I ordered a medium-sized, old world pepperoni pizza on Saturday night from Flyers' Hayden Run Rd. outlet. It came very early and well before the 45 minute deadline. So the service was great. I ordered the thin style with extra sauce. Delicious! I had it delivered to my home. So, I provided the ambience, which, of course, by using my own paper plate and napkin, was perfect. The young man who delivered my pizza was kind enough to place the box on my rollator just inside my front door. The occasion was further enhanced by witnessing the Cleveland Guardians win the ALDC. I will order from Flyers again and, no matter what I order, I anticipate a delicious experience. read more

Always love supporting local businesses and this is one of our favorite pizza places. The sauce has good flavor and the pizza is always good quality whether we pick it up or get it delivered. read more

Flyer's Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

Staff is super friendly - seating area seats 50... always great and trying Baked Meatball Sub - delicious read more

See all

pizza arrived on time and was still hot. crust was soft and no crunch or crispness at all. Flavor was kind of bland. Not bad, but for price, not impressed. read more

Coming from the northeast, I worried we wouldn't find a decent pizza place out here but was pleasantly surprised and delighted with the Pepperoni Pizza we got from here...thin crust (love it!!) and tons of pepperoni and cut into little pieces versus big slices (like Ronzio's used to do back in the day) ...it was perfect. We will be back!! read more

Flyers has been our go to place for years, but recently we've been underwhelmed by their consistancy and pricing. Ordered 2 Italian subs for delivery. Delivery was fast enough, but $27 (including delivery fee) for two 9 inch subs that were light on meat? I'll order somewhere else next time. read more

Menu has a lot of options. We ordered pizzas. The crust is thin. The cauliflower crust bbq chicken pizza was delicious. There was plenty of sweet sauce and chicken. The pepperoni pizza was covered with slices that had crisp edges. Dining room is spacious with booths and tables. Order at the counter. When ready the staff brings out the food. There's also a drive thru window and a large shared parking lot. Friendly staff. read more

See all

We're in town for the Arnold and were in the mood for some pizza. Decided to try Flyers and we're glad we did. The staff was very friendly, easy to get to, and best of all, we could see into the kitchen and saw it was hopping. Always a good sign when a place is busy. I asked the woman behind the counter if she recommended the bread sticks with cheese or garlic cheese bread, immediately she said the garlic bread so I got that and a pepperoni pizza. It didn't take long to make, got back to the hotel and started to eat. She was right about the cheese garlic bread, oh man, was that good! And the pizza! It had a flavor I've never tasted before, the sauce was a little sweet and the peppers was cooked just right where it's a little crispy and curling up. There was nothing left between the two of us, we wished we had more. If we're back in town next year for the Arnold again, Flyers will definitely be a place that we visit again! read more

Food average. Sub light on meat. Service was fine. Many in our group of 8 were happy with the pizza and wings

On Sunday June 8th, We had 18 people that confiscated the dining area for graduation celebration, Drew & Joe exceeded all expectations of hospitality & service for us. The food was least notable & we all love Flyers pizza. read more

Can't believe I haven't reviewed this before, b/c this is our favorite pizza place! The pizza, Strombolis, subs(try the nightmare!) all are delicious! It overtook our previous, Columbus based favorite with their quality & service. The employees are fantastic. Extremely friendly & helpful. I've never had a rude experience. I've only done the pickup window, but there's delivery & walk in pickup too. I can't speak about dine in. Absolutely worth trying if you haven't already. read more

Wow, this place continues to get more and more expensive. While the pizza is decent, the thin crust means that I can polish off a medium pie and still be hungry. I just noticed that they also now hide some of their prices online, and the delivery fee is now up to $4.99. As for service, this place has always been good. Professional and courteous, so no complaints there. But the pizza is not filling at all, and costs way too much for what you get. read more

the food is pretty good, but the customer service is not up to satisfaction. most of the staff was rude and barely did their jobs, they just stood around on their phones. there was however, on little pizza saint who caught my attention who said her name was mira i believe. she was there the second time i went and made the experience at least ten times more enjoyable. she was the only one working who seemed to be doing much of anything, and she was cheerful and polite unlike the rest of the staff i encountered. read more

Great pizza and great service. I wish more places answered the phone like they do here. We get their pizza and least twice a month. Love the drive-thru window for pickups. read more

Awesome food I love the pizza and the nightmare sub is delicious and a lot of food. I wish the service delivery area was larger to reach my house. read more

Placed an order in the app. Stated time was 20 minutes. Waited 40 and then went to pick up window. Was told my order was given away. They were going to make up by giving me an extra pizza. Instead, they made me wait 10 more minutes. Informed me that they gave that gave the extra pizza away. Tried to make up with a coupon, for $10, which doesn't even cover the cost of a pizza, while this other customer was given their order as well as the extra pizza. That doesn't include that we also ordered a sub that was made when the pizza was and was room temperature by the time it was given to me. Not sure I'll ever return after this fiasco. read more

Really good subs and pizza is good as well. The pepperonis are really good and the sausage is too, but note the sausage is a little spicy and because of that I did not enjoy the pizza as much as I could have. But spicy lovers of sausage will absolutely love this pizza. I'd recommend Flyers if I were in the area for carry out or delivery (no inside dining) but unfortunately they are far away from Marysville so it's unlikely I'll be dining here often. read more

Flyer's Pizza & Subs - Old world pepperoni w sausage and extra sauce - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

Staff was friendly. Pizza was piping hot and we were surprised with the generous amount of toppings! Will definitely be back when traveling thru again. Don't forget to order the wings. Our kids loved them! read more

Favorite thin crust local pizza. No matter the location, each pizza has been made perfectly. The employees seem to enjoy their time.

This is our favorite pizza spot! The service is quick and they have a pick up window which is nice. Price point is comparable to other places in the area. The old word pepperoni is our go-to but their speciality pizzas are well done. The chicken ranch and buffalo is good with nice flavors. My incredibly picky daughter even loves this pizza. We've never dined in but they do have a space for dine-in. read more

We love Flyer's, but we definitely have to stick to just their pizza and not their sides. Our favorite is the thin crust Old World pepperoni. It is always consistently delicious. Every side that we have had, hasn't been great. The pretzel sticks were especially awful. Their pizzas and salads, though are terrific! I ordered a basic garden salad and added grilled chicken, and I swear, it was super simple but one of the best salads that I have ever had! The chicken was so tender and full of flavor. This is my husband's favorite of Columbus pizza places and he would order it once a week if I let him! haha read more

It's not a secret their prices are not cheap. Their pizza is good though so many people are willing to pay for the quality. I just picked up an order and asked for some paper plates and napkins. They literally wanted to charge me for the paper plates. Just ridiculous greed. I'm done with flyers. read more

All the toppings, Interesting sauce Received a flier for Flyers and noticed they were running a promotion for Hawaiian pizza 11" so decided to try it. Ordered it for carry out and picked it up. I was immediately impressed by the density of toppings; I could not see any cheese due to the whole pizza being covered in toppings. Went home to eat the pizza and it was tasty, the sauce was very distinct. It tasted like a barbecue kind of sauce which seemed odd on a Hawaiian, but it all worked. I will be back to see if all their pizzas have this sauce and are covered in toppings read more

Great pizza and sub, awesome staff (Kelly? Kelli?) who took our order over the phone this evening and super friendly young man who delivered everything but the icing is different for the funnel fries and it's a Not good at all. read more

Came in and tried the Italian sub- delicious! Will be trying the pizza at my next visit!

I ordered thin crust. It wasnt. I ordered well done. it wasnt. I like Flyers but inconsistent sucks. read more

Flyer's Pizza & Subs - Not well done or thin crust as I orderd It. - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

I was a walking on a Saturday afternoon during an Ohio State football game so figured I would be there for a few minutes. Not so my order was taken very quickly, ordered a pizza and salad to go and was ready and short order. Staff was very nice, eating area was very clean. Pizza and salad were excellent and I would definitely recommend. read more

I order from here all the time and they get it to me very quickly! The food is DELICIOUS!! There isn't anything that I've tried that I didn't like! Plus the delivery drivers are always so happy and kind! I would 10/10 recommend this to anyone. By far my favorite pizza place!! read more

Ordered a large pizza. Brought it home and took a bite of it. To my surprise there was a shard of what appears to be glass or acrylic cooked into it. Promptly called and the manager was extremely rude. Unacceptable service. I will not be buying from there again, steer clear. read more

Flyer's Pizza & Subs - Pizza with glass in it - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Was in the mood for pizza today. Looked at the Yelp reviews and decided on Flyers. Plenty of parking and easy to find. I was greeted promptly by a friendly young lady. Ordered a 15 inch "Bomber" to go. They do have a separate seating area to eat at. The ingredients all seemed to be fresh and tasted great. I believe they make their own Italian Sausage which also tasted great. The only down side was the crust wasn't as crispy as I would prefer due to the travel time back to the local office. Best pizza I've had in this area. I would recommend and will be back as well. read more

Flyer's Pizza & Subs - 15" Bomber - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Flyers has solid pie. It's not as good as Dante's or Tommy's, but very similar in style and taste. We've also tried their subs and appetizers, all were good. Flyer's is definitely one of the better pizza places in hilliard. It's a little pricey, so sign up for email coupons and watch for deals! read more

See all

I have tried it couple of times. I did not try the pizza. Resorted to the subs. Very pleased with the quality. They have a lunch menu everyday including Sunday. The sub was very well made, full, stuffed, and tasty. They put a cookie in that lunch box. Don't throw it away by mistake. I almost did. That would have been an unforgiven sin. Oh Lordy.... The cookie was fresh, chewy, and a nice yummy treat. The fries were waffle style, fresh and hot. read more

I love coming to this location! My order is always accurate and hot. I stick to the Old World Pepperoni - more flavor overall and worth the little extra cost. I've never had the subs but my family enjoys ordering them. This location also has seating so you can eat on site instead of carry out only. read more

Flyer's Pizza & Subs - Old world pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Love Flyers pizza! Every time we order from here, our pizza and experience are great. You can never go wrong with an old world pepperoni and the breadsticks are good too. They're more on the plain, butter side, but that's right up our alley so we get them every time. The staff is always kind and they are usually early on deliveries. Definitely recommend giving Flyer's a try. read more

Drove in late to Columbus, OH didn't feel like driving anywhere plus it's cold has h*** outside found Flyers on Yelp most of the time pizza I order from for some reason not very good it hit or miss. I travel all over US driving everywhere (I hate flying) I've eaten Pizza in NY, TX, FL, PA, DC and OHIO I say this it's in my top 5 the sauce is really good I ordered from the Hilliard store service great pizza awesome Thanks Flyer's read more

Ordered the lunch sub combo today and let me tell you how delicious!!! My usual go to is the chicken garlic supreme pizza which is also amazing! I'm glad I tried something new today! Also no photo because I inhaled it read more

Best pizza in town. Garlic chicken, Buffalo Chicken my all time favourite. Best Veggie pizza u can get. read more

Flyer's Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

We went here based on the high Yelp reviews. The staff was very friendly. We got a sampler, macaroni bites - they were out, pizza bites -very good, boneless wings - OK but they were the size of nickels, wedge fries - ehhh they gave us crinkle fries not wedge. Free home made potato chips if you dined in were very fresh and good especially if you dipped them in cheese sauce. We ordered 2 large pizzas and a Stromboli. The Pepperoni pizza was covered with pepperoni from edge to edge. The Sriracha Southwest pizza had no heat and leaned more towards sweet. Stromboli had pepperoni, sausage, mushroom and was really good. Salad was blah but it was ok. So 4 sodas and $97 later why did I give it 3 stars? If you like a sweet pizza sauce you would give it a 4-5 star. I absolutely hate sweet pizza and marinara sauce. To me, pizza sauce should be savory, not sweeten with so much sugar. If you like sweet sauce, this place is for you, if not move on. read more

We ordered a deluxe and a pepperoni pizza for carry out and wow both were terrific. It was my first time trying Flyers but my girls have had it several times. Everything was hot, delicious and on time. Can't wait to try it again! read more

Got food a year ago had a cockroach in bag with sub , disgusting , so i called manager the offered me a free pizza lol, told them keep it, watch where u eat lol. read more