The famous desserts here once inspired me to devise an email subject header entitled Their A&R Man Said I Don't Hear a Swingle, but the truth is I don't recall if I've gotten one of these as I prefer the purity of the outstanding regular pie. Bad planning and weather meant absurdly late breakfast on Saturday so I was stunned to find they have tamales here. I enjoyed the chicken with red sauce. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Chocolate and key lime pie is a great combo, I love that the tartness is cut through with the chocolate. My only complaint was that the pie still felt a bit frozen when I bit into it, I assume they store them frozen but I feel like that's not usually the texture I prefer to eat a pie. No line at the window on a Friday afternoon and service was super quick. They have picnic tables nearby you can sit and eat at. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - The Raspberry Swingle - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Delicious desert, we got original small pies, frozen dark chocolate covered and (my favorite) frozen white chocolate raspberry covered. Dark chocolate cover itself didn't taste too good, and both frozen were messy to eat. Key lime filling was tart, creamy and refreshing. Great location by the water, limited outdoor sitting area that frees up frequently and pier to walk around near by. Line was long and ended up being a bit of wait, priced on the higher end, overall definitely worth trying. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

As a key lime pie lover this hit the spot! In addition to classic key lime, they have other variations like raspberry and even a spicy chipotle one. We went with the classic swingle which was delicious and exactly what you'd expect. The dipped chocolate is a great elevation to already delicious pie. The perfect sweet treat! read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - The Classic Swingle - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Key lime pie was very delicious. Not too sweet. However it could've been more tart. The keys still has the best key lime pie. The vegan carrot tamale was absolutely delicious. Loved the flavor a lot. Line was pretty long on a beautiful Saturday afternoon. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I took the ferry from FiDi and came to Red Hook with a friend. I came to go to a candle making class at Apotheke. After the class, as we waited for our candles to set, we took a walk and ended at Steve's Key Lime Pie. We both had The Original, on a stick. SOOOOO YUMMY! The pie was dipped in really good chocolate!!! We walked around, took in the view, and checked out the brewery next door and Compound Art & Sound Gallery. read more

See all

Well, well, well. I came here after I officiated a wedding at The Liberty Warehouse. I waited on a line but let me tell you it was worth it. I order one frozen 10 inch key lime pie and one 10 non frozen key lime pie. The price was right and let me say it was the best key lime pie I had ever had. The key limes were fresh and the homemade pie was perfect. I saw a lot of people order the chocolate covered key lime pie stick. I was thinking about it as I waited in line. I can see it that sweet and tart taste, but I am more of a traditional guy. They accept cash or credit card. Go check them and order some key lime pies. You will not be disappointed. read more

See all

The small key lime tarts were so good yesterday ! I usually get the pie but these little tarts are just as delicious. The filling has just the right amount of lime flavor with a little bit of zest. The crust is so much better than anything you can buy at local retail stores. The people working here are very friendly and kind too. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Steve's Key Lime Pie - pickup window - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I had the Raspberry Swingle and while really good, I didn't get much of the key lime taste as the raspberry and chocolate overpowered the taste! read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - The Raspberry Swingle - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I was so excited to go here! And even more thrilled when I tasted the tart. The place is adorable with a pick up window. All 3 of us had the tarts. And since it was a cold day, my friend ordered a coffee too. You MUST go here! Even if it's a drive to get here-- worth it! read more

See all

So mediocre! I'm confused how this place is famous! I would not get it again! The key lime pie did not have ANY lime flavor and left me feeling disappointed. I did enjoy the graham cracker crust which was tasty but overpowered each bite. We also got a chocolate dipped frozen raspberry key lime pie on a stick. It was refreshing on a hot day but again, there was no key lime pie flavoring. It tasted like a chocolate covered raspberry. The personal sided pie was $6.50 and the frozen chocolate one of a stick was $9. The line was about 10 people deep when I joined it and took about 10 min. There was only one person working behind the counter. They have picnic tables outside to eat at or you can walk over to the park and sit on a bench to enjoy your treat. No restrooms were available for customers. read more

See all

Rating: 7.5/10 Date Last Visited: 9/6/2025 We ordered the Raspberry Chocolate Swingle ($9.50) and La Victoria Swingle ($9.50). The swingles are individual servings of key lime pie dipped and coated in chocolate. The raspberry swingle was delicious - there was a good balance between the raspberry jam and key lime pie plus chocolate. It tasted exactly like what you would expect a chocolate dipped key lime pie to taste like. The La Victoria had a spicy kick to it, and I personally was not a fan. It's takeout only but the surrounding area has nice views. Overall, if you're a fan of key lime pie and chocolate, this place is worth a visit. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - The Raspberry Swingle - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I went to Red Hook Tavern twice since I needed to try the key lime pies at Steve's. The first time I went, I didn't realize that Steve's closed at 7pm, but we made sure not to make the same mistake twice. The key lime pies are all amazing, and the seasonal fruit flavored ones are even better! The crust is perfectly crumbly and the filling is tangy and sweet. I wish they had a regular frozen version without the chocolate coating since it is a bit too sweet, but the serving sizes are just right. If I had a car or if it wasn't so humid, I'd buy a full pie to go. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Steve's key lime pie is some of the best I've ever had! The shop is a walk-up with no indoor seating, so keep that in mind if you visit during the winter. You'll have to enjoy your pie outside, but there are plenty of benches available. The service was quick and easy, and I'd definitely come back in the summer to enjoy it in warmer weather. Still, it was well worth braving the cold! read more

See all

The pies were the best I have ever had. I had the original and mini pie on a stick that has a raspberry layer and then dipped in chocolate.

Absolutely incredible! The key lime pie is perfectly balanced, refreshing, and unique for a hot summers day. Service was quick, no line at noon on weekday day. The server also gave some great recommendations and answered all my families questions about their menu and store hours (Came back twice in one day because it was just so good). Laid-back vibe by the waterfront which makes this Red Hook gem the perfect spot for a sweet treat with a view. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Cute sign that directs people to the shop. - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Expect a wait but the line moves fairly quickly and well worth the wait! Service is great and friendly. Stunning views of New York harbor and you can enjoy your pie on the picnic benches, especially on warm summer days. Purchased a single serving pie - the graham cracker crust is buttery, the filling is really silky and smooth, the lime is nice and tart. Really refreshing! read more

First off. The pie is yuck!! Too sweet and "lime" tastes weird. The owner Steve is annoyingly arrogant and will defend his pie ad-nauseum. What business owner has time to reply to every review ?? He thinks he owns this little corner of Red Hook, and posts illegal no-parking signs claiming the spots belong to him. There are businesses to the left that need to park, and the waterfront park visitors needs to park also. The guy is so annoying and his overpriced product is at best mediocre. read more

Love this place, especially the white chocolate dipped key lime pie. It's right by the water so nice place to walk and eat. Keep in mind there's no seating indoors. read more

I spent a day in RedHook and heard so much about this place I had to give it a try. I'm a big fan of key lime pie so I was looking forward to this. I got the small tart and the frozen pie with raspberry. Both pies lacked the tart like flavor I look for in the pie. The crust was standard but for the price I don't think it lived up to the hype. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I was really looking forward to key lime pie. Sadly, Steve's isn't quite what it used to be. The custard filling lacked the creamy texture and that signature balance of sweetness and tartness that makes key lime pie so deliciously satisfying. The graham cracker crust was crumbly and didn't hold together well, making it a bit tricky to enjoy each bite. The treat was edible, but definitely not the zesty dessert I had hoped for. read more

See all

A cute, unassuming bakery serving up key lime pies -- for someone who doesn't love citrusy desserts... I liked this a lot. Swingle is popular but can be messy to eat -- I'd probably just get a small pie next time! read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Swingle - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Abs love love loveeeeee! Menu is small and straight to the point. It's a little booth in a building with some parking spots. Great views. Service was great. Tried the classic swingle...omg...it was amazing! Served cold and that's best. I loved how the crust of the pie isn't thick, but still gives a nice crunch for each bite. It's perfectly portioned. I can't believe I missed out on this for so long. Prices are reasonable. This is a must try if you're in the red hook area or a visit in NYC. They also have coffee here which I didn't get to try as it was a hot summer day lol. I will be back to try more of the menu for sure! 10/10 read more

See all

yummy spot specializing in key lime pie! expect a line that moves quickly on the weekends. I will say, Cait's keylime will continue to have a hold on my heart, but I appreciate the ease of getting Steve's. It's a very cute location by the water, and you enjoy the pie at picnic tables outside (no inside seating). you order the pie at the window and the order gets to you super quick as everything is pre-made. I enjoyed the crust of the pie, and we got the mini and a swingle (dipped in chocolate with raspberry sauce). The swingle was served from the freezer and resembled a cake pop! Prices are a smidge high but definitely a treat read more

See all

I love coming here so much that anytime we have family visiting us in Brooklyn - I feel it my duty to take them here. The key lime pie here is refreshing, tart, and oh so delicious. No matter the weather outside, these pies are such a great treat for when you're journeying through Red Hook. If there's a line on the day that you visit - just wait. It always moves super quickly. PS: If you're a chocolate fan - they have a chocolate dipped key lime pie that is so worth trying. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I love that this is a dedicated key limee pie place (besides the surprise tamales), but truthfully, I wish the key lime was more tart!! I want my key lime to smack me in the face with sour. This one was a bit too sweet, especially when you get the frozen ones on a stick dipped in chocolate. I'd be interested in trying the larger sizes to see if the filling to crust ratio helps improve the balance. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Menu and sizes - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Went to Steve's with my girlfriend on a chilly afternoon in December. We heard amazing things about Steve's Key Lime Pie and we were excited to give it a try. When we arrived, we were surprised to find that this was not an indoor bakery. It is a window where you order and they give you the pie to eat outside. Knowing this now, would definitely recommend patrons come to visit when it is warm outside...it can be very windy and brisk in Red Hook during the winter. We ordered 1 classic 4 inch key lime pie, and 1 Classic Swingle - a 4 inch key lime pie dipped in Belgian chocolate. To our surprise, the Swingle was absolutely delicious! The chocolate coating was bright and fruity and complimented the key lime pie nicely. The standard key lime pie was good, but the crust was a bit crumbly for our liking and the custard was lacking a punch. That said, it is still a solid key lime pie. Would recommend but wouldn't go so far out of my way to try again. read more

See all

The chocolate covered key lime pie on a stick was sweet and tasty. I found the concept interesting and new. The place is far to reach by metro and out of the way by public transport. read more

Did you know that (supposedly) only two bakeries in the US fresh squeeze limes to make key lime pies? One is located in Key West, FL and the other is located in Red Hook Brooklyn (spoiler: it's Steve's Key Lime Pies!) This bakery has a cute small-town feel and really adds to the whole nautical theme that all of Red Hook seems to have. You walk up to a window and order what you want so you're technically not stepping foot inside. Raspberry Swingle (6/10): A Swingle is a small 5-inch Key Lime Pie that has been dipped in chocolate and served like an ice cream popsicle on a stick. I never seek out key lime pies so take my rating/review with a grain of salt. I thought that the dark chocolate shell really overpowered the flavor of the lime/pie. I also thought the raspberry jam (as delicious and fresh as it was) also overpowered the pie itself. This place gets a 3/5 for taste but a 4/5 for vibes! read more

See all

We wandered over to Steve's pies after having dinner in the area. Steve's has a relatively small menu consisting entirely of key lime pies in various sizes, and small pies dipped in chocolate. It was my first time here so I wanted to start off with the basic key line pie, but I'll be back to try the chocolate dipped versions later. The pie shop is actually just a window you can pick up pie from with a bunch of picnic tables out in front. Since there is no heated area, I would recommend taking these to go in the wintertime. The shop is right on the waterfront, and you can see a distant view of the Statue of Liberty from the seating area. The tarts have slightly crumbly graham cracker crusts which balance out the fresh lime flavor in the filling. The filling is not too sweet and the lime flavor tastes super fresh and well balanced - just enough tartness, just enough sweetness. Looking forward to coming back to try the chocolate dipped version. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Views - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Out there in the far reaches of Red Hook. This is a station of the cross for key lime pie enthusiasts. Not much to it, A Dutch door where you pay and pick up the goods. A few sizes and varieties. Know what you want before you reach the head of the line. Don't waste the man's time. Service is business like. No frills. Suggest walking out on the pier in the nearby park to enjoy your pie. read more

What a treat this little key lime pie shop brings to the neighborhood! As someone who doesn't even like key lime pies, I enjoyed this a lot. We arrived 10 minutes before closing at 7pm on a Sunday and there was a line of about 15 people in front of us. The line went by quickly as you just order, pay, and get your key lime pie right away. I noticed he continued to serve everyone until there weren't anymore customers even if it was past closing time. I want to assume it was the owner himself serving at the window (but maybe it could be an employee); either way, he was super friendly and nice. He happily welcomed each customer with such enthusiasm and kindly helped me when I asked for my $1 off with Yelp checkin. Even though a single mini Key Lime Pie ($6) was enough, I also wanted to try the Raspberry Blonde Swingle ($8). It was such a nice balance of tartness and sweetness that was so smooth. While I enjoyed the swingle, I wish the white chocolate option didn't have the raspberry since that was too sour for me, but I'm not personally a fan of regular chocolate. Needless to say, it was still delicious and I finished both by myself. Make sure you grab some napkins as the treat gets a bit messy. I love how it's conveniently located at an oceanfront park and right off the Ferry, so it's the perfect spot to enjoy your key lime pie. read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - The Raspberry Blonde Swingle. - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

It was less than a 15-minute drive from 7th Street Burger to Pier 44 Waterfront Garden. Luckily, my good friend Jenn found a parking spot. The weather was in the high 70s today. After checking out Pier 44 Waterfront Garden, we decided to try Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies. I informed the cashier about my food allergies. Drinks *Ask for a sample* Limeade (2): refreshingly delicious The Swingle (frozen chocolate-dipped key lime tarts) Jenn: The Raspberry Me: The Raspberry Blonde - Mmm, after my first bite of the raspberry blonde. I am in heaven. One word: Scrumptious Bookmark this spot to try! read more

See all

Food: This is the best key lime pie ever! Everyone I know who has their key lime pie loves it as well. The pie has a buttery graham cracker crust. The key lime filling is smooth and creamy with the perfect balance of tartness and sweetness. They sell three different size pies as well as frozen ones if you're not eating it right away. They sell frozen chocolate covered key lime pies also. If you like key lime pie, this is the place for you! Service: Staff is friendly and packs the pies nicely for transporting. Ambiance: The place is small with tables and benches outdoors if you want to eat there. Most people purpose the pies to go. Overall, I highly recommend this place. It's worth the trip to Red Hook just for this pie! read more

See all

Steve's key lime pie is absolutely incredible! I tried the classic chocolate-covered swingle, and it was insanely good--rich, flavorful, and unforgettable. It's a small joint with picnic tables outside when the weather is nice, making it perfect for a quick stop. More of a grab-and-go kind of place. While you're there, make a day of it by visiting nearby spots like Strong Rope Brewery, Red Hook Cidery, or Red Hook Winery, all just steps away! Definitely stopping here every-time I'm in Red Hook! read more

Saw a video of the spot on TikTok and knew I had to give it a try! We came on a Monday afternoon and we were the only ones there. It was a cute storefront with a lot of outdoor seating. I got the raspberry swingle, which was kind of like a key lime popsicle with raspberry filling and chocolate. It was so good and a perfect treat for a hot day! I'd highly recommend checking this spot out if you're in Red Hook! read more

See all

Line goes by fast! 10 min wait in a holiday Monday. Nice sweet treat by the water. Recommend checking out! read more

Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

If I had to describe this, I would say heaven on a stick. Omg!! I ran 5 miles this morning and was so glad I did after eating this sinful treat. You must try one. This is quite honestly one of my most favorite desserts. read more

I love the concept of this spot so much. I got the strawberry swingle and it was a delight. I only wish it was all a bit more tart and less sweet. Would love it they had a dark chocolate version! read more

Because I was staying smack dab in the middle of the city, this was a bit of a hike, but let me tell you, it was WORTH IT!! Do you hear me? There was absolutely no line/wait on that Sunday afternoon, so I let out a sigh of relief exiting my almost $50 Uber . I ordered the white chocolate, raspberry key lime pie, and Lord have mercy, I needed to fly back to Dallas to slap my mama extra hard! I was caught by surprise because these delicious treats are frozen, so I recommend not immediately getting down to business if you want to keep all of your teeth....let it thaw for about 5ish minutes. The white chocolate and raspberry complimented the pie very well. Wasn't overly tart or too sweet. Perfect in every way! This is another "MUST" every time I visit! Steve did his thang, here! read more