Attended the most joyous Baby Shower at Sparkill Steakhouse! In the upper dining room with high ceilings and ceilings windows! Elevator available! The service was exceptional! The food was so flavorful and prepared! Even the broccoli was amazing!!! Open bar- loved my Mimosa and Expresso Martini with Bailey's! Dinning spacious! For Baby Shower activities! Parking on site!! Highly recommend!!! read more

See all

This was by far the worst piece of filet mignon I ever had...and I've had plenty. I ordered the center cut filet mignon, which was the pricier cut. I ordered medium and specified pink in the center, NO red. The waiter asked if I'd like it sliced and I ordered a sauce on the side. The FM was served rare , unsliced and no sauce. I sent it back. It came back out, well done and crispy in some slices and still raw in others. Absolutely no taste. I couldn't eat more than a few bites, which I only ate because I was starving. The waiter stopped by after he served it the second time to see how everything was...I told him it was terrible, something I have never done but this was BAD. He offered to bring it back, no thank you...3 strikes your out. Dinner was ruined. It was a Friday night, 8:15 PM reservations, the restaurant was fairly empty. I now know why. My friends salad was good and I felt obligated to tip 20% so he wouldn't be uncomfortable...but I have to say, it killed me to give the 20% for a horrible meal and horrible service. I will NEVER go back there EVER!!!! read more

The food, service and ambiance can't be beat! Always a great experience no matter if you order steak or another meal. Carlo and Sal really know how to treat you right. read more

So much steak, so little room in my belly. This place has been around a while but the standards remain the same. Quality steaks, awesome sides, great wines. read more

Great place for a porterhouse which was perfectly cooked. Owner greets you at the door and is very friendly. The main dining area is very cozy and low lit - loved the ambiance of this place. Was a great dinner and overall experience would recommend. Yea it is a bit pricey, but its one of the only steakhouses in the area in a gorgeous building and area by piermont so supply and demand! Would go back and eat!!! read more

Sparkill Steakhouse - Dry - Aged Prime Porterhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Sparkill, New York

Although the food was good, the service was less to be desired. We were there early (6:30 on a Friday) and our waiter seemed annoyed. I asked for Gluten free (which is a no brainer at at steak house) and ended up having a major reaction the rest of the night. Upon calling the restaurant, (I did not want anything other then to teach the chef about GF) I was treated rudely. We have been to steakhouses all over the world and were surprised at the lack of decorum for a steakhouse at that price point, especially given that it wasn't at peak hours. I am sad to say we won't be returning. read more

Food was perfect steak cooked with perfectly,everyone went above and beyond to make sure Our visit was completely enjoyable .Most steak houses that are good are all about the same as quality of food and preparation that goes into it.Which separates Sparkill Steakhouse is the Ambiance and the staff.You cannot go wrong if you are in the area.This is a excellent choice read more

Sparkill Steakhouse - Martial - Steakhouses Near Me - Sparkill, New York

Went for New Year's Eve dinner with a 9pm reservation. When we saw the menu, we were surprised to see a stupidly overpriced price fixed menu with minimal choices. I wish I knew this before hand as I would have gone somewhere else. $150 per person for a choice porterhouse for two, two shrimp cocktails with 3 shrimp, 2 sides, and 2 desserts. The steak wasn't even prime! Other choices were a surf and turf, salmon, and something else that wasn't even memorable. I've been there before and got the porterhouse for 2 for $150, but that was prime dry aged and extremely good. So we basically got charged double for an inferior steak. Extremely disappointing. They even felt the need to include a 20% tip at a table for 2. The total was $420 including tax and tip. We sat at 9pm, our appetizers came out at 9:30, and our steak and sides didn't arrive until 10:20. An extremely long wait for an understandably busy day. I really feel bad for someone that ordered salmon for $150. I don't mind paying for exceptional food and service, but this was clearly an establishment taking advantage of its patrons. Shame. read more

I was just here very recently with my husband . I needed to leave a review. The food here was fabulous! The service and everything ! I really want to say thank you to the staff for the excellent dining experience. The food, servers and ambiance all get 5 stars!!! Thank you thank you!!! Main courses we ordered the porterhouse steak for 2 it was cooked perfectly, and the twin lobster tails . I am going to leave a couple comments which could make it even better . I'm not complaining!. Just suggestions..., 1. Coat check. I don't know if you don't have one and it was taken away due to a past negative experience ?? 2. When dinner comes to the table the server should be present so the food doesn't get "auctioned off"and it is placed at the appropriate person. I will definitely recommend this restaurant to friends and family! read more

Sparkill Steakhouse - Lobster tails - Steakhouses Near Me - Sparkill, New York

See all

The steaks were very good but I ordered an Old Fashioned and it was muddy colored and filled with little ice cubes. Very disappointing for a steak house not to be able to make a decent cocktail. read more

Extremely underwhelming and very expensive, definitely wouldn't go back there is much better steakhouses in NJ that taste better and are cheaper, I got 2 steaks that had no flavor and was still cold in the middle, the service wasn't good and they weren't even busy. The inside is very nice and cozy and is very well designed. read more

Sparkill Steakhouse - Fe Filet Mignon Macaroni & Cheese - Steakhouses Near Me - Sparkill, New York

My wife and I are not regular visitors, but we come every second or third year. As always, the food is perfectly cooked, and the meat has a fabulous taste. Each time, we choose something different, including the side dishes. The wine selection is superb. The ambiance is exceptional, and the service from the staff and managers is outstanding. Overall, I give a 5-star rating for the restaurant's food and service. Thank you! read more

Happy Valentine's. Day. This is for anyone searching Yelp for a review of Sparkill Steakhouse for Valentine's Day Dinner. I'll try and keep this short and sweet. A year ago on Valentine's Day, we decided to finally try this place. And I know what you're thinking it's Valentine's Day. It's a fancy restaurant. Yes there's most likely a prefix dinner menu. Yes there was and we were completely prepared for it. What we weren't prepared for was the fine print of the pre-fixed 20% tip. Let me tell you, I've seen many things in my life, but I've never been handed a bill with the tip and total already written by the staff for their 20% tip. Probably the most appalling thing I've ever seen in the restaurant business. The fine print should've said "On Valentine's Day all our class goes out the window" As for the food it was nothing special and they stood over us and watched us like hawks the entire meal which was very uncomfortable. read more

Sparkill Steakhouse - a receipt and a receipt - Steakhouses Near Me - Sparkill, New York

The food was what I expected; quite good, but with prices that were straight Manhattan. Ergo, the 4 stars. Dinner for 2 at a New Jersey steakhouse shouldn't be $225. Consider my curiosity satisfied. read more

My husband and I dined this evening for the first time at Sparkill Steakhouse. It was nothing short of perfection. I would easily compare this restaurant to any of the top steak specialty restaurants and prefer this one. Each item ordered was excellent from the Long Island oysters, porterhouse for two, selected sides and dessert. The wait staff was courteous, attentive, and elegant. Thank you for a lovely evening and great experience. read more

Sparkill Steakhouse - Porterhouse for two, creamed spinach, hand cut French fries - Steakhouses Near Me - Sparkill, New York

Extremely disappointing We got our apps and cocktails all good , then ordered the steak for 4 , We asked for medium rare, Came our under cooked charred black and tough like it was in a grill fire, absolutely terrible for the price it should be perfect, service was good, This place is way over priced for the quality you get will not be going again for sure awful , River palm for me from now on at least it on the money, read more

The most delicious romantic place in Rockland I have eaten at all restaurants from NYC to the Canadian boarder This place is consistently good Delicious steaks Fresh sides Real bartenders The most romantic atmosphere Old school service Love this place for a drink at the bar or an amazing dinner read more

fancy and pricey steakhouse with great ambiance. I've been wanting to try this place for awhile and was finally able to go. got last minute reservations with no trouble on a Friday night. the place is huge and was decked out for Christmas. the dining areas are gorgeous and theres even a fireplace in one of the rooms. we started with the lobster bisque which was pretty good but super heavy and a large portion. i wish i didnt finish the whole thing because i was really full by the time my dinner arrived. steaks were tasty and cooked well. FYI none of their dishes come with sides. you need to order them separately and they only come family style which is kind of annoying. we got the creamed spinach and the macaroni and cheese. huge portions but really tasty and made for excellent leftovers. would definitely visit again. read more

Sparkill Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Sparkill, New York

Best bone-in Ribeye I ever had!! And I've had a lot. The service was wonderful with nice pacing between courses. There's nothing not to love about this steakhouse. No more, or less, expensive than any other steakhouse so go for a great steak!! read more

From the service, to the food, to the atmosphere, everything was spot on. I couldn't have wished for a better place for me and my family to spend Mother's day. We started with three appetizers, with three of us getting cocktails, and each with an individual entree. Everything to land on the table was spectacular, steaks with a perfect sear and each cooked to perfection based on our requests. Shoutout to our server Denis, who was incredibly friendly, and was spot on with every request of ours. Not a single complaint, if you're thinking about dining here, don't think twice and reserve a table. read more

Waste your money right! By Nina Paolercio The first feeling of walking in. A couple of days ago, I visited Sparkill Steakhouse in Sparkhill. From the moment you walk in, the ambiance strikes a balance between modern style and relaxed comfort, with dim lighting and rustic décor creating a welcoming atmosphere. And my mom was greeted by a lovely doorman dressed in a suit and tie. We proposed walking into the slightly lit hallway and up the stairs. We were seated in a booth in the corner of the room right after that. We were approached by a waiter. A first impression. Later. After, a different waiter brought menus. When the first waiter left, I noticed glass shards scattered on the table. Although no one was hurt, the presence of glass was confusing and concerning. A third waiter was called to address the issue, and while the situation was handled, it left me and my mom feeling uneasy. The clock is running.. Although I said it was getting better, we aren't done yet. My mom and I hadn't even ordered, and it was 6:30. We got there at 6:00. We still had the menu, and we were wondering what to order. After careful consideration, my mom and I decided what we wanted to order. I requested the burger with a large side of fries, and I made sure that the burger was done medium well, too. My mom got the shrimp salad and bread. After a while, a different waiter finally came to collect our orders and the menus that were left with us for quite a while (45 minutes ) The lights are out.. After we placed our order with the waiter, we began chatting, trying to enjoy the atmosphere and pass the time. But not long after, something odd happened: the lights in the restaurant began to dim. At first, we thought it might just be part of the ambiance, maybe a subtle shift in lighting to create a cozy evening mood. But within seconds, the lights didn't just dim, they went out completely. For what felt like an eternity, but was probably around 30 to 45 seconds, we sat there in absolute pitch darkness. Eventually, the lights flickered back on, not all at once but in a sort of shimmer and spark that only added to the confusion. I glanced around the room, trying to make sense of the situation. My mom and I weren't thrilled about being left in the dark, but we tried not to make a big deal of it. We brushed it off as a glitch or temporary issue and patiently waited for our food. However, that patience was starting to end. Time dragged on. The first 45 minutes passed, then an hour. Still no food. Not even a check-in from the waiter. What made it more frustrating was the fact that we weren't in a packed restaurant. So it didn't make sense why everything was taking so long? There was no excuse for such a delay, especially when the place was nearly empty. We exchanged glances with the other couple, who seemed just as puzzled and annoyed as we were. At that point, the whole experience felt strange and uncalled for. The food.. The menu at Sparkill Steakhouse featured steaks, wines, salads, and soups, with no vegan options but offerings for gluten-free and diet-specific needs. After about 30 minutes, my mom and I ordered appetizers, calamari with lemon, and cheese mushroom soup. The calamari arrived 10 minutes before the soup, which was unusual, but both dishes were well-received. I rated the calamari 10/10, and my mom gave the soup a 9/10, showing the restaurant was starting to make a good impression despite earlier issues. Despite a long wait to order and get the food, over an hour and the portions were massive, especially the burger, which I rated 9.7/10 for its size and taste. My mom's meal was smaller and rated 8.5/10. Dessert, a tiramisu, arrived quickly and was a standout, earning an 11/10 rating. Though there were delays in service, including a 35-minute wait to get the credit card back, the overall experience was very positive thanks to the excellent food. Final overall rating: 9.0/10. Despite the many Cons during this experience, I still believe that this is a gracious rating, understanding the experiences my mother and I went through just to order a burger and tiramisu. This experience is one I will remember for the rest of my life. While talking about things, you should remember here: remember to waste your money right! Location.. Sparkill Steakhouse. 500 Route 340. Sparkill, NY 10976. The phone number to contact this restaurant is (845) 398-3300. It closes at 10 PM, and delivery hours are from 4 PM to 8 PM. The entrance is through the main door. Closing Thank you so much for reading my review. I hope you liked it! read more

I've been here about 4 times. Every time I leave I say I'm not coming back. But I go back. This place is lackluster There's a ton of waitstaff but nobody is really paying attention to the tables. Tonight we were the only ones on the restaurant at 5:15 and there still was confusion as to who's appetizer belonged to who. The drinks were delicious, the shrimp disgusting, steak was delicious and the service boring. We got pasta bolognese which was good. Ok bottom line. Nothing special about this place. I don't care for the outdated decor. This time I'm not going back! read more

Sparkill Steakhouse - Fresh oil with a side of smelly shrimp - Steakhouses Near Me - Sparkill, New York

Nice classy decor. It has friendly and professional wait staff. Prices are $30-60 per main meal ( than you need to order sides if you order steak). We (table of 4) shared an order of mash potatoes, Mac n cheese and cream spinach. Size was ok but All were ok - not best we ever had but not bad. Steak came under cooked to my liking but ate it anyway. Lobster bisque soup was good (very creamy though) . My friend ordered the French onion soup - which she liked it read more

Sparkill Steakhouse - Prosciutto with Buffalo Mozzarella and Tomato - Steakhouses Near Me - Sparkill, New York

Came here last night with my buddy and we loved it. Very classy high end place. All male wait staff gives u the old school steak house feeling. Started with dozen of blue point oysters my buddy said the were very fresh and juicy. Had to get baked clams with were nice and crispy on top but clams were overdone. I had a lobster bisque soup which was ok mostly cream no lobster pieces at all Inside soup. Wife had onion soup which she loved. Nice soft onions creamy cheese broth was tasty . Caesar salad nice and crisp cold and good dressing. Buddy ordered rib eye which came out with a dark crust outside but when he cut into it wow so pink and temp was spot on. Really large pice of . I had surf and turf. I have to admit it was one of the best cooked lobster tail I've had in a long time . Juicy and soft not dry at all . My 8 oz filet mignon was nice and seared outside and pink and juicy inside def enough steak . The girls ordered Rigatoni Bolognese with chunks of filet mignon. Sauce was really good. Taste the wine and tomatoes. They didn't finish was a good portion .now I have lunch today !!! Table ordered chocolate mousse wow huge piece of soft clouds of Chocolate Tiramisu was big piece and soft amd fluffy All In all this is a go to spot will def be back again. Break the piggy bank it's not cheap but you def get with you pay for. Plenty of parking outside. Wait staff too notch. read more

See all

Mediocre food for the price. Porterhouse steak was bland and flavorless. Steak sauce tasted more Iike cocktail sauce. Won't be returning.

First time dining out at Sparkill Steakhouse there's a lot to be impressed about. First the owner Carlo greeted us and treated us like VIP customers. Secondly the atmosphere was a traditional-steakhouse feel, good vibes and solid crowd. The Porterhouse for 3 was cooked to perfection medium rare and the aged and charcoal crust mouth watering. So go ahead and make a reservation and tell Carlo that Lou Galdo sent you. Ciao! read more

First. I've been a chef for 25 years, and have opened restaurants in NYC, Miami, Hong Kong, Singapore, and more. I have eaten at Sparkill several times, and worked my way through about 80% of their menu. Everything, every time has been on point. Yes. One can nitpick at this, or that. However, the overall experience and general quality of the food surpasses most of the storied steakhouses in the City. Or, any city for that matter. The porterhouse has always been cooked exactly to the requested temp, and with the perfect amount of dry age funk and high temp char. Crab cakes -jumbo lump, always with more crab than breading. Sides are all excellent examples of steakhouse classics. And, the cocktails are always poured with generosity. I might even say more so than I would pour for myself. And to top it all off the service is just what one would want -understated elegance. Friendly, mindful, and always eager to make the Sparkill experience special. Even on a week night when you just feel like treating yourself. read more

Lovely atmosphere, friendly service. The steak is perfect for the medium rare. Spinach were perfect book to match the steak. Perfect place when craving for a good steak read more

Sparkill Steakhouse - Old fashion - Steakhouses Near Me - Sparkill, New York

Came here to celebrate our anniversary. Granted we did not make a reservation as it was a weeknight (Tuesday). There were only 1-2 other tables of customers there that night. The ambiance was nice, fireplace going, cozy, soft tunes playing.. It was romantic. We did mention to the waiters... Twice in fact, that we were there for a special occasion-- to celebrate our anniversary. We ordered the crab cake for appetizer- which was pretty decent and reasonably priced. The pomegranate martini was ok. My date enjoyed his salad. For entree, I had the Colorado rack of lamb chops--4 lamb chops on top of a bed of sautéed spinach. They were delicious. Truly enjoyed this dish. My fiancé had the surf and turf. He asked for medium well. Steak was charred on the outside but clearly, had a lot more red on the inside. We had to send it back and have it cooked a little more. The lobster tail was a decent size -- looks more than 8oz and it was delicious with lemon and melted butter. Mashed potatoes side order were plain and average, not worth the extra $12--I would skip it. For dessert, we had the tartufo. It was a nice way to end the meal. Our only gripe for the night was that we didn't feel the waiters acknowledged the special occasion we were celebrating that night. There were only 2 other tables that dined in the restaurant, which meant they were certainly not busy. When celebrating a special occasion, every little bit counts. A gesture (happy anniversary written on our dessert plate), or a simple congratulations would've been nice. Instead, it was just a plain dinner experience, on a regular Tuesday night.. nothing special to rave about considering we were spending over $200+ for a 2 person dinner. Lesson learned-make a reservation ahead of time and indicate the special event you're celebrating as the waiters may not get the hint. Overall, the place is decent. If we had to do it over, would we come here again to celebrate a special night? Most likely not. On a regular night? Maybe... IF I'm craving lamb chops because they were delicious. The lamb-chops and the lobster tail were the highlight of my night. Food-3.5 Service-3 Ambiance for a date night-4 I give the restaurant 3 and a half stars overall rating. read more

See all

Since Restaurant X closed, this is now the preeminent high end restaurant in Rockland County, NY. The steaks are absolutely fantastic. They're on par with any other steak house in the New York City area, including Peter Luger and Sparks. The service is very personable. I felt totally welcomed from the moment I walked in the door. It's expensive as heck, but it was my birthday present from my daughter. I had a bourbon Manhattan and a ribeye steak--both were delicious. I wish I had kept the portion I couldn't finish, but I let my daughter bring it home to her husband. I know he enjoyed it. This place is one of HIS favorite restaurants. read more

Updating review to reflect that I have now received a call from the restaurant apologizing and offering to make this right next time I go. This would have been a 5 star review however given what I experienced and the lack of response afterwards, it is now 3. Went here Friday night for dinner to celebrate my boyfriend's birthday. Made a reservation through Open Table. We were seated promptly when we arrived. Service was great and very attentive. The drinks were good as was the food. We did an app and a salad to start and then did surf & turf and the T-bone for entrees. Given I had been so full from the app and salad, I didn't even eat half of my meal. Maybe a fifth of my steak and a quarter to half of my lobster tail. When the waiter came around to check I asked that everything be wrapped. We couldn't check the packages because they were not clear and assumed everything was in there. Saturday I went to have my leftovers for lunch and all that was in my container was the steak. They'd thrown out the lobster and my potatoes. As you might imagine I was pissed. This dinner was over $300 with the tip. What gives the waiter the right to pick and choose what gets wrapped up a very pricey meal that I paid for?! I sent them a message via Facebook complaining the next day. It was read but nobody ever responded. Very disappointed that after spending this kind of money, that's how they handle a complaint. No apology, no nothing. read more

Sparkill Steakhouse - Surf & Turf, T-bone steak, mashed potatoes and steamed broccoli - Steakhouses Near Me - Sparkill, New York

My favorite steakhouse! The best steak I have ever had, better than Peter Luger's, Sparks etc. The owner and service couldn't be better, you are treated like family. read more

you've heard the saying " You Pay for what you get"? Well , you WILL pay And you' WILL get one of the best Steaks around ! Porterhouse for two was delicious and perfectly cooked. Restaurant decor is nice , service was very good. I'm from Jersey ( Bergen county) and it's not that long of a drive to get here. I definitely recommend you make the visit and enjoy a great dining experience. read more

This is my special occasion place with my love. We've been here numerous times. The dining room is lovely and modern. Every time we have gone, the service is spectacular. You can not go wrong with their food, from their thick cut bacon, wedge salad, lobster bisque, oysters, and of course the porterhouse for 2. Sparkhill also makes their own steak sauce that goes great on everything. I usually wouldn't put a sauce on a quality grade meat, but they compliment each other. They also have "slog" which is their own version of whipped cream. It's so delicate after a meal. It pairs nicely with their chocolate mouse. Only downfall of this restaurant: I wish they had scallops. I love pairing scallops with a steak for an unconventional surf and turf. Otherwise, everything is always so great here. read more

Nice atmosphere - decent food, but overpriced in my opinion. Steaks should be perfect for that price ...

Extremely expensive which most steak houses are. However ordered a shrimp dish with 5 shrimp on a plate - $42.00 Totally ridiculous - glad we ordered french fries - not going back read more

Restaurant is nice. Food was very mediocre. Ordered Porterhouse for 3 - $209.00. We each didn't want to ruin the good mood so we said nothing to each other and kept eating it. At the end of dinner one of us said that he really did not enjoy the steak and had much better ones in similar places in this area. It had no flavor, and a little too tough to chew. We all immediately confessed that we completely agreed and felt foolish for not sending it back. A ruined evening. read more

Well we were very hopeful because so many friends have been raving about this restaurant recently, but yet again we were very disappointed. We came here years ago when the restaurant was newly opened and we were underwhelmed, the food was okay but the service not so much but we chalked it up to "grand opening blues." However, our experience remains the same, NYC prices but the food remains mediocre at best. The lobster bisque was all cream not one piece of lobster meat to be found. The ribeye was extremely fatty with lots of gristle, Park Steakhouse's ribeye is far superior to the one we ordered here, same price point though! The service was lacking considering pricing for example, no fresh black pepper for salad, the waiter checked on us once right after getting our meals and that was it! Not sure why everyone is raving and giving this place 5 stars? read more

We came on Friday afternoon around 4. Of course we were the only patrons at the time. The bread was amazing. However, they don't refill your bread basket. The salad is excellent. I had the salmon which was dry. I tried to ask what the sauce was, but we didn't see the waiter or anyone for that matter until we had finished. They were too busy conversing in Russian in the kitchen. The chicken parmigiana was ordered by my dining companions. They said it was ok...nothing to write home about. I had the tiramisu which was very good. They had the hot fudge sundaes which they also said were very good. I will come back for the salad. I read more

Unfortunately, this gorgeous place was totally empy, We were the only couple for lunch. It is such a cozy a welcoming place, I fell bad for the owner. But he said, they are busy at nights. I wish them luck. Our steaks were delicious and cooked to perfection. The waiter was very attentive and professional. We will definitely be coming back. read more