Soooo I really wanted to like this pizza, I did, but it was awful. I read that they changed ownership, and man I really wish I had the chance to try them before they did. Older reviews and pictures looked bomb so I decided to give it a shot. Friday night we ordered 2 cheese pizzas and a chicken parm sandwich. Today is Tuesday and I've been trying to force my kids and the neighbor kids to eat it there's still a whole pie in the fridge that's about to go in the trash. Like imagine how bad pizza has to be that I can't get 8-11yr olds to eat it. I did try one slice I don't know how to describe it, kind of like frozen pizza but worse bc you've obviously paid a lot more for it than you would have a frozen pizza. Let's not even talk about the chicken parm sandwich that I tried to "fix", and I still couldn't save the rubbery chicken they put in there. That all wound up in the trash as well. I hate throwing food away, honestly I hate it, but I couldn't stomach anything we got from them. read more

Bridge Street Pizza - Chicken Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Great service and great pizza. Dined in with my family on a weekday night and the two guys running the shop were so friendly and welcoming. Support your local pizza shop!! read more

Bridge Street Pizza - Medium half cheese half Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

UPDATE - I was given a refund. Ordered delivery and it was an hour late and ice cold. After we heated it back up it was mediocre at best. read more

We decided to get pizza for supper tonight because we really don't want a lot to eat. Got a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza. It was really good. Great customer service. The only reason I did not give the 5 stars is because of parking. It is really hard to get in and out of their little parking lot. There really is not parking. Really small place inside. Probably enough seating for 5 people. Would we go back, yes!! read more

Unfortunately I found out the hard way that this place is under new management. They were friendly but the pizza has definitely changed. Flat, greasy, and bland. The ingredients don't really taste fresh, but rather cheap. They also got my toppings wrong. I ordered pepperoni and banana peppers with sausage on half. What I got was pepperoni on half and sausage on the whole pie. Sorry to say I don't think I'll be back read more

Unbelievable pizza! This is the coolest place. We were looking for local boutique pizza and tried Bridge Street Pizza. We ordered the chicken primavera and it was incredible. The staff were all fun and very polite. I'm sold on this place. 5 stars easily. read more

New owner! We went 2 nights in a row to get the margherita pizza! It actually had fresh mozzarella on it in big slices. Excellent hand tossed dough as well so we will be back. read more

Bridge Street Pizza - Margherita pizza with pepperoni added by request. - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Do not get wings from this place! They are small pieces of boiled chicken that they pour some sauce on. They were inedible and cost $15 read more

Bridge Street Pizza - Chicken Wings - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

I thought it was mediocre. Reviews are good, but the pizza was just so so. The garlic bread was kind of a cheap rendition I would not recommend it read more

Their pizza used to be amazing! I'm not sure what happened. The crust now appears to be premade. It lacks taste and the killer bread sticks were just twisted premade dough. It's been a few years since we had it last, but I remember it being so much better. The guys working were really nice though. read more

Bridge Street Pizza - Twisted Killer Bread Sticks (Medium) - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

If you are looking for the place walk right past domino's and there you go. A small shop that right now only has one employee also the owner. Very friendly guy, he's a steelers fan which we will not hold against him (Go Giants). Let's start with the garlic bread with cheese, love the thickness kf it and thebsauce had a great taste. I wish I had a pasta dish for this to go with rather then a pizza. Now on to the pizza. As a NYer I have a pretty good sense of what good pizza and this very good. The pizza had a nice thin crust and great flavor, the cheese pull showed that it was not a cheap brand of cheese and he cares about the products he uses. If you want pizza walk the extra 10 feet down from domino's and go to a real local pizza place. If you don't care about throwing away money and have no taste in pizza order from domino's. read more

See all

I don't know what happen with the previous owners but this guy knows what he is doing! I picked up my pizza, it was ready in a timely manner. The service was friendly and knowledgeable as well as flexible with omitting toppings that would normally come on my pizza. I ordered a gluten free shamrock pizza. It comes with pesto, spinach, artichoke, pine nuts and feta. I swapped out the pesto sauce for regular pizza sauce and omitted the shake that would have been on it. It was fantastic! Perfectly done ..yes, including the bottom! This will be on my go to list for pizza! Now, if they would just use a delivery service.. I hear he's working on it! read more

Bridge Street Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Unfortunately, our pizza arrived barely cooked and inedible. The crust was doughy and cold. It's in our oven now attempting to be salvaged, but with a few hotels in the area, customers would not have that option. Way too many other options with quality food in this area. ( salad also had brown lettuce and zero dressing). Wish I had a better review but cannot recommend this restaurant. read more

Stopped in mid afternoon for a bite to eat. I was the only one in the restaurant. Owner was very accommodating and pleasant. Italian sandwich was very large, warm and tasty. Hit the spot! read more

Bridge Street Pizza - The Italian Sub - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

did bridge street go under new management? they have a call center answering the phones and don't know what's on the menu. also, the pizza has definitely dropped down a couple notches. read more

Bridge Street Pizza - Pep and sausage.. used to be over loaded with toppings - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Bridge Street Pizza--- as I have stated Pizza is really not my thing, however i would call this my favorite pizza place, always comes fresh and hot and the boneless wings are excellent During these strange times we have jab more than our usual share of pizza and this is the one we keep going back todefinitely worth a try read more

Bridge Street Pizza - The Dubliner - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Today I ate my words. Literally. After a frustrating experience with Bridge Street I decided to try and call them again. Somehow the stars aligned and not only did they answer but I wasn't put on hold. And thank goodness because that meal was amazing. We are in town for hockey for my oldest son so I made sure to order a big meal. Garlic cheesebread - yummy though not a show stopper Wings - wow. Amazing quality and fantastic flavor though the spicy bbq could've been hotter Meat pizza - now that's was fantastic! Perfect crust massive amount of toppings. Phenomenal flavor. In summary this place was a hat trick. Yum! read more

See all

We were so glad to try this place! Apparently the owners had just taken over this business. Tbh I was a bit worried if it was going to be good as the previous establishment. So GLAD we decided to try it anyways! One of the best pizzas we ever had from a small business! (I forgot to take pics of the pizza). ENJOY!! read more

Really great and flavorful pizza. Perfect crust. Garlic bread with marinara and hot wings. Pizza made fresh. Great mom and pop shop. Enjoyed this. Would recommend. read more

See all

Carry out order, 12in pep. Crust had a nice crunch on the outside and got a little soft toward the middle, definitely not soggy though. No big deal for me. They use cornmeal, albeit not that much. Significantly less compared to Minelli's where you feel like you're choking on sawdust. Not a fan, but it's pretty minimal so I can let that slide. Pepperoni was different than most and had some chew and pull to it. Felt like I was eating a different type of salami until the taste of the peppers kicked in. I loved the flavor. Sauce was decent, no sweetness which is a plus for me. Chewy cheese with good flavor. Didn't blow my mind, but for comparison it blows the Dominos next door out of the water. How anyone could get dominos with this place next door is insane to me. read more

Bridge Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Overlooked quality pizza place. Have been pleased with consistency too. Love the pep deluxe.

Have lived in Dublin for years and never tried Bridge St. I was encouraged by all the great reviews in the Pizza Connoisseurs group and decided today was the day. We got a meatball pizza with half mushroom added. The crust had great texture (thanks to cornmeal!) and a hand tossed feel (not crackery thin but by no means doughy). The meatballs were a little spicy for my husband but I think they were great. Mushrooms were delicious. The gentleman who was at the store was very kind. It was ready in about 20 minutes. All in all, fantastic pizza. Would definitely get it again! read more

See all

Best pizza in Columbus! Small, simple operation that packs a punch. Every pizza I've ordered has been delicious. My favorite is the pepperoni and sausage pizza. Unlike a lot of places, BSP uses ground up sausage like Marion's Piazza in Dayton. As a result, sausage is less fatty and each bite includes some sausage thereby enhancing the flavor. Salads are basic, but well mixed with ingredients. BSP gas gluten free crust, which my sister gushes about. Check it out. You won't be disappointed. read more

Bridge Street Pizza - Pepperoni and sausage pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Their pizza is very good. I ordered an extra-large all meat pizza and it was loaded with toppings. Very fresh and delicious. You need to note, they are only open Thursday-Sunday. I will definitely re-visit. read more

The food is outstanding. Pizza is one of the best I've ever had, and I eat a lot of pizza. They use white onion, which makes a major difference in taste over the usual purple onion. They also grind their sausage up to fine pieces, with no other pizza places I know doing that. You will be very happy with this top-scoring pizza! All others don't come close, with the exception of Enrico's in Dublin. Both I would rate it five stars, with different positive styles. Give it a try you will not be disappointed. read more

Pie cut, mozzarella and great sauce.. simple right? Nope, most ohio pizza can't figure it out. This is a hidden gem, and finally pie cut..

Bridge Street Pizza is the first Columbus, Ohio pizza that I have been completely impressed with. The quality of ingredients was impressive for a pizza shop. We ordered a stone baked gourmet pizza called "The Pottsy" described as a double helping of homemade pizza sauce amp'd up with extra garlic, coarse black pepper and crushed red pepper flake & topped with pepperoni, Italian sausage, black olives, red onions, mushrooms and banana peppers, all sandwiched between a layer of mozzarella and provolone cheese. Let me tell you... it was incredible! Even my leftovers were amazing skillet heated the following day. We also ordered the "Killer Breadsticks with Cheese" and they were tasty. Bridge Street Pizza delivers so get at it! read more

Bridge Street Pizza - The Pottsy - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Our favorite pizza in Dublin, always great service and quick to pick up. When guests are in town, this is now the pizza over Massey's and anything else nearby. read more

Fresh ingredients! Dough made daily, meat from The Hills Market butcher in Worthington, stone baked, I mean seriously why are you not calling to place your order right now?! The Shamrock is a pesto-sauced veggie treat! The Potsy is bonkers delicious with the sausage and red onions stealing the show! Light, thinnish crust. A hidden gem in downtown Dublin. The owner goes 100 everyday and it shines through in his product. A must try for pizza fans! read more

See all

I am from Jersey and this pizza is Papa Johns, without the better ingredients. The box says hand crafted.. which apparently means previously frozen crust topped with canned sauce and plastic cheese. Look at the grid on the bottom of the pie... that is a factory pie. It is better than nothing when you're hungry; we have the same thing at home for $6, Hot and Ready. Expect more, you are paying for it. read more

Bridge Street Pizza - Large, plain pie. - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Decided to look up the best pizza In Dublin last night and Bridge Street Pizza was listed. They did not disappoint. I ordered the Potsy pizza and it was was excellent. The topping were spread from edge to edge and were very fresh. The garlic butter and shaky stuff on the crust took the pizza to another level. Don't let the fact that it is a small place without a fancy exterior keep you from trying it out. Bridge Street Pizza is a keeper on my list of best pizza places. read more

High quality pizza due to the quality ingredients used on the pizzas. Castro is a welcoming, fun guy to engage with while waiting for a pizza and always makes sure you're taken care of. If you like your pizza on the crispier side, ask for a little extra bake. I recommend the Potsy, Pure Pepperoni, or our custom pizza of choice - Kickin' Chicken sub garlic butter sauce instead of red sauce, and regular chicken instead of BBQ chicken (not a BBQ fan) read more

Great pizza and my daughters loved your bread sticks!! The potsy has some heat but so good!! We will be back. read more

Bridge Street Pizza - The Pottsy - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Totally love this pizza and the bread sticks!!! The pizza is always yummy!!!! It is small place where you can sit for a few minutes but not really a good place to go with 4 to 6 people. The owner is awesome too! read more

The pizza here is outstanding. The crust was perfect. Other toppings were also good and generous. If you want pie cut, you have to ask. I found the service a bit abrupt but only one person was working on Friday night, some of their busiest hours. read more

Traveling for business I am not easily impressed with pizza. I am with this one. Had the pottsy, excellent ingredients, delicious and took a fork lift to pick it up. This is a true hidden gem. read more

Ordered on a Saturday and it hit the spot for a pepperoni pizza. I would highly recommend and will be back in the future read more

Bridge Street Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Sometimes 5 stars doesn't need fancy stuff, fancy menu, fancy service or fancy food. Sometimes 5 stars is just a perfectly made margharita pie, all from scratch, a quiet Saturday afternoon, OSU game on TV, that indescribable smell of fresh baking filling your being, and you know it's going to be good, and it's the best late lunch decision you made. read more

I always feel bad when I have to write a less than amazing review... however how else will the public know?? Anyways, I was sooo disappointed with Bridge Street. A cpl good things: the guy who took my carry out order was very nice and the pizza was ready in a reasonable amount of time (25 minutes), and was hot. There were a few tables inside for you to eat if you wanted! Rundown: I ordered a medium cheese pizza and a small order of killer breadsticks. When I ordered the breadsticks he asked if I wanted to "add cheese" to them... I said sure! The bad: I ordered the breadsticks bc of the other twisty bread pics I had seen ppl post-looked yummy! However, when I opened my box to see my twisty breadsticks topped with cheese... surprise! It wasn't breadsticks at all! It looked like a thin crust white pizza, cut into small rectangle strips. Some might call this cheesy bread, but why would I think that's what I was getting when I opted to add cheese to their normal breadsticks? ‍ they were garlicky, buttery, cheesy, but nothing special. I wish I could now tell you all the good things about the pizza, but I can't. I expected they're "hand tossed" pizza to have a little more substance. It was thin pretty soft, not a lot of chew. Overall it was very bland. I could barely taste the sauce. Also the sauce for the breadsticks was lacking flavor. There was a fine amount of cheese, but the grease flavor was overwhelming. Would not get again unfortunately. read more

Bridge Street Pizza - Medium cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Was super good. Great service. There was a lot of options for food they had subs pizza