We had a Clipp coupon so decided to check this place out on a nice weather evening. Walking in, the pizza cottage has tables and booths and then through a connected area, you can walk into the tavern bar area. They have a full bar with booths too. The covered patio is cute and we had it all to ourselves. There are TVs mounted and a small space for love music. We ordered a large pepp and sausage Sicilian crust pizza. My husband order a water and root beer. The water never came. He asked for a refill on his root beer, it came back with possibly cherry coke? The pizza was a 6/10. The crust was crispy, but the cheese either fell off when trying to take a piece from the pizza, or during a bite. The ambiance was a 10/10, but outside of that, the experience was fairly underwhelming. read more

See all

They can never seem to get our order correct. Too bad because my toddler absolutely loves their chicken tenders. Our order is always wrong. Ordered two pizzas, one plain cheese, one pep and onion, received two different sized cheese pizzas smh. read more

Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

So I ordered a pizza and wings tonight on a friday night. Got the email 90 minutes for my order so I called the store and yes 90 minutes. Ok cool wasnt in a hurry. So I waited the 90 minutes picked up my order and everything is cold. Maybe a food order tracker would help on when its in process and actually done. Wish everything had not been sitting for who knows how long. read more

The pizza was very good. The service was excellent. I had the bbq chicken. It was good and plenty of chicken. They took care of me and fixed a small issue. Friendly and knowledgeable. read more

I had the BEST PIZZA EVER tonight at the one and only Pizza Cottage. I would recommend this place. The personal pizzas are just the right size and, i would recommend the Pepperoni and Banana pepper personal pizza. The bathrooms were also very clean. I will definitely be coming back to the one and only PIZZA COTTAGE!!!!!! read more

Hot, fresh and really great service . First visit , but not the last ! Cute tavern attached with live music too. read more

Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell - Sausage and onion pizza - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

This location has been recently remodeled. The inside of the restaurant is very nice. Cannot wait to try the outside seating when the weather gets better. My wife and I eat here weekly and enjoy the whole hog pizza. Pizza is very good with healthy amounts of toppings added. The fact that they serve Pepsi product is a big bonus. The service has most always been top notch. We are at the point where they remember our order when we arrive. Will continue to support this place. read more

I stopped in on a hot Saturday and decided to check it out (part of my pizza journey). The service was great. My server was attentive and made sure I had what I needed. I ordered a small pepperoni and sausage pizza. The pie was crispy and thin. It had big hunks of sausage and the pepperonis were just starting to crisp (how I like it). It was on the greasy side but all good. The bottom was dusted with cornmeal The place was clean and had booths and pizza stands. This place would be great to take kids for lunch. I am not sure if they sell beer, but the menu does incldcated they have bottle and draft beer Good place, I will be back. read more

Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

First time ordering here and we won't be back. We weren't impressed with pizza because it tasted very salty. Coupled with the fact that a 14" thin crust pizza was over $20. I had purchased a Clipp promotion that should have given me $20 worth of food but they refused to honor and only gave me $10. There are so many far better choices for pizza in the area but I thought I would try bought the promotion only to be scammed. read more

Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

The service is absolutely amazing. The workers are always so kind and helpful. The tv in the booth is so helpful with 2 kids. I did the chef salad which has very fresh toppings and filling. The Wednesday $10 large one topping deal is great. We did sausage, pepperoni, cheese and onion. All were delicious!! The dessert pizza is a favorite way to eat dinner. read more

See all

It's very hard to find a place that will make a pizza sub. Best pizza sub ever! Have been back several times for it.

I've been to this Pizza Cottage on numerous occasions. They have a great lunch special with a personal one topping pizza (or 1/2 sub), salad and huge soda for only $10.99. My wife and I both think it's one of the best pizzas around. The only downside is that the servers that I've interacted with could have been friendlier which would have made the dining experience better. read more

This was my first visit inside Pizza Cottage since this location opened it's doors, much more efficient. Our server put our order in and it didn't take long to get the pizzas back. The restaurant itself is laid back and great for large and small tables. I did read that they have a trivia night, looking forward to taking part in that with the family soon. The pizza is delicious, a medium to thin crust, the pepperonis are crisp around the edges, not too greasy but not dry. The BLT pizza is my absolute favorite, I've been eating this since I was a child at the original location. There are a lot of specialty pizzas on the menu and I can't wait to try a few more out! read more

It's a chain but I never heard of them until this year! The concept of this restaurant is ideal for families and groups. You get a variety of crust options, sizes as well as toppings and specialty pizzas. Salads and wings, dressings and sauces. Dine in, carryout or drive thru. It tastes pretty good, too! It's really successful East and South of Columbus. Zanesville, Circleville, Newark, Athens, Lancaster. They've got it covered! Nearly! Set up one in Cincinnati! read more

The pizza is mediocre at best. I would say this is the perfect pizza for a little baseball team after a nice win. With that being said, i feel bad for whoever has to pay the bill after said celebration. i spent $34 on 1 large thin Pepperoni, and 1 thin medium cheese. Excuse me Pizza Cottage management, but you are not serving up artesian pizza with ingredients imported from italy. I can pay the exact same price ordering from a much fancier pizza place in town like Sextons, or Brenz. I will not be back ripoff. read more

Newly remodeled patio and new pub. Very nice inside. Food was good and service was excellent!

I came here a few years ago when it opened and had some of the worst service I've ever experienced....figured it survived this long, must have gotten better...spoiler alert, it hasn't. 2 servers....working a full restaurant with probably 35 tables...TWO....whats worse, these two were also hosting, bussing, answering the phone, and cashing out carry out customers. The two were working their hardest, but it simply isn't possible. If the management and ownership simply seem unwilling to staff for the business they are running. Table next to us was dirty when we walked in. It took 15 min to get our drinks, and well over 40 to get 2 kids spaghetti's and a personal thin crust pizza....and when we left after being there over an hour, the table hadn't been touched...if you want a refill, take your cup up and do it yourself, it will be 25 minutes till a server comes back to your table. If this was a delivery only business fine, but you CAN NOT run a full service restaurant with this little staff. I gave them a second chance, I will not be giving them a third. To any staff that reads this, RUN! The slightly older female blonde server and young high school guy spent more time apologizing for everything going wrong than they did providing service. You two worked hard, but you deserve better! Run far from the owner of this place who doesn't seem to want to run a restaurant. read more

Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell - While Whole Hog Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

Why it takes 40 minutes to get a personal pizza at 4pm I don't get. There were 8 employees standing around not doing anything and barely any customers in the dining area. read more

See all

Delicious, fresh, hot and tasty! The official start date is January 11, 2021, but they opened for business on 12/28/2020. Pizza Cottage will open its seventh location in Powell, Ohio. This will be the first Pizza Cottage located in central Ohio. I placed an order ahead of time for carry out. When I arrived I was greeted at the door and my order was ready. The food was hot when I got home and everybody agreed that this food was really good. Order: 14" pepperoni pizza, thin crust Calzone (pepperoni, ham, bacon) Tenders, small order, teriyaki The food was fantastic and tasted amazing. I'm not sure how they did it, but the pepperoni was crispy. They had a little heat, but the sauce was sweet, making a nice combination. The thin crust was cooked just right. The Calzone was stuffed with pepperoni, ham and bacon, and that delicious sauce oozed out here and there. The top was dusted with a wonderful blend of spices. Very good! We chose tenders over bone-in wings. There were 5 good sized tenders covered with a tasty teriyaki sauce. They were crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. Our toddler said they were "so good" and then asked for seconds. @ohiofoodlover read more

See all

Pizza cottage is new to this area, and we couldn't wait to try it! We ordered a large thin crust pepperoni pizza, and pepperoni, ham, and bacon calzone, and chicken tenders in teriyaki sauce. I must say the chicken was the highlight although all of it was amazing. The teriyaki chicken was delicious. It was so tender that it almost melted in my mouth. The three-year-old asked for seconds! The pizza was great. The pepperoni was crispy with a little heat. The cheese and sauce were just right. The thin crust was perfect. The calzone with pepperoni, ham, and bacon also included cheese and sauce on the inside and extra dipping sauce on the side. The spice blend on top would make a great addition to the pizza crust as well. It was all so good. We're always going around trying different pizza places, but this place will become a regular spot for sure. read more

See all

Love PIZZA COTTAGE ! Great sauce , crust , toppings Love the salads too One of my Top Pizza Spots for sure ! This location in Powell is nice , and clean , great staff and service too every time I've been here . My only Pizza Cottage complaint is that I'd like to see more locations open up around central Ohio ! :) read more

Not as good as all the years we have had it at buckeye lake. Dibnt taste like pizza cottage

It was our first time there. We heard that it was a great pie. Well, the pizza we disliked had lots of flop to it. Pizza should have a crispy crust. What we got was not crispy at all, and the sauce was bland. I'm not sure what happened, but a no return for us read more

Best crispy crust style pix I have had. On par with Tommy's Pizza on 161. Will be our go to since Tommy's has gone to No Dine In. Service was good but would not say exceptional. Ambience - nothing special. Clean with comfortable seat spacing. Overall nice place, will go there again , read more

We've eaten at the Pizza Cottage in Newark years ago and it was excellent, this new location is every bit as good! A must stop if you like a great thin crust pizza! (They do make a thicker crust but we've never tried it.) The jalapeño poppers were great & the 14" sausage/onion & green pepper pizza was very good! Matt waited on us and while they were a bit short on help he did an excellent job!!!!!! (NOTE to Pizza Cottage - Hire some HELP!!!) We shall return! read more

Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell - Jalapeño poppers an order of 6, they were very good! - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

Elizabeth (Ellie) was our waitress. She did a fantastic job. We were greeted within 2 minutes of arriving and she was very attentive. My wife got the cauliflower crust veggie pizza. I got a large anchovy (Neapolitan style) pizza, both we requested pie cut, and both were some of the best we have had in the Columbus area. The garlic bread sticks are very good and the sauce is superb. The restaurant is clean, modern, and many of the booths have their own TVs (heads up sports aficionados). We will be back! read more

See all

I was mistreated by one of the employees when I went through the drive thru last night. The other employee was kind though. However due to the one employee that at one point failed to treat me like an adult. I will never ever come back. read more

Pizza Cottage is always delicious! It's a must try. It's a little on the expensive side for pizza, but well worth it when you get the urge.

Since Pizza Cottage took over the old Ruby Tuesday, we decided to finally give them a try. So, they darkened windows which is actually nice. The decor is nice and the TV at certain tables is different but interesting. Our server was nice. He had to give us more time because only 1 of us had eaten there before. So, we got the jalapeño Poppers for me which were so good. Just a bit spicy but not that bad. I will definitely order them whenever we decide to go back. Potato skins were ordered but I didn't have any. I got the chicken Philly pizza ,no onions but kept the green pepper slices and mushrooms. It was really good! This will be my go to pizza for here. My son got a meat pizza which he loved. It was a nice dinner with really good food and good staff as well with no issues or mess up with our orders. All in all? This is a place worth looking into and trying at least once. read more

See all

Terrible experience at Athens Pizza Cottage tonight. Inside temp had to be in 50's but was told that management does not allow employees to adjust thermometer. Service was slow, probably because servers were so cold themselves. With all that money invested in refurbishment, it's insane that customers can't enjoy their meal at a proper temp. Will never go back. read more

My wife and I tried this restaurant for the first time. Had a specialty pizza, the sauce was way to salty. Asked the waitress if they were adding salt to the tomato sauce and she said no, that they make their own sauce daily first thing in the morning and that is just how it is. I suggested that they try using a little less! Also noticed that when we left quite a few tables had a lot of pizza left once they had left also. This is a new restaurant to the area and if they don't change I don't expect them to last. read more

The breadsticks were good, the pizza was good. If I lived closer, I'd probably have this pizza one time every other month or so. It was good but I won't drive 20 min to have it again. read more

Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell - Breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

I love the crispy pepperoni, which reminds me of the pizza I grew up with! The calzone was stuffed with so much cheese and meat. The tenders with teriyaki sauce were juicy and tender. Everything was tasty! read more

Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell - Large thin crust pepperoni pizza, calzone, and tenders with teriyaki sauce - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

Food was meh. Service was good. Restaurant was messy. Would not go back. I had high hopes but they were dashed. The waitress was very nice.

Ordered the Meat Lovers pie and the garlic bread. The pizza itself is great if you love flatbread style! It had a thin, crispy crust. Was not really impressed with the garlic bread; it sort of tasted like Texas toast to give an idea. Unfortunately, there wasn't a lot of staff in the establishment however, our server did a great job! read more

Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell - Garlic Bread with Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

Yes!!! This pizza is SO GOOD! It's so fresh! The ingredients are piled high on the pizza. My son is obsessed with their Wings. The staff are very friendly and professional. Restaurant is super clean and they have Sports on the TVs! We drive WAY out of our way to get it. It's a hidden gem that people are mistakenly driving by. Don't miss it! Don't forget the Fried Pickles and their desserts! YUMMO! https://www.pizza-cottage.com/ read more

The place was clean, which was nice, and the people were friendly. Food however was sort of subpar. Tasted ok, but the spaghetti I ordered had sauce that was a little too watery. Same with my sister's ravioli, and would poop at the bottom of the dish. If the sauce was a little thicker, then it would have been better. But, I feel they cater more to pizza than the other dishes, since Pizza is literally in the name, so I'm not too upset. read more

One of the worst places I've ever been in they took wayyyyy too long to give me my order and waited over 30 mins , this isn't professional and it wasted my time , read more

Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell - Waited in here for about 32 mins , real real bs - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

Online Order be warned! They don't do their own delivery & don't advertise it's Door Dash. I had a problem with my order, my fault, mistyped house #, order never arrived. I called store & they claim no fault, not their problem. The address I mistyped doesn't exist, but no one ever called my contact # even though I got a text saying pizza was delivered... Pizza Cottage won't make it right & say "they know" it should state a warning about delivery being from Door Dash & yet still wouldn't give me any contact info to try to get this fixed. Lost my business for good. read more

Very slow service, appetizers were mid. And for the fries being 6 dollars you think there would be more in the basket. Would only recommend the desert pizza. Also, My family was very creeped out by the family across from us who let their children crawl around on the floor like bears while they ate dinner. The kids also crawled like bears to the restroom. Overall a beary bad experience. read more