I had a sandwich there and a bag of chip the sandwich was so nasty bread was hard like a rock the chips was better and I pay 10$ never again don't go the people read more

OK people were really nice but our order took a long time and when we opened it it was completely the wrong thing we ordered egg sandwiches on a bagel and they were on a roll the roll was cold and the sandwiches were honestly fine I probably could've made a better one myself probably would definitely most likely never go back. Maybe call it smithtown rolls read more

Best Bagels in town! All the staff is so pleasant and friendly. They always greet you with a smile as well! Chicken salad is so yummy and is always my go to favorite! read more

Wait was barely a few minutes. Service pleasant but most importantly the bagels were incredible!!! My family is new to the area so trying a bunch of stuff! We shall return to Smithtown Bagels! read more

This place has a nick-name around the office: "5 Hour Deli". The service here is very slow... The food is really not great either, but it's the closest deli to were I work. The bagels are OK, but Strathmore is much better. read more

Same two guys taking orders, prepared and cooked the food as well. Line took forever. The egg sandwich I ordered, was so pathetic, and not worth the wait. read more

The bagels here are always fresh and the coffee is great. The counter staff is always nice and attentive. There is ALWAYS a line out of the door every time I am here, that is a testament to the quality of the food and the friendliness of the staff. The owner works hard to make sure everything runs smooth and they do a great job of keeping up with the weekend and holiday rushes! read more

Absolutely the best bagels in Smithtown! Friendly and courteous staff and a very clean restaurant! The chopped salad is the best I've found and very reasonable. Never disappointed and I order from them every week. read more

Been going to smithtown bagels forever. Great customer service. Seth and Freddy are awesome! Place is very clean. Food is delicious - bagels, sandwiches - coffee fantastic! Ordered platters for work meetings. Just great service ! And Best bagels in smithtown! read more

I've been going to Smithtown Bagels for years. From Mike to Seth, Smithtown Bagels has always provided top quality bagels and friendly customer service. The employees there take Seths lead and treat customers with kindness and respect. For those who have been going there for years and employees who have been there long as well, we know each other's names and at times carry on conversations to get to know each other better. it's a friendly environment and I enjoy going there and certainly let my friends know about them too. read more

I ordered a toasted bagel and it wasn't toast. I was the only one there too not get my order correct I was given incorrect change back and to add the cashiers nails looked unkept almost a bit dirty. She was pleasant. read more

Best bagels I've found around Smithtown. I used to like the place by the pork store yet they went south a while ago. We have to wait a bit for the bagels, yet it's worth the wait. I go every time I'm in Smithtown. read more

Smithtown Bagels - Smithtown Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Been going here recently because the bagels were pretty good. However the wait times are a bit lengthy even when there is no one there. How ever what really brought this place down was I placed my order and while waiting I watched the kid ring someone up for a Gatorade and then proceed to make my bagel and lox with the same glove he was handling money with. I got his attention and asked him to change gloves cause of what he was doing and he looked at me like I was issue. Pretty sure he didn't even remake the bagel and I still got gloved made bagel and lox. Buyers beware this seems to be a trend I find in my area. I can't stand it at all. It's unsettling. read more

I've moved from LI to an area where bagel shops are few and far between and you can't get the variety or quality that you can find here. I was happy to find lots of options at this cafe. I had a sesame flagel w/ walnut raisin creme cheese, nothing like anything I have tried before. Was quite larger than a regular bagel and I had to save half in the fridge for later. My friends order was larger and the staff member put in the wrong total which my friend had to point out to him and then he needed a manager to fix it. All-in-all a good place to get breakfast or lunch though. read more

Smithtown Bagels - Sesame flagel with walnut and raisin cream cheese. - Bagels Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I feel like it's a bit over priced for the nothing you get on a sandwich. I don't know if bread prices went up but $2.50 for a toasted bagel with cream cheese is a bit much especially when I get a bagel here toasted with nothing for $1 as of last week. The sandwiches are reasonably priced but the last two I got from here was mostly bread. I don't know if they are always that way but if it's $8-$10 a piece you would think there would be a decent amount of filling. The breakfast sandwiches are good with plenty of toppings. I guess I shouldn't order lunch. read more

I'm not sure if I caught them in a bad day or not. Let me set this up. The day after thanksgiving at 10:00 am. There's roughly 7-8 customers on line ahead of me. I only see 2 people behind the counter. Then another emerges so there's 3 people working with about 8 customers. Chances of being served soon is very high. NOT!!!! We waited about 15 minutes before placing an order (not exaggerating at all) then another 15 minute for them it make it. Here's the order: BEC on a bagel, buttered bagel and 2 bagels with CC. Not a big order at all. Not really sure what took 15 minutes to make. Service was less than desirable but again, it was the day after thanksgiving so I'm not sure if it's a huge bagel day so I'll cut them some slack. On the positive side, the owner seemed to know everyone walking in and this place seems to have a ton of repeat customers. The bagels are pretty good and the egg Sammy was delicious. I'll have to try then again on a normal day and report back. read more

First time here. The service was friendly and it was very clean and bright inside. The bagels were average. Not sure what but something was missing in the taste. read more

Great food and really accommodating staff! Great bagels, speciality bagels for holidays, great cold salads. Great iced coffee also. Owner also very philanthropic for local nonprofit in town. read more

Nice service. The lady behind the counter treats you right. And I'm sure that the bagels are pretty good. But when I decided to get a ham egg and cheese on a roll, it was a HUGE disappointment. The roll was tiny, dry and flavorless. Add I had to double check to see if I got the 2 eggs that I asked for, as it seemed there was only one. But no, there were 2. Probably Robin's eggs, they were so small. And to top it off, only ONE slice of ham and ONE slice of cheese!!!! A busy place like this doesn't need to be so cheep with their rations..... read more

I tried this place twice. Once for 2 egg sandwiches that they messed up. And another for 2 lunch sandwiches that they royally screwed up. Waited over an hour between the 2. I watched the young kid write my order down and still get it wrong. As a deli on Long Island you can not be this consistently bad. Over $20 and an hour of my life I can not get back. Disappointed family when I came home both times. If I could give negative stars, I probably would. This bothered me enough to open my yelp app and type all of this. read more

The bagels are delicious, freshly-made and authentic; with a variety of unique cream cheese flavors to choose from. There's sandwiches and food as well. The ONLY downside to this place is that staffing levels do not sometimes match the amount of customers in line during peak hours. Prepare to wait a little. read more

To-fu cream cheese on a warm bagel.

I turned another year older waiting on line for an order I'd made by phone. 45 minutes for egg sandwiches? Never again.

Used to love this place. Not sure what happened, but ordered an egg sandwich this morning and it was basically bread. Pretty sure they used half a slice of bacon and definitely only one egg for this sandwich. Maybe if we weren't in New York I'd expect this but dang. There's a great place across from the citibank that's so much better. If you read this I'll see you at the other one because I'll never be back. read more

Food is not bad, and they are always busy. One thing that really bothers me is that every time the floors are a sticky disgusting mess. Please clean up!!! read more

I recommend this business for catering as they've put together a great spread for business associates of mine for the past 2 years. Very accommodating and friendly, and they can't do enough to help. Michael, the gentleman who I've delt with the past 2 years is easy to talk to and gets the job done. read more

Only bagel place worth going to in Smithtown. Great variety, fresh bagels and the staff is great. Great place to sit and enjoy the paper in the morning too read more

Awesome service by experienced sandwich makers. Never disappoints. Consistently good service and fresh food. Don't mess around, stick to the best. Smithtown bagels is the best deli in the area read more

Weirdest bagel place in this whole area. Literally line of people waiting for empty bagel baskets. One person working behind counter while line piles up. Horrible music from the 60s playing throughout the store while everyone just stands and waits for no bagels. Twilight zone bagel place never go here read more

Not sure about the bagels but the service is brutally slow. Just stopped in for a morning bagel. I was second in line. 10+ minutes later I was at the front of the line. Finally gave up. read more

Messed up my bagels but heck they were awesome. And the service outstanding!!! Definite recommend going there

What can I say other than I love this bagel place and not just the bagels either. I love all of their sandwiches, soups salads etc. the owner Michael radiates warmth & kindness as is his staff (Seth, Freddie and oop I can't remember the ladies name). They know me as the lox lady lol. I usually order a lb as my hubby loves lox with tomatoes and red onion on a get this cinnamon raisin bagel. (Not my choice but whatever). They have a excellent chicken salad among a lot of other choices. I was Supercuts and was hungry and the girl swore by the bagel place across the street as I heard from others as well. So I decided to give them a shot. First, they had no menus! The menu was high up and I couldn't read it at all (my fault for not having my eyeglasses). I ordered a lox & cream cheese on a garlic bagel. I was truly disappointed. The lox was smelly and a tad slimy. I could have gone back but decided why bother as I won't ever order from them again. Oh, my dog Prada wouldn't eat it either!! read more

Always good food and worth the wait. Just because there's a line doesnt mean they're not working or too slow. You wouldn't want them to rush through your order to get to the next customer quicker, would you? They treat each and every customer with as much respect as the next. It's a testimony when there's a ton of repeat customers. Very nice staff always friendly and the owner is a great guy that knows almost everyone that comes in. Just solid people and a great business. read more

Just an average bagel store. Not bad but nothing special about it at all. The reason for the negative review is the staff, in particular a woman that works there and the reason I have never gone back. On a recent, and my last, visit I had an horrible experience. While at the counter waiting to give my order, the woman had her back to me making someone else's order. Apparently she tried to ask me want I wanted but I didn't realize it due to a hearing defect. When she turned around and faced me she shouted something to the effect of "You need to clean your ears out? What do you want?" Obviously I took offense, walked out and have not been back yet. read more

Placed an order for a dozen bagels plus some other things on Chrismas Eve for Chrismas morning. When I arrived to pick it up, they told me they were too busy to get my order together and were out of 1/3 of what I had ordered. "To make up" for it they gave me a couple of free bagels. According to the sign in their store you get a couple of free bagels anyway for ordering a dozen. Not only was I not informed about this when I ordered, the bagels they gave me were buttered. I can only assume those bagels were left overs from someone else. Never even got an apology. Just "we are too busy" I'll be sure to keep that in mind next time I go to spend my hard earned money and don't want to disappoint my guests. read more

I am flabbergasted by these poor reviews. Smithtown Bagels has always been - and will likely always be - the most orgasmic bagel institution on Long Island. When I am out of town, I dream about their egg everything bagel with butter. It is the softest bagel I have ever consumed. Prefer a breakfast sandwich? Their egg sandwiches bring it every day of the damn week. Get out, haters. Smithtown Bagels deserves five stars. read more

Plain Bagel with lox. Bagel wasn't soft and barely any fish in the lox spread. Terrible letdown. On top of that $3.91 for one bagel. Um no thanks. read more

I love this place. Guys behind the counter are great. Had salads catered from here for an event and everyone said they were the best salads ever. It was for Halloween and they didn't bat an eye when I asked to have a rubber mouse put at the bottom of the jack o lanturn containers. Bagels are great here. Not fancy but wonderful. Can't understand the negative reviews I have never had a bad bagel or bad service there. The take special orders and have green bagels for St. Pats. Sandwiches are good too. read more

Pretty generic. I usually order chicken salad whenever I go to bagel places, and this place doesn't have good chicken salad. It's very salty and that kills any sort of salad. Their bagels are small and flavorless. read more