Wow! Can't believe I never knew about Hershey's Ice Cream & more place till now! It's a hidden gem in Levittown, NY! I'm so happy I found this place on Yelp. It's even more unbelievable they were open on the 4th of July! It was awesome Paul answered the phone, he let me know he would be open today. I was super happy when I found out I could pick up an ice cream birthday cake for the bbq we're going to. I picked up a quarter sheet ice cream cake and everyone loved it! Several people wanted seconds of the delicious ice cream cake. They also have a variety of ice cream which will be a great excuse to come back next time we're in the area. Paul is the owner of Hershey's Ice Cream & more and an incredibly funny guy. Paul & his pal Jerry had my sister and me laughing till tears were coming out of our eyes! lol I would definitely recommend Hershey's Ice Cream & more to family and friends anytime. Hershey's Ice Cream & more definitely deserves my Yummylicious Stamp of Approval! Two thumbs up! read more

Hershey's Ice Cream & more - Quarter Sheet Ice Cream Cake chocolate/vanilla w/chocolate crunchies- everyone loved it! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

My daughters first job was at Hershey's Ice cream when she was 16, now she's 25. She loved working there, Paul, the owner, always made the job fun and she holds some great memories! Since I moved out East, I'm not in Levittown much anymore, but I always try to make it to Hershey's for some delicious ice cream whenever I may be back in the area! You will find some very interesting flavors here. Moose Tracks is my favorite but at Hershey's, you will find Mint Moose Tracks. Not an overpowering mint flavor but instead, this flavor is refreshing and very tasty. Paul is always super friendly and very generous with his scooping! A small ice-cream cup which is one scoop, you get almost 2 scoops, for $4.00. The interior may catch you off guard, it has always been messy as others have described in their reviews, but, once you're there, and talking with Paul, it really won't make a difference! Besides, you want some great ice-cream and Hershey's is where you will find it!! read more

Strange experience. We were excited to come here as we read it had a lot of vegan options. Drove there. Saw signs on the door to call, but the door was open. The interior is in disarray and looks unkempt. Very off putting. The owner may live to ere, who knows? Anyway, it was so off putting we decided to leave. There are enough other options around that I don't need to feel I am entering disaster zone. read more

It's in a small strip mall with plenty of parking. Somewhat non discreet but they do have a bright sign if you at night. It isn't in the best condition as far as how everything is inside the store. Lots of boxes everywhere but the gentleman behind the counter was very nice and he was also very accommodating as well. Great selection of flavours and they have pre made ice cream cakes as well. Somewhat of a hidden gem read more

See all

Seems like the owner lives there 24/7... has hours that says 24 hours, but a sign on the door that says if the door is locked to call him. There are boxes and what looks like garbage in the doorway and front entrance, was a little nervous to walk in. Opened the door and said are you open and heard someone say "the doors open isn't it?" I couldn't even see the man behind all the piled up boxes, got kinda freaked out and left. Strange way to run a business, who knows what goes on there. read more

Fun ice cream spot with a variety of flavors. I picked the peanut butter cup and it was delicious! The small cup was pretty big. I could have done with a kiddie cup! My boyfriend got a shake. It was super chocolatey. Large as well. Cute spot in town. The town itself has adorable little restaurants and stores all around. Enjoyed it! read more

Hershey's Ice Cream & more - Peanut Butter Cup - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

I went here with my wife on a whim one night because of how many Vegan and dairy free options they offered ( my wife is lactose intolerant). Paul realized it was our first time he gave his welcome schpeel, which was really entertaining and impressive. I wasn't planning on getting anything but after seeing the multitude of flavors and Paul's fantastic customer service I couldn't resist! It was really great ice cream, I got a cherry vanilla normal flavor and my wife tried their vegan butter pecan and caramel fudge. We will definitely be going again when on Long Island! read more

Visit Date: unsure So I was pretty happy with the ice cream and the owner of the store was super friendly and gave me a good explanation of all the ice cream they had to offer. The reason I give a 3 star review was because the store itself was a hot mess. There were boxes around, a partition with things behind it and I am a hot mess too I will admit it but for a store presentation it definitely wasn't good and felt a little on the sketchy side. Besides the messy store vibe if I'm in need of ice cream for dinner because ice cream or frozen yogurt is now a standard lunch or dinner for me I would consider coming back. read more

We stopped by here one night after seeing some decorated Christmas homes in the area, good ice cream. I didn't go inside but my hubs did and mentioned the mess inside but that the guy was really nice. We'd go back here but seeing some pictures my husband couldn't help but take pictures of, come on clean up a little bit lol. I mean you want people to leave talking about the ice cream not the huge mess :P ice cream was good though I wanna make that clear! read more

Is it really open? Visited but "no one home" despite a " We Are Open" sign. Ug Closer inspection showed a small sign on the door stating that they were out for a delivery. read more

Walked in, the place is a mess. Empty boxes, bags, a shopping cart full of stuff. The fridge has several open cans of soda that look like they've been there a while. Papers, receipts and tons of crap on the counter. The gentleman seems nice but he appears to be a compulsive hoarder, hopefully he can find some help. We walked out. Don't believe me? Check out the pictures of the establishment on google. read more

Stick to Carvel or Ralphs...while the ice cream was pretty good the store was very sketchy. Boxes everywhere and the front counter was also very cluttered with what appeared to be garbage as well. Owner was friendly enough but the interaction was overall awkward and weird. Not sure I'd return and I definitely would not recommend. read more

Hershey's Ice Cream & more - Back of the store was a disaster - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

This is a cute little store that has great ice cream!The staff is very friendly and welcoming. I received a presentation of all the flavors they had as well. We ordered the cookies and cream shake, ice-cream sundaes and a waffle cone. The prices are extremely reasonable. It satisfied my craving and was delicious!! I will definitely return. read more

See all

First things first. When you go to this Ice Cream Shop, Paul is great. We came here because my stepdad said that his friend owned this place. Paul gave us the whole run down, not only did we get good ice cream but great service. Most of the people that walk in are coming in smiling and he even has people that you can tell regularly come here. There are so many different flavors and options. They even cater to vegan, lactose free, kosher, and just about whatever you can imagine. Will definitely be returning! read more

DAIRY FREE OPTIONS! The owner is so nice and informative and has a huge selection of dairy free options and also has dairy free cakes which is great. Love this place read more

The store's inside might seem a little messy at first, but Paul's amazing customer service and the delicious ice cream that he provides more than makes up for it. 5 stars. read more

The location is weird. Bed sheets blocking off certain areas. Unpacked boxes just sitting on the floor and in front the door. Weird ambiance in there. read more

I am thrilled to find an ice cream place that sells vegan ice cream nearby!! Hershey's Ice Cream and More has a spectacular amount of both vegan and traditional ice cream, some of which are even kosher! The customer service was spectacular, warm and welcoming. The owner is incredibly friendly and took time to explain all the different flavour offerings, as well as the array of traditional and dairy free ice cream cakes. I so far have tried the dairy-free chocolate, cookie dough, cookies and cream, and mint chip ice cream flavours. The ice cream was delicious and had the ice cream consistency that most dairy-free ice creams are lacking. The owner even said that he could make a shake with the dairy free ice cream and soy milk which I can't wait to try. Hershey's Ice Cream and More offers everything that you would want from and ice cream shop: Delicious ice cream, an extensive array of flavours, and a warm welcoming staff. I'm thrilled to have found a place to get delicious dairy free ice cream close to home, and will definitely be returning to buy an ice cream cake, and more ice cream. read more

There are more than 30 flavors of Hershey's ice cream. The owner was very friendly and explained about everything they were selling in a fast salesman pitch. We ended up getting a scoop of the banana cream pie. There is plenty to choose from. Great local ice cream shop. read more

So today was my kids 9th & 11th birthday party at Adventureland and the cake was a huge success. Sarah and Paul delivered big time. The cake was a huge hit. Each parent commented about how delicious it was and asked exactly where I bought it. I could not be happier with the way it all came together. I cannot wait for the next party so I can find a reason to buy another cake. read more

Hershey's Ice Cream & more - Sweeeeeet - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

I have always loved Hershey's ice cream so when this family owned and operated shop opened in my town I was very excited. The staff is very friendly, they are open late and the decor is classic ice cream parlor. My favorite ice cream is the peanut butter swirl which Hershey's has always been the only ones to make it with such huge chunks of creamy peanut butter inside their super rich and creamy signature vanilla. Did I mention I love Hershey's? Awesome addition to downtown Bellmore!! read more

Best ice cream !!! I come here all the time with my family. Highly recommend !!!!!!!!

Absolutely terrific customer service. 10/10. Paul is a great guy, he even waited for us to come in way past closing. The ice cream was delicious and has such a wide variety of flavors and toppings. Highly recommend this place read more

Super nice owner/worker at this place. Ice cream was fresh and delicious and reasonably priced! Will definitely be back soon.

AMAZING!!!! the vegan options are abundant, the regular dairy ice creams are out of this world and the owner is so friendly, knowledgeable, friendly and so entertaining. looking for a good ice cream parlor??? GO. TO. THIS. ONE. I live all the way in babylon but will be driving the distance to eat dessert here! read more

Great ice cream and amazing service!! So many flavors and options to choose from. Has that old ice cream shop feel. Highly recommend!

So glad we gave this place a try. Just had dinner with relatives and husband was looking for an ice cream place. He considered Carvel because that's what he knew visiting his cousins and spending summers on Long Island away from the city, but didn't think there would be anything for our daughter who is lactose intolerant. Husband didn't know if place would be open because it was the 4th of July so he gave a call. The owner answered and asked if 10:30 p.m. or 11 p.m. would be late enough. He would be there. We headed over right away. It was a little after 7:00 p.m. The very personable owner asked for 30 seconds to go over the offerings. We would then be knowledgeable enough to be behind the counter according to him. There were over 32 flavors of ice cream to choose from with some not in the front because there is only so much room. There was Serendipity which has 3 times the vanilla flavor and more butter or fat. Husband had to have a scoop of that and the mint moose tracks. He found the mint moose tracks crunchy. He and older twin daughter liked the rich vanilla flavor of the Serendipity. Husband even considered the all natural fruit smoothie with Dole fruit and a base of Mott's apple juice. I had the peach ice cream. The ice cream was very natural with chunks of peach. I enjoyed it very much. There was even lactose free ice cream for the younger twin daughter. About 9 flavors for her to choose from. The base was different from anything she had ever tasted before, but she enjoyed the cherry vanilla she chose. Normally, she is forced to have a sorbet of some sort. The owner could also make a shake with soy milk. I was tempted to take a scoop of the dark chocolate raspberry truffle back to the hotel with me, but husband felt that I should wait for another visit. Maybe we can stop by before we have to get on our plane. read more

What a Gem, you don't find many of these around. Owner is very kind, and ice cream is top notch. Support this ice cream shop,you wont be disappointed. read more

Hershey's Ice Cream & more - The new Andes Chocolate sandwich! Delicious - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

See all

I absolutely love this place. Been here a couple times and tried a few flavors. So far I loved everything I tried here. The owner is super friendly and hospitable. He remembered us the second time we walked in. Can't wait to try the rest of the flavors. The pricing is fair for the portion, I think the double scoop is worth it. read more

Hershey's ice cream! What else is there to say. The decor is a nice touch, and the ice cream and shakes are all excellent. A refreshing change from seeing all the frozen yogurt shops popping up all over the place. read more

The ice cream was good, not mind blowing but it was good. The main plus for this place is the guy who works here, I'm thinking he is the owner. He's very passionate about his work, and really seems to like what he is doing. I'd come back just because of him. read more

Clean store, friendly service and ice cream was fresh. You know its not good for you, but don't let your taste buds know. read more

Hershey's Ice Cream & more - Moose tracks. Yummy! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

Delicious! Be aware that there are more flavors available than what you can see in the freezer, just ask. "Green tea ice cream is always available." read more

I'm sure the ice cream would have been awesome, had we only been allowed to buy it. We came in with a Living Social deal and the store clerk not only wouldn't honor it, but dismissed us rudely out of her store for trying. For a store trying to get rid of merchandise a day before closing for the season, selling to us would have been the smart thing to do. SKIP the Hershey's in Bellmore and take a 5 minute ride to the one in Wantagh. read more

The guy working when I walked in was very disrespectful. He had a bad vibe and made me feel uncomfortable. Ice cream tastes like it's been there for years. The store is on a corner and is a dead spot so that is probably why. Inside the store was also very dirty, looked like they were doing construction inside. A lot of stuff unpacked and looked like they just opened. It wasn't very sanitary, everything looked old and dirty. This just ruined my first time experience at Hershey's even though I love their ice cream. It was just this Hersheys ice cream that tasted weird. I would never come back here ever again. read more

Wonderful ice cream and amazing service! He had closed the store but saw us pull into the parking and opened back up for us!

I can't have dairy and was new to the area. I found this place and I come here about every other weekend. They have a great selection of dairy free ice cream which are great. I love the cookies and cream, pistachio and butter pecan.I think there are 9-10 dairy free and 32 flavors of the regular ice cream also the owner is great! read more

The owner here is very friendly! He welcomed us as soon as we walked in and took his time to explain everything to us. Very friendly man. The ice cream was very good and the portion sizes are big. I honestly have zero complaints! I would suggest trying the green tea ice cream it's amazing and one of the best I've tried. Enjoy! read more

We love Hershey's! Friendly people, great ice cream and vegan choices. An excellent experience every time!

This place is never too busy, it's an undiscovered gem! The prices are a fraction of other ice cream shops. The owner is so nice and welcoming and the ice cream is top shelf! read more