The best selection of ice cream and Italian ice around! Friendly, fast service and the prices are great. We took our whole family and my youngest son chose best - a split small dish of "Sweetest Fish" and "Rainbow Sour" ices, which tasted like a cold refreshing bowl of gummy candies. Yum! The ice creams were delicious as well - try the bluer-than-blue Monster Cookie or the Salty Caramel Truffle. Wish our trip here was longer so we could go back again. read more

The owner was nice and helpful. They had generous sized milkshakes for the price! Lots of ice cream flavors and a wide candy selection...everything from my childhood they had which was cool too read more

Best ice cream place hands down!! Lots of great ice cream/Italian ice flavors and different/old school candies to choose from. Owner is the nicest guy ever, he will make you feel like he's always known you and is super grateful for your business. Prices are unbeatable!! The drive thru service is super cool. Cool and unique decor inside. If you go to carvel you are doing a disservice to your palate, bank account and supporting local community read more

Excellent vanilla egg cream. The owner is a great guy. I recommend going there for ice cream

Great place! Ice cream is GOOOOD best birthday cake ice cream I've ever had. The owner there is super nice and accommodating. Love this place. It's definitely my to go to around the area. My son LOVES the candy options read more

Paradise Ice Cream Parlour - Birthday cake & strawberry ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mastic Beach, New York

Best ice cream in town we come here at least once a week throughout summer ! So many good flavors to choose from . We love the owner very welcoming and always loads up the ice cream . read more

Omg this place is awesome . It has some old school .25 cent candies. The ice cream is soooo good. He gives you so much and it's really good. The owner working this place is such a nice guy working his butt off. Great sweets, decent prices and great service. You can sit and chill out or take it home. We will be back. read more

Exactly service!! Great flavors of ice cream! Prices are amazing! We love supporting our local business owners!!

Outstanding customer service. Always fresh ice cream with lots of gluten free options available. The prices are great too. I highly recommend! read more

Friendly staff, they have lots of candy and different varieties of old-school candy to choose from. The ice cream itself is OK,

This place has a terrific selection of ice cream flavors, lots of fun candy and even a drive up window. Sundaes are great, So is the hot fudge, ices and whipped cream. It is a winner. And the prices are decent,too! read more

My grandchildren and I come here whenever we're in the area. They have the best ice cream and all different kinds of candies. The owners work so hard and he's so friendly the prices are excellent and he's always so sweet to my grandson who is special needs highly recommend this place. read more

Clean establishment and super friendly owner operator. Jacob usually greets everyone by name. Gives the community a small town feel.

And now our bodies are oh so gross, not light I never felt so good, I never felt so right And we're glowing like the yellow on a butter knife The sign out front states, albeit in relatively fine print, that they accept all competitors' coupons. "Let us take you back to paradise", they assert. They boast a dollar menu - churros, hot dogs, knishes, funnel cake, corn dogs - much like the other additive-stricken, obesity-inducing, diabetes-initiating national institutions, but run the gambit on a local level. Sweet tooth engage, with Visa or MC or cash, at least. There are racks of HFCS, air hockey tables and arcades that don't seem to be turned on, and tables & chairs that seem to be on the verge of collapsing. They cite homemade ice cream but display Ben & Jerry's font inside. Their "two for Tuesdays" BOGO soft serve mirrors that of Ice Cream Cottage but won't steer me farther from home to Paradise, for a variety of reasons. The small gets you one flavor but 2 or 2.5 scoops, and I made my selection from the backmost display, one largely out of view unless you do some exploring. I went with the blueberry cheesecake, struggling to order from the guy on a personal call the whole time...after he actually even looked in my direction at all, that is. I coupled my purchase with a Twizzler assortment and sat at their umbrella'd tables outside. The frozen blueberry chunks were far from endearing and overpowered the flavor, but the overkill was still delicious. Though it's cold and lonely in the deep dark night I can see Paradise by the dashboard light read more

Paradise Ice Cream Parlour - $3.25 - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mastic Beach, New York

See all

Can't say enough about this place- absolutely LOVE it. I've cream cottage has nothing on this place- by far my favorite is the cotton candy my Husband loves anything with peanut butter. Only stinky part is they're seasonal- I count down the days til it opens again read more

a hidden gem deep in the 'hood. Surely worth a trip off the beaten path. Support local!!!

The kids just love it there. Good service. Lots of candy to spoil the kids! Vanilla malted is excellent

Have been going here for years and it still really really good ice cream my favorite is the peanut butter and chocolate glad its still around read more

Absolutely love this place, not only do they have a wide variety of what feels like 50 flavors of ice cream and italian ice, their prices are incredibly fair when compared to carvel. The owner is super nice and was very friendly. I will continue to support here and I suggest everyone do the same as well, this is a great local business that needs to stay here. read more

This place gives Baskin Robins a run for their money! This place is every kids dream. Hard to find novelty candies (aka Box of Bugers), old fashioned candies, and endless flavors of ice cream and italian ice. There is a .25 cent arcade in the back. If you trying to quit smoking they even have candy ciggaretts......which are sooooo polically correct!! ha ha I probably would have given them 5 stars except Neighborhood Rd. is skeevy. As I was eating my Pumpkin Spice ice cream in the front I must have seen at least 3 different people walk by who clearly looked wasted on some sort of needle drug. Ughhhh..... read more

This is the best place around. Huge candy place inside. Great prices. Friendly and nice staff. Amazing drive through window. Ice cream is fresh and delicious. Have anything you could possibly want and more. read more

Hidden gem. We were staying at a friend's house and after a few days just at the beach we had a couple of days exploring. I regret finding this place on our last day as I would have gone everyday. Unlike a lot of modern candy/ice cream places, who are about their flashy displays without an unique choices, this place had an interesting choice, good prices, old school arcade set up at the back, huge selection of ice creams and ices and a drive thru window....... Brilliant. I wish them great success and maybe suggest trying to tape into beach traffic with more than just the road sign. read more

Best ice cream and service in the area. Love the friendly staff and the vast assorted choices of flavors.

What an awesome place to bring the kids and the whole family. With so many flavors to choose from, it was hard to decide. So I got the chocolate browning and my girlfriend got the blueberry cheesecake. Let me tell you it was delicious. My two kids got German chocolate cake and a Spumante ice. YUMMY!!! On top of delicious ice cream, the prices were great am affordable. The service was wonderful. Also they don't just have ice cream, I love all the old fashioned candy, and glass coke bottles. It's just was a great experience and wonderful atmosphere. Highly recommend!!!! read more

Maybe I'm just easy to please? But in many ways ice cream is ice cream? Paradise has a nice selection of flavors and candy, plus a quarter arcade. I think the atmosphere was great; fun place to kill some time with the little ones. I find it more of a destination than an ice cream parlor. I found it FUN! Kids said " Dad this place is cool" read more

Great ice cream, lots of flavors, and huge portions for the cost! So, so much better than the Ice Cream Cottage. Lots of vintage type candy too. Don't let the parking lot in the back turn you off; the place is amazing! read more

Definitely the best ice cream place on the island! Paradise has so many flavors of ice cream to choose from so your sure to find your favorite here, the flavors of the ice-cream is absolutely amazing. I came here a minute after closing and I was politely greeted and let in to the establishment and got my ice cream with probably the best customer service I've ever experienced. I'd recommend this place to all my friends !! read more

Nice local candy store / ice cream shop with tons of selection great prices they have candy I have not seen in 25 years

honestly what ice cream place is better then this 1?? thats right none, ice hockey, shooter, n fighting arcade games, atleast 100 variety of candy to choose from, and amazing ice cream flavors. this place is great =D also in this store they sell ipods, cellphones ( at&t -blackberrys, iphones, tmobile- sidekicks, and many more cell phones, mp3 and mp4 players, toys, laptops u name it they have it like i said this place is hands down the best ice cream place on long island. read more