are bad.

I would definitely eat here every single day if I lived in this area. The bagels are amazing.the…read morelox bagel - perfect!!! The cream cheese tastes like homemade and the lox - not too salty! This is a gem!!! The owner and staff were so welcoming. I can't wait to go back. Listen, if you live in Baldwin or near by, do support this business.

12/6/25. Cinnamon bagel didn't have much cinnamon flavor, tasted more like a plain bagel. Lox…read moreseemed fresh and was given ample amount of onions. Scallion cream cheese was average. The chocolate rugelach ($15.99/pd) was average as well. I liked the sugar crystals on top but it was a bit mushy, and oily on the bottom. Service was quick and friendly.

Being new in the area I wanted to support a local business. When fresh, their bagels are delicious,…read moreinexpensive and generously sized. But twice I have gotten bagels that were apparently made yesterday. After buying bagels at 7:30 AM, we discovered they were not fresh because they crumbled when cut. When we called to ask when they were made because these were not what we were expecting, the response was surprising: "Nobody else has complained". If we've gotten the correct response, which would be bring them back, and I'll give you new ones. They'd have gotten a loyal customer.

The food is good, prices are decent however the drinks and chips are pricey and limited. The staff…read moreare nice and the place is clean. Overall a nice local bagel shop.

I slept over my sister's condo with my son and her 3 kids. My son and his cousin stayed up the…read morewhole night. My sister slept upstairs with her daughters and I was downstairs with the boys so I couldn't walk out in the morning to find a bagel place. After scrolling through grub hub I was happy to find three guys and they were reasonably priced compared to other bagel stores. I ordered a dozen bagels, some cream cheese and coffee. I liked the coffee and the bagels were the right amount of soft and hard combined. The cream cheese was creamy and good. I'm pleased with this bagel place.

First tip. Found out after the fact that it's best to place your order in advance to get your…read morefavorites. Lesson learned, as we specifically wanted the now sold out, Sesame Bagels in our order of a dozen. Had to pivot and order what was left. Additional tip, stay away from the novelty bagels, they move less and will not be freshly made. Another lesson learned. Their schmear's. I was hesitant, but went ahead and opted for a small container of Salmon Cream Cheese. Instructed my server to please incorporate as much salmon as possible, as the display looked quite scant on Salmon. Thankfully he obliged. To conclude. One thing I always ask someone while dining in or ordering to-go. "Questions is...would you come back?" or "Would you order from them again". My answer...No. Too many other bagel shops on the Island to try out.

Came here the other day after a pedicure. it's in the corner near the train station. It's a quiet…read morelittle tucked away place. I ordered a matcha and the new yorker breakfast sandwich with turkey bacon. The matcha was okay. But the breakfast sandwich was unforgettable! It was by far one of the best breakfast sandwiches I've ever had. There was a little confusion with the sandwiches someone ordered the same but with regular bacon but the situation was rectified and we were accommodated. matcha 6/10 the new yorker 100000000/10

Stopped in for a coffee decided to grab a breakfast sandwich too…read more Caramel latte for me , matcha latte for my wife and Bacon, egg and cheese sandwiches for both. Coffee was good, sandwiches were okay. The staff was nice. Wasn't to sure if the guy that came out the back was maintenance and or the cook. Small cafe. Probably best suited for better weather as they also have outdoor space. Great location for the commuting public on the LIRR.

Great costumer service, really nice guy. Got a BEC on a huge everything bagel, and also got a…read morecoffee on the house! Highly recommend

Food - I ordered a egg and cheese on a everything bagel. Bagel was not toasted, should I have asked…read morefor it to be? Egg was not the freshest. Cheese was gooey and good. But the bagel itself was extremely flat in taste. They gave me a free bagel with my purchase. Not the best. Threw it out. Service - decent, guy taking my order looked confused. Ambiance - dead inside. On a Tuesday morning at 9 am. Should've been a clue. Verdict - I would not return. Not a good bagel shop for me.

Visit Date: April 28, 2026…read more I came to Kookaburra before my endocrinologist appointment. It was in my LI Cafe Passport book. I've noticed some reviews say they are cash only, I paid in cash but I also saw some customers using debit cards. I got my dad a bag of coffee because I have Christmas money I had saved to take him out and we only went to Panera a few times so I've been buying him bags of coffee from the nice coffee shops. I got an iced cafe mocha with half and half. It was very good, creamy, chocolately and it gave a nice buzzzz. The coffee shop itself is very small, most of the space is dedicated to their coffee machines and food service. There is limited seating outside but it's not a place where they encourage you to stay and hang out after you get your coffee. It's still good though. It's more of a grab and go coffee spot. They also have no bathrooms but if you ask for a bathroom they will refer you to the train station or the cathedral near the coffee shop. I would recommend coming here for coffee it's really good but if you're looking to linger you can't.

Saw there were a bunch of people sitting outside, so I went in to see a short line. I was helped…read moreright away. Got a toasted marshmallow iced latte which was very good. I think I have gotten this flavor in the past but it seemed better than I remembered. They now have a screen to tap your card, so it's not cash only anymore!