Delicious pepperoni pizza and stuffed garlic bread! Crispy bacon and crispy crust just the way I love my pizza. Lucky I got to snag a piece during a local event and thankful I did! I can't wait to come back here again read more

Rotolo's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza and Garlic Bread with Provolone Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Columbus has no shortage of pizza options and popular brands. If that's your jam, cool. But for those like me who enjoy a local, family-owned creator of our pies, Rotolo's is near the top of the list. I've had the pepperoni slices and shared an Everything pizza, and I recommend both! Even more recommended are the Palloncini - cheesy bread bites with pizza sauce. When it comes to the staples, Rotolo's does it right. read more

Rotolo's Pizza - Tutto (Everything Pizza) - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Save your money - your food won't even show up. They'll be happy to keep your money and a tip though. Then after 3 hours they'll not even answer the phone and leave you hanging. Don't get donatos either - they don't believe pizza should be cooked all the way around here for some reason.. grandads is the only choice left read more

Best pizza in Columbus. Don't go anywhere else. All you need is one slice and you'll know I'm right.

First pizza is great. I love there pizza. Itilain sub was good. Great flavor , perfect amount of toppings and well cooked. Service is ok , sometimes them seem annoyed when you call and order but the food makes up for it. Def a place we get often read more

Rotolo's Pizza - Half pep half deluxe. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Haven't had for years, but remember it as delish. It's nice and cheesy. I used to go there after work.

I picked up some pizza and bread twists from Rotolo's one evening. They have a slick online ordering system and my order was ready on time. The "Palloncini" were cheese-filled bread twists and they were really tasty. The appetizer wasn't too garlicky and I was happy with the generous portion size and dipping sauce. My boyfriend loves Hawaiian pizza and he was happy with Rotolo's version thereof. The large pizza was plenty for a group of 4 and the crust and cheese were tasty. Overall, Rotolo's isn't a bad spot for Ohio-style pizza. read more

Rotolo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Visited a friend in the Grandview Heights Area this weekend and wanted to order some pizza. He suggested Rotolo's, and we were not disappointed! We ordered pickup of a pizza and tossed salad. Food was ready early, and the pizza was piping hot. Salad was fresh and delicious. Highly recommended! read more

Favorite pizza place in town. Don't live close anymore but still swing by when I'm in the area. I always go with pepperoni with extra sauce. If you're a pizza fan and you haven't tried Rotolo's yet, you really should. read more

I can confirm these are the cheesiest Pizzas I have ever see and tasted, but something really really catch my eye and heart is that I ordered a family Spaguettis with meat sauce. OMG! You are not wrong with this Pizzeria. Only take out no dinning inn. read more

See all

Wow! If you want a flavorful delicious original Italian pizza, this is your only stop! I cannot say enough how great this is. You have to try it for yourself. The people here are amazing too! You will not be dissatisfied and I will definitely be coming back in!! Thank you! read more

Rotolo's Pizza - Papa Rotolo 's Everything Pizza Papa Rotolo 's Chef Salad - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This was my first time at Rotolo's and I ordered a medium pepperoni pizza with banana peppers on half. The flavor was good but the cheese was puddled in the middle of the pie and there was no cheese on some of the outer pieces. Also much of the crust as burnt and several pieces only had one lonely piece of pepperoni. A little disappointed but would probably go back. Only next time I would ask them to evenly distribute the toppings and not burn the crust read more

Rotolo's Pizza - One pepperoni on some pieces, puddled cheese in middle, no cheese on some pieces and partially burnt - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

In a town that has the best pizza in the United States Rotolos is the best. And that is saying something. Never a bad pizza. Never thought I would like a pizza as much as Planks but rotolos did it. P read more

Leonardo's Pizza's reopening prompted me to revisit another old classic pizza place - Rotolo's. I checked out their original location here in Grandview about a week ago. It's been years since my last visit and now? I'm a fan again. Medium Mushroom for $11.75. Came with plenty of cheese and mushrooms, although they could have used a little more mushrooms. It has a really great tasting crust which was a combination of chewy and crispy. It's that crust where you get the crunch on the outside and then the chewiness is inside. A rich, fresh tasting tomato sauce rounded out the pie that was cut into squares, as it should be. 15 minutes from call in to pick up. (carry out only) Hot and steamy - I couldn't wait to get home. Another Columbus Classic Pizza and a solid choice. read more

See all

Rotolo's was way way back in my history books of pizza. At the urging of our fearless YELP* leader, Jayme, encouraging take-out on April 11 Rotolo's hit the spot. The choices were; (a) VERDURA - veggie pizza medium; (b) MAMA Rotolo's tossed salad with vinagarette and; (c) Veggie sub. Pick-up time was 25 minutes and I arrived to a piping hot array of food. Back home things were divvied up and the eating fun began. I have been missing out on Rotolo's tasty cheese and full range of fixins. Even though I went full veggie across the board everything was delicious. Way to go, ROTOLO'S! Covid-19? Kiss my backside of The Moon! read more

See all

They catered my daughters bridal shower. Food was excellent, hot and delivered on time. We ordered lesagna with meat sauce, meatless rigatoni with meatballs on the side ( those went first!), salad and bread ( which arrived warm). Comments were all positive from the attendees and we were happy to have leftovers for the next day! Definitely a place to order good italian food. This is a family owned small business you will want to support! read more

My friend brought me some pizza from here and it was delicious I mean outstanding. Can't wait to try it again.

I remembered going to Rotolo's on 5th Ave., when I worked in the area 25 years ago. It's still a carry out in the same location, but a bit better looking. Unfortunately the pizza is not better. I had heard that what made the pizza so good in the old days was a Vulcan oven. That must have aged out of use, and sad to say, the pizza dough was awful--dry and hard around the outer 2 inch perimeter. Too bad. It used to be so very good. read more

sauce isn't that canned stuff! They catered our new year's eve dinner at work and if this is what they cater, I can't wait to go in person! Very delicious read more

Rotolo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Used to love their pizza. Got it last night and was disappointed. The sub was good, salad was old iceberg, pizza was doughy and toppings were skimpy. read more

3/5 Stars for me. I stopped in late on a Thursday evening. The staff was beyond friendly and welcoming. I ordered my pizza waited 15 minutes and was on my way. (Good Clean fun) I've heard great things about Rotolo's so I think that jaded my score here. If I were honest if just seemed like regular pub/ bar Pizza to me. I had heard so much about their sauce, but I didn't think it was amazing. Disappointed for sure. Giving a 3/5 because although I wasn't in love with the pizza they had good customer service. read more

First experience was great. But today as a second big order was HORRIBLE. Just uploaded pictures of a big order we purchased. It was delivered all bad. They would not take the blame. The driver was female holding pizzas on both sides of her. She clearly dropped them. Thanks for nothing. Will not be back. read more

Rotolos what can I say, this establishment is the best pizza I've ever had. Ricky the manager on shift blessed my pizza. I've never had my flavor palette fulfilled in such a way. I've had dreams the last few nights of that crisp, tasty, scrumptious pizza. The effort ricky puts in is unmatched. read more

STILL THE BEST ...!!! My parents used to bring us here in the mid-1970's when I was a child. I loved Rotolo's pizza then, and I still love it now. Maybe I even love it even a little more now because I'm the parent and I get to decide which toppings get ordered, rather than having to compromise with my sisters. :-) The crust is delicious. The sauce is tangy and full of real tomato flavor. The cheese tastes like real mozzarella - salty and cheesy - not that cheap, tasteless stuff so many pizza joints seem to use these days. Toppings are generous. Service is still friendly. Their prices aren't the cheapest, but who wants the cheapest pizza...?!? Instead, I want the best pizza we can find. The location (of this, the original Rotolo's) has never gotten bigger and never changed at all. It still looks exactly the same as it did through my 9 or 10 year old eyes. Love Rotolo's. Love that they have other locations now, too. But love this original location like a fond memory of pizza night with my parents during childhood. STILL THE BEST ...!!! read more

The absolute BEST PIZZA SHOP in Columbus. My husband (Eric - Colorado Mtn Sports) has been eating pizza from this shop since the late '70s. Our family tradition is that we have pizza on almost all game days and every Tuesday :). The ingredients are the highest quality and they don't cheap out on anything. I am extremely surprised that I have not reviewed this pizza shop before. If you're from Columbus and have good taste, check it out. read more

Rotolo's provided amazing catering for those of us who had to work at my company on New Year's Eve and the entire spread was fantastic! If you're looking for a flavorful and authentic taste for Pizza and Pasta, this is the place to find it. read more

Although pricey, Rotolo's is definitely one righteous pizza joint. much has written about how excellent their pizza is, and having eaten there as many times as I have, I can vouch for all of it. Every element of their pizza, from the cheese all the way down to the texture of the crust, is of the highest order of ingredients. What really got me hooked on Rotolo's was the crust, which is tender, chewy, and just garlicky enough to whet your appetite for more every time you bite in to it. The taste is distinct without being overbearing or leading you to believe that you wreak of a pizza shop for days after digging in. On a very rare occasion, I decided to get to share a lasagna dinner with a friend that had eaten pizza far too often in the days leading up to the situation. The meal included bread sticks and a salad and was well worth the 8-9 we paid for it. It's definitely more than enough food for one person, and it was no surprise that it was delicious as well. There was visible grease around the edges of the lasagna, but everything else about it was top notch, just like the pizza. If you're curious about what Rotolo's has to offer, I'd recommend calling in an order on a Tuesday, as they are currently offering large one-topping pizzas for either $10 or $11 dollars. Not a bad deal for one of the best pies in Columbus you'll ever sink your teeth in to! read more

Rotolo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Rotolo's was absolutely incredible! Excellent service and even better food! I got the Rigatoni and let me tell you... I didnt think it was going to be worth $12. but wow! thank you Rotolo's read more

Wow. Just picked up a pep pie from here. Im a picky picky girl, especially with my pizza. This pizza is AMAZING. This crust is incredible, the cheese is abundant and a really good quality cheese. And thank you for not skimping on the sauce!! Thank you! Keep up the great work!!! read more

See all

I will never order from them again. This has time was the third time that the person that took the order has not turned it in. When I arrived on time for the pickup I was told that they could not locate the order. I had to provide proof of the time I called. Then the person taking the order said it was because there were 3 listings with my name and phone number so that was why-I asked how would that make a difference when it was the same name and phone number. The he came back that it was the other person that was new-I asked if he was training him and he said yes -So then I said he should have been checking the orders. He said oh well and wanted to know if I wanted to order/ I said yes an hour ago. I then placed the order with his attitude that it was my fault and waited the additional half hour. When the i guess was the assistant manager handed me my order I explained to him I order at least once a week and would not be returning. His response Ya I know I recognize you. No comp for next time -Nothing taken off the total of the order. I guess the saying the customer is always right is not their motto One gone and many more will not be ordering from them. read more

Had a friend bring this pizza over - we had veggie pizza and a chicken pizza. It's so sad to have to give this low reviews because it is close to being good, but the pizza had almost no sauce at all. Maybe they forgot the sauce on our pizza? Idk, the ingredients tasted like pretty good quality but the lack of sauce just made the pizza pretty bland. read more

had to pull a d*ck move and order really close to closing, they were so nice about it legit A+ service, food was delicious, and again they were so kind and generous! don't forget to tip in cash for service workers!!!! read more

Rotolo's Pizza is a real deal Italian Family Pizza Place. Nothing but the best ingredients and genuine friendly service. The Pizza is legendary good, but I want to write their individual and family size Lasagna, Rigatoni and Chicken Parm. Each dinner comes with salad and bread. The Lasagna is better than most any other Lasagna in this city costing twice the price. read more

I wanted to grab something to eat after my hair appointment at Salon Local. So I looked at maps and saw this place right next door and I love pizza so decided to give it a try. I had never heard of it before but the Yelp pictures looked like my style of pizza. It was pretty good! It's "thin" crust style but it's on the thicker side for thin crust. Perfectly crispy crust and edge pieces. It's definitely one of those places that puts a TON of cheese on the pizza which I already figured based on the pictures. Not sure leftovers will heat up to taste as great as it was fresh (because of the amount of cheese), but I'm sure it will be decent! Good amount of sauce. I got pepperoni and pineapple and I do wish they have put a smidge more pineapple on it. As someone else mentioned some of the edge pieces have less cheese, but honestly it's "crust" and the variety of super cheesy pieces and crispier pieces was nice! I will likely pick up a pizza after every hair appointment now. read more

I love this pizza. It used to be a "special" occasion pizza in college. Back in early (early) 80's and it is still as good today as it was back then !! Employees are so nice and helpful. I'd recommend it. I have not tried anything but the pizza but they have pastas and salads too. read more

This has been my favorite pizza joint until tonight. I regularly drive from Hilliard to West 5th Ave. When I arrived for my pizza tonight, I was informed that they didn't have my order. The young man working the register said that he remembered taking my order. I wasn't offered an apology or a free pizza. When I told him that I had driven all the way from Hilliard, they just looked at me. Rotolos clearly doesn't value my business that I have given them for 20 years. read more

Ordered 7 pizzas from this place. This is how it was delivered. Called them back and told them and they offered a 10% discount on a $131 order. Negotiated to 20% but they would not refund. They really didn't care and the owner was too chicken to take the call. Will never order from this place ever again. read more

See all

This is Italian food. Not made on a conveyor. Not made in three minutes by a robot. I know the Rotolo's history, growing up in the Grandview area. I remember Papa Rotolo teaching his kids the business. This is the standard for all pizza. They have never let me down on any order I have placed. This is a clean restaurant with quality and customer service as its top priority. The people behind the counter are awesome. You can tell they like what they do which is rare. The food awesome. Small batches made by hand. Momma still controls the quality. Dominic watches everything with an eye for quality. Thank god we have this place. You want to know what other restaurants are trying to copy. This is it. We don't live in the area any longer. However when we drove by to my family's house. My fussy eater asked me to stop in. Good thing we ordered a lot. Pizza was spot on. The meatballs, the sauce, the buns, full of flavor. This is the flavor you want in food. Thank you to the Rotolo's family please keep the standards high. And god bless you. read more

Still haven't ordered from this place and never will again! I really feel bad about this b/c like so many that grew up on this local, family owned staple of a business, I have completely lost faith in them. The people that work there seem to have an attitude of disdain for customers. This is NOT what I remember growing up with & it really doesn't work anymore! Was at a friends house that ordered pizza's for 20 people & it was a joke all over again. Can't get away fast enough from the sophomoric crap with this place & with people that work there. Here's a clue; We have money for what you make/ deliver... Try serving others without the arrogant attitude as if we need to kneel down for pizza! read more

Sadly, I've not yet tried their pizza. I did recently order a to-go dinner for a group -- rigatoni with meatballs, bread and a salad. We asked for the meatballs on the side as some folks in the group were vegetarians. Rotolo's, in a moment of hilarious inspiration, put the meatballs on the SIDES of the dish...as in, near the edge. Our vegetarian friends were none too pleased. The food ended up being a mixed bag. The pasta was a tad overdone but good enough. The scandalous meatballs were great. The sauce was simple and tasty. The salad, unfortunately, was just a chopped iceberg and carrot sliver affair. It was likely out of a bag. The dressing was flavorful, though. The bread seemed stale. I'd love to go back and try the pizza...but I won't ask for anything on the side. Who knows what they'll do. read more