Love this place! Great, no-frills, casual spot to grab a little pie and sit by the water. Go! You won't be disappointed.

The absolute best key lime pies. They use fresh ingredients and take pride in the final product. The servers are always pleasant and the service is prompt. read more

Why can't I give more than 5 stars?? I've never disliked key lime pie, but I never would've said it was my favorite. When I found out my boyfriend loves it, someone told me about Steve's, and since I work in the area I bought him a few of the mini ones and brought them to him at his firehouse. He LOVED them. For Thanksgiving, since I had to work, I bought a large pie for my EMS station, and all but one piece remained at the end of my shift....so I brought it home. I had it for breakfast the following morning and since then, I have found myself CRAVING it, lol. I may be stopping by later today to pick up a few for myself and my boyfriend!! Thank you read more

Edit: The owner replied, and as you can see, would rather his customers drink from the garden hose than throw in a cup of tap water. The pie was pretty good, so I'll bump it up to three stars. Super lame. I wanted some water to go with my pie, and despite there being a stack of cups with a faucet right there, the kid working the counter was under instruction to not give me any tap water. He was just following orders, but this is such a lame, greedy policy on the part of the owner. Fortunately, the guys at the furniture store next door were kind enough to let me use their sink (edit: water dispenser). read more

OMG. The chocolate swingle was one of the most satisfying desserts I've ever had. I totally understand why people would come all the way here to try it. The chocolate was out of this world and the key lime pie inside was amazing with that heavenly graham cracker crust. Will have to come back to try the others! read more

I meant for the Swingle to be a surprise. But her endless complaints as we walked through the deserted, industrial streets forced me to tell her that the reason I was walking her over to the waterfront was because I was going to get her a chocolate-dipped, frozen key-lime pie on a stick. And then she shut up. Until we actually sat down at the picnic table outside Steve's, and she bit into the pie. Then there was a lot of "Oh my god. Oh my god. Oh my god." I've never heard her sound so excited before.* If you plan to take a trip to Steve's, beware: 1. In this heat, the Swingle gets messy. I found chocolate all over my arm hours later, which if you're not aware, looks extremely professional. 2. It's windy by the water. Put something on top of your napkins if you don't want to chase them around for a while. But you better chase them if they blow away. Littering is a crime. 3. It really is kind of a bitch to get to, if you don't live nearby. If there was ever a shop that needed to start distributing via food truck, it's Steve's. This is a million dollar idea, and Steve, when you finally realize the brilliance of this, I will take pies in lieu of my royalties. __________ *Hmmm. read more

BEST key lime pies I've had. The custard is a lot softer than most of the key lime pies I've tried, and the crust gives the perfect balance. The location is kinda out of nowhere, but if you come to Red Hook for Hometown BBQ or Crab Shack, stop by here for dessert after your meal. There's also a park that's right next to it so you can bring the pie and eat at the park while admiring statute of liberty. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

From the first bite of Steve's Key Lime pie you are hooked! Fresh squeezed key limes are the secret to this delicious pie. If you like Key Lime pie and your in the neighborhood, stop by, you won't regret it. read more

I love everything about this bakery: - Single-minded dedication to one product - The quirky signposts that point you toward the bakeshop - The remote location that keeps the hoi polloi away - Outdoor picnic tables surrounded by Floridian foliage - The Swingle: frozen pie on a stick covered in Callebaut chocolate ($5) - The bracingly tart key-lime filling that makes my mouth pucker - Reasonable prices: $15 for 8-inch pie, $25 for 10-inch - The sign on the door that says, "We do not sell coffee"; "We do not know about available real estate in the area"; "We do not make apple pie" If I ever started a business, I'd run it exactly this way. (Except I wouldn't make key lime pies, or any type of pie. I hate baking.) read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - It's frozen pie on a stick covered in chocolate! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is not a pie you pie your friends with. For a minute we laughed about this notion and I had mental images of pie-ing someone with Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies. Before even reaching my friend's face, the pie filling would slide down my arm. Although chilled, the filling is not quite set and when sliced, the pie just runs... so scoop it up fast with your spoon, get a little (or a lot) of crust to go with it and insert in mouth. Oh happy day! Do not ever waste a Steve's key lime pie on some Three Stooges or birthday hijinks. This is not a pie you eat with a fork or on a plate. Such civilized utensils are not provided at Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies. Simple stacks of napkins and spoons are yours for taking. Some got creative and made a makeshift plate out of it but after two scoops, I could already see the "paper" plates getting soggy. The best way to eat a communal 10" pie at the wholesale bakery is to really dig in. Take your spoon, fight for your slice, scoop away with one hand, use your other hand to shoo away flies, and just enjoy as a little kid would. Forget prim and proper. The pie is messy and if you get filling on your face or shirt or lap, oh well. Oh happy day! The pie is all you need but if you must, if you have a craving for chocolate, or are really on that popsicle trend, then get a Swingle. It's a 4" pie dipped in dark Belgium chocolate on a stick. It's delicious but the high quality chocolate tends to overpower the key lime. And we are at Steve's for key lime pie! not chocolate!! The graham crust is divine. Butter is in through and through. The pie filling is less sour than you can imagine and perfectly tart in every way, not too tart and the pie itself is not too sweet. It's yellow not green as true Key Limes are, so I am told. This is as authentic as it can get north of Key West. There is also a sign on the door that says all "unruly humans should remain outside, preferable on a leash". Yes, if you ever decide to use Steve's key lime pie to pie someone, you should be leashed. read more

See all

Checked out this place after Hometown BBQ and it really hit the spot. Tried one of the chocolate covered key lime pies with raspberry and it was a perfect sweet ending. Definitely worth checking out if you're in the area. read more

See all

This is the way I imagined how this business was first conceived: Steve: I just had the most delicious key lime pie off of key west in Florida. It reminded me of how much I miss eating them as a kid when I lived there. Why don't we have anything like those in NYC. Every version of it tastes like crap here. Friend: Oh shush. That's all I've been hearing about since you came back from your vacation. I'm tired of it. If you think the pies sucks here, why don't you make some yourself and see if you could make it any better smart ass? Steve: Hmm... you know what? I think I will. I'll make it as authentic as theirs. In fact, I want the customers to feel as if they had just left NYC and gotten the real deal. Friend: Ha ha. Like you know how to bake. Besides, how would you make them feel like they have left NYC by eating your pie? By starting a store all the way in Jersey and make them drive all the way there? Steve: Traveling for the pie.... My friend you are a genius!!!! Making them travel far would make it seem like they are on a trip. But I'll locate it in Brooklyn instead of Jersey. To make it just as hard as getting to Key west, I think I'll locate it at Red Hook where it is far from the nearest convenient public transportation. It's going to be an adventure for all just to be able to even eat it!!!! Friend: I was only kiddi... Owner: In fact, I'll even decorate the surrounding area with various crappy Key West memorabilias and even a small boat in random nonsense places as if it was dropped from a hurricane. Friend: *Waves hand up in the air* I give up. Thus was born Steve's Authentic Key lime Pie. Opened in a warehouse building, the only way to tell that Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie is nearby is the interesting signs and nick nacks leading up to the plain door of the place. It does not look anything like what you would expect from a place that sells pies. There are some wooden benches outside where you could enjoy the nearby Hudson river breeze. You could even see a frontal view of the statue of Liberty from there. The in house baked pies were custard like in texture, nicely tart and mildly sweet, plus the filling were encased in a crumbly graham pie crust. These come in various sizes such as a personal pie that is 4 inches for $4, 8 inches for $15, and 10 inches for $25. There is even a Popsicle version of the key lime pie here known as the Swingle. It's not really a Popsicle in the true sense of the word but more of a personal pie encased in a chocolate casing, stuck with a Popsicle stick, and then chilled till it's cold but not frozen inside. The chocolate used for the Swingle, like the pie itself was made in house from their own recipe that they perfected over the years. Delicious for $5. Words have spread over the last few years that there was finally a Key Lime Pie that would be just as good as what you get in Florida. As the saying goes, "if you build it they will come." Come people did, cursing the long difficult travel to this remote location in Brooklyn. But in the end, most people found that it was worth all that effort for what they were able to find here. I know I did. ***************************************************************** Disclaimer: You could read up on how the business was really started on their website. If you believed what I wrote as the origin of the pie is real, you are certainly very gullible. How good the pies taste and what it was made of is real though. Oh, and the long difficult travel is real too. Swingle: http://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/CoJmKwsXt3esEKVB6-3EkQ?select=CC5z0SNb_3NouK8q_Clr_Q 4 inches personal Key Lime Pie: http://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/CoJmKwsXt3esEKVB6-3EkQ?select=NX7Bp2Bozn1E4QJzFZuNVw Ship found at the entryway of the shop: http://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/CoJmKwsXt3esEKVB6-3EkQ?select=e-GwgZ9C-5SXB_ZvCTQ5sg Popsicle review #9 read more

See all

YUM!!! I find it tough to get a good key lime pie in the North East but this is as good as it gets!! I ordered the small 4" pie and it was perfect for the personal size!! Crust was delicious and pie part was the perfect amount of lime-y. Steve's is such a hole in the wall spot in Red Hook but it works! Beautiful views of Manhattan since it is right on the water. It is decked out like Key West inside and the service is fantastic - very friendly! The picnic tables outside are the perfect spot to enjoy it as well. If you like key-lime pie this is a MUST TRY!!! read more

Red Hook still on my mind... I knew this place had to be amazing for two valid reasons: a) my good foodie friend / fellow yelper, Andrew C. put Steve's on the itinerary of our Food Tour last weekend in Red Hook. And if I can tell you anything about Andrew, it would be he has an amazing palate. This guy does his due diligence and knows a thing or two about good eats. I had cow tongue (lengua!) for the first time on his encouragement, and will never look back. I'm now a slave to his suggestions (I've got Graffiti in my horizon now as well)... b) Steve's is located in a secluded area tucked far away from the heartbeat of Red Hook, behind warehouses left in an aftermath of barrenness. Hole-in-the-walls are always good indicators of food that will make you sing, and I chirped like a rockin' robin after having the Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie experience! Andrew had been boasting of their "swingle" - which is an entire 4" key lime tart dipped in dark, semi-sweet chocolate, then frozen on a stick like an ice cream bar. I can see how this drew many folks, it was good. Great in fact, but I fell head over heels for the unadulterated excellence of their key lime tart. Made without pre-made crusts, or concentrated bottled key lime juice, it's a simple medley of honest ingredients that taste absolutely incredible. The key lime filling is soft and buttery, not too tart but tempered by the texture of the homemade crust. I didn't feel like I was eating something off of a factory assembly line (dear Twinkie, I will always have love for you, but Steve's in a league of his own, sorry). It just goes down so nicely and is refreshing on a hot summer day. You know, I have never been to Florida, but I imagine this little engine that could in Brooklyn would hold its own in a rivalry with the best key lime pies FLA may have to offer. read more

See all

5 stars for the pie, -1 star for the price and the ordeal it requires to get to this location. Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies is a small shack reminiscent of a Santa Cruz surf shop directly on a pier in the middle of the less-traveled neighborhood of Red Hook, Brooklyn. Why? You will have to bike, bus or drive to get here as there is no easy train access to anywhere in Red Hook. Perhaps it lends a keen perspective on the scrum-diddly-umptious-ness of Steve's limey goodness that people actually DO make that trek. Customers arrive in waves perfectly synchronized with the arriving B61 schedule for some reason... (Hint: You can take the B61 here.) They then disappear almost as quickly. Where to? Good question. You may find patrons sitting on the dock overlooking sweeping views of NYC; without all the noise and garbage trucks to derail their minds from the overwhelming bliss that is naggingly persistent when delving into one of Steve's slime-colored discs of the gods. When you come - and believe me, YOU hope you do - you will have to order a regular pie (6$) which is good for one person, and a frozen pie dipped in chocolate. I enjoyed the chocolate dipped key lime pie with raspberry filling to the extreme. Trust me when I tell you that your seventh cranial nerve will thank you, and of course Steve. read more

See all

The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. The swingle. Can Gordon Elliott, Al Roker and those kids on the NY 1 programs all be wrong? Get the swingle. Get it? Also, the location could not be more picturesque and charming, with even a waterfall by the little patio outside where you can suck down your pie while your dog looks on in envy. Water bowl out for the pooches, too, while your pooch grows with every limey bite of pie. See photos. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - The Swingle - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Best key lime pies anywhere, period and that's all you need to know. Oh, that and swingles. What's a swingle? Imagine a key lime tart dipped in Belgian chocolate and frozen on a popsicle stick. YESS! You still with me? Why are you drooling? Don't worry I am too just thinking about it. The raspberry classic swingle is my favorite here... adding raspberry purée is simply sweet genius. Sweet and tart. A great decision if pies aren't your thing. Raspberry blonde (if white chocolate is your thing) and i hear there's a jalapeño option if you're in the mood for some zing. Grab one and walk the nearby pier and take in views of the N.Y. harbor. It's a real treat. Both of them. Never mind that they're somewhat secluded but somewhat walking distance from IKEA. The location is somewhat small and accommodating for small groups but that's why they have a picnic table and a park/pier nearby (if it's not raining). Don't forget they sell pies too. Tarts, 8" and 10"ers for the big boys. It may be the best thing you could put in your mouth. Wait. What?? Don't take my word for it. Go. Now! Mind you, the few ways available for you to get there are either via car, bus, or bike it. If you decide to take the subway, you can transfer for the B61 Red Hook bus and ride for 15-20 mins. If you decide to drive, there is ample parking but mind the cobblestone roads. New York Waterway ferries for Pier 11 to Red Hook-IKEA is an option too. Vastly underrated is the key limeade if you want something refreshing and don't have the itch to eat (yet). The original Red Hook Lobster Pound is a short distance away. read more

See all

It's very cool to have an authentic key lime pie place in red hook. The pie is a great addition to a hot summer day, and it's a close walk to great foods to pair along with read more

Had doubts about Key Lime pies as being too sour and tart, but this place changed my perception of how I view this fruity flavour. The pie was rather refreshing with the right amount of tangy after taste that makes you want to continue eating. The Graham cracker crust adds a nice touch to this dessert pie that doesn't overwhelm the taste of the filling. A great way the end the summer with this treat. Place also boasts a great view of the city read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - 8' Inch Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

It's a fact of life. There are just some businesses that are just so accustomed to locals and regulars that if you don't fit either of these buckets you can expect tepid service at best. Expect that here, and that's okay, but as good advice to any small business that hopes to grow: it pays to show the same friendly service to new customers as you do to your regulars. No one should have to tell you why. Regardless of service, my rating is based purely on the key lime pie. It's good, but not great. Its always a surprise to me to see key lime pie on the menu at any restaurant, and when I order it, I feel pretty satisfied, but always with the caveat that it's not nearly as good as even the most mediocre Floridian example. I kind of expected more from a place that specializes in key lime pie, but it wasn't really the case. It's definitely more custardy, less tart than expected, and the crust was definitely far too loose and crumbly (yes, I ate this fresh). Finally, price. $20 for a so-so 8-inch pie is pretty steep. $30 for a 10-inch and $5 for a mini are not any better. What's needed here is balance. If that's really the pie you're going to serve and at the price, maybe work on service and manners. If not, that pie needs to be a whole lot better. read more

Before coming here, we heard that this place is eccentric when it came to its operating hours. According to their webpage, they use twitter on a daily basis to let people know if they are open and what hours. Since we were on vacation without easy access to the internet, we just took a chance and made the trek out to Red Hook---and got lucky! With a good map in hand, we headed out after getting off the IKEA ferry. We found a sign painted on a building as we got closer pointing the way to Steve's. Still, it took a bit of exploring to find the exact entrance to the shop. We both each got a key lime tartlet and since it was a gorgeous day, we sat outside at a picnic bench and so eagerly delved into our tartlets that we forgot to take photos LOL! However, others did take photos---good thing! My husband, who loves key lime pie, raved about Steve's. No fake green coloring, just good, tart key lime juice (he uses real key limes which are more tart and more aromatic than regular limes). The graham cracker crust is in proper proportion so that it doesn't overwhelm the pie. Next time, we're in Red Hook, we're making a stop at Steve's! read more

I'm glad I can review the old location, despite the fact that by now, Steve's has moved around the corner to 185 Van Dyke St. Notoriously hard to track down, the website's home address isn't even working today. But here's the About page, which IS working.....for now: (http://www.stevesauthentic.com/about.html) Forget calling on the phone. Forget their "updates" on social media. Forget anything and everything you've ever heard...you just have to show up next time you just happen to be tooling around Red Hook during business hours. Which is for most people hardly ever. Every day at this business is apparently just like the weather in Key West during hurricane season: fickle and unpredictable, if not a complete shutout. Yet, the little Red Hook curiosity has managed to develop a rabid cult following. Especially because where in the hell are you ever going to find a place that JUST does key lime pies, and in personal pan sizes and dipped in chocolate at that... Last fall, pre-Hurricane Sandy, a friend stayed there for like a month during her visit from New Zealand and WENT WITHOUT ME. When I was done flipping out, I asked her how it was. "it was all right," she said, somewhat dismissively, and I was horrified and untrusting. I had to see for myself. When I FINALLLLY got to experience Steve's was after a shopping trip to Fairway, which had just reopened after Hurricane Sandy's destruction. So, the concrete lot and warehouse seemed more dilapidated than ever. I followed the still-bright painted signs to a little door where a tiny woman stood quietly, ready to take orders. Not another soul was around. There was no noise or smell indicating a bakery, and yet in exchange for a sum of cash, I walked out with two glassy looking circlets of the goods in paper bags that crinkled in anticipation of being reopened. Oh, and P.S., the lady let me use the bathroom, which had a magazine rack filled with both kitschy and antique reading material. Not that I lingered long enough to really sample the content. I waited until I got home to fork into the dense citrus desserts. They were great. But were they the best I'd ever had? Of course not. Then what IS the best I ever had? I don't know. Probably something from someone's kitchen, or out of Jimmy Buffett's chain restaurant in actual Key West. But like I said, it's just a relief to know that, if you ever have a hankering for some Key Lime pie, you can find it here if you're lucky enough to have time to physically go to the site AND they are open AND they have pies left. Next time I'll try the chocolate, but I don't think the fact that I haven't yet undermines my opinion of the heart of the matter - the pie itself. Like Florida itself, Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies exist in all their ordinary, mouth puckering, brightly colored, casual glory. And they ARE all right. read more

See all

I'm going to get lynched by the people who love this place. It was just OK. I felt the filling was lacking in something. It definitely was key limes that they used but the flavor was missing a little something...maybe if they used some of the zest from the key limes it would have helped...but for some reason the tart flavor that usually comes through from a key lime vs. a regular lime just wasn't there... Super easy to find the the shop though but it is in an obscure location.... Maybe they were having an off batch of limes..will give them another try again soon. read more

You can now get Steve's key lime pies at WHOLEFOODS TriBeca!

This place gets a nice solid 5 stars for bringing some legitimately delicious Key Lime pie to NYC. Have you ever seen that episode of Dexter where he has to find the perfect Key Lime pie for Camilla? Other than the fact that Dexter is in Florida, he probably could have just come to Steve's and mission accomplished! Tucked away in Red Hook, this is what people make a trek out there for (other than the ball field vendors and Ikea). On a nice hot Summer day, this has got to be one of the most refreshing desserts to indulge in. The limeade is equally delicious and when paired together with a slice of pie they become the killer duo for foodgasm overload. Get out here. It is most definitely worth it. read more

Steve's Little Key Lime Pie Shop is set next to Louis Valentino Jr. Park and Pier (which is also little). Yes, it has a great view of Lady Liberty but more importantly, KEY LIME PIE! If you've ever had the pleasure of having true Florida Keys Key Lime Pie then you know I take this seriously. These pies and tarts are the real deal. Delicious, sweet, tart, smooth, and baby, it gives you a good reason to go into Brooklyn. There's always a line, no seating inside, small seating outside, and literally their menu is just Key Lime Pies. It's everything your sweet tooth could ever want. I won't go to Brooklyn without hitting up Steve's. You can't miss it! Absolutely delicious! read more

Definitely five stars for evoking a childhood food memory of mine with one bite! Standing in line at this spot is worth it just to meet all the friendly dogs on a summer's day :) read more

BEST KEY LIME PIES I DONT CARE HOW FAR IT IS! This is so worth the trip - seriously. The raspberry blonde is fantastic. I look forward to coming every time read more

Bite into a slice of sweet key lime pie heaven here. I'd heard about Steve's for years but never made it over as it's far from the subway. Long forgotten from my mind vessel of "amazing sweet things to eat", I stumbled across their giant painted pink sign while driving around Red Hook. Spotted just in time to make the left turn, I got really excited. The first time I found it, they were closed. Boo. Their hours are spotty so it's best to check 4sq or give them a ring before hand. If their closed, don't fret. Though you may be disappointed, there are plenty of goodies like Fairway Supermarket and Brooklyn Crab nearby. Now, onto the delicious stuff. Second time, they were open and Steve himself was manning the front desk. Passionate about my key lime craving, I stuck with your simple key lime tart pie. Graham cracker crust and pure key lime filling and flavor. I even learned that Steve's is only one of TWO bakeries in the US that use fresh key limes. Can you believe it?! Where is the other one you ask? Not where'd you expect. It's in Georgia. I know, I thought it would have been in Key West too. Anyway, one bite of this delectable little treat and I was sold. I bought two and I can't believe I still have one waiting for me in my fridge. My second round here wasn't as enjoyable as my first. And it's not because of the space, I just made a choice not to my liking. Lured in by the infamous swizzle, I spring for the raspberry one which is basically a frozen key lime tart with a smear of raspberry jam on top and dipped in dark chocolate. Sounds delectable doesn't it? it wasn't. Now, apparently I'm not much of a dark chocolate fan, unless it's filled with mint like a york peppermint patty but I felt the cocoa flavor completely over powered the pureness of the key lime pie. I didn't taste the raspberry at all. I actually started picking off pieces of the dark chocolate to get a small taste of the key lime. Needless to say, I was happy I bought a plane tart for later. All in all, I love this place and will continue to come back. Again, remember to call ahead and check the hours. Especially during the week. Weekends you'll have a better chance of catching them open for longer. When you visit, don't feel you have to leave. They have picnic tables outside and there's a beautiful park/pier across the street with a great view if the Statue of Liberty. A perfect place for an "off the beaten path" date. read more

See all

Went back again and came home with two 8 inch pies this time...so much for being healthy!! The guy behind the counter (not sure if it was Steve) was super sweet and knocked down the price a bit because we bought two pies...now that's customer service! The pie was just as delicious as I remembered it and so worth the trip. Also tried the limonade (sp?) which was just the right amount of sour and not overly sweet. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - 8 inch pie of yumminess - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Haters gonna hate. Sure it's not next to public transit or easy to get to, but do people who wait hours for some stupid fad (points to cronuts and ramen lines) still bitch about it? Thes key lime pies are mighty tasty - super creamy and smooth with a nice bite to them. My only regret from coming here was that we only got 1 pie. Get as many as you can fit in your freezer because they're flash frozen and do travel well. read more

Frozen chocolate covered key lime pie. Need I say more? I found out about this place in the winter and went on a cheesecake binge. I bought 4 mini frozen ones and they gave me the 5th free! The best is the dark chocolate covered on with raspberry jam. I dream of it Very cute spot overall, there's a trail that goes around the back by the water so it's nice to get a mini pie in the summer and go for a stroll A great family owned neighborhood Brooklyn spot read more

See all

The lime pie is small and it's almost $6 but I thought it was pretty good. I wouldn't get it again but it's worth a try if you are in the Red Hook area. The crumbs are good and the lime pie really did taste like it was squeezed and baked fresh. It wasn't too sour or sweet but just enough sourness. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have had a few key lime pie slices before and was never too crazy about it. I am a pie lover but citrus pies was never my thing until I finally tried Steve's today. I work only a few blocks away and have long heard of the legend of these pies. Well today my boss had to pick up a few pies for his wife and bought a couple of the 4" for the office and I was blown away. So tart and refreshing with the most amazing crumbly graham cracker crust. I couldve ate 4 of them. I love that this eclectic little place is in the eclectic little area known as Red Hook which Manhattan folks will say is dangerous or far away. Its not dangerous (well maybe Ikea but for other reasons) and as far as being far away you can take the Ikea ferry over. These pies are well worth it. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - God I love this little guy! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

So here's the thing: I don't like Key Lime Pie. Or rather, I have never eaten a Key Lime Pie that I've enjoyed. Usually the crust is mushy, or the filling so tart that my mouth wants to shrivel up and die. For years I've pretty much ignored the dessert, writing it off as one of those things I simply don't enjoy. During my research for a trip into Red Hook, I found out about Steve's and it seemed like the perfect place to take my girlfriend to (she loves Key Lime Pie). I figured I'd at least try a bite and see if my feelings on it aligned with those of my fellow Yelpers. Steve's is kind of hidden but fortunately they've painted on walls and put up signs to point you in the right direction so keep an eye out for them (they're pretty bright and hard to miss honestly). My girlfriend and I tried the Swingle, which I kid you not is a small version of the pie in "tart" form ... on a stick .... dipped in chocolate. I was skeptical at first, but I went for it and man...my mind is changed. This thing was AWESOME. Sweet but tart at the same time, a tasty crust and the chocolate was a great finisher to the combination. I could tell even without the chocolate I would have greatly enjoyed this pie! My mind was changed! Be warned, this is basically a stand (though they are moving soon a couple blocks away). Seating is mostly outside but you get a view of the waterfront so there's little to complain about. Be warned, this place is all about the pie. No coffee, no cookies, no scones, no muffins. You come here, you come for the pie. I really felt relieved and happy after my visit! Definitely check this place out if you can! read more

TL;DR: Get the classic key lime pie popsicle!!! Tucked at the end of Van Dyke Street is the Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies. Along the way, you will wonder if you will ever reach the store. But don't give up! Search for the big Steve's Pies wall mural at the intersection of Van Dyke and Conover. If you see it, you're almost there! The store is inside a warehouse near the water. You won't miss it. I got the classic key lime popsicle! It's basically a small frozen dark chocolate covered key lime pie with a popsicle stick inserted into it. Best invention ever. Thank you Steve! Just the right amount of tartness to sweetness ratio and great for a hot summer day. There are other popsicle flavors, but definitely grab the classic before venturing back for additional tastes! read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - The classic in front of Steve's - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The Key Lime Pie of my dreams. It was worth the trip. Next visit, I will also purchase a frozen pie to-go.

The location isn't the most ideal.. My friend and I got off the ferry in front of IKEA, and trekked through some barren looking streets of Red Hook, like Lewis and Clark, for what seemed like an eternity to Steve's, trusting that Yelp (Sacagawea) would lead us the way to those famous pies. And when it did, I loved it! We shared a small pie (well, he had a bite) right next to the quaint storefront, which happens to face the water and it was perfect. It was a warm Friday evening and the scene was absolutely picturesque, I couldn't have asked for a better day, setting or companion to enjoy the pie with. Despite some of the negative reviews, Steve is wonderful. He was patient and answered all my many questions in detail and it was lovely to see that this man is really passionate about his craft. After we finished our pie, I came back to get a second for a midnight snack later and a frozen raspberry pie for the journey back. If you're wondering if their key lime pie is really as good as they all say: it certainly is. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Adorable! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Wasted time going there, he was closed when we got there. The hours on his website and yelp dont even match.

Best key lime pies in the city. Crunchy, crumbly graham cracker crust with a zesty creamy custard filling. Eat them on the water for a picturesque view. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Key lime pies for deux. Yum! Best key lime pies in the city. Eat them on the water for a picturesque view. - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York