Rotolo&#x27;s Pizza

The best vegan pizza I've ever had!! My friends brought me…read morehere during my trip to NY. The ambiance is popping. The service was great and for how busy it was in there, the pizza came out in reasonable time. I can't wait to go back!

First time at Paulie Gee's (I know, late to the game) and holllllly moly. We went on a Sunday right…read morewhen they opened at 3pm and got seated immediately. The Sunday special includes any two pizzas and a salad for $40 and we couldn't pass up this deal! The Caesar salad was absolutely phenomenal, topped with freshly shaved parm and bread crumbs, and mixed with this incredible spicy red pepper that was so delicious, we asked for more on the side. Both pizzas left us speechless as well, I really don't think you can go wrong with whatever you order. Service was great, food was prepared quickly, and there is plenty of seating and a bar area. Can't wait to be back!

Kitchen view

Supreme pizza add hot honey

See all

Fibonacci’s Pizzeria

4.4(41 reviews)

3.7 mi•Clintonville

We came to Grandview Theater to try Fibonacci's pizza while seeing the new Michael Jackson movie…read more We ordered a pizza and one of their sandwiches, which is made using the pizza dough. The sandwich was honestly the highlight of the meal. It was delicious, and the pizza dough as the bread was such a unique touch that you really don't find at many Italian sandwich spots around Columbus. The pizza itself was just okay. As you can see from the picture, the toppings weren't distributed very evenly, so some slices had mostly sauce with barely any cheese while others had way more toppings and cheese but less sauce. I also wish the pizza had been cooked a little longer overall because it was pretty floppy and doughy. One thing that makes it tough is that once the movie starts, it's hard to go back and ask for changes or anything since the theater is packed and getting in and out of the seats feels disruptive. We'll definitely be back to Grandview Theater because we love the experience overall, but next time I'll probably stick to the sandwiches and popcorn and skip the pizza.

A fun option for takeout pizza with lots of options to choose from. That said, I suspect that the…read moreexperience would be enhanced dining in with a drink and a movie. I tried half of the Licensed to Dill which was just okay. Pickles on pizza isn't really my thing. Pesto on pizza wasn't really my thing either, but having half of a an Ecto Pesto changed my mind. Perhaps the chicken and bacon on the pie was what I really liked, but the point is that it all came together surprisingly well. It definitely gave me hope for the more meat-heavy pizza options that I tend to prefer.

2.8 mi•Short North, Italian Village

Bar interior

See all

It's a bar with a movie theatre and pizza place attached? Or is it a theatre with a pizza place and bar? Who knows?

Pie of the Tiger

4.4(45 reviews)

Finding this place took a little effort since it's tucked away in the back of a bar. Once you walk…read morein, you'll spot a small window where you place your order. The food does take some time, so be ready to wait and maybe grab a drink while you hang out. The pizza was really good, but definitely on the heavier side. Wings were decent. Come hungry or bring a few friends so you can share and try more without tapping out too early.

You ever walk into a place and think, there's no way something special is hiding in here?…read more Yeah....That was me. An old tavern in Columbus. Dim. Historic. The kind of spot where you expect a solid beer and maybe some decent bar food. What you don't expect? One of the best Detroit-style pizzas of your life hiding behind a window in the back like some carb-based speakeasy. And when I say hidden, I mean hidden. No flashy signage. No "best pizza in town" ego. Just a quiet little window cranking out square pies that deserve a standing ovation. I ordered the classic red top -- already a bold move -- and added pesto because balance matters and I like to live a little. The result? Beyond reproach. Fresh, loaded toppings. Sauce with depth. And that crust... that beautiful Detroit crust. Crispy edges with that caramelized cheese halo, but still chewy and pillowy inside. The textural contrast is what separates amateurs from legends -- and this? This was legend-level execution. Easily top 3 Detroit-style pizzas I've had. And that's not a casual statement. If you don't understand the life-altering power of true Detroit-style pizza, I regret to inform you... you have not been living. Go find the window in the back. Trust me.

Detroit love.

See all

Pepperoni Pizza

OH Pizza & Brew

3.8(512 reviews)

3.4 mi•Downtown

This pizza joint was right across my hotel that I was staying at so it as a convenient place to…read moregrab a quick bite. I arrived in the evening to grab some take out and the place was empty . They have an open kitchen concept and staff were super friendly. However, we waited quite a long time for our food. I got a small Hawaiian pizza and it took well over 25 minutes for it to be done, especially when there were no other patrons in the restaurant. After getting the pizza the staff were so nice to also give us some ice water. I think I'd give the pizza itself a 3/5 mostly because it was very salty and greasy. However, I did enjoy that there were lots of pineapples on the pizza along with the crispy crust. Having the pizza the next day cold was also okay. Would be interested to know how their other food items are as their menu was pretty big. Staff overall was super nice and friendly. Could use less salt on their pizzas in my opinion though.

While out of town, I needed a late night pie after working all day, so I decided to check out OH…read morePizza & Brew based on a recommendation from a local. When I arrived around 10pm on a Sunday night, the place looked like it was in transition to closing (chairs flipped over on tables, no patrons, staff members watching TV in empty booths). However, I was welcomed in to order by the friendly woman at the counter. She answered a few of my questions and when I asked what her favorite was, she immediately said, "Buckeye Garlic Pizza." I took her advice and was also able to add up to three toppings at no additional charge (mushroom, olive and sausage). I took a seat and waited about 10 minutes for my personal 10" pie, which came out hot and with a friendly, "Thank You, Sweetie." I ran the pie back to my hotel and opened up the box. The pie looked amazing. Perfectly crispy outer crust, six cheeses and garlic, along with my toppings. The pie was pretty damn good, with steam coming off the top. The six-cheese blend was interesting, with the dominant flavors being American and Cheddar. The sausage, olives and mushrooms were all fresh and plentiful. Definitely a good option to satisfy my hunger for a late night pizza in Downtown Columbus.

The salon

The food I was served. Besides the container of Ranch that spilled.

See all

Burnt bottom

Moon Pizza

Such a sleeper hit. Moon Pizza is a non-assuming food truck literally hidden behind an event…read morecenter. You have to know it's there to find it. Service is always excellent, online ordering is easy and the pizza is always ready when they say it will be. But most importantly, the food: what a genius idea to serve the flavors of Northern India in pizza format. Sooo delicious. Our favorites: veg samosas, chicken tikka masala pizza, paneer makhani roll. But we've never been disappointed by anything we've had. The next time you need takeout and can't decide between Indian food and pizza, go ahead and get both!

After an outstanding first trip to Moon Pizza, I had to try them again to see if the magic could be…read morereplicated. The answer is ... mostly. The Samosa Chaat was great. Get it and don't think twice. But the butter chicken pizza just couldn't live up to the Chicken Tikka Masala that blew my mind during my first visit. Fortunately, the always trusty tandoori ranch was on-hand to give the pie a little boost.

Masala Chicken wings

Chicken 65

See all

Vegi Manchurian

Big Daddy Pizza

4.4(9 reviews)

17.3 mi

I want to thank to god and this pure nation for this Amazing pizza joint. SPECTACULAR!!! I think…read moreis not gonna get old any time soon, They don't skimp on the ingredients as you can see on the pic and the flavor is amazing. My only complain is that they told 30 min to pick it up and I had to wait 10 minutes more at the location, totally worthy at the end but be more precise with the waiting time, that's all peace

This place has great pizza! I love the olde world pepperoni flavor…read more I was adventurous and ordered from them, great customer service and reasonable prices.

Pepperoni & jalapenos

Pepperoni pizza

See all

Garlic bread with cheese

Rubino's Pizza

4.3(349 reviews)

7.0 mi

Makes me feel like I went back in time with a "TimeMachine" Delorean*…read moreTalk about OldSkool & basic simple "Good Eats" Very lively place with lotsa OldSkool Charm & Character 4get about it Takes me back to "Little Italy" on Taylor Street in Chicago's Southside Nothing Special here or fancy schmancey Just the vibes & easygoing environment with happy customers eating & conversating. I had a 3 meat pizza with extra cheese ~ Pepperoni, Bacon & Sausage ~ very thin crispy & saucey Pizza that hit the mark with me. Definitely some "Good Eats" & the rest of the Menu look's appetizing. This was my 1st time here & I'll be back for some more. Thank's Familia Rubbino Well Done

Parking is limited. The inside was like time forgot it and you were in the 80's again when you…read morewalked thru the door. CASH ONLY. Service is fine. We were weary due to past reviews. Pizza isn't something you come across elsewhere outside of Columbus or maybe outside of Ohio but it's interesting. We wanted to try this crispy thin crusted pizza at least once so Yelp lead us to this establishment (because of our location during dinner time). We shared a half and half large pizza. No extra cheese but it was suggested when we ordered and after eating the pizza - so get it and I probably advise it. It was fine. Just not something I'm use to and probably wouldn't get again but since we were in Ohio for the first time we wanted to try. *Soda is canned soda only (not fountain).

Inside

Pepperoni pizza

See all

Little Sicily's Pizza House

4.2(197 reviews)

12.7 mi•Southeast

Legit some of the best pizza around the area, have been eating here for many many years. Very…read morefriendly employees and fast service, employee even brought my pizza out to me !

Just had a carryout large 3 item pizza and 1/2 order of Italian garlic cheese loaf. Cheese loaf…read morewas not toasted, had no garlic butter or seasonings so just warm bread with melted cheese. For the pizza, we have eaten here for over 30 years and this was one of the worst pizzas from here. Sauce almost nonexistent, toppings didn't fully cover the crust, some toppings not spread but piles. Could have gotten better pizza elsewhere at much cheaper price. Could be just a Sunday crew issue.

2.1 mi•University District

Where pick up are gotten

Check your box BEFORE leaving.

See all

First timer. Finally.

Adriatico's New York Style Pizza

4.2(403 reviews)

It's been years since I last had this restaurant pizza. Customer service was great and helped me…read moreplace an order over the phone for delivery. Food arrived fast as well hot and fresh! I can say it's a little expensive but worth it. A must try if you in Columbus and want good food locally.

My whole family goes nuts over Adriatico's, and for the longest time I could NOT figure out why it…read morejust completely missed the mark for me. Well... mystery solved. We started with the Parmesan breadsticks and got both the garlic butter and pizza sauce for dipping. I took one bite with the pizza sauce and immediately thought, "Yep. THAT'S IT." Something about their red sauce just does not work for me. It's incredibly thick -- almost like drywall mud -- and while it definitely has flavor, it's just not a flavor my taste buds enjoy. HOWEVER...the breadsticks with the garlic butter?! Some of the best I've had. Seriously delicious. So this time I decided to avoid the red sauce altogether and ordered the chicken pesto pizza. And THAT was the move! It was fantastic. The crust was perfect, the toppings were delicious and plentiful, and the pesto worked so much better for me. My daughter devoured her BBQ chicken pizza, my sister thoroughly enjoyed her six cheese, and those breadsticks were so good that I ordered another batch to take home. Our server was super friendly and efficient and the vibe inside was chill. So after all these years, I can finally say it: I DO like Adriatico's! ...I just have to stay far, far away from that red sauce.

09/17/22

09/17/22 Sicilian Pizza - Mozzarella Cheese, Tomato Sauce, Pepperoni

See all

@endoedibles on Instagram 09/17/22

GoreMade Pizza

4.3(265 reviews)

2.9 mi•Italian Village

Absolutely fantastic pizza!…read more Really great local vibes! Staff was very friendly and attentive. Love the local ingredients and the variety of pizza available. The cheese and the sauce were the stars of the show. We are very excited to go back. This for sure goes on our rotation of local eats.

Tried GoreMade Pizza last month for the first time & I will definitely be going back! Fittingly…read morelocated in Italian Village, the service is quick, staff is friendly & vibes are on point! This is a great spot for take out, a date night, or sharing a pizza with friends! I snuck in on the last day of the month & got to try the Sweet Heat pizza of the month; it was fire!! The pineapple-Gochujang Hot Honey brought this pie to the next level; all of the toppings are great quality, and this was one of the best tasting pizzas I've had in the city! The cheese on the classic cheese was so fresh & the pizzas are cooked great in general! Make sure to get some of their awesome house made ranch too!

Side Salad

See all

Car in outdoor dining section.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Logan B.

15

1

0

6 years ago

Try the palloncini! Once you do, you'll add them to your Rotolo's order from that day forward. They now sell bottles of wine, too, so you can really serve up a good dinner with nothing but Rotolo's food and drink. read more

Christine M.

1

51

78

4 years ago

Delicious pizza that we will definitely be back for more. We got it to go but started eating it on the way home because we couldn't wait!

Michele K.

0

35

0

6 years ago

Was good but their sauce is too spicy for me. The quality of their pizza is very good, homemade stuff; however.

Jennifer S.

1

2

5 years ago

Best pizza ever. Hands down. Always hot and fresh and good and best customer service ever

Jobe G.

5

14

2

10 years ago

Tried again because I can't keep myself away. Perfect pie. Woohoo!

Daniel S.

0

3

0

9 years ago

Simply put....The best pizza ever!

Ryan P.

44

17

15

16 years ago

Fantastic supreme pizza

Joshua H.

12

0

15 years ago

Best pizza ever !!!!

Rotolo's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Columbus, Ohio Restaurants near Rotolo's Pizza

BEST of Columbus, Ohio Coffee near Rotolo's Pizza

BEST of Columbus, Ohio Breakfast near Rotolo's Pizza

BEST of Columbus, Ohio Desserts near Rotolo's Pizza

BEST of Columbus, Ohio Things to Do near Rotolo's Pizza

BEST of Columbus, Ohio Parking near Rotolo's Pizza

BEST of Columbus, Ohio Dinner near Rotolo's Pizza

BEST of Columbus, Ohio Burgers near Rotolo's Pizza

BEST of Columbus, Ohio Shopping near Rotolo's Pizza

BEST of Columbus, Ohio Movie Theatre near Rotolo's Pizza

Best of Columbus

Things to do in Columbus

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Rotolo's Pizza also viewed

Bexley Pizza Plus

3.8

(105 reviews)

Great service and absolutely delicious pizza thank you not greasy, great crust and generous…read moretoppings...we had pineapple & pepperoni. It was so good. Only suggestion is offer some garlic salt on the tables just for people who need a little extra seasoning ...super surprised at some of the bad reviews. I would definitely say everyone thinks they're a professional foodie and or wanna be food influencer with no credentials these days. It's getting quite annoying. I'm a legit local Private chef and this pizza was completely satisfying for my family and I.

Ordered a large pizza for 24.45 undercooked , now I know why it took me almost a year to order…read moreanother one, But Never again.

Panzera's Pizza

3.4

(73 reviews)

Great pizza. Old school pizzeria and ovens. They know how to make a reasonable and traditional…read morepizza.

Another recent find due to Experience Columbus' Pizza Trail. The pizza is really good, with more…read morepepper than you usually get from a pizza place, so it has some nice heat to it, and the cheese is perfectly melty. I did take out, but they also seem to have a nice patio if you want to eat your pizza out of a box outdoors and people-watch. The app they use is fine for ordering and terrible at tracking the actual order status, so if it says your pizza will be ready at a certain time, I would trust that instead of the tracker.

Josie's Pizza

3.8

(41 reviews)

We've lived down the street from Josie's for 21 years. It's never been our favorite but has always…read morebeen decent in a pinch. Well, unfortunately I think I had my last Josie's pizza. Ordered last night and walked to pick it up. Service was friendly. The pizza however was one of the worst I've ever had. Ever. Idk what has happened (new mgmt? different supplier?) The crust was paper thin, bland, and super floppy. I hate to complain about too many toppings but that was the case. Ordered old fashioned pepperoni which are good but just piled on it. And way too much cheese which seemed to be pretty cheap quality as well. Oh, did I mention the crust? So so bad. Like I said. We had a good long run supporting Josie's but I think they've finally tanked. What a shame

Ordering and pick up was easy . Everyone was friendly . Nice little spot tucked away off broad…read morestreet ample parking and the food was superior .

Pizzeria New York

3.9

(58 reviews)

When I moved from Philadelphia, Pizzeria NY was like a taste of home. Authentic NY-style…read morethin-crust pizza. Pepperoni Pinwheels are a meal in themselves. True story - my step-daughter and her husband visited NYC. They tracked down the place that was supposed to have the best slice in New York. "It tasted just like Pizzeria NY," they said.

White pie is incredible! Unfortunately no gluten free options. Staff is great, quick turnaround.read more

Pizza Primo

3.9

(50 reviews)

The staff was nice. The pizza is by far one of the worst pizzas I've ever had. I tried Pizza Primo…read morebecause it is next door to my nail salon. You basically taste nothing but dough. There was barely any sauce, any cheese, any pepperonis and literally only had 15 sausage on the whole pizza. Some slices had zero sausage.

Greatttttt pizza! The kind that is hard to put down. 10/10 Everyone and the owner is truly…read morekindhearted. Great place, highly recommend!

Classic Pizza

3.5

(58 reviews)

So classic pizza of up Sunbury Road in Westerville is a tiny restaurant that puts out some amazing…read morepizzas!!! One would not expect that, but I'm here to tell you they're the real deal. My order is always perfect and the staff is quite delightful. Thank u guys.

You can never go wrong with Classic Pizza! I am always going to order at the OG location.read more

Ange's Pizza

3.5

(68 reviews)

Service 100 % The Spaghetti and meatballs was not worth serving. The garlic bread was lacking…read moregarlic and just a sub bun buttered. Meatball was worse than GFS premium. Sauce ? Absolutely no labor or care went into the creation of this order. It was horrific. Thankfullly the staff had humor. Do not Order this for any reason!!!@

Great quality food. Always delicious! Delivery is spot on & food is always hot. Love Ange's…read moreeverything. The three cheese garlic bread is sooooo good.

Josie's Pizza

4.0

(33 reviews)

I was happy my friend Chris took me to this location. Had this pizza twice in a few days because I…read moredid not know that there were 2 locations. (Sorry for delay review). This one has lovely people working there who treated you like they knew you all their life. Very funny and very kind. The pizza was the same as the other one and I loved every bite! I was updated on the history of this place while we waited and it was fun listening to the story they had to share. I'm going back soon to have this pizza 3 times in 1 week.

Why. Just why? I have never had such a terrible pizza. As a…read moreyelper and pizza enthusiast, I try new pizza everywhere I go. With the higher rating, I was like "heck yeah, let's try it". No joke, it tasted EXACTLY like one of those frozen pizzas you get for a dollar with the super thin cardboard crust. It was just ... sick nasty. It just tasted frozen. Middle school lunch pizza but thinner. 1/10.

Padova's Pizza

3.6

(58 reviews)

It is pretty good pizza. Not top 10…read more Staff is pretty shady. First time I went there, the guy overcharged me on the Pizza cause he thinks I didn't know how much it should be. Next time, I asked him when I called. How much is the pizza to be sure. It's very rundown the website doesn't work. There's no menu posted anywhere. The guy said the menus are on order, but we haven't received them yet. That was months ago still haven't received it.

Food was ok. Not great not memorable just ok Service was ok…read more Ambiance is a take pizza place.

Possum Holler Pizza

3.5

(68 reviews)