I've been eating Plaza Pizza for as long as I can remember. (40+ years!). When I loved in Newark is…read morewas a weekly staple and when I moved to Columbus in 2003 I'd make as many trips as I could just for the pizza. I was worried when ownership changed hands and had heard a few rumors that things had changed drastically. I'd not eaten there since the change but had a major craving this past week. I was happy that I could now order on line ahead of time and even schedule a pickup days in advance(and pay ahead of time).. I had a question and the owners answered me asap and even checked back to see how I enjoyed my pizza. Pickup during this time of social distancing and Covid 19 was a breeze and they'll even bring it to your car if you call them. Pizza review... Pretty damn close to the original taste! That amazing cracker crust... Just enough grease....yum. I did notice a little more spiciness to the sauce but that didn't bother me one bit. I'll be back very soon!!!! Keep up the amazing pizza and service!!

My husband and I have always made it a point to stop at Plaza Pizza whenever we're in Newark…read more Unfortunately, our most recent visit was a huge disappointment. The restaurant just doesn't seem to have recovered since COVID. They no longer offer dine-in service, and all of the tables have been pushed in front of the prep area, so customers can no longer watch the pizzas being made--a feature that used to add to the experience. The condition of the restaurant was concerning. The ceiling tiles were stained and discolored, several were out of place leaving openings to the floor above, and there appeared to be visible mold on ceiling tiles and around the vent above the pizza ovens and prep area. Given the location, it raised concerns for me about sanitation and food safety. The drink cooler was completely empty. When we asked, we were simply told they were out of beverages. We ended up buying drinks from the business next door, where they mentioned that Plaza Pizza customers regularly come there because the pizza shop doesn't have beverages available. The pizza itself wasn't what we remembered. The signature cracker crust that made Plaza Pizza special is gone. It lacked the crisp, fresh texture it once had and instead tasted stale. The bottoms of both pizzas were also dotted with black debris from the oven deck -- the oven decks have been cleaned between pizzas which should be a standard operating procedure. The restaurant was extremely hot inside, and I noticed ingredients such as sauce being kept in containers on the counter rather than in a refrigerated prep table. Having spent many years working in food service, those observations prompted me to review recent Licking County health inspection reports. I found multiple repeat violations that had reportedly remained uncorrected, which made the issues I observed even more concerning. This restaurant used to be one of our favorite stops, and it's disappointing to see how far it has declined. I genuinely hope the owners invest in cleaning, maintenance, and stronger food safety practices because Plaza Pizza was once a local gem. Until then, we'll be taking our business elsewhere.

I really like their pizza! Also their long subs! They are always very nice and quick with my…read moreorder. I call it in and it's ready when they say it will be.

Fuel prices are always at or below the average. Well stocked grocery. Their Pizza and sandwiches…read moreare amazing.

Decent food and reasonable prices made the visit acceptable, but service felt slower than expected…read more The atmosphere was pleasant enough, although nothing especially memorable happened during our dinner together tonight.

Top Shelf Ohio Style pizza. SMALL, not large peperonis and good sausage.. Great fam…read more ily owned business...they deliver to Granville and locally around Alexandria. Delivered to us(2 miles away) on THE coldest night last winter. That says it all. Pizza was hot steaming when we opened the box!!!

Gahanna Pizza Plus is amazing. They are consistently great. They have amazing subs as well…read more. A guy who worked there for years bought the place which I think is really cool. Plus he still delivers pizza, I love his work ethic & how he isn't afraid to do whatever is needed... You won't be disappointed

Been meaning to come here for ages, but we always forget about it till we've already gotten supper…read more Today, storm coming, Sweetie wanted pizza, and this is one of the closest local joints. Called and ordered easily (aside from kitchen noise.) 25 minutes, not bad at 630 on a Friday. They were jumping when I got there. Super friendly and professional. Got our food, headed home, car smelled great. Pizzas looked great. And tasted pretty darn good. K got cheese, said the sauce was "too spicy." I didn't think so at all. Sweetie got pepperoni and liked it. I got pepp and sausage, and a 6" sub. The pizza was pretty good: medium-thick crust, perfectly cooked, good sauce, good cheese, plenty of good toppings. Some complain about the sausage "bits" but I liked them. The sub is small, but I did that on purpose since I was getting pizza too. If you want just a sub, get the 9" at least. Perfect Italian sub: good bread, good meat and veggies, held together well. Gone in a flash. Standard menu: pizza, subs, salads. But a few interesting specialty ones, like Lorraine, Florentine, Greek. Price was reasonable for as much food as we got, and the quality. I'd go back.

The food is awesome and a supreme value. For a very small place you get very big service.read more

So clean and friendly. Pizza was a bit too doughy and not enough sauce…read more Maybe have a suggestion box. I really want to see this restaurant succeed!

My go to spot and yes worth the wait.. I get the meat lovers extra sauce double cut done well and…read moreit's amazing every time. Go online and order trust me. Ok get to it the service is usually great and the sausage is homemade

Nothing special about it. Very underwhelming. Pizza was Columbus style. Thin but this was pretty…read moreboring and bland. Unfortunately had to wait a bit in the front as I watch them not do much from the counter.

Update: As a loyal customer at their Johnstown location, I've been ordering from them at least once…read morea week via DoorDash since they opened. Tonight, I found out they charged me $.86 for a packet of mayonnaise for an Italian sub and an extra $1.00 for some red onions on a small salad. In a previous order, I contacted the company via email because I hadn't seen any onions in the salad. The manager responded quickly by sending me clips of their security cameras showing the cook chopping onions and adding them to the salad. I admit there were onions in the salad after stirring it up, but they didn't seem more than the usual amount in a normal salad. It's laughable that the manager took the time to review security footage instead of just refunding the $1.00 charge and saying from now on, that fee will be added. Against my better judgment, I kept ordering, but tonight, I was charged again for the packet of mayo. I spend at least $25 a week there, often more, and these two instances leave such a bad taste in my mouth. While companies are free to charge whatever they want, frivolous charges like these really hurt the relationship for me. Tonight was the final straw with the $.86 mayo charge. I understand that maybe their business is struggling in this economy and maybe they need the money, but I hope it was worth losing so much more. From now on, I'll be using many other pizza places in town!

Average, nothing more. Our order was 6 Traditional Buffalo wings, a BLT sub and a Chicken Parm sub…read more For my wing order I got 6 flats, no drumettes. I was stiffed the meatier drumettes! Both subs were ok. They were heated but not toasted so they were a little soggy. Everything tasted fine but nothing special about it.

EVERYTHING!! Love the pizza, it's the BEST!!…read moreWish they would expand out. We live in orient, and drive there all the time, JUST for their pizza. Won't eat pizza any place else.

This is our Friday go-to pizza at work. Always cooked perfectly and toppings stacked on top. Its…read morehard to finish a medium between me and my brother.