If you are reading this review instead of getting on the line to order you're already wasted too…read moremuch time. I didn't know what to expect when the suggestion came up to come here, or if I thought I could find anything to satisfy my ice cream fix from the looks of the old school store front. But I'm so glad I was 100% proven wrong, because this is a hidden gem and needs to stay that way to keep lines from forming. As soon as you walk in you could tell there were too many delicious choices to narrow down into an order including pralines and cream, banana nut crunch and bartman. And if something doesn't quite fit your fancy, you can choose to add toppings to your mix from the large variety of options. The line moves fast, and the friendly staff are super helpful and ready to answer questions. The menu also provides favorite concoctions and sundaes. The interior may seem small, but you don't need much room to get in, order, and get out quickly. The only problem is I only had two hands to hold my order as I wanted to try everything.

Don't be fooled by the outdated and small look - this is the most delicious ice cream you'll have…read moreon Long Island! Living close to this place is very dangerous, as we already went back twice in 1 week. From ice cream to pup cups to nostalgic candy, this is the perfect spot for someone with a sweet tooth. We tried the Mint Cookies & Cream (I usually never order mint) but it was perfectly flavored and not overly minted. Everything is homemade fresh - highly recommend!

BEST COOKIES EVER!! I ordered custom decorated sugar cookies for a few events now, from a…read morebachelorette party to birthdays. The owner, Jess is so easy to work with & always brings my vision to life! Not only are her cookies beautiful detailed & fun, but they taste delicious!! We also love her classic chocolate chip & salted toffee peanut butter cookies!!

Food & Quality: The shake was a solid 10/10--perfectly made and not overly heavy, which made it…read morereally enjoyable. Service: The staff was great, and the owner was especially friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. Ambiance: The atmosphere was warm and inviting. It's also a nice touch that you can watch them prepare the ice cream rolls right in front of you, adding to the overall experience.

If you want to support a family owned business this is it. There products are beyond delicious,…read moreemployees are not just friendly they go out their way to make you feel at home. I would only like if there were multiple colored waffle shells daily but definitely not a deal breaker

The real thing, icing covered brownies tasting like old world heart and soul in every bite, flavor…read morepopping on all cylinders making your eyes water, wow, Highly, highly recommend!! Mike Guerra

Such a cute place. So happy to have found it. Hot coffee and some delish cakes and donuts too…read more Staff were so sweet. So peaceful to sit outside and enjoy the grounds there. We will definitely be back.

The Cake Jar Shoppe…read more Is a very cozy spot located in the village of Bellport. Walking in you're surrounded by lots of sweets , beautiful decorations. They have candy right by the window area and also so much cakes and other sweets you can select from up front. Was greeted coming in. And was being told about all the products there. All is freshly made and homemade there. They have cakes you can order for birthdays and other events you name it. Service is amazing there. Helpful when asking to set a cake up for mothers day. I ended up also buying a lot of sweet there to share with my love ones at home. All great pricing and taste so rich and fresh. Recommend to check in if you live around the area or even passing by!

Little corner shop. Make sure you come early to get the cupcakes or they'll be gone. They had…read moreGluten Free and Vegan options too. We also bough a few cake jars and all where delicious.

best rainbow cookies. ever…read more Local bakery that's been here forever. Family owned and operated. Bread, cookies, cakes, they've got it perfected. It's grab and go with a small inside.

I have been coming here for many years. Service fluctuates and so does the quality of the items. I…read morereally do LOVE their rainbow cookies and their butter cookies. I recently ordered a cannoli filled chocolate cake with whipped cream frosting, it was a big hit at work! I had ordered a 10' cake and was worried that it was too big when I picked it up. Well, the whole cake was gone in 2 days (we have a small office of 12 people). We normally try to convince people to take cake home to get rid of it but didn't have that problem this time! A few years back I had an issue with burnt pignoli cookies that I ordered for a party, I picked them up but didn't see them until the box was opened. I called to complain and they said they weren't burnt. I brought them in the next day to show them and the chuckled and said the baker must have fallen asleep. I said they should have thrown them out, the employee told me those are too expensive to throw out! I thought (and should have said) I know, I had to pay for it!!! I was offered more of the burnt cookies! No reimbursement! Really hit and miss

I drove 30 minutes for this place a it was definitely worth it. The ice cream was baked to…read moreperfection and I don't even know how you bake ice cream. Cookies and cream was great. I mean who doesn't like homemade ice cream! And if you don't you're a psycho just like me (however I like homemade lce cream it's just some people are born psycho )Only complaint is that the lights are barely on so you can't really tell if it's open until you get in. But besides that the ice cream was greatly appreciated.10/10

What a cute place. Super nice staff and very good ice cream. Price was also very good. Highly…read morerecommend!!!

This place has a terrific selection of ice cream flavors, lots of fun candy and even a drive up…read morewindow. Sundaes are great, So is the hot fudge, ices and whipped cream. It is a winner. And the prices are decent,too!

The owner was nice and helpful. They had generous sized milkshakes for the price! Lots of ice cream…read moreflavors and a wide candy selection...everything from my childhood they had which was cool too

Still my favorite coffee shop on Long Island! Stopped in today after a long time being away and got…read morea graham cracker latte with their homemade graham cracker syrup. Absolutely amazing! The store hasn't changed, still the nice little cozy shop it has always been. Excellent selections of coffees to purchase Along with wonderful products. Wish I could buy myself a nice Tumblr, but my budget says no this week lol. Sue, the owner is just as I remembered her, so happy her shop is doing well. Hope this place stays for a long time to come. Can't wait till I come back from Long Island to have this again!

I was talking to a new friend the other day about how much I love this place, then realized I've…read morenever reviewed them My friend Deirdre is absolutely in love with this spot. She'd been asking me to come for years and a few months ago we finally made it. On her own she goes all the time. Now we go together whenever I'm off from work as a special new tradition. They have the coolest creative lattes and teas like a peanut butter & jelly one, lavender etc. I'm also obsessed with their soap! (The coffee one though. Def a matter of opinion but I wasn't crazy about the scent of the orange one. I had thought I liked it in the store, but it didn't smell good on my body. Maybe doesn't mix well with my body's natural scent or something. Or maybe just me bc I kept feeling like I smelled but no one else thought it smelled bad lol. I LOVE how I smell with the coffee one though!) Staff are very sweet. Not a lot of space to sit just a few tables but they do also have a few benches out back.