I mean the food is alright but every time I'm here I feel like I'm overcharged and quite honestly I'm not come back. I can't wrap my head for a BEC on an egg everything 1lb of chicken salad and a 99c arnie Palmer drink comes out to $27. This is the 3rd time I left feeling like I got robbed. Unfortunately I won't be coming back due to the prices. Growing up in centereach/selden there are cheaper and better bagels there that might be worth the drive. Edit: I just checked my bank account it was actually $29.10 read more

Smithtown Bagels - My $27 order.... - Bagels Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I have to out them. Big fan of flat bagels and gave one a try. It was simply an regular bagel that pounded down a bit before baking. Exact density as a regular bagel, just flattened out a little bit. The final insult was the price, $2.50 EACH. However super friendly and helpful people that work there, that's the other star. read more

Bagels are a bit of "a thingg" on strong island. Smithtown bagels is at the top. This place is tiiiiight. Bagels are often hot and staff will suggest whatever is freshest. Alot of Customers are greeted by name. They also sell newspapers which is clutch read more

I ordered an egg sandwich on a bagel and I got no cheese (paid for this) and I got it on a roll that literally looked like a hot dog bun. I am not one to complain but when I tell you I threw it away after a few bites it was that nasty. I couldn't believe what I was served. I work at the hospital down road and never will we order again here read more

See all

My prior review was based on a few bad experiences under the prior ownership and the business has since changed ownership. As such my experiences with the business are much better. The bagels were always the best but in the past the orders were wrong, quality of take out orders poor and help behind the counter annoying. That has since changed and if you want the best bagels give this place a try. read more

Best bagels around!! Amazing service and the bagels are always fresh! The owner is extremely dedicated and hard worker. I love their Bacon egg and cheeses. Prices are also reasonable. read more

Came here after my gym session - the bagels are perfect. Nice crust and the chewiness fights your bite just the right amount. Excellent bagels! read more

If you are a New Yorker who wants to showcase the joy of New York Bagels to someone out of state then this is the place to take them. Hands down, these are the best bagels I have ever eaten living in New York for over 60 years. Every bagel I have eaten at Smithtown Bagels is a 10 out of 10. They are always so fresh that I think I hear angels singing in my head with every bite. Additionaly, everyone is so friendly here that I think this place might actually be Heaven sent. Don't pass up a chance to experience it yourself! read more

Smithtown Bagels - Oh my God this was sooooo good - Bagels Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Okay, so for anyone who reads my reviews you know cleanliness is the most important thing to me next to the quality of the food. This place is VERY clean!! The food is okay. I have hit this place up 2 Saturdays in a row for lunch and both times the food was okay. Honestly nothing to write home about. However, I'm not sure if the guy behind the counter is the owner, manager, worker, I don't really know. First time, really rude, didn't want to help me, gave me attitude, and made a mess of my sandwich. I'm pretty sure he over charged me as well. All the pricing for sandwiches reflects hero size sandwiches but he claims he ran out of hero's so he put it on a roll, but charged me the same price as a hero. He made the sandwich so sloppy I had to pull it apart and remake it. I also asked for mayo and mustard and he made it dry. Today the kid made my sandwich, nice kid, very friendly. He made a better sandwich for sure. The entire time I was there that same guy from last week kept giving me dirty looks. I mean REALLY dirty looks. Total stink eye. A woman with a kid came in to buy bagels and he was all thank you "Sweetie, Baby, Honey, and then looked at me like I should be dead. The entire experience was creepy and cringy, and made me feel uncomfortable enough to say I will not be going back. Going to let everyone in my office aware of this too. I'm sure this place is going to lose some business. I just don't get how you can be a business owner and treat people like that. read more

Long islands best bagels and service . Their attention to detail and consistency are bar none . Great attitudes and personalities . I travel Nassau and Suffolk and they are the BEST ! Kevin : read more

I love this place. Delicious bagels!!! A wonderful place, highly recommend coming here!!!

Always the best bagels around. Owners are so nice! Love going here so lucky to have this as our neighborhood bagel store!

Best bagel place around! Been coming to Smithtown bagels my whole life and they never disappoint

Best bagel store around! So many choices of bagels and they are always soft and fresh! Egg sandwiches are yummy and the staff are so nice!

My family loves Smithtown Bagels. We are there a few times a week. Everything is delicious and the staff is amazing. They know us by name and service is amazing. If I could give this place more than 5 stars I would. read more

Best bagels in town! Staff is always friendly, prices reasonable, place is clean. Highly recommend.

Best bagel place in town and great friendly service! You can eat there or take out. The owners are personable and have been there a long time. I've been going here for 20 years! read more

To me this was the first time I went to this bagel place and the last .i understand things went up but to pay for two eggs bacon and cheese on roll with a cup of coffee for 11 dollars is absurd think twice about going here read more

My favorite Bagel place! The bagels are ALWAYS good, the service is always done with a smile. Today, they were a little off, a tad slow (hey, it happens to the best of us!)...but we sure did have a good time while waiting! read more

Smithtown Bagels is the best bagel store around! Not only are the bagels delicious, the staff is super friendly and the restaurant is clean and pleasant. They not only have bagels but also yummy sandwiches and salads. They do a wonderful job making everything. Prices are reasonable. The staff and the bagels are great!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND SMITHTOWN BAGELS!!! read more

Smithtown Bagels - Strawberry Bagel with chocolate chip cream cheese the best! - Bagels Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Not the best, not the worst. I found it to be very over priced and the bagels were pretty small. Friendly staff though and super clean. read more

See all

Quick and kind service. Bagels tasted great had tons of options for smearables. The owner was really kind and welcoming so early in the morning! read more

Excellent customer service. I don't eat bacon and asked them to make me egg and cheese. There were nice enough to make it in a clean pan for me. Definitely stop by again and recommend to family and friends. read more

Best bagels around. Clean environment, friendly people and love the new staff. I've been going to Smithtown bagels for 15 years. The only thing I could say is sometimes it gets very busy in there and you have to wait for a sandwich but it's worth the wait read more

Smithtown Bagels - a person holding a sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Always good bagels and sandwiches ... never disappoints. Friendly and there's always parking. Super convenient.

I go there every Tuesday with the child I care for after going to The Little Gym. I starting caring for him 3 months ago and he loves going to this bagel-deli every week. His Mom has been taking him as well before me and still goes sometimes. The food is excellent. The bagels are still fresh at 2 p.m and the yogurt parfait are wonderful. The staff gets along great which is a true sign of a great business! Andrea goes extremely out of her way with Jared, the child I watch ,treats him special gives him cookies and lots of attention! Freddy and Steve are very helpful and friendly as well as anyone with a child know you will need some special requests or take a bit longer ! I have also seen them with other customers as we do stay and eat and they are wonderful with everyone. Plenty of regulars ! Store is spotless as well ! Great job! read more

I visit Long Island frequently, from Florida, to visit family. My cousin lives in Smithtown and he introduced me to this location. Every time we go, the customer service is excellent. The family that works the counters, the mom n daughter are always friendly, courteous and extremely helpful. The bagels and selections they have offer a great variety and their bagels are excellent. They do not skimp on the cream cheese either. I always make sure to stop here at least once to get my bagel fix and sometimes to bring bagels home to Florida. If I had one minor critique, it is they put too much milk in coffee when I order it. However, this time, I remember that and asked for very little milk and they made it to perfection. That is good service! The atmosphere and efficient service they provide is worth mentioning because they get busy and occasionally have a long line. When this happens, everyone "jumps" on the counter to help the customers and they move them fast, but still with the great service they provide. I will definitely visit them again when I return 'home' to Long Island. read more

Smithtown Bagels - Everything bagel with veggie cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Smithtown, New York

If you're looking for a tasty, fresh LI bagels, Smithtown Bagels is your place. The bagels are always soft, not stale; the store is clean, and the staff is masked up. You can tell they care about their customers. I can't vouch for the other food at the store because I always go straight for the bagels, but they do use quality ingredients. Highly recommend! read more

Best bagel in town! We have been going for years. My whole family's favorite. Bagels fresh, service great.

Best deli/bagel place in area. Staff is sooo friendly which makes me always want to give them my business. Great breakfast sandwiches and regular sandwiches. Their chicken salad is great too. Fair pricing. Their side salads are also tasty! Never disappointed read more

Bagel was shit. People need more training on taking orders. Was annoyed the whole time. Had to go to another bagel after tasting the saltiest everything bagel. Don't go here if you trying to enjoy your morning. Complete waste of money. read more

Went to Smithtown bagel for lunch with my wife. The man who helped us asked my wife what she wanted then walked away without asking my order. Wile putting her order together he kept walking away on his phone . Finally brought the order to the counter and started to ring it up. I said i would like to order something. I tried to to get your attention , but I guess you didn't hear me. He says to me very nasty" so than what do you want". Not wanting anything at this point , I just said A 1/2 pound of cream cheese. He didn't hear me so I repeated The order again , and he yelled back at me I heard you. Another customer next to me said wow. The man was obviously having a bad day. Bald head and goatee. Bad experience at Smithtown bagels. Not going to that place again read more

We just got egg sandwiches on bagels, which were made perfectly and tasted great. The salads all looked fresh as well. But what stood out was that the service - they were very friendly and appreciative. This place NEEDS a tip jar. Some of us still want to tip when we receive good service, and there wasn't one. Please put out a tip jar. read more

Been coming here for 20 years and everything is always good. Whether it be the bagels, sandwiches or whatever you prefer. Seth and Freddie are always a pleasure. read more

One of the Best Bagel stores in the area. Their cinnamon raisin are my favorite as well as the everything bagel. The staff couldn`t be friendlier or the store cleaner. . The store is always busy which should say something in itself. Never a disappointment .Always keep a few frozen in case the weather interferes with my travels. read more

Yeah.... This place has been here forever. I don't want to trash the neighborhood bagel store. The bagel itself wasn't too bad. Just waiting on line and looking around, the place is dirty. The ceiling tiles are stained and when you first walk into the store, the display jars are all dusty. The best I can give it is a 3 star meh. read more

First time going here in years. I remember liking it but today I ordered 2 different types of bagels and a chocolate chip muffin. Everything was stale. It was only 11:30am when I went there so everything should have still been fresh. Also, kid working the counter used his bare palm on top of my coffee lid to close it and pushed down right where the drink spout was. read more

Always been my favorite bagel spot. Great food, Freddy and the guys are friendly and remember your name / order. Family owned spot too I believe. read more

Most of the employees are nice ; except blonde older lady with nose ring , decided to fix the stapler instead of making my bagels , had me standing there waiting. Barely put any cream cheese on my bagel and when I asked for more she rolled her eyes and said there's extra extra cream cheese , so as I was leaving , she ran over to the other employees and told them about what happened laughing at me as I walked out the door , won't be returning here ever again, which is unfortunate because I have been going here with my family Since I was a kid . The cream cheese also tasted super funky read more

I had a sandwich there and a bag of chip the sandwich was so nasty bread was hard like a rock the chips was better and I pay 10$ never again don't go the people read more