First tip. Found out after the fact that it's best to place your order in advance to get your favorites. Lesson learned, as we specifically wanted the now sold out, Sesame Bagels in our order of a dozen. Had to pivot and order what was left.
Additional tip, stay away from the novelty bagels, they move less and will not be freshly made. Another lesson learned.
Their schmear's. I was hesitant, but went ahead and opted for a small container of Salmon Cream Cheese. Instructed my server to please incorporate as much salmon as possible, as the display looked quite scant on Salmon. Thankfully he obliged.
To conclude. One thing I always ask someone while dining in or ordering to-go. "Questions is...would you come back?" or "Would you order from them again".
My answer...No.
Too many other bagel shops on the Island to try out. read more