I used to come here a lot with my mom as a kid, but hadn't had it since. My friend and I stopped in after visiting some family friends in the area. The workers were super friendly and helpful as we made our decision. We got a large pepperoni with hot honey and garlic butter crust. we also ordered the corn nuggets. This pizza was amazing. Like so damn good. Please go and try it. They also gave us a good movie recommendation so we went home enjoyed our pizza and watched Harold and kumar go to White Castle. Super excited to come back and try other options. read more

The food and service were amazing. This is a Gem in Columbus. We definitely will be back

We had Carlucci's the other night and it was fantastic. Best mushrooms and mozzarella sticks we've had in a while. The potato skins also were a hit. When we pick up from places the appetizers get soggy by the time we get them home. These were crispy still and the pizza crust was perfect. This will be our go to place for pizza from now on. read more

Amazing pepperoni pizza! Was hot and delicious. Easy order and quickly made. We will be back!

Lived nearby for a few years and we decided to check them out finally and this pizza joint is our new favorite go to for pizza night! The food is good and they staff is friendly. The prices are pretty decent too read more

I ordered the Mexican pizza. It was absolutely disgusting! The crust was paper thin and the ingredients were worse. Sure could find any meat at all. I would have been better off buying a frozen pizza from the grocery store! Save your money. read more

After reading another persons review, we ordered from Carlucci's Pizza and they did not disappoint! I ordered the fried mushrooms with the horsey sauce. Very good!! They are portobello mushrooms, which fry up differently than your traditional mushrooms. Again, they were VERY good, not greasy at all. Their pizza was very good also! Crispy crust, which is hard to do when they are delivering it. Good flavors! They also sent plates and napkins which came in handy since we were at a hotel. :) Very nice people and great food!!! Sorry, forgot to take pictures:( read more

These guys are so good! Their pizza is thin crust, plenty of toppings and cheese, great flavor and endless options! They wings are also big and plump and juicy. Their pepperoni cups are genius! You get about 100 ( I may be exaggerating!) cooked pepperonis. Simple but mighty tasty! I've only ever ordered this as delivery so I can't speak to the atmosphere or service but we always get our delivery either as or before expected. Great alternative to national chains. Most certainly will order again and again. Yum! read more

See all

As carryout pizza goes, this is one of the good ones. Family owned, good service and consistent pizza.

I stopped in to order a pizza and take it on my way. Their pizza is very good. Tavern-style with a crispy crust. The order took about 30 mins but well worth the wait. This is my speed. A high recommend. Please note they have some seating but this is really a delivery/take out place. read more

Carlucci's Pizzeria - All meats - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

I'm impressed, Carlucci's! I've had countless "Supreme" or "Deluxe" pizzas in Columbus, and they're all pretty much the same quality. There's something about Carlucci's version of a Deluxe that sets it apart. The toppings were generous and delicious. I don't even like mushrooms, but they blended in well with the pepperoni, onions and green peppers. Shout out to the sausage for being the MVP ingredient. This was my first time going to Carlucci's, and I would go back to try additional pizzas - like their Super Deluxe! read more

**Columbus Trip** Location; small location in within a small strip mall, but super friendly and appears like a locale favorite. If you are close and looking for a spot to make a usual, this is it. Food; Ordered a Stromboli, with Jalapenos and Pepperoni and may be one of the best ones I have tried, it was huge enough to share. Cooked to perfection, with enough of the ingredients to make it just perfect. Must order Service; we did a pick up, but the counter staff was very friendly. read more

Carlucci's Pizzeria is one of my absolute favorite restaurants ever. There are many places in Central Ohio to get good pizza and Carlucci's is one of the very best. There used to be a Carlucci's Pizzeria location a few blocks from my house in Dublin, but that location closed during the pandemic. I was devastated when the Dublin restaurant closed because we had dinner from there at least once a week. Now, we drive 25 minutes each way to pickup pizza, Stromboli, and salad with fresh made Ranch Dressing - it's worth every minute and mile traveled. Carlucci's uses old world pepperoni, finely ground sausage, great quality cheese, and a perfectly seasoned pizza sauce. If you are a fan of thin crust pizza, you MUST try Carlucci's. I truly do not like sausage, but I order pepperoni and sausage every time because it is finely ground or chopped instead of a big hunk. The flavor and texture of the sausage at Carlucci's cannot be improved upon. It is perfect! The Stromboli is outstanding, too. There are two sizes of Stromboli, but do yourself a favor and get the large. You'll thank me later. It's just as good 2 or 3 days later when I reheat it in my air fryer. Carlucci's is a sisters owned business and the only location is in Powell on Smoky Row Road. The staff has always been friendly and professional. They have specials on certain nights of the week and their prices are reasonable even at full price. Amazing! read more

See all

We recently ordered two large pizzas for takeout, and we were blown away by how good they were. One pizza was half Hawaiian and half Deluxe White, while the other was half BBQ Chicken and half create your own (Pepperoni, Banana Pepper, Hot Honey Drizzle). The crust was perfectly crispy, the toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the combinations of flavors were creative and exciting. We also ordered a Tossed Salad to share and all the prices were reasonable. Highly recommend Carlucci's Pizzeria for delicious, thin-crust pizza! Also their Calzones looked amazing, will definitely be trying the next time we order! read more

See all

Got carry out and it was on time a AMAZING!!!! Guess he is the owner, man working the oven and register was a genuine great friendly guy! The pizza was just outstanding! Made our night. Couldn't get a pic very a piece got taken from the box! Deck oven is key it's a very out place fyi. Or eat it in your car you won't be sorry read more

Carlucci's Pizzeria - 15" pepperoni and mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

Sad to say my food disappeared before my camera could bust out! Try the fried mushrooms, ohhhhhhhhmigoodness, they are so dang good! They are huge, perfectly coated and super juicy inside. The staff is always friendly and keeps the interior up nicely. You really can't go wrong with anything on the menu. read more

My go-to pizza each and every time. I've tried so many different variations of their pizza and have enjoyed every one. My favorites are the 'Sisters Favorite' and 'Hot Boss'. Their fried mushrooms are randomly the best I've ever had, w/ thick slices of meaty savory (portobello?) mushroom tossed in breadcrumbs and fried perfectly crisp; I get their horseradish sauce for dipping em and it's just delicious Their chocolate chip cookies are fresh baked to order and delicious. Enjoy read more

Delicious food! Pizza great quality ingredients ! Even delivered , pizza arrived hot and fresh ! Highly recommend !

Our first time ordering from here (I've heard so much about it over the last few years ) probably because of our location. Tucked in a strip Mall with Ange's pizza and the bar The Filling Station. Only a few tables In the restaurant as this is a carry out location. Typically my husband asks to Get the crust well done. We decided not to ask since it was our first time and to his surprise he thoroughly enjoyed it and didn't have to extra bake! Their specialty pizzas are great as well. We got half and half. I absolutely loved the pepperoni, they use the old World ones which I like much better than normal ones. Unfortunately they do not deliver to our area (bummer) making this a reason we have not indulged in this awesome pizza before. Looking forward for a second return . We are pretty basic with our pizzas so Generally only get pepperoni or cheese. This is definitely one of my new favorite pizza joints! read more

Carlucci's Pizzeria - Pepperoni well done. We couldn't make it home wit out eating it - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

Best Stromboli in Town, convince me otherwise. I'm not kidding. No matter what kind of pizza or wings you order, you always need to get the Stromboli. It comes with a mega container of sauce. Perfect for dunking every piece. We eat here once a month. Always a family favorite. read more

See all

Found out about Carlucci's from the Ohio Pizza Party (OPP) food review channel on Youtube. So after leaving the lights at the zoo, we gave them a try. I can honestly say that they make a quality pie, I am not the biggest fan of extremely thing crusts, but the toppings they use make up for the cracker-like crust. We got a sausage and pep and the flavors were really satisfying. If they made the crust a little thicker, they would get a 5 all day! Pizza 1-5=4. read more

Damn good pizza! First time here. Got a cheese pizza and a pepperoni pizza.I think the best pepperoni I have ever had. That cracker thin crust was my favorite, even reheated. I loved when I walked in and was greeted with several hellos from the Carlucci team. what a great place. will definitely be back read more

Carlucci's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

Busy place, everyone working like crazy and a lot of care going into the product as I put in a late order on a busy night and hung around to watch. Good pizza, but the crust style is not my favorite though it is clearly the favorite of many. I am going back to get a Stromboli to try as they looked amazing. Still five stars because my crust preference isn't a reflection on what Carlucci's could control. Nice to see a local business thriving. read more

Very much like Tommy's pizza from Arlington. Thin and crunchy crust, that is not burned. Zesty but not over powering sauce and toppings that are deliciously fresh. Good job girls. read more

We ordered pizza here for the first time. Delivery was on time and everyone enjoyed it. The crust was good

Service was great. We ordered two medium speciality pizza for three of us. Very tasty and plenty of leftovers!

The best pizza around! I tried it when my family was in from Dallas. They are very particular about their pizza, and they absolutely love it. The Sister Favorite is unique and delicious, and there are many other great selections. read more

Love the pizza and Stromboli here! Service is always incredible. Always recommend to friends in the area.

I rarely write reviews, but the staff at Carlucci's was so friendly I knew that if we liked the food, I needed to pay them back. This was our first time trying Carlucci's and my husband's first time trying a calzone. He was not enthused with my description of calzones so he ordered a pizza, but when we sat down to eat, he finished THE ENTIRE veggie calzone. As you can see, they provided a ton of sauce to go with the calzone and it was very easy to customize online. The pizza was your typical thin crust, but also delicious. We will be back :) read more

Carlucci's Pizzeria - Calzone and pizza - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

It's mostly a takeout place but there are a few tables and we were a little hungry and chose to dine in rather than drive 30 minutes home to eat. I liked the tossed salads, they were simple but fresh. Deluxe pizza was great - crispy crust, savory sauce and evenly distributed toppings. We'll try the Stromboli next time! read more

One of the best pizza and stromboli places in the Columbus area. I used to come here like one a week and make a point to come here every time I visit. The best stromboli is their house stromboli with no onions. It's great because usually pizza places don't serve good sauce with stromboli but this sauce is some of the best in the world. read more

I ordered with roughly 2O min to go before closing time.. not typically what I'd do but I trust them and they're almost always good to us... TONIGHT... the ball was dropped... Threw toppings all over my pizza... my Potato skins were awful and they almost always do a great job!!!! You guys sucked tonight... I'll take my talents to Angies for "sub par" pizza moving forward since you guys wanna be fucking Lazy as fuck.. Do your job until your shift is over, fuckers. Ryan Richardson is my name for any questions, comments, or concerns. ‍ read more

Carlucci's Pizzeria - Some weak ass potatoe skins - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

This is a review for the NEW DUBLIN location (They assumed the old Creno Pizza Shop). Great pepperoni pizza, good crust and sauce. I like it a lot better than the local thin crust favorite. This reminds me of great Youngstown pizza. We also got the chicken parmesan and it was respectable. I will definitely be back to try the specialty pizzas. They have a Monday $9.99 1-topping that makes it pretty easy to try them out. The staff was friendly and eager to promote their new business. FYI: this is take out only. read more

Carlucci's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

Great Pizza!! We were in town for a music festival and late night checked this place out. It was some of the best pizza we have had in years! read more

Great pizza! Very generous on toppings and great flaky crust. Friendly staff-- a lot of regulars! read more

Carlucci's Pizzeria - Large pizza, half pep & half lotta meat - very delicious!! - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio

Classic Columbus style pizza. One of my go to places in this area for pizza. They're usually pretty quick for carry out too

Great pizza! When I saw the pepperoni pizza on the web page I had high hopes for the quality of the pepperoni. I was not disappointed. We also got a mushroom pizza. It was also tasty. read more

I'll be honest...I have never had better customer service at a pizza place. I got a pick up order and showed up a bit early, but it was their every intention on getting me my order and out the door...I was thoroughly impressed. And I got smiles from the staff too! That's huge in my book. Plus - the pizza is AMAZING. The sauce is outstanding. I'm not going to elaborate because everyone should go try this pizza! Great job, guys. read more

Holy lord, this is is the best pizza I've ever had in my life. Other pizza is kinda terrible in comparison. I have had other pizza since this that I used to enjoy, but no longer. read more

Dropped in to place an order for carryout. Carlucci's business is primarily carry-out and delivery. Although they have a few seats inside, dine-in is not an emphasis of the business. Carlucci's is located in a small strip mall along Smokey Row. The parking lot has seen better days. The parking lot can become quite busy from its shared neighbors. These buildings have been around for a while. Carlucci's is a great locally owned business. The energy inside was welcoming, upbeat and neighborly. These folks take pride and enjoy making pizza for their customers. The atmosphere did catch me off guard a bit and made me feel at home. On one side is a large refrigerator full of different drink options. In the center is a table with about six seats and covered with a red and which checkered tablecloth. Signage over the order counter displays their menu and prices. I was greeted warmly. They offer four different pizza sizes, 11", 13", 15" and 17". As with most places, they do offer a number of pizza specials or you can custom build your own. Although the Stromboli peaked my interest, but I went for a medium veggie pizza. Surprisingly, they allowed me to substitute items. I replaced the banana peppers for black olives. Most places have not allowed me to do that so I end up doing a custom pizza instead. Their pizza was prepared with fresh ingredients, covered edge to edge and dusted with parmesan cheese. The crust was thin and crispy cracker like. I loved it. Definitely will give them another go again. read more

Carlucci's Pizzeria - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Powell, Ohio