We were pretty disappointed with both pizzas and wings - we got the Ezzo Pep and North Shore. Both pies were oblong, with toppings disproportionately applied, blackened at the edges and borderline under cooked at the center. The Ezzo pep had one slice with a skyscraper stack of at least 8 peps piled up that didn't cook while the other pieces had hardly any peps on them. The North Shore had several pieces that didn't have jalapeño or pineapple and the bacon appeared to be dumped in the middle so you got just a bit on the end of each slice. The wings were excessively dry and the Buffalo garlic sauce was just a buttery franks like hot sauce that was very thin with chunks of coagulated butter in it. Paid for two Hot Honeys ($2 a piece) and had to remind them at pickup or would have drove off without. For more than $60 - I'd recommend just about any other place in Columbus. Very disappointed. Also, online ordering system said our order could not be placed - but it did withdraw money from my account and after calling I was able to confirm it had worked. Glad I didn't double order or order somewhere else only to be double charged. read more

Good pizza, a little pricey. Way to loud to be enjoyable, but the staff was attentive. Wouldn't go again.

Ordered a pizza late on a Tuesday evening and upon arriving, the lights were off & the doors were locked. (It was my fault as I missed the pickup window versus when they closed.) The staff was there cleaning & they opened the door and gave me my order.....it was absolutely delicious!! This was my first time having Sextons and given their service and great tasting pizza, it's a thumbs up for me. read more

The food was pretty good. We got a sausage, onion, and basil pizza. They didn't put on the basil and they were pretty light on the onions for $3.50. The sausage was sliced like pepperoni which was different. I like a crumble personally but the flavor was good. The crust on the NY style crust is really great. Thin, but still crispy. The cheese is great. I folded mine and geese poured out on my plate. The ambiance was average. I like their pizza, but I don't think it will be my go-to spot. read more

Sorry know it was a busy night with the tree lighting but you are a pizza place, to run out of pizza at 7:00 is not acceptable. This was our second try, first time pizza was not good. This would be our last try read more

Best pizza! We first tried sextons last year and cannot get enough of it! The ambiance is fun and lively and the service was great. Me and my husband moved to Columbus in 2021 from the land of pizza (chicago ) and not only is it our favorite kind of pizza but it's my in laws favorite pizza as well. It's a request every time they come to visit. All the the fun toppings and names of pizza make the experience even better! Make sure you get the MIKE! It's unbelievable! read more

One of the best pizza's in Columbus. I get tired of people saying it's burnt. It's not burnt. It's in a super hot brick oven and it's called crispy. Go back to Little Caesar's if you think it's burnt. read more

Pizza's are amazing with so many different ones to order. The wings are good too. It's a fun and friendly place.

The place has a wait staff but no host/hostess so it's a free for all to get a table. There's also no place to wait for a table, so you just kinda hover over people. The appetizers aren't very good - garlic boneless wings meant chicken strips with a packaged cup of garlic butter (like you get at Papa Johns). The pizza was pretty good. I'd go back for the pizza, but hopefully the hype dies down first. read more

Hours are wrong, 3 different websites say 3 different things not sure what to trust, not sure how a business doesn't even have a phone read more

Sexton's Pizza - Hours are wrong on Sunday you should change this. 3 different websites have 3 different times - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

The pizza is quite good, nice crispy crust (yes it may look a tad burnt but it's meant to be that way, it adds flavor/texture), nice selection of specialty pizza. Had garlic tater tots, they were pretty standard bar food tots. Not overpriced by todays standards in my opinion (with the exception of $1.25 for a small side of ranch, ouch). Our server was attentive. The location is nice, but they could definitely benefit from stepping up to actual plates/silverware/glasses. All the plastic is pretty wasteful and downgrades the atmosphere. Even if they didn't want to deal with washing dishes, that's cool, but the napkins and silverware are cheap and make eating a messy experience. They could benefit from investing in something a little higher quality. Will get their food again for sure, but probably won't dine in. read more

Love this place! So happy to have one close to home now! Always enjoyed the OG location and Gahanna location. Love the brick oven pizza and crispy wood fire edges! Great pizza place and love supporting local business owners! read more

We decided to get a pizza from here per suggestion from a friend and was not impressed. we got the NY style 614 and the crust was burnt and had little to no flavor. With the crust being burnt it really stole the show away from the toppings. We may give it a second chance but will not go out of our way for it! read more

Despite my rating, Sexton's is absolutely my most favorite pizza in the city especially their thick crust. Overall, the pizza is amazing! The three stars is because they often run out of dough and I mean OFTEN and it's super annoying and if you ask why they don't have any dough they typically respond in a very rude and disrespectful manner. I went there at 6:30pm (They close at 9) on a Saturday with intentions to get pizza with date. They said they ran out of dough but any of their fried items were still available lol. I asked "really?" about the absent of dough and the lady behind the bar gave me an incredbly snarky and dismissive response. Again, you're a pizza shop. How the hell do you run out of dough? Other than that, the pizza is amazing but they gotta get their dough and employee friendliness together. read more

Love the Pizza (thin crust is our go to) and the atmosphere!! Staff is always really nice. It's definitely one of our favs. Great spot!

I have had a few different styles of the pizza here. They are always fantastic. I absolutely love the NY style. It reminds me of the pizza I used to get where I grew up. I highly recommend trying this place. You won't be upset! read more

This has to be the only place that you can not get pizza ordered or get pizza. I have tried numerous times to order on line and who can't get pizza after 9:00 pm at night. It is a real shame. I am from upstate New York and you can get pizza anytime. Maybe you need to look at your production or the size of the kitchen. You need to be able to handle the volume and customers. Thank you. read more

Place is way over priced, way overrated and very average pizza. I live in Hilliard and I can, blind folded, throw a dart at 10-15 better pizza options. Look else where. Have had very terrible experience with their service and wait time. Oh, and if you do get this average pizza, plan on cutting it yourself. I will be supporting other local Hilliard pizza spots, I suggest you do the same. read more

Under staffed. We tried it once over the summer and enjoyed the atmosphere and the food but they had only one server. They were great about it and gave us a gift card to make up for the wait. Very nice. However, we went back on a Saturday and were not greeted. We waited about 10 minutes and saw someone else at the bar, also looking for a server. He approached a young lady and asked if anyone was working there today and she said yes, she was, and when he said he'd been waiting for 15 minutes, she asked if he was going to leave!! We left, disappointed because the pizza really was good, but I'll be hesitant to go back if no one is working there! read more

Good pizza difficult to order and get. Wish they had a bit more selection but it is high quality pizza.

Pre-ordered 5 Pizzas for a Birthday. As I was heading to pick up, I received the txt that my order was in the oven. Arrived to find my order on the shelf for pick- up and the steam was coming from every box. Great pizza, went over great with our guests, lots of compliments. Thanks for the great service and great pizza! read more

I've never done dine-in at this location but have gotten carry-out several times. Hands down the best pizza in Hilliard. Highly recommend.

Pizza was excellent, but way over-priced. Can't get a 2 item for less than ?23.and $1.25 for a very very small side of ranch dressing..2 pizzas,large fries,and 2 cokes.$67 before tip. read more

Look after living in multiple states where there are 15 solid pizza options to coming back to Columbus Ohio to visit family for a few months. I'll say hands down Sextons has the best pizza in central Columbus. Yes I've tried them all, pizza is my thing and Im a connoisseur. Most of the pizza in Columbus is mediocre at best. Been to Sextons on multiple visits and have tried most of the pies. Have dined in have picked up and have used Uber eats for delivery. Pizza is best fresh there, commons sense. It does travel well for pick up and delivery. Round and square both slap in different ways and some pies are better square than circle. Service has been hit or miss but it's a pizza shop. The service is legit for the type of establishment and there are some really awesome employees. I don't care that Dave Portnoy came here. I've been to many places he's scored high where I wasn't a fan. That said he was on point here and we agree. Best pizza in Hilliard, best pizza in central Columbus. Will be back again. read more

Took a long time and we got it to go and then when we got home it was burnt on bottom and most pepperonis and bacon were also burnt read more

Sexton's Pizza - If you like burnt puzza - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Excellent pizza and very good service! I got a Hakuna Ricotta and I would highly recommend it.

Pizza was good but way overpriced. Nearly $50 for 2 large pepperoni pizzas. And not a single phone number to call just to be able to talk to a person. Are you really that busy that you can't talk to a customer that's paying money for a simple question? read more

When we walked in, there were a couple of people at the bar and no one at any of the tables. The server approached and took our drink orders and said she'd be back for our food orders. We watched another server take other tables' drink orders, then their food orders, and then bring them their food but we still sat and waited for our server to come back and take our order. She was working at the bar and could see our table from there but never looked over, despite us trying repeatedly to make eye contact. Finally, after 35 minutes without her coming back to our table to take our order, we went up to the bar to place it. There was no apology or acknowledgement for the wait. We waited another 35 minutes for our food to arrive. The salad was a bit underwhelming but the pizza was delicious. We ordered the Kevin Bacon and really enjoyed it. But after some of the worst service we've experienced, I'd be hesitant to try it again. read more

Pizza is really great, I have no complaints when it comes to that.. however, the cheese sticks "appetizer" really left me feeling disappointed. First off, if I'm ordering an appetizer for my family then it better be enough food to feed us all, especially for nearly $10. I was charged $8 for 4 tiny cheese sticks, what I consider to be enough to comfortably feed 1-2 people. Technically a side. I know people have different opinions, but I can eat 4 cheese sticks EASY to myself. With that being said, as a customer, I will never purchase this appetizer again. Left feeling very disappointed in description/size, quantity and price. read more

Sexton's Pizza - Cheese sticks appetizer - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Our son heard about this place on a podcast. I'm always skeptical about hyped places. But this is the real deal. The pizza is delicious and you can order a variety of crusts and styles - Detroit, New York, Nashville, ect. You can travel the country thru your pizza. They have a nice beer selection as well. read more

While their pizza is very delicious their take-out is greatly lacking. During a previous take-out order they did not text me that my pizza was ready (like they said they would), so I waited a short while after the expected finished timeline which led to my pizza being cold. Then when I attempted to complete another online carry out order their online ordering was down even though it was 5:00pm on a week day. This is now the third time I have attempted to order pizza online but have been unsuccessful yet again because they "aren't accepting orders". Then when I try to call their phone number to gather more information, I get a "your call cannot be completed as dialed" letting me know they have put an inactive number on their website. Again, while their pizza was delicious when I ate in the restaurant, I have been extremely underwhelmed with their carry-out and "online ordering" system. read more

Ordered delivery. Not much cheese and not much sauce. The crust...great fresh dough and great taste. The pizza had a Smokey taste overall. read more

Sexton's Pizza - Sextons pepperoni mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Yum! A bit pricey but if you want to splurge a little, this is one to try! The hand tossed crust is perfectly done and pepperoni just tinged. Sauce is great too. read more

I feel like it's impossible to try to order pizza from here. On a Saturday evening at 4:00 it was quoting a three hour wait. Then Sunday at 4 I try to order and it says it's not taking online orders till the next day. I like the pizza but for the price they are charging it shouldn't be so difficult to get some. Super disappointed in how they are handling business. read more

I'll start by saying the pizza and wings are great! However, we came in shortly after 8pm (closed at 9) with my family after raving to them about how great the food was and were irritably greeted by a bartender asking what we wanted to do.. we sat at the bar for hopefully a little more grace period but Candy was rushing us the entire time. Upon leaving and being friendly the entire time (on top of leaving a hefty tip), she commented "come back another time or don't, that's fine"... understandably so, it left a bad taste in our mouths and now my family refuses to go back. There are other bartenders/waiters(resses) there that we adore. She just isn't one of them. read more

Wanted to order two whole pizzas with each a different half specialty pizza like I've seen all over social media. I was told they can't do half/half specialty pizza's but they can do "build your own" to make them that way. Perfect. I told the man the specialty pizza's we wanted and he input the individual ingredients for me. Got home to so many missing/wrong ingredients that they aren't even close to the specialty pizza's that we wanted to try. No hot honey, red base instead of the garlic base, no queso, no ranch dressing. We will not be coming back here again. read more

We went to Sexton's on a Wednesday since our daughter and husband were raving about the pizza and service. Immediately, we were put on the spot to order because we arrived a half an hour before they closed. We obliged and ordered immediately. When we got our pizza, it was burnt and the bartender was extremely rude the whole time she waited on us. She even asked us to pay immediately and literally took the food away from my husband that he was eating. My husband is very vigilant about leaving at least a 20% tip, which was $40 for the hour that we were in the restaurant. As we were walking out, the bartender yelled "come see us again, or not!" When restaurants receive a good review from Dave Portnoy, that is not a free pass for bad and rude service! Don't waste your time. This place is overrated and we won't go back. read more

My family and I have made two trips to Sexton's and been really happy each time. the service is fast and friendly. The atmosphere is casual and fun. The pizza is the star of the show. The sauce is good, a little chunkier, and very flavorful, but not at all overly sweet or salty. Just a great overall sauce. The crust is the best in Columbus. Definitely get the Detroit style. It's thick, chewy, and has the signature cheese to the edge and crunchy bottom of real Detroit style pizza. Best pizza I've tried in the greater Columbus area. read more

Like I am sure most people, we saw the barstool sports review and were so excited to try Sextons Pizza in Hilliard. Their website talks about how its a good idea to order early since they have been so busy because of the review, so we did. We placed an order at 11:15am, to pickup dinner at 7:30pm. My husband got there this evening to pick up 2 pizzas, and was told they were not ready. While annoying, not the end of the world. My husband (a black male) inquired with the male bartender about the order, and was told to wait at the end of the bar. The female bartender (Kaitlin), who my husband was not even speaking to, was rude and condescending to my husband. No explanation was offered as to why our order was not ready, but when a Caucasian older gentleman walked in and inquired about his order that was also not ready, customer service, an explanation, and general human decency was presented. After reading other reviews from non-Caucasian customers who had similar experiences, I am saddened that this is the experience ANYONE would have. My husband did eventually ask for our money back, and our check was voided. Maybe service is better if you dine in, or maybe their pizza is THAT GOOD that human decency is optional...we will not go back there. My husband and I have both worked in restaurants historically, so we understand dinner rush, business, and general operations. There was no excuse for the immature "REALLY? WOOOOOWWWW" and other snide comments that Kaitlin made. read more

Enjoyable place, friendly service with a nice patio. Convenient location to bike trail.