I finally got a chance to Catch The Wave in Plainview & I'm still riding high!! Get the vanilla custard!! Vanilla isn't boring it's the baseline, the gold standard that other flavors strive to be!! Remember vanilla isn't hiding from anyone, it doesn't need fudge,swirls or cookie chunks to get your attention!! Like Arnie says I'll be back!!! read more

See all

Choices are fine, a little bit limiting flavor wise. Service is rushed, and there is no self serve toppings option anymore. So you tell the workers what you want and they PILED it on. When I asked for a FEW Swedish fish she gave me a scoop full, I said "that's enough" and she gets another scoop and piles it on. She did it with a number of toppings. That adds money onto my order and now I have more toppings than I cared to have in the first place and the ratio between what they pile one and the froyo is ridiculous. I wanted a small treat and I left with a bowl full of candy with little frozen yogurt. If self serve, I'd go back but otherwise, I'm good. Clean place, can get loud especially with a number of kids in there. read more

Catch The Wave - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainview, New York

Located in a strip mall. It's your typical Fro-Yo shop. Plenty of flavors to choose from and just about any toppings you want to go along with it. It's self serve and you pay be weight......so go a little light handed unless you want to remortgage your house. Nice, bright fun vibe inside. Staff is friendly. They keep the place very clean. I wouldn't make this place a "destination", but if you're in the neighborhood, give it a try. read more

The flavors at the catch the wave yogurt store are a bit stronger tasting then the TCBY near by. This said I found an aftertaste too. The toppings are behind counter ask help for your choice. The strawberries were literally 4 sliced equal to maybe 1 strawberry. The coffee shake list as Mocha Madness 16 oz 1 size = $6.43 . They also have a loyalty rewards program using a QR for quick access. The receipt notes to use the member ID barcode for every purchase.The server noted to me that they have been there for 13 years. Inset in a line of stores, We found it after seeing the yogurt flag outside by the traffic light and decided to check it out. ( see pix). read more

See all

Great flavor options! Fantastic topping options one of the better frozen yogurt places on long island.

So good ! Had a really good time here! The place was clean, had a great variety of toppings, and the frozen yogurt itself was solid. Only thing I'd suggest is maybe offering a flat-rate cup option--like Swirls does--so people don't accidentally go overboard. I wasn't paying attention and ended up with a $13 froyo, which caught me off guard. Still, everything tasted great and I'd definitely come back... just with a little more self-control next time. read more

When I was delivering for uber eats I stopped in here one night to get a delivery and I ended up getting frozen yogurt myself. The yogurt is here is so good, it's very different and very creamy and a little thick. I topped it with peanut butter sauce. You pay by weight here as you do with most frozen yogurt shops. read more

Catch The Wave - a bowl of ice cream with a spoon in it - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainview, New York

Froyo was good. Staff was rude. Maybe because they were teens. You know how some teens can be. I ask for a topping and they either add way too little or way too much. I don't get it. I like to serve my own toppings but this place didn't have that option. It would annoy the employee if I said " a little bit more please". That's why I just let them put how ever much they decide to put. They do have mini samplers so you can taste which flavor you like best without annoying the employees. Just would prefer if this place was self serve with the toppings. read more

Catch The Wave - a bowl of ice cream with sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainview, New York

This is by far my absolute favorite place to come to get frozen yogurt! The inside of this place has a tropical beachy feel to it which I love! It's clean, it's big and they have a big variety of flavors and toppings as well as syrups as well. They have the cookies n cream flavor which is usually my go to with strawberries, chocolate sprinkles, Kit Kat pieces. What's great about this place too is not only do they have frozen yogurt, they have sorbet, açaí bowls, smoothies. I've only been here for the froyo but one day I'll definitely come back here to try the açaí bowls. The froyo is fresh, delicious and they have great flavors! Highly recommend giving this place a try! read more

Super friendly staff on the evening we visited. Place was super clean. My MIL wanted "ice cream" so bad but cannot have sugar. They had sugar free strawberry and cheesecake. No complaints from our party of 3! read more

The yogurt is great there! The service give you as much toppings as you need even if you want every topping (who gets that though). The music is ok I don't really care though! I am on my moms account. read more

I was in the mood for some yogurt and was near by so decided to try a new place. Catch The Wave is a self serve yogurt place like many of the others these days. You take a cup and pick the yogurt you want then put on the toppings you want then bring up to cashier to weigh and pay. I find that in general a serve yourself place gets more money as you tend to forget about portion size and pile on yogurt and toppings. I had a mix of coffee and chocolate yogurt with blueberries, strawberries, pineapple & raspberries. The yogurt was really good and I love fresh fruit toppings. Catch The Wave had a really good selection of both yogurts and toppings. The cashier was friendly and I would definetly go again if I was in the mood for yogurt and was in Plainview. read more

See all

Great product but terrible service when ordered through any 3rd party delivery services. Do not follow any of the notes so you never get what you ordered and paid for unless right off the menu. Highly recommend walk in only. Too bad since they would get and keep more business if the staff knew how to read and follow simple instructions. read more

They were great! The staff was friendly, all Ingredients were fresh and tasty, we'll definitely be back! My son loved it. Requested his birthday cake to be from here lol read more

Great frozen yogurt place. People there are very nice. Place is always clean Very happy with catch the wave in plainview

Came here for a snack with my sister. The customer service was horrible. Worst that I have seen in a while. I have worked in the food service since high school. The short blonde girl that helped us with our toppings was beyond nasty and unfriendly. She did not smile once and she snatched the cups from my sisters and I hands. The froyo is good. The vibes of the shop are nice. The customer service alone has made me not want to ever go back which is absolutely disgusting and sad read more

Ok ...now let me say one thing off first. I hate this parking lot so be prepared for a difficult parking experience especially in the early evening now with that being typed let me move on to the yogurt in one word perfect! I so love that tart stuff it seems to be more real then then other flavors such as cake batter this is a small cute place love the colors would like better chairs fresh tasting lots of yummy toppings just wish they were someplace else other then Plainview read more

Catch The Wave - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

I tried this place for the first time just moments ago, and I was very impressed. The first thing I noticed is how CLEAN it was! Spotless floors, machines were clean and there weren't drums anywhere which is very important to me whenever I'm going somewhere that sells any type of food. My mom decided to get the Acai Bowl which was loaded with fruit, granola, honey and tasted amazing ! Great prices too. I definitely recommend this place and want to try their smoothies and frozen yogurt next! read more

Catch The Wave - Acai Bowl - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainview, New York

The place was a little and thus we were rushed through the toppings. Since they don't let you scoop your own toppings, you are just stuck with whatever they give you. I got brownies, which was a huge mistake. They tasted disgusting, almost inedible. I had to pick them all out to be able to finish the yogurt. I regret spending my money here. read more

I tried the Vanilla Custard and the Raspberry Pomegranate Sorbet. It's self-serve and you pay by the ounce, so that's convenient for someone like me that doesn't have a big appetite. read more

Ordered uber eats from here recently and was so impressed! Some flavors definitely hold up better than others do without melting so fast. I got the cookies and cream and it stayed well. Best froyo in the area! Really nothing else competes. Def coming back read more

I usually love this place, but I have been having bad experiences lately. This time the workers behind the counter were too busy talking to each other and joking around when I was trying to ask questions and make sure my order was correct. They did not listen to me when I was ordering and were very dismissive. I asked them to fix an issue after they charged my card incorrectly and they said there was nothing they can do to help me. I received dirty looks and no support. I thought they would be more helpful and care about their customers. read more

Everything here is not nearly as sweet as the flavors offered at other frozen yogurt spots, which is maybe a good thing. They offer a variety of flavors that aren't usually found at other places (like chocolate custard, praline, coffee, etc) and a bunch of flavors that are found everywhere else (cake batter, banana, cookies & creme, etc.), and they clearly indicate the flavors that have no added sugar, and items that have no sugar at all. If I were to go again, I would again get a mix of the coffee (no sugar) and praline (no added sugar), with a few toppings like Kit Kat, Peanut Butter Cups, Chocolate Raspberry Cups, and you automatically have the perfect combination. It's perfect for people trying to control their sugar intake, and kids. Seating is limited. read more

Catch The Wave - Coffee & Praline. Toppings: Rainbow cookie, Kit Kat, Peanut Butter cups, Dark Chocolate Raspberry cups - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainview, New York

Catch The Wave is an awesome yogurt joint. Sooooo many options to choose from. The store is very clean and bright and the staff is helpful. They let you try as many flavors as you would like and dont make you feel guilty for trying them! The only reason why Im giving it 4 stars instead of 5 is the price. I filled my cup to the top and got a reasonable amount of topping and it came to $12 !! Dont come here if your trying to save money lol read more

See all

Went in today and the yogurt was amazing and the staff was just the nicest ! Will definitely be back !

Yes, parking is an issue in this strip mall that has three active restaurants, hair stylist, ice cream parlor, walk in clinic and many other stores. There a lots of great flavors to choose from and toppings that will make you feel like a kid when you enter this yogurt ice cream parlor. read more

Catch The Wave - Top Clients - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainview, New York

This place is good. Nice setup, clean, friendly servers. Yogurt is good, topping selection is excellent, plenty of yogurt choices. It's simple, but there's nothing to complain about. Pro tip: go in and get a cup filled with toppings. Kill off the middle man. Toppings are where it's at. read more

Catch The Wave is an excellent place to go for FroYo. It's a hip new place to hang out with friends and family. The staff is very nice! Heck, I wouldn't mind working there due to the atmosphere and the discounted amazing yogurt. :-) A+++ read more

Catch The Wave - the logo for the ultimate yogurt experience - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Plainview, New York

This is my favorite place ... Froyo tastes great all time . Fruits are very fresh and the place is always clean. Staff are friendly

Pricey like most froyo places, and the same flavors as most froyo places as well. Catch the waves more of a local favorite but I wouldn't suggest going out of your way to come here if you're not a local. Employees are always nice and the place is always clean. read more

Picked up a birthday cake for my daughter and some raspberry pomegranite sorbet for my wife. They don't carry ben and jerry's here or any other full fat ice cream so skipped anything for myself. What I like about this place was the set up and the service. Great idea, serve yourself throw it on the scale pay and go. While I was there I was watching the yogurt people and they were in and out in a minute. The service was excellent considering the fast pace set by the customers. Being an obvious newbie one of the employees came around the counter explained the set up and the machines. That is a great way to get new customers, too bad they don't have anything for the old fat guys like me. read more

First - I love fro-yo, and I'm very glad this still place exists, as the fad seems to be passing. I am a regular patron whenever I'm in the area. That said, this is an average fro yo bar, with nothing particularly interesting or different to set it apart. They have a good variety of flavors, and I've never seen a machine out of order or empty - but their yogurt tends to be very sweet, with no original/tart option, which is my preference. The toppings counter is usually kept organized and clean, and I've also never seen any empty containers there. It's a typical pay-by-weight setup, and prices are on par with other yogurt shops. In short - a decent option, but not necessarily a place I'd go out of my way to visit. read more

They make really good tasting frozen yogurt. They have some really great flavors like Salt Caramel Pretzel and Nutella. The prices are outrageous though once you get to the counter with your cup. I also realized that every time I ate the yogurt here my stomach hurt. I'm not sure what is causing it but I wonder if there is just a ridiculous amount of fake sweetener or something that just doesn't agree with me. read more

Not great selection compared to other places. Music outside is loud and blown speakers. Not necessary especially at 9am when your closed. This place just does not do it for me. Worst part and beware is that they only have one size cup and guess what it is? Yup ......... extra large. Joke! Tcby has different sizes. Never again read more

This is my favorite place to go to for frozen yogurt. The taste is just better then any other place. They also have a large amount of topics that I like. This place is my guilty pleasure! I am eager to try their yogurt cakes as well...... it all taste so much better then regular ice cream anyway! I just wish this was not all so expensive..... everything is this do it yourself and then have it weighed frozen treat days........it is so darn expensive. read more

We went to Catch the Wave with 10 of my sons close friends (2 & 3) year olds. It was amazing the kids were able to run around and there was plenty of seating and options. The staff was very nice! read more

This yogurt place rocks my socks! I used to decorate my own birthday cakes until I tried this yogurt. Its light not heavy but does melt usually before I get home. Still so worth it. read more

Though it's a bit out of my way, I find myself making the effort to drive to Catch The Wave anytime I am in the mood for some frozen yogurt. This is quite telling especially considering there are at least 4 fro-yo places within a 5 mile radius from my home! The culmination of fun ambiance, delectable flavors, friendly staff and clean establishment make Catch The Wave the obvious choice. read more

This is the best self serve yogurt shop on Long Island Plainview. The yogurt is so good and the toppings are amazing. The staff are really helpful. Good yogurt. Good staff. And good toppings read more

As a frozen yogurt place this is awesome big selection very clean helpful staff and places to sit. A bit expensive but a local favorite