Ordered a large pizza for 24.45 undercooked , now I know why it took me almost a year to order another one, But Never again.​ read more

Bexley Pizza Plus - Doughy and undercooked pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Id give it 6/10. Got the Hawaiian. It was just plain. Wasn't anything special. The service was amazing. Quick and easy. Was ready when we walked in for pickup. The place as clean and quiet. Busy. Pizza is pizza. read more

I llllove a good Margherita pizza, and Bexley Pizza Plus didnt let me down. Chill vibe here, sat outside and enjoyed my pie (doused in parmesano and chili flakes ofc ). They made it fast and brought it out to me, thanks guys! read more

Bexley Pizza Plus - 8" Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Best pizza in Columbus! Delivery is great! I always have to remember to ask them to pie slice my pizza not in little squares. They also have the best brownies! read more

Walked in and was greeted first thing by multiple gentlemen. They have a cute small dining area that had 2 TVs and a fountain soda machine. Let me tell you that they have some of the most interesting pizzas I've heard of. My husband and I tried the carbonara pizza and it was amazing. The crust is fresh and homemade and had a nice crunch to it, but not overly burnt tasting like some places. We also had a Felix chef salad which the toppings on the pizza and salad were not lacking at all. My son had a sub and said it was really good too! Overall great pizza and great experience Would recommend and visit again read more

Over priced !!! Charging 1095 for a small side salad calling it. A chef salad literally had three pepperonis, three tomatoes and a pinch of black olives what a joke read more

The delivery was smooth, even gave tips to reheat the pizza. It made me feel very good.

This is one of my go-to places for pizza and for meeting with a friend or two for lunch -- lots of sitting space, no rushing, and good parking. As for the pizza, I've tried both plain cheese and several different topping combinations, all of them great -- tasty, well placed, not over- or under-stuffed, with a good chewy-but-light crust. I keep going back over and over. read more

Great food! The pizza is Amazing!!! Great service! Delivery is awesome too. Their drivers are quick and extremely nice.

Love the pizza. Everything about it tastes great. I believe that the flavor of the sause is unique. I wish they would stay open later. read more

Small pizza shop with a wide array of toppings. We enjoyed the cheesy garlic bread, sausage and pineapple pizza, plus a chicken florentine. Having the variety of flavors worked well. I'm glad i decided to stop here on my pizza trail! read more

I am so disappointed with Bexley Pizza, I ordered a peperoni pizza that had very little peperoni on the LARGE PIZZA they admitted that they cut back on the ingredients and upped the price. That used to be my favorite pizza place, but no more. read more

Ordered around 8:50 PM and was told they'd have it ready shortly but they close at 9PM as opposed to whats on Google/Yelp. I told them if it was too late to order it wasn't a problem but they assured me it wasn't and again they'd have it ready shortly. I was very happy with the service provided and the pizza itself was great and will definitely be ordering again in the future! read more

Came here around 8 to find they were already closing the inside and only serving take out. I was excited to try some Columbus style pizza so I happily took my order to go. Got and 8" pizza and a salad. Pizza was delicous, would highly recommend, the crust is the perfect crispy thin and the toppings were plenty. I'd pass on their salads. The salad itself didn't match the menu description, it was missing a lot of ingredients and the salad dressing wasn't very good. read more

See all

Had an amazing experience at Bexley Pizza Plus, tonight. Ordered a meatball sub, over the phone, easy, friendly service. Picked up in about 10 mins on a Saturday evening. Food was spectacular, portion was large, sauce was so good. Pizza is good but don't sleep on the subs! read more

Thicker crust than most "Columbus Style" places. Good pizza, super friendly staff. Good stop on the Columbus pizza trail. Got the kids the basic cheese (Not the 6 cheese), they loved it read more

Bexley Pizza Plus - Small Greek work no olives - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Plus: Hot, fresh, with very minimal grease. For a thicker style crust, it is very light (almost too light, lacks some needed density) & crisp. The ingredients are fresh & the toppings were an adequate quantity (they don't skimp nor do they overload it). Closer to 4 stars then 2. Minus: Nothing special to write home about or leave you dreaming of your next visit. While fresh, the sauce is in need of that signature touch that most popular pizza joints stand on, I struggled to find any real flavor separation. The cheese was also low on the flavor meter. Overall an above average, decent, hot & fresh pizza that is definitely worth trying, but it wont make any "top 3 lists" in my opinion. Service: Fast & friendly. Both the dining room & bathroom were clean. read more

Bexley Pizza Plus - Medium 12 " Pepperoni (parmesan from the table shaker). - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Today went for lunch. I ordered the 8" one topping pizza with a beverage for $5.50. The pizza was ready when I got there, although I was probably 3minutes late. The taste was good and there was ample amount of the one topping. read more

Bexley Pizza Plus - 8" pizza with onions - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I LOVE pizza and try to get to as many different places as I can! I drove out to Bexley to give this pizza joint a try. It did not dissapoint! I just gota small pepperoni pie and I loved it. It Putney in the mind of the pizza you get at a fair, but even better. Good in its own unique way. Can't wait to go back. read more

Bexley Pizza Plus - Individual pep n cheese ... delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

A Bexley original and always a great lunch. Pizza and sandwiches always delivered with a smile. Seems that most people do carry out but decent dining room. Service is no frills but hospitable. read more

Subs that taste so great, I'm going back for more! And the price less than $4 for a six inch? Awesome! The only problem I have is I have to buy two subs to combine into one because they skim so much on the meat and cheese. It's 75-80% bun, lettuce, and dressing. Not sure if they have always been that way or if it's a Covid cutback. I'm going back anyway. So good! read more

I first heard of Bexley's from the Food Network. I just had to try it the first chance I got to Columbus. The town of Bexley is cute and quaint. The restaurant is not very big and was super busy when I went. We ordered a 14" pepperoni and mushroom, green pepper, brocoli pizza. The crust was very good. It was crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. The sauce was a tad bland for my taste, but the veggies were fresh and made the pizza delicious. read more

See all

BPP has Bexley's best pizza, which is a tough call because Rubino's - another Bexley icon- is right next dOor. We like the easy parking, the casual family-friendly dining (small, no-nonsense) and of course the specialty pizzas. Mega Meat is our favorite, but they have about 12 that are great combinations. The salads are easy to throw-in so you feel a little healthy. read more

Nice cozy atmosphere, very friendly staff. Far better than houndogs pizza, so if you are downtown cone here instead, they will treat you right! see my other review. And wow you talk about some fresh basil, you would have thought it was hand picked off a plant, very fresh ingredients. It was my first time here, I will definitely tell my friends, and will be back. read more

Bexley Pizza Plus - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

So I have not been to Bexley in probably 15 years. I was really looking forward to going to Rubino's pizza that is next door, a true landmark. Unfortunately I was there with my family on a Monday, the only day Rubino's is closed. So right next door there is Bexley Pizza. Who opens a pizza place next to another pizza place? Anyway, we went in and ordered two large pizza. One large pepperoni and one large margherita. Both pizzas were just OK at best, very little taste, very little zest or salt or flavor. I had to apply generous portions of parmesan, red pepper flakes, and salt. Price was also way of point, around $55 for two pies. read more

Pizza was decent, it's a mix of Detroit style and Columbus style, so a slightly breadier version compared to the traditional square cut slices. The sauce was VERY light, which was disappointing. We tried a few different pizzas, including Margaretia, Meat Lovers, and Loraine. Of these meat lovers was the best, but overall just acceptable considering price. It's very pricey - and the website has outdated pricing info, so be prepared to pay $2 more. read more

I don't like to be negative. And because of that, I keep trying the pizza here thinking it will improve. I know lots of people who prefer it as their favorite Bexley pizza. It isn't bad. The toppings are all fresh. It's just my opinion that the crust borders between thin and thick in an awkward middle-ground and the sauce doesn't taste like a whole lot. Put simply, it just isn't anywhere near the delicious pizza next door at Rubinos. Because the two are so close together, it is hard not to compare them when ordering a pizza. Having eaten here several times, I thought about what brought me there, and realized that there are a few pros. - In the summer, if you want to dine-in, there is air conditioning, whereas Rubinos reaches what feels like 100 degrees. Simple choice. - If you want your pizza delivered, this is your option. I can recall many Bexley pizza parties with their pizza, mostly because they will bring it to your door, and in a box, whereas Rubinos has pickup only and wraps it in a tented bag, making it impossible to stack multiple pizzas for, say, a party. - Everyone working there is very nice and the place is clean and new. Rubino's is a bit more rough around the edges, but heck, that one's going to be up to you. These are just my thoughts. Changes are very good that I will be at party with their pizza or friends will insist on going there, and I will do so without protest. It's not worth avoiding, but not one that I will seek out, personally. read more

All the while Covid-19 has been goin on they never disappoint. Date day with my love and never disappointed! Please keep up the great service. read more

Love this place. The lunch special is perfect and service fast. A bit small inside but thats cozy and fun. I really love the pizzas. read more

Bexley Pizza Plus - Lunch sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I hate to say it, but Bexley Pizza Plus might just make the best pie in the city. With its silly name, I figured Bexley Pizza Plus must be shady as heck -- like on par with Little Caesars or something. Boy, was I wrong. They offer up an array of specialty pizzas. Some the most interesting (to me) included Lorraine (spinach, bacon, onion and swiss), Primavera Plus (artichoke hearts, spinach, Roma tomatoes, fresh garlic and fresh basil) and Greek (artichoke hearts, black olives, sun-dried tomatoes and feta). I tried the Maximum Pep, which featured two types of pepperoni on a thick-ish crust. The outside was so crunchy and the inside was so soft Awesome! I dig their lunch specials too. $5.60 for a fresh 8-inch pie and a soda can't be beat. They have a decent beer selection to boot. This is a great place to stop and eat some pizza. read more

Bexley Pizza Plus - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great pizza! We always get the Farmers Market, Veggie or Plain and it's great. They aren't stingy on the toppings and the quality is good, very fresh. We have also gotten delivery before and they've been pretty good. We once got our pizza and it must've been held sideways or something because all the cheese fell off to the side and wasn't on. But we called and they immediately sent a replacement quickly and it was perfect we were thrilled with how they handled it. They lose 1 star for staff. The girl at the counter isn't friendly and for some reason every time I go for pickup she's sick, I don't know who let's her come to work sick but cmon that's unacceptable at a food place. Also they will quote you 20 minutes and will take their time so keep that in mind. read more

Bexley Pizza Plus - Half Cheese Half Mushroom/Banana Pepper/green pepper. The cheese wasn't fantastic but the veggie part was great. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Have to downgrade my rating. Their delivery area is very limited. I'm less than 1 1/2 miles away and they won't deliver here. I'm trying other pizza places for now. Previously- Really tasty pizza. The crust is fresh. Not too thick, not too thin. Crispy and soft. We had the ultimate pizza - great if you love pepperoni and mushrooms. We will be ordering here again. read more

The guys behind the counter were great. Pizza came out quick. Had a small sausage pepperoni onions. Crust was crispy which I liked. Sauce had a great flavor. Great pizza for the money. I would recommend it for anyone any time. read more

Bexley Pizza Plus - First time here. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The ultimate is what pepperoni and mushroom pizza dreams are made of!! Very good pizza that is clearly made with high-quality ingredients. Made in the style of many traditional Columbus area pizza shops with a thin and crispy crust. However, the crust is much more fluffy and lighter on the inside than others. Very good and I can't wait to come back! read more

One if my favorites. Don't sleep on this place. Yeah a basic pepperoni is delicious but some of the specialty ones are just amazing too, like the CO2 which has sausage, caramelized onions, and fresh basil... sooo good! I've had the pleasure of meeting the owners too. They're phenomenal people who support their community and live literally a block away from their shop so it's near and dear to their heart and they take great pride in it. read more

I'm a man of freight words. Damn good Pizza Crust Perfect mix between thin and semi thick read more

Great pizza! Best in Bexley! Had a wonderful experience with my Grandma and family. Truly a local gem, if you have not been i highly recommend. read more

Yep, this is your "go to place" for your pizza appetite !!! THIER pepperoni pizza and cheese pizza are what a good pizza should be in my honest opinion; Fresh, non-greasy, Flavorful, chewy center with a crisp crust, YUM and just the right amount of sauce, I can't count how many times I have order pizza here in C-bus that you can barely tell it is even on it.., and it's a regular pizza, no specialty pizza. I am new to the area and so happy to have found this place:)) read more

There's nothing really spectacular about Bexley Pizza Plus. It's decent when you're hungry. It's definitely pizza but it never makes me wishing for more. read more

Boyfriend and I carried out a medium pizza and Italian sub. We were too hungry to take pictures. This was my first time trying their food. The pizza was a little bit thicker crust than a thin but was fresh, hot, and crisp. We chose pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, banana peppers, extra sauce, and oregano sprinkled on top. Lots of toppings edge to edge! After a few pieces I then tackled my half of the sub. The bread has a nice flavor but there was a lot of it compared to the amount of toppings on it. I really did not taste much Italian dressing on it. It was really good though and I would not mind eating this again. read more