Stopped by to pick up a few bagels and an iced coffee. Didn't expect anything special. But what happened next was not only a total surprise but an indication that this is a place that has pride in the service they provide... As I was putting my iced coffee together, I was asked if I would like my coffee wrapped with suran wrap so it will stay together and not spill during the travel. I was not expecting it and was touched that the worker cared enough to help me out so that I can enjoy my drink with minimal spillage. What a nice way to make someone's day! For that I give them 5 stars and a big ! Don't see this type of care much anymore and am glad it still exists. Definitely will stop by again when in the neighborhood. Thanks for your service! read more

Mustachio's is simply the best! From the staff to the food, it's a must-have for us every single weekend that we're in Merrick. We travel from the city for Mustachio's and for the off-menu Sledgehammer (aka the Justin). Don't skip this deli! read more

Mustachios Deli is truly a neighborhood gem and we are so lucky to have it right around the corner! The staff is incredibly friendly and always so accommodating, and the owners are some of the most professional, kind, and hardworking people you'll meet. Ask for anything and they'll make it happen -- no question! The food is always fresh and absolutely delicious. I've been trying (and failing ) to crack the secret formula for their Bang Bang Chicken, so I guess I'll just have to keep ordering it every Thursday! Honestly, my family and I practically live here. They're amazing with kids, so personable, and genuinely make you feel like family every time you walk in. Between the wonderful atmosphere, incredible food, outstanding service, and just an all-around fantastic group of people, Mustachios Deli never disappoints. Highly recommend! read more

Well this is why I don't go out to deli and pizza places anymore because To spend $26 for a turkey sandwich that is literally about a couple of slices of turkey and two slices of Swiss cheese on rye bread for $12 is absurd if you're gonna charge something make the sandwich worthwhile and then a chicken cutlet hero that's basically lettuce and bread for $14 ever since Covid and all of the horse shit over pricing everybody still sticks to those prices and screws all of the consumers over that's why I don't go to these places anymore I figured I would give this place one more shot but it's sad that they can't put a little bit extra meat on a sandwich they just don't know how to make sandwich sandwiches read more

A hidden gem we found on google maps!! We were craving some sandwiches to bring to the beach on this fine day. Upon entering, they were quite busy and attentive to everyone. There is a wide variety of things to order from; sandwiches, breaky sandwiches, platters and salads. We got the brookmeadow sub and it was huge we decided to split it. I can't wait to try out the paninis. Grab your lunch/breakfast before heading to the beach! I also want to try their coffee, it looks promising. read more

Mustachio's Deli - Menu - Delis Near Me - Merrick, New York

See all

Unfortunately felt like the food was not worth the price I paid for it. 2 breakfast sandwiches came out to $24. When paying $15 for a bacon egg and cheese you'd think it would have more than 2 strips of bacon and a slice of avocado for the upcharge. If I paid $3 for extra bacon and it only came with 3 slices, how much does it usually come with? 1 slice? So I paid an extra $3 for 2 slices? Over medium sandwhich didn't have cheese and the egg was already broken leaving it a mess. For their top tier pricing I'd expect better products. Does that bacon egg and cheese look worth $15? Do you think it's fair I paid extra for extra bacon and that's how it looks? Was left unsatisfied. read more

Mustachio's Deli - Eggs and Bacon Sandwich - Delis Near Me - Merrick, New York

Betrayal. Treachery. A Judas kiss, if you will. All of these describe Mustachio's Deli. I was a regular customer for six months, and all was well in this beautiful world--until I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese with extra bacon. They charged me $2.75 for extra bacon! This is how they treat loyal customers? With disrespect? Let's do the math on how ridiculous this is: A pack of bacon costs $6 and contains 12 strips. That means each strip costs about $0.50, right? So for two extra strips, it should only cost $1.00. But no. They had the audacity to charge a loyal customer an extra $1.75! The only way to describe that is pure greed--money-grubbing and gluttony. Mustachio's Deli should go to confession for the sins they've brought upon a great man like myself. read more

The food is overall tasty and good! I really wanted to become a return customer, but it's just priced way too high for a grab and go deli with no tables. I'd check out Freeport deli that's nearby, it's half the cost, just as good plus you can sit and eat there. read more

Great sandwiches, friendly service and reasonable prices. Huge tasty muffins. Cheapest egg sandwiches in the area. What else can you ask for? read more

The best deli around! The owners, Felix & G (and kids ) are the best. Friendly, professional, and a real local Family business owned by people who care and you can taste it in everything they make. read more

Decided to treat myself to a late takeout lunch at Mustachio's after getting a key made next door. Stepping in to the small store I was immediately impressed by the cleanliness, extensive menu and friendly atmosphere. The deli had a steady stream of customers, a good sign late on a weekday, and everyone was masked and socially distant. I remembered reading a glowing Yelp review of Mustachio's roast beef sammie so ordered one of those. The fresh seeded kaiser roll was stuffed with rare roast beef (the way I like it), lettuce and mustard, neatly wrapped in paper for easy eating. Then I saw their yummy desserts in the cold case near the register so just had to get a slice of fudge cake with whipped cream too. Everything was fresh and scrumptious (especially the cake), and prices were reasonable too. Old school family owned delis are becoming rare these days so I'm glad to have found Mustachio's. read more

Mustachio's Deli - Roast Beef onna Roll Delish - Delis Near Me - Merrick, New York

See all

This place is crazy good. I found it when I stayed next door at the gateway inn. Good food coffee atmosphere everything is good. Excellent muffins read more

Delicious muffins! We had banana walnut, Raisin Bran, and apple cinnamon muffins over the course of two weeks. All were just the right amount of sweetness, moist and fluffy with the right chew. Will come back and try the other ones! read more

Mustachio's Deli - Delis Near Me - Merrick, New York

Excellent service and very helpful staff. If you like sandwich's and sweets this should be your number 1 spot!

Welcome Mustachio's Deli! Suppose it's been time for a change. Same location as our old favorite place, however COMPLETELY renovated. You won't believe how new it looks until you see it for yourself. First impression is certainly good so far. Lots of family / familiar faces at the counter you may recognize from other local businesses. The menu looks incredible if you don't feel like making a custom order. There are good grab and go salads or ready made paninis just waiting to be heated up for you. The Cuban looked delicious. Seems they have a deep fryer (they must have totally started from scratch in the kitchen). The build your own chopped salad station also looks great. Started simple with a bacon egg and cheese / tomato/pepper / ketchup - it didn't disappoint. Order was perfect. Seems we've got a new go-to breakfast / lunch spot in Merrick. read more

See all

I have been coming to this place since it opened. The owners knows their customers and greet them by name. They remember my wife and daughter's names too. The team is great at remembering your frequent orders and the food is always well presented, tasty and quick. Highly recommend this place. read more

This hidden gem will not let you down!! Happened to pass by here one day and so glad I stopped in. I tried The Godfather sandwich and it was SOOO good. The staff were is so friendly and helpful and made sure I was happy with everything I got. They have plenty of options in both cold and hot food for breakfast and lunch as well as some prepackaged things if you're in a rush. Can't wait to come back here again for lunch! read more

Mustachio's Deli - The Godfather Sandwich - Delis Near Me - Merrick, New York

Stumbled upon this place this morning. Great customer service, large portions. Food was delicious and they have a variety to choose from. Definitely recommend! read more

Mustachio's Deli - Banana nut muffin - Delis Near Me - Merrick, New York

New place ! Very clean! Delicious breakfast ! Overall a great experience. I got egg& cheese on a croissant so good. My brother got bacon sausage egg and cheese on a hero he loved his. Everything was fresh. I will definitely be coming back for more ! read more

Mustachio's Deli - Delis Near Me - Merrick, New York

Stopped here on the way to the beach. It had everything we needed and the staff was super friendly. The sandwich was a little on the dry side but it hit the spot. I would visit again and try something new. read more

Mustachio's Deli - The Godfather Sandwich - Delis Near Me - Merrick, New York

Good food and friendly people. They're pretty quick even when busy too. So glad I found this place. I was tired of the ridiculous long waits and being mistreated at Smith St deli, where staff only seems to be nice to cops, EMS, fire firefighters and construction workers. read more

Best egg sandwich I've had in a long time. Friendly on the phone, which gets stars from me. They get the order right every time

Staff is amazing!!!! Helpful, happy and take pride in their work. Food was fresh and packed well. Crumb cake coffee is delicious as well. Bye Starbucks!!! This is my new home!!!! read more

See all

The friendly, courteous staff and owner, the clean operations and store ( a 100% health code rating ! ) and a variety of fresh, well-prepared and delicious food for every hour and taste will most certainly give those nearby high-priced delis over on Smith Street and Merrick Road a run for their money. From now on, I'm placing MY money on Mustachio's. Winner ! ...You're still here ? I thought you'd be on your way to Mustachio's already ! read more

Well worth driving a block off sunrise Highway for. Stopped off here coming back from Freeport with work and was blown away by how tasty my panini was and my partner got the sideline which was spicy but delicious! Everyone working there was super friendly and will definitely be coming back read more

Mustachio's Deli - Chicken Delight Panini - Delis Near Me - Merrick, New York

Fantastic Deli, the service is great and makes you feel at home. You can taste the fresh ingredients in each sandwich, I'm so glad that I have discovered this place , friendly and clean, read more

My godfather sandwich tasted so good on the beach. I love an Italian sandwich and this one was perfect. Only wish I could have finished it.

owNEW Had 16 guests coming to my house for lunch and wanted to get a 6 foot hero 2 feet turkey, 2 feet italian and 2 feet chicken cutlet. Felix assisted making sure we had just the right amount of food and sides. He was a true pleasure to work with and the heroes and sides were amazing. Would highly recommended this deli!! read more

I called jn my order 5 days before my event and they made it happen. The food was amazing and packed really well. The owners are an amazing couple . Will be ordering from them again . read more

Mustachio's Deli - Catering order Chicken marsala, beef and broccoli Teriyaki, baked Ziti, penne ala pasta, roasted veggies and Spanish rice - Delis Near Me - Merrick, New York

Wonderful deli with workers that actually give a hoot! Sandwiches are new and different and of course delicious. We'll worth the trip from Seaford and I will definitely go back again! read more

Amazing food and great service! My new favorite deli spot on the island! Keep up the great work!

HAPPY DANCE IN FULL EFFECT! Thanksgiving was around the corner and I needed some fantastic desserts to come after all the food I was cooking. I asked Felix if he would create a coconut flan and some pastries. (His regular flan is amazing if you haven't tried!) He went the extra mile to create the coconut flan to go along with the cherry and cream cheese and apple danishes. WOW!!!! They were all a hit. Just taste the love in each bite. And although the food is always fresh and delicious, it's that extra touch Felix, his wife and the staff put into everything. There are tons of deli's around but only one MUSTACHIOS's.....We all have our "go to" spots and this is certainly mine. If you haven't stopped by, please do. I promise there's no way to not love this place and the people in it. THANK YOU GUYS for the morning greetings, the perfect iced coffee, and all the attention you put into everything you serve. read more

New place in the area and they are doing it right. Ordered a breakfast sandwich for my husband and a lettuce wrap for me we split home fries everything was amazing. I never leave reviews but our food was too good to not share!! Good job Mustachios read more

Mustachio's Deli - Buffalo chicken lettuce wrap - Delis Near Me - Merrick, New York

See all

Got 2 Godfathers on a hero, great bread and great tasting sandwich. Super friendly atmosphere. I called in my order, heard they were busy inside but took my order with a friendly tone. Walked in and they directed me to the front cashier where I can pick up my order. The cashier was also friendly and gave me a business card that explained to me that I can scan and then text in my order. Great food and great place to spend your money. read more

Great/fast service! Everyone is super friendly! Great variety on the menu. Extremely clean. Great prices too! I tried the stash wrap and was not disappointed. The home fries inside the wrap and the stash sauce were my favorite part of it. I also tried the pork loin, it was well seasoned and delicious. Got one of their apple pies too it was fresh and just as good, if not BETTER than bakery quality! Will definitely be returning and telling all my friends and co-workers about this place! read more

Mustachio's Deli - Stash wrap (eggs,bacon, cheese , home fries, and stash sauce) - Delis Near Me - Merrick, New York

It was clean and tidy in there and the workers were friendly but the egg sandwich I got was a pretty weak example of a bec- wouldn't go back if that was the norm. Cold cheese, one piece of hard burnt bacon. read more

Mustachio's Deli - Weak Bacon egg cheese - Delis Near Me - Merrick, New York

Bread was chewy! Microwaved my Chicken cutlet!!! Not a fan at all. Sandwich was not horrible but would never get it again.

Best deli in merrick by far. Foods always on point staff is always friendly and accommodating. I use mustachios for catering for my kids birthdays every year. You can tell they care about their buisness and their customers. read more

There are so many great delis in Long Island and this is one of them, there's a family owned business everybody's been very polite very attentive it desserts or homemade reasonable prices for the hot lunches deli sandwiches well worth the priceHuge portions, they renovated the place I believe it was the old Wardon's deli, stop by you won't regret it read more

First off let me just say my Bacon Egg & Cheese with salt pepper ketchup was DELICIOUS!. My coworker had a breakfast sandwich and I figured I'd give Mustachio's a shot. Man am I glad i did. The place was clean! Super friendly customer service and staff. My club roll was nice and soft although i wanted it toasted but that's the least because my sandwich was so good! I'm happy to say i gotta new spot for when I'm at work or even my off days read more