Best Pizza in Columbus, The all meat is exceptional. When you walk in, you know why they're so good…read more, awesome team, and Team Work. I see people going around rating Pizza and none of them are as good as this.

I don't usually love a cracker crust pizza but the sauce and topping really made this pizza…read moredelicious! Loved the veggie pizza especially! Placed an order for pickup and the service was timely and accurate!

Great pizza, wings as well. Has Consistently been good quality food. The owners are involved in…read morethe quality checks of take out orders, as well as a friendly environment dine in.

Been meaning to try this place. I love mom and pop pizza places. This place did not disappoint…read more The drinks selection is great. The specialty pizzas all sounded delicious. The cluckin loaded fries were delicious. We got the sweet heat sauce and it was really good. The bbq white meatball pizza was amazing. I will absolutely get that again. The all the way was your classic supreme. It was really good too. Almost edge to edge toppings but left just enough crispy crust which I love. We will definitely be back.

Fantastic pizza and really good service…read more We moved to Pickerington a few months ago and tried Gionino's almost immediately. So glad we did. Every pizza we've tried has been fantastic. Great salads too. They have very good Jojo potatoes as well. When they say 20 minutes for pickup they are always spot on. You walk in and its ready. Thicker crust than I usually go for but great taste and very filling. Give them a try.

Had some at a party. Got there still pretty hot. I grabbed a slice of pepperoni…read more First impression, which I shared with others: "it's not great." But that's not fair. It's not bad. It's fine. Just maybe a bit too floppy and greasy for me at that moment (and in general.) Square cut. Fairly doughy thick soft crust. Lots of cheese. Enough sauce to hold things, and it tasted fine. A minimal amount of pepp, but what there was was tasty. And all in all the taste was pretty good. Just the schloopiness and doughiness and greasiness didn't do it for me. I didn't go back for more. But it'll probably fill your basic pizza needs.

Had Pizzeria New York delivered. First time having it. Was delicious! Had the white pizza,…read morepepperoni pizza, garlic knots and meatballs. Everything was hot and tasted great! Will be ordering again.

This place is awful. My pizza was not even cooked. In the service was also very very rude. People…read morehurt my feelings.

Ella's We went to…read moreElla's on Saturday, 5 September 2026. We'd been here before, but some things had changed. The management is different, and they now offer full table service. In the past, some nights they made us go to the bar to order. They have also made some changes to the menu. For the most part, the menu changes were positive, but they no longer offer the shrimp basket, which my wife liked. Reagan was our server, and she was very attentive. My wife had the chicken parmesan, which she thought was very good. I had the Barbacoa Steak Tacos with chips. The tacos were disappointing. The steak in the tacos was a little tough. The steak either needs to be cooked differently or shaved instead of sliced. This is a swell spot and could use a little more notice. If you are looking for a place in the Canal Winchester area for date night or a night out with the girls, give them a look.

Crispy Brussels about in a balsamic glaze, a gooey chicken dip with crisp chips, pulled steak Mac…read moreand cheese, and the spicy peaches bruschetta were on the menu for the delivery order. The order was very well packed with decent portions. The peaches were a bit limp but were flavorful. Some sort of cream would really help hold the dish together. The other items were delicious.

Judging by the foot traffic coming and going from this festival place, it's a regular place for a…read morelot of people! I found this on google when i put in find gluten free near me. I was delighted to find a lot of options! Keep in mind there may be cross contamination so take it as you will. I ordered the Italian sub on gluten free and it was so very close to a normal sandwich I was very excited! I also ordered a gluten free pizza and found it great! The big restaurant held a lot of people and was pretty comfortable.

Our friends are regulars here. We pop in with them here and there. It's always good. Always busy…read more They have a nice variety of options. The pepperoni pizza is so good. Thin crust. Crispy. The good little pepperonis that curl up. The donors sub is delicious as well. It's your classic Italian sub. The pork nachos are delicious as well. Don't forget to try the meatballs.

In the area for work and apparently this is a go to place. Took the recommendation and went. This…read moreplace was hopping. It was very busy. The locals said it wasn't usually like this but it was busy. Our party started as 5 and then grew to 7. This could have added to the slowness issue. Typical local pub interior with a great bar area in the center. I had the Hawaiian pizza with shrooms and there were several other pizza at the table. Very good just took a while which is to be expected. The fellow next to me had the wings. Wow they were huge. He was unable to eat the 10 he got. I was unable to finish my 10" pizza. Love the popcorn they give you while you wait. Awesome just a bit slow but they were very busy. Sorry Jo pix as it was a business meal.

Just had another Kingy's All the Way and it rocks it!! The drive thru window makes it so easy to…read morepick up my favorite pizza. I love this place!

I can't say enough great things about this place, we have a large birthday get together here, the…read moreplace was amazing. The staff was amazing. The drink came out in record time and same with the food. The food was delicious. We live in Westerville but will driving back to eat here more. Thank you again for the amazing service. We don't find that often..

The food is delicious, the atmosphere is amazing and the staff are super friendly. The happy hour…read moreis unbelievable $1 beer and $1 wine!!! We will definitely return.

One of the best and consistent features about the Farmers Market. Fresh ingredients, wood fired…read moreflavor, and the right balance of elements. I wish they had a small friendly shop to get this pizza all year round.

I discovered Pompeii's Inferno at a "Pizza on the Patio" event at Wyandotte Winery. Upon seeing…read morethe tiny set up (basically a wood burning oven on wheels), I really wasn't expecting much. Boy, was I pleasantly surprised. PI pushes out some pies out of this oven on wheels that rival, if not beat, most pizza joints with wood burning ovens. The crust is what you would expect from this type of oven - thin under the toppings with lots of joyous air pockets and char-spots for flavor around the rim. The sauce was fantastic and the toppings were all quality. Due to the nature of PI's business (mobile pizza parlor used for "events"), the toppings were a bit limited (hey, they had pep and shroom, so what do I care?) The wait for the pizza was also extremely LONG, but I had to forgive them this for two reasons: this was a VERY crowded event with only one food option and, oh, did I mention I was at a winery? To their credit, PI finally stopped taking orders so they could focus on the backlog and push it out. This may be the wine talking, but that was one great pizza! If PI is near you, I'd definitely check them out (or hey, maybe hire them for an event - this is quality stuff).

Picked up a large all meat pizza and Buffalo wings. So good. Generous toppings, Good price. Good…read moreservice. Nice break from chain pizza shops

It is pretty good pizza. Not top 10…read more Staff is pretty shady. First time I went there, the guy overcharged me on the Pizza cause he thinks I didn't know how much it should be. Next time, I asked him when I called. How much is the pizza to be sure. It's very rundown the website doesn't work. There's no menu posted anywhere. The guy said the menus are on order, but we haven't received them yet. That was months ago still haven't received it.