I love it when an unassuming place does something out of character right! I've been to Alkemy before for its dark chocolate ice cream. Service is usually quick and friendly. And the ice cream I got had a good chocolate taste to it, even with the novelty of nitrogen. The sipping chocolate however? God tier. Supreme. Its so luxurious and at the same time, not too sweet! You get this wonderfully bitter chocolate taste that's not overwhelming but still manages to warm your insides. Get it with a torched marshmallow ring and it rivals any sipping chocolate you can get in the city. Overall, well worth a visit in the winter (yes, its true!), if not for the ice cream, than for the sipping chocolate! read more

Alkemy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

Very unique and innovative ice-cream spot. You can watch the fresh liquid nitrogen preparation process right in front of you. I had the matcha green tea flavored ice-cream on a waffle cone topped with a Stroopwafel cookie. I thought it was excellent and tasted great. It's hard at first and has a different consistency than regular ice-cream. The difference in taste is certainly noticeable. My wife had the Ooey Gooey Butter Cake Ice Cream. It was a memorable experience, but an expensive one; two ice creams cost $25, which is pricey, but understandable given the process it takes to make the ice-cream. read more

See all

Alkemy is such a fun and unique ice cream experience. Everything is made to order with liquid nitrogen, and you can really taste the difference -- super creamy and fresh. We tried a few of their signature creations and the Dulce de Leche was honestly the standout, one of the best ice creams I've had in a long time. The roasted strawberry with the balsamic injector was really creative, and the s'mores with the torched marshmallow was perfect. The space upstairs is also a great place to sit, relax, and enjoy your desserts, especially with the Main Street views. The staff was friendly, the presentation was great, and the whole experience was memorable. Definitely worth checking out if you're in the area. read more

See all

Cool place with good icecream but EXPENSIVE! I got chocolate with a bubble waffle and my daughter got cookie butter with a bubble waffle. $28? Ugh read more

Alkemy - This is $28 worth of Alchemy icecream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Cute place on the corner; street metered parking. There is a second floor but the AC isn't as strong up there. The staff were very helpful, patient, and friendly. It was quite pricey I spent $60 for 6 items so about $10 per. Strawberry alkemized - Oreos, banana with Nutella drizzled on the toasted marshmallow 8/10 Bubble waffle with Nutella drizzled 9/10 (warm and soft) Strawberry with gummy bears and strawberry 8/10 Vanilla bean with banana and hot fudge syringe 9/10 Cold brew creation with caramel syringe 9/10 (there's a little bit of the bubble waffle in it) The strawberry flavor tasted similar to haagen dazs - our favorite was the vanilla bean and the cold brew creation. read more

See all

We pulled up when they opened at 6pm (and even got a front parking spot, yay!) and were the first customers in yesterday! The staff was friendly and helpful (this was our first time). When you enter, this is a small spot with a few tables, and large tanks for the liquid nitrogen, which made us very curious! You pick your dessert, whether shakes or a sundae and they create it right on front of you. The mixers start spinning and the liquid nitrogen is released (make sure to have those cameras ready!). The ice cream was so creamy and delicious, almost like gelato. read more

Alkemy - Dark Chocolate sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

The inside is really cute and there is a nice upstairs. Workers are nice and helpful too. I tried the special of the week which was Guinness Oatmeal Cookie Ice Cream . It was topped with coconut and an added cookie butter injector. I think this is a great treat for children to see the process and how adorable the presentation is. I find it a little pricey but worth it for a treat. Street Parking and a lot not that far. read more

Alkemy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

I would say this spot is very tasty and innovative, but definitely on the pricier side and takes quite awhile to get your order. If you order more than one item you won't receive them at the same time. However, the taste of the vegan flavors were very good. Creamy and flavorful. They have a number of toppings that are dairy free, vegan, gluten free, etc. I tried the vegan matcha and vegan vanilla with Oreos crushed inside. Both were great. read more

Alkemy - Vegan matcha - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

It's very cool concept. Can't talk about the service so much it's more of a machine but the women working here were working very hard. The concept is interesting. I got the gooey cake and it was hard as a rock and didn't enjoy it too much. The hot chocolate was fantastic. But that's the only thing that would bring me back. read more

Alkemy - Ver - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

My five year old was ordering ice cream here. A man was standing all the way to the right of the store, nowhere near the register, and started yelling "HEY IM WAITING HERE!" I apologized and said I didn't realize he was waiting (bc the register was empty and the dude was just standing in space not ordering, not near the register) - the man was super rude and didn't even acknowledge my apology. The cashier made my 5 year old un-order his ice cream, move to the side and wait for a grown older man to order his ice cream. Yes, it's not necessary to have let my 5 year old order because the older man was there first. But I did apologize, explain why we didn't realize - at that point the kind thing to do would be to let the FIVE YEAR OLD get his ice cream. Instead he was dismissed and made to stand to the side. Nasty work. read more

Alkemy is totally worth the hype. I thought the liquid nitrogen was going to be a total gimmick, but once that freshly made ice cream hit my lips, I knew I was wrong. I had the matcha green tea special, and it was incredible! The matcha was subtly sweet, and tasted so fresh after having been created literally in front of me. Going from liquid ingredients to a fresh scoop of ice cream really made it taste amazing. As if that wasn't enough, the waffle under the ice cream was perfect - warm, with a crispy outside and a chewy inside. The combination of flavors and textures was excellent. The special is a little pricey, somewhere around $13-$15 as of July 2024. But you really do get great, fresh ice cream, I could see myself coming back here for sure. read more

Alkemy - Matcha Green Tea (Signature) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

Truly never experienced such incompetence before coming here. Tuesday night and the two workers are literally moving in slow motion. 50 minutes for 4 simple ice creams. People that ordered after us got theirs before. No system whatsoever. Never again! read more

If you're a kid, you would love this place, but it is such a gimmick and the ice cream isn't even that good. I'm sorry to say watching the process is exhilarating because you have probably have never seen anything like it before but the end result is a big black cluster, and idon't need to take my word, go try it for yourself, take a big science experiment I usually like my ice cream scooped, but I had to try it read more

See all

I went to try Alkemy Ice Cream in Huntington, curious about this unique sweet treat--but was completely turned off by the staff. Walking in, there was no line, yet the employees purposely avoided eye contact and ignored me. I stood there for over 20 minutes, even asked if that's where you place an order, and got zero response. WTF. I ended up walking out and heading to Ralph's Ices instead--where the ices were delicious and, more importantly, the staff actually acknowledged my existence. Sometimes good service makes all the difference. read more

Alkemy - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

Cool ( get it? Ice cream.... Nevermind ) spot for something fancy after dinner at any one of the nearby restaurants) when you want to stretch your legs after a meal, come and be wowed at the ice cream made on demand with super duper secret nitrogen or kryptonite or something more alien special process and the kids will certainly love the experience as well. Service each time we have come has been friendly and otherwise efficient. The tanks which hide the secret mojo that make the ice cream are visible and any of the staff will explain the process to young and old alike. Some seating downstairs and even more upstairs so you can enjoy your dessert whilst sitting. Modern and clean, this is a very..... cool.... Thing to do on probably the best intersection of Huntington Proper. read more

Alkemy - Nitrogen made ice cream! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

Was in Hungtington NY and took a walk at one corner was Alkemy Ice Cream Store. What caught my attention was a sign in the window. Seems the process of making this icecream was from a Science Project. The server noted that they make the ice cream individually with natural items. The machine inside sorta looked like a giant metal pressure cooker. I was going to buy some as they had some nice noted flavors. I asked for the smallest cup. A 4 oz cut is only of Vanilla or Chocolate Gelato already made. The 6oz cup is the smallest for one scoop. Ok I am ready to do this. I ask, by the way, do you know if there is High Fructose in the icecream? The server checked. What I thought I heard was that their products have this in their processing. Then, I oped not to get the icecream. :( -The Business owner- (thank you Alan) has clarified that they do NOT have this ingredient in their products. I do expect it is cool to watch . So, when in the area I go shall go in and order some icecream ang get an upclose on how it's all done. read more

Alkemy - Window - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

This place is a rip off. I paid 11$ for this with barely any ice cream in it. It was supposed to be cold brew with Reese peanut butter cups but it did t even taste like coffee all I tasted was some peanut butter. Seriously if you're gonna charge this much for a cone atleast give a real scoop. Aweful place I'm sure it will be out of business very soon. I will never go here again. read more

Alkemy - Waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

The ice cream preparation at this establishment is what sets it apart from the other ice cream shops. The use of nitrogen to freeze the cream while it is being mixed in a mixing stand is intriguing. The person serving us was pretty cool, with her sunglasses while making the ice cream. The ice cream along part was a little loud, so be careful if you have sensitive ears, just cover them while they make your ice cream. I got the matcha flavor ice cream, something simple to start out and it was good. I like my matcha flavor to be more prominent, but this one still had a bit more of a hint. Just a scoop cost about $9 My friend got the cookie butter flavored ice cream with the waffles and topped with whipped cream. This choice was absolutely amazing. The waffle was crispy and soft and also warm when we had it. It paired really well with the ice cream. This was about $13 Another friend of mine got a milkshake. The milk shake was not really worth it as they liked more of a thicker consistency. The flavor was cookies n cream, but there wasn't much cookies in it. It cost $13, the cookies n cream were an additional $2 to the base cost of $11. The cost of these are a little pricier than what I would normally pay for ice cream. I may come back to have a waffle ice cream myself as that one was the most worth it. The scoop by itself and the milkshakes were not worth the price. The ice cream was also melting really easily, which I personally do not mind, but letting people know for preference. read more

Alkemy - Matcha Green Tea, Cookie Butter (Signature) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

Julia, Emily& Ray were a great team! Super friendly & great customer service. We tried 5 different items . They were all delicious ... a little pricey but oh well. It was a special day ! read more

Alkemy Ice Cream in Huntington Village Long Island is freshly churned liquid ice cream using nitrogen to instantly freeze it. The concept is very interesting. to watch as they do it right in front of you. There many flavors as well as variety of choices and toppings. The staff is sweet and very helpful. The store is very cute with upstairs seating and a view the Village. Parking is not easy so be patience. read more

See all

I had this saved and when I saw it as a top hot cocoa place of course we made sure to venture here after dinner in the area. It was amazing. So good when we came back to go to dinner in the area we came here again. Our son is obsessed with watching the ice cream be made and loves it. Place is cute inside and service is always great. Next time we're in Huntington I'm sure we'll be back :P I'd highly highly highly recommend this place. read more

See all

This was one of the "coolest " ice cream experiences to date! I was so happy that I decided to stop in. Once I saw the concept for myself I was in! The staff was friendly and let get pictures and videos of my experience because I was fascinated like a kid. read more

Alkemy - Cookie Butter with toasted marshmallows instead of cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

So the ice cream place is very fun and new and everything. It's very cute. But God help you if you're there and there's even a little bit of a line. Went in to get some of their specialty ice creams - just three small not super crazy things. I believe I was in there 1.5 hours waiting for three ice creams. On top of that they didn't even come out at the same time! And what's even more shocking - is that it was in March 2025 when I visited! I don't even want to imagine what the wait time here is for the summer months. They were clearly under staffed or I'll equipped to handle the walkins - if they got their stuff together if gladly go again since the ice cream i did have was actually pretty good. read more

Love this place's non-dairy flavors but they were out. So disappointing!! It really is an epidemic among Long Island ice cream establishments, do better LI! read more

Alkemy is a pretty popular spot for ice cream (specifically rolled ice cream) in Huntington and rightfully so. Yes, it does take some time for the staff to prepare the ice cream, but remember- good things come to those who wait! I got the ooey gooey butter cake and my friend got the s'mores ice cream. Albeit I liked my ice cream, nothing could beat Ample Hills for their ooey gooey butter cake so unfortunately I kept mentally comparing it. My friend really liked his as well. The only thing I would change is the cup size- yes I'm a messy eater but the cup is overflowing with whipped cream/etc at the end ie it's inevitable that some of it will fall (and we don't want that)! I'm glad to see that they're doing well and bringing some innovative things to Huntington. read more

Alkemy - S'mores & Ooey Gooey Butter Cake Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

Kinda cool, kinda gimmicky. Overall it's a cool place to try out to experience something new. They use liquid nitrogen in real time, right in front of you. It's cool and unusual. But understand that this also means that there will be a long wait time. The restaurant was very packed when we went on a Saturday afternoon and it took about 15 minutes to get our order. On the other hand, you can absolutely customize anything you want and but to be honest, it's still more show than taste. The taste was fine, don't get me wrong. But I don't know if this is where I would come to get my favorite ice cream. Overall, I'm glad I tried it, I would definitely bring someone else here to try it out. It's a cool spot for a first or second date. Family friendly. Limited parking though so plan for that. read more

What a seriously cool place (no pun intended). Seeing how the ice cream is made was very entertaining, and the staff were very friendly. It was a busy night, but everything moved smoothly and all the flavors we got were delicious. Even the dairy free vanilla! read more

Alkemy - Interior - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Great new addition to Huntington! We tried it for first time today and it was delicious. They use liquid nitrogen and make it as you order it. It's not cheap, but it is all whole ingredients, no added chemicals or stabilizers so that is what you pay for. Staff is friendly and explain the process and products. Place is new, sleek, and there is additional seating upstairs . read more

See all

A delicious new ice cream experience to have in Huntington. We stop by Alkemy last night in the heart of downtown Huntington to have an amazing experience how liquid nitrogen ice cream is made. They use fresh milk and cream, vanilla, Bean, Coco's, and premium chocolate mixed in bowls with liquid nitrogen. This experience makes the ice cream so creamy and delicious and when adding on the toppings, it is the best ice cream my family and I have ever had. Don't walk, but run to this fantastic place and meet the from the owner and his wonderful staff who give an experience like no other. read more

See all

Delicious. Yummy. Innovative. These are the words I wish I could use to describe this place. Instead, I'll use the word that even this place used to describe its ice cream methods: GIMMICK!! Remember Dippin' Dots?? At $18 for 2 small cups that take 30 minutes to make, you are getting a very expensive cup of Fruity Pebbles ice cream. I've had better ice cream at hospitals. read more

Genuinely the best ice cream you can ever have in Huntington, NY! The owner and the staff are extremely friendly and passionate in what they do. The ambiance is very nice I highly recommend the s'mores ice cream for sure. If you ever stop by, this is the first place you should try! read more

Not good. This ice cream itself has no flavor. The only things that actually have a taste are the toppings (actual bananas and caramel sauce) It's pricey for no good reason. Go to Cold Stone instead. read more

Alkemy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

This was a fantastic experience. Very different. The ice cream was incredible. The best hot chocolate with homemade marshmallow ever. This is definitely a place to try. I had the vanilla bean ice cream with fruity pebbles mixed in and it did not disappoint. The employee were so nice! read more

See all

This ice cream was horrible. It was so expensive. I think 12.50 for one big scoop essentially. We put our spoon in the ice cream and it all came out of the cup. The consistency was so weird. I have had other nitrogen ice cream before that is so much better. For 12 dollars I was expecting much better quality. The concept is cool, I just don't think it is well executed. read more

Empty store 4 people working. Ordered 4 scopes of icecream. Nothing special that requires long prep. Waited for 15 min and were told they wanted 10 more minutes. Almost requested refund. Employees literally more with slow motion. Terrible! read more

Cool concept (remember nitro space!?) but not a good value at all. Shockingly, it cost 13$ for my ice cream and it didn't even fill the cup - not even close. Ice cream was creamy but nothing remarkable. In a village with 7+ ice cream spots, there are plenty other options that have same or better product for half the price. read more

Alkemy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Ice cream is sweet but the customer service left a sour taste in my mouth. It was pretty busy when we got there and a bit crowded. There is a second floor for customers to eat at. Taste: This ice cream place had interesting flavors and they were good. I got the dulche de leche and my boyfriend had the Aztec chocolate. The Aztec chocolate was spicy but well balanced. The dulche de leche was very sweet and the caramel flavor was strong. It actually was one of the better caramel flavors I've had. If you don't like extremely sweet things I wouldn't get this one. Mine was more melted when I got it but the Aztec chocolate had a better consistency. Most likely the amount of nitrogen used was not enough. I also would recommend asking to get the dulce de leche without the stroop waffles, I could not bite through them. For the service it made me I regret coming here at all. I love supporting local businesses and worked at a restaurant in the city before. Dealing with annoying customers is the worst and I get it. I don't expect amazing service but the rudeness from all the workers just threw me off. There was a minor mixup where the cashier forgot to give change, $40 for two cups of ice cream would have been a bit much but it was not a big deal. When I got my order, the chocolate injector was missing from it and again no big deal, but the way they handled it was rude. I asked if the chocolate injector was inside the ice cream since I didn't see it on top. They pointed out the caramel syrup (it was not chocolate) saying that they put it. When I told them it tasted like caramel syrup they gave a very off putting look. They even questioned if it was supposed to go with it and read the menu again (yes it was on there), but still sounded as if I were in the wrong. Normally I wouldn't bother with trying to correct something small like that but again, the caramel was very strong tasting. It definitely did need another flavor besides caramel to balance it out so it wasn't so overpowering. I wasn't surprised by the rudeness of the teens working there because that's just how they are, but coming from a middle aged man who I presume is the manager or someone higher up? Really setting a great example. Definitely wouldn't go back to that place. read more

Service was great, a bit pricey though. Ice cream was a bit too sweet for me but for someone with a sweet tooth they'll love it read more

Alkemy - Snores yogurt and caramel pretzels ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

We were in the area and looking for dessert, and stumbled onto Alkemy. They have some unique base flavors and toppings. I got banana ice cream with torched marshmallow on top. It made for a delicious combination. The ice cream was incredibly smooth and tasted like actual banana. I tried a little of my husband's Ooey Gooey Butter Cake and it was equally tasty. It was fun to see the ice cream being made and the staff looked like they were having fun. Looks like a great addition to the town! read more

Alkemy - Torched marshmallow topping - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York

I really enjoyed the vegan ice cream options here and am looking forward to trying more dairy free flavors in the future. The concept is cool and different and I like how they make it in front of you. read more

Alkemy - Vegan vanilla - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Huntington, New York