The pizza is delicious, fried mushrooms are tasty. Kids love that they bring free popcorn to the…read moretable. The chicken tenders are great portion size for kids and the buttered noodles are great for kids. The service is usually on top of their game. The atmosphere has a good vibe and plenty of sports games to enjoy while you eat and visit with family and friends. Prices are very reasonable.

My pizza was not as ordered and when I asked for a replacement, the manager accused me of lying…read more He eventually replaced my pizza; however, there was a long piece of hair in my pizza. Never returning.

Stopped by for pizza and boneless wings, the food was great and the staff were friendly! Plenty of…read moreseating to bring the whole family and grab some pizza right in historic Grove City town center.

This place for me is the perfect destination to stop in and eat some perfectly cooked Italian food…read more The pizza is phenomenal. The crust is the perfect combination of chewy and crispy and the toppings are fresh cut and great portions.. the Italian sausage is sliced them and not crumbled and makes just a fantastic compliment to in my opinion pure Pizza perfect perfection!

Back after awhile The wings are very meaty and delicious…read more I'm pretty picky, always get sauce on the side. I'll get them again, would enjoy a sweet/spicy option but not complaining the buffalo was good Italian sub was also very good, much better than last time!! See you soon

We just left and are really happy with our experience. The salad was large with fresh greens, the…read morepizza was good with excellent cup and crisp pepperoni, and the meatball sub was delicious. I saw a review here on Yelp about bad service. That definitely was not the case. They have a "push for service" call system - when you need something, just push the button! (Though she was very attentive and we didn't need to use it.) I imagine they started this after that review about bad service. How nice to see owners who take action and make a positive change after a bad review. The restaurant was clean and tidy. Recommend!

Amazing Tikka Masala pizza. Great crust! Loaded with toppings . This is a not to be missed…read morepizza!! So creative!

I I ordered online at 4:35pm. On email stated it would be ready by 4:50 another email stated it…read morewould be ready by 4:58 pm I went in at 5;00 just in case. We had a little issue communicating because I'm deaf. The person thought I wanted to place an order but I had to explain I already placed an online order. He then went to check and told me I needed to come back in 10 more minutes. When I came back 15 minutes later it still was not ready. There were two men working and they could have been the owners. I ordered the chicken parmigiana. The sauce tasted fake. Like not even from a jar but I'm sure it was. Hey guys a little tip. Learn how to make sauce. Then you can jar it and use it on a lot of your dishes. That will make a difference. I promise you. The bread tasted fresh so keep that up. I did not try the pizza and apparently that's what they are known for because when I was there they were making a lot of them. Maybe I should have tried that instead. Sooo the final question, would I come back? No. Remember my criteria is based on 3 things. 1.ambiance 2. Service 3. Food / taste 1. Well there was none. Unless she was willing to arm wrestle me for the check 2. I received 2 emails with two different times and none of them were right. I had to wait even longer. 3. Taste. Disappointed. Sorry guys but please take this advice. Make your own sauce. It WILL make a difference!

We wanted to try something new so I called and picked up a large pizza and two chicken parm subs…read more They said it would be twenty minutes and it was! The kids liked the subs and the pizza was pretty darn good. The crust was slightly overdone but I love it that way. Delivery to about a mile away was quoted as 1.75 which I think is totally doable. This is NOT a dine in at all place . Lobby is limited to three people. The guys inside were friendly and fast. We would definitely go again.

It has been a while since I've been here and decided to give them another try. It was pretty good…read more The pizza was good. I think having an extra 5 minutes to make it more crisper would make it even better. The sub was a bit dry so I would suggest asking for more dressing if you get the Italian. Other than that, it was good. I feel the wings were my favorite food of choice between the 3. I wouldn't mind coming back for more, but like the pizza I mentioned, asking for extra time on the wings would make it even better.

Unlike what the page says, this restaurant is not closed. It's been open for about five months…read moreunder new management, according to the new owner. We tried this place for the first time last night. I had a bunch of family over and thought it would be nice to try something new. I am glad I did. The pizza was very good. The crust was quite crispy - crispier than any crust I've ever had. We definitely ordered too much pizza because there was a ton of leftovers, but everyone was stuffed and said the pizza really hit the spot, which is the best kind of praise. We'll definitely order again from here.

The pizza looks good, but it's not. There is no sauce - I taste none and, for some reason, these…read moreflavors are not blending together very well. I don't know what it is.....almost taste sour? Wanted to try a new pizza place but won't be returning.

I stopped in on a hot Saturday and decided to check it out (part of my pizza journey)…read more The service was great. My server was attentive and made sure I had what I needed. I ordered a small pepperoni and sausage pizza. The pie was crispy and thin. It had big hunks of sausage and the pepperonis were just starting to crisp (how I like it). It was on the greasy side but all good. The bottom was dusted with cornmeal The place was clean and had booths and pizza stands. This place would be great to take kids for lunch. I am not sure if they sell beer, but the menu does incldcated they have bottle and draft beer Good place, I will be back.

We had a Clipp coupon so decided to check this place out on a nice weather evening. Walking in, the…read morepizza cottage has tables and booths and then through a connected area, you can walk into the tavern bar area. They have a full bar with booths too. The covered patio is cute and we had it all to ourselves. There are TVs mounted and a small space for love music. We ordered a large pepp and sausage Sicilian crust pizza. My husband order a water and root beer. The water never came. He asked for a refill on his root beer, it came back with possibly cherry coke? The pizza was a 6/10. The crust was crispy, but the cheese either fell off when trying to take a piece from the pizza, or during a bite. The ambiance was a 10/10, but outside of that, the experience was fairly underwhelming.

Absolutely delicious pizza! The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside while staying soft and…read morechewy inside, and the sauce had just the right balance of flavor. The cheese was fresh and perfectly melted, and the toppings were generous without overwhelming the pizza. Everything tasted fresh and well-prepared. Definitely one of the better pizzas I've had, and I'd happily order it again. Buffalo chips were very good as well. This spot is definitely worth the trip and the visit!

No matter how long it's been since I have been here..... it always tastes the same and it is always…read moresoooo good!! We talk about Angelina's all the time. Living in Tampa we have not found a pizza place that compares. Not even a little bit. So it's so good to have a taste of some good pizza. We got the Angelina's Supreme. The best of everything they have to offer. It was so tasty and fresh. We loved it. Can't wait to come back for more. And if you are reading this.... Trust me when I say you can not and will not go wrong with Angelina's Pizza.