Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sexton's Pizza

    3.6 (129 reviews)
    ModeratePizza
    Closed 11:30 am - 10:00 pm

    Order Sexton's Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Sexton's Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    SEXTON'S PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Casual
    Good for groups
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sexton's Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Kevin Bacon oink!!
    Juan D.

    Ok. Back again and tried the Kevin Bacon with a side of Hot Honey, Hot Honey wings and a CBC IPA. I'm gonna keep this short. Give me an IV filled with Mike's Hot Honey, plug me in and let me walk towards the light. I'm hooked and can't get enough or say enough about this simple but amazing concoction. I got the wings crispy and baptized them in Mike's. Quick ranch dressing dunk and there were no words. I just sat there grunting and smilin. This is what I wanted today. AND they were playing old school R&B... Kevin Bacon was equally impressive. This has quickly become my favorite pizza spot. I have to exercise a little control living within walking distance to this place or I'll be 400lbs and single. 5 stars. There ya go!!!

    East Village
    Saphace A.

    I see why some people say this is one of the best pizza places in town! I ordered the East Village (pepperoni with basil), 16" NY style pie. They are known for selling out so I ordered in the morning for an afternoon pickup. Easy to find behind the cultural and arts center. A lot of parking spots in their lot. Not busy when I walked in since it wasn't even 4pm yet. Nice staff who greeted me. I got a text when my pizza was going in the oven too. Very helpful to know. It tasted delicious! The basil and the mozzarella tasted fresh. You could tell they used quality ingredients. Price was reasonable for what it was. I'm sure I'll be back!

    Extra Sausage, Extra mushroom, onion! Super good!
    David G.

    Really good pizza in a super competitive pizza city! I like that they have gotten way more consistent with their pizzas! It shows me that quality over quantity is the secret!

    Elizabeth Y.

    First time here and found it through barstool pizza reviews. The pizza was really tasty, the best part was the crisp and fresh crust of the pizza! We got the garlic knots as well. They were good but the marinara was ice cold. The server also said it came with a cheese dipping sauce so was disappointed in just getting marinara. Would def come back for another pizza!

    Dairy Air
    Talor B.

    Have given sextons a few tries and honestly I do not get the hype. It's not horrible pizza but for the price and extreme wait times I don't find it worth the hassle. It tastes burnt to me and I don't find the ingredients super fresh or appealing. They have an interesting menu but a lot of the pizzas are kind of similar. It sucks because they are super close to me but I just can't get with it. With so many pizza options in the city I just can't recommend.

    Pepperoni and Cheese NY 16"
    Jodi S.

    Inside was very nice and clean. Bartender made me want to stay and have a few cocktails! Pizza was awesome!

    Extra cheese, Pepperoni and Basil Pie. Very tasty!
    Lex J.

    First timers ordering the Extra cheese, pepperoni, basil. Delicious combo, worth trying again!

    Pepperoni and half banana pepper
    Katie O.

    Good news is the topping still aren't evenly distributed. It's very disappointing. Service was great

    Inside
    Joseph S.

    I haven't heard of this place until my buddy told me about it, so we did a double date and checked it out. They got the pizza with fried pickles, and we got the garlic tatertots with the same 16" pizza. The pizza was amazing, and the service was great. I'll for sure be back to check out a different pizza topping.

    Aubrie H.

    Finally got a chance to try this pizza and it is tasty. The menu had lots of specialty pizza options but also gave you the ability to make your own pizza but choosing your crust and your toppings. We went with a New York Style with cheese and banana peppers and enjoyed every bit. Nicely cooked and the sauce had great flavor.

    Cheese sticks

    See all

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Good pizza, a little pricey. Way to loud to be enjoyable, but the staff was attentive. Wouldn't go again.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Dan G.
    18
    3
    1

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Pizza's are amazing with so many different ones to order. The wings are good too. It's a fun and friendly place.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Love the Pizza (thin crust is our go to) and the atmosphere!! Staff is always really nice. It's definitely one of our favs. Great spot!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Matt S.
    0
    26
    15

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Nick P.
    0
    35
    13

    2 years ago

    Good pizza difficult to order and get. Wish they had a bit more selection but it is high quality pizza.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    I've never done dine-in at this location but have gotten carry-out several times. Hands down the best pizza in Hilliard. Highly recommend.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Francis V.
    156
    35
    12

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Excellent pizza and very good service! I got a Hakuna Ricotta and I would highly recommend it.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Sue P.
    0
    52
    4

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Enjoyable place, friendly service with a nice patio. Convenient location to bike trail.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 4

    Ask the Community - Sexton's Pizza

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 14,225 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Halwani Pizza - Large Taco Pizza

    Halwani Pizza

    3.4(7 reviews)
    2.4 mi

    If all you want to know is whether pizza is good, then let me assure you. It is very good pizza. I…read morefirst had it at the Grandview location and it was memorable for both excellent service and unique flavors on an excellent crust. When they opened a location in Hilliard, closer to my home, I couldn't be more excited. Since they've opened the Hilliard store, I've ordered 4-5 times. It probably would be more, but not once have I had a perfect experience. The pizza is still good but the restaurant management is abysmal. Just recently I had a bad enough experience that I may never order again. Saturday night. I order two one topping pizzas. I know the place has been understaffed and running slow, so I wasn't exactly surprised that I waited 1.5 hours for my delivery order, but it still kind of sucked since the Slice app estimated the order available 40 minutes earlier. The unforgivable problem is that when the order arrived it only contained one pizza and the one they delivered was 1/2 burnt and inedible. No self respecting person should have ever served that pizza and definitely shouldn't have shipped out just one pie. I called Slice and they took care of the issue, but ended up refunding only the food cost and none of the service or delivery fees. I understand somewhat that Slice isn't at fault but I ended up paying $13 for a 1/2 burnt pizza and that is unacceptable.

    Taco pizza from Halwani's in Hilliard. Not bad. Good enough that I'd go back to try other…read morepizzas/menu items. Hand tossed crust, mildly spicy. Supposed to come with lettuce on the side, but didn't. This & 2) cans of pop were $30. Service was friendly & helpful. We ordered carry out & they explained the pricing for card vs cash. Patient & helpful. I've been told to try other items, so I think we'll definitely be back for more.

    Photos
    Halwani Pizza - Medium Tandoori Chicken Pizza

    See all

    Medium Tandoori Chicken Pizza

    Grandad's Pizza & Pub - Individual veggie pizza

    Grandad's Pizza & Pub

    3.5(140 reviews)
    2.3 mi
    $$

    Wonderful spot. I never had this place before and it looked tasty from a TikTok I saw, so my wife…read moreand I headed there. We enjoyed the pepperoni pizza, but the works was very delicious I would recommend that. We got it without mushrooms. Great visit and great vibe.

    Needed to buy plumbing parts at Home Depot in the Mill Run area Saturday so we stopped for lunch at…read moreGrandad's. We were one of the first customers there and chose to sit at the bar. The bartender was quick to give us menus then she didappeared. I know she was the one to bring pizzas from the kitchen out for pickup but I would have liked a little more attention. My husband finally asked her, while she was washing glasses down from us, if their mushrooms were fresh or canned (they are canned which I prefer.) But that question prompted her to ask if we were ready to order? Um yes. Our menus have been closed and our drinks are half gone. We are politely waiting for you. When the pizza arrived it looked fantastic but the crust was chewey and just off. The topping were fantastic we loved the sauce, pepperoni and canned mushrooms. I couldnt put my finger on what was wrong with the crust. It looked golden brown on the bottom but it was just off. My husband ate it and was happy. I was the only one questioning the crust. I think she checked on us once in passing. I know I asked for a refill for my empty glass of water. I set my credit card in front of me, pretty close to me ,- not pushed toward the bar tender. My goal was to signal "check please". She reached over and took the card without saying a word and ran it. Thankfully she gave us the bill with the slip to sign. We were billed correctly. I Signed the slip and we finally left to fix our plumbing issue at home.

    Photos
    Grandad's Pizza & Pub
    Grandad's Pizza & Pub - Piece of pepperoni & mushroom pizza.

    Piece of pepperoni & mushroom pizza.

    Grandad's Pizza & Pub

    See all

    Black Dog Pizzeria - Gluten free pizza with creamy Buffalo sauce and chicken. Delicious but could use extra sauce.

    Black Dog Pizzeria

    4.1(91 reviews)
    3.4 mi

    My kid is in college in Athens. We decided to drive up to try this pizza (and garlic knots!) after…read moreseeing this place on Instagram. It was totally worth the 3-hour round trip. The selection of specialty pizzas with dog pun names was amusing. We got the Three Little Pugs pizza, which had bacon, ham and sausage, along with artful dollops of ricotta cheese to cool down the spice from the hot garlic chili crunch oil. The garlic knots were big, fluffy and super garlicky and better even than the hype. We got some of their Tyrannodog Sauce (A house-made, dragon's breath chili pepper spicy ranch dressing) and dipped the knots into it. It was so good, we left with a bottle of it. It's spicy and garlicky in all the best ways. Staff was friendly and helpful. Be aware, there is ONE TABLE inside and a few outside the shop. It's mostly a to-go spot, but it's totally worth it. Absolutely amazing.

    I had a Pick up order for 4:30pm via their online order form, unfortunately the Pizza was…read moreovercooked which is pretty disheartening when paying $16.95 for a 10 inch Specialty Pizza called "Lady & the Ramp". The Garlic knots were just okay for being awarded one of the best in a competition last year. I ordered a side of their "garlic butter" however its a very artificial butter substitute of some sort which went straight into the Bin. The Stromboli with Pepperoni and Mushroom was the best of the lot. My second visit here, the first time we waited in the tiny dining space for a long time because the staff forgot we were waiting for our order. I won't be sadly disappointed a third time & will take my money elsewhere.

    Photos
    Black Dog Pizzeria
    Black Dog Pizzeria - Sausage Stromboli is off the hook..... as are al zas. Love the cheery staff and owners Jessand Nick.

    Sausage Stromboli is off the hook..... as are al zas. Love the cheery staff and owners Jessand Nick.

    Black Dog Pizzeria - Columbus style veggie

    See all

    Columbus style veggie

    Sexton's Pizza - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...