I don't usually love a cracker crust pizza but the sauce and topping really made this pizza…read moredelicious! Loved the veggie pizza especially! Placed an order for pickup and the service was timely and accurate!

We went out to eat on a Saturday night and decided to try Little Sicily's for the first time since…read moreit had been recommended to us. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza with mushrooms. It's hard to pinpoint what I loved most about their pizza. It was loaded with toppings, and the pepperonis were perfectly crisp. There were plenty of mushrooms, and the pizza had just the right balance of spice and sweetness. I really appreciated how they baked it; there was no undercooked dough at all. The cheese melted perfectly with just a slight char, and the sauce had a wonderful sweetness that reminded me of Columbus-style pizza. The crust was thin but not overly crispy; it had a nice bite and chew without being too thick. For a Saturday night, the dining area wasn't crowded, and our server was quick and friendly.

Pizza was as always on spot. Pep& cheese, pork pizza and pep, mushroom & cheese. Very good!read more

Been meaning to try this place. I love mom and pop pizza places. This place did not disappoint…read more The drinks selection is great. The specialty pizzas all sounded delicious. The cluckin loaded fries were delicious. We got the sweet heat sauce and it was really good. The bbq white meatball pizza was amazing. I will absolutely get that again. The all the way was your classic supreme. It was really good too. Almost edge to edge toppings but left just enough crispy crust which I love. We will definitely be back.

Ever since I first tried this place, I've been nothing but satisfied. Everything is prepared in a…read moretimely manner, the service is good and the food is delicious and filling. I've had the "build your own" calzone, lasagna, wings, pizza and fettucine alfredo (added chicken) and salad. Never had an issue and always met with a smile. I usually order online, being a member and I enjoy how easy it is to accumulate points towards discounted purchases. You all definitely have to try this place out.

Was excited to try this New Pizza in Pickerington after good reviews But. When I arrived the door…read moreto the place had so many hand prints and grime on the door. Walking in I noticed right away all the New Decor on top of a nasty Old floor. Approaching the register I noticed a Fryer that was not in use Thank God because I've never seen one that dirty. The prep area where the pizza was made look very clean but that was the Only clean place in there. There was 1 person working and that was it. Taking orders, making pizza and doing it all. I saw him punch in the computer my order and the same plastic gloves he used on my dough. So I started looking around while I was waiting and everything from the door to the trash can to the men's room was nasty dirty. This all being said I do not think the health dept would pass inspection. The Pizza itself I would give a 7/10 was not bad but lacked sauce . The crust was very good and tasty. I personally will not return only because there are so many good pizzas in and around Pickerington like Grapevine, Kingy's, Vick's and Tyler's .

Absolute great service! Food tasted great! Chicken outstanding as always. All workers very nice and…read morehelpful to eachother! Overall 10/10 experience and food.

Good food at decent prices. Love their jojos! Pizza is…read morepretty good too. Quick delivery nearly anytime of day too.

So glad we live a couple mins away. We're new to Ohio and we're from Queens, NY. The pizza's pretty…read moreclose to the real deal. Problem is it's not consistent from visit to visit. And don't understand how 16" pies are considered extra large in this state. That's a small in NY. Regular pies are 18". Looks like slices were sold many years ago. Should bring that back and open for lunch! I don't mean a few slices under a heat lamp, actual pies of different kinds ready to sell by the slice. With all the local businesses and homes, fast, cheap, lunch should kill in Pickerington!

Such a good establishment! Yummy authentic NY style pizza, I love it reminds me of home . All the…read moreemployees are super nice ! Continue the great work

Friendly, attentive staff in a casual atmosphere. They have great pizzas, salad options, and…read morebar-style appetizers. The FRESH smash burgers are delicious. There is a good variety of draft and bottled beers. The manager is very knowledgeable about wine and they carry a nice selection. There are live-music days and I have had the pleasure of hearing some great performers here. There's a game room available and pool table for those wanting to hangout for a while with friends. Definitely worth stopping in. The Vibe: Relaxed. The manager, Brian, did a great job breathing life into this place.

Tried to give them another chance after a long hiatus. Tried to order two different appetizers, out…read moreof both. Tried to skip appetizers and order dinner out of that too. Should have known it wasn't worth it when we walked in at 5:30pm on a Saturday evening and there were two people in here... It's too bad, their food is generally very good but they do not run this business well.

Our friends are regulars here. We pop in with them here and there. It's always good. Always busy…read more They have a nice variety of options. The pepperoni pizza is so good. Thin crust. Crispy. The good little pepperonis that curl up. The donors sub is delicious as well. It's your classic Italian sub. The pork nachos are delicious as well. Don't forget to try the meatballs.

Judging by the foot traffic coming and going from this festival place, it's a regular place for a…read morelot of people! I found this on google when i put in find gluten free near me. I was delighted to find a lot of options! Keep in mind there may be cross contamination so take it as you will. I ordered the Italian sub on gluten free and it was so very close to a normal sandwich I was very excited! I also ordered a gluten free pizza and found it great! The big restaurant held a lot of people and was pretty comfortable.

Just had another Kingy's All the Way and it rocks it!! The drive thru window makes it so easy to…read morepick up my favorite pizza. I love this place!

Heard so much much about this local dive, I had to bring the fam out and check this place out…read more Every time I drive past this place in the evening, the parking lot is full. I always look at cleanliness first, which is so huge for me. A+ for that, no question. We were seated right away, basket of popcorn right off the bat, service is tip top. Very friendly, very fun vibe inside, love the scent of food in this joint, just has the aroma of that old school pizza parlor in the air. Wings were sauced very generously, probably on par with the top 3 wings I've had, very plump in size, plenty meat on the bone. Not easy to find a dive that has great wings. The thin crust of the pizza was very delicious, we're big thin crust fans, and this pizza was on point. My wife had the turkey club, and do they pack that deli slice turkey in this sandwich, yes they do. We brought food home, but snacked on it later that night, and it was just as good. If you're wanting to beat the rush, I recommend you come around 5ish. This place has a family feel to it, which is a plus for me, this may be our family night spot going forward.

A wonderful collection of "Americana" food. Everything from Fish & Chips to Artisan Pizzas &…read moreBurgers. Pinball machines all over the place (I hear they have a league) Great service and comfortable, even though we visited during the "Blizzard" of 12/13 for the Hofstetter show at the Wagnall Library. Definitely going back for the pot roast. Great service & attentive staff Happy Holidays!!

I had been here with my wife, but totally forgot to post about this place . I then brought my…read moredaughter here after school, to enjoy some time with her before college comes around. Totally chill vibe inside, customer service is very friendly, and the cleanliness is nothing but spic n span. Wings are legit, very saucy, and definitely a choice not to pass up on. The burgers are where this place really hits on. The reason it's very delicious is because this place doesn't go on too fancy of a presentation for a burger. Simple is best, and this burger doesn't stuff you to where you can't breathe, but hits the spot satisfactorily. The pizza is a pizza, my daughter is very simple with cheese pizza's being her go to choice. Overall, I like this place, as I said, very chill inside, and definitely a great spot to enjoy the outside atmosphere patio setting and enjoy a beer.

This place could have killed me! Ordered some subs and the only thing I asked for was no peppers…read morebecause Im allergic to them. Drove 25 mins to get them get home and they had poppers all over them so I called them to have them replaced and was told "pick them off" they refused to replace them or give a refund. The audacity of this place. If I wouldn't have checked i would be in the hospital. Beware if u have any good allergies. Or if they mess up ur order chulk it up to a loss because they refuse to actually have costumer service. I recorded the man on the phone telling me to pick them off and refusing a refund or to replace. If I wasn't deathly allergic them it wouldn't be a big deal but the way they treated me on top of it!!! Yeah unexceptable!

The worst customer service I've ever experienced. I belittled , mocked and felt attacked by someone…read morewho claimed to be the owner. Placed an online order that was made incorrectly. Instead of correcting he insisted I placed the order wrong and told me to never order from there again. I explained how I was a loyal customer and advocated for them, he mocked me by saying they will have to close because I've decided not to do business there any longer. I have never felt so disrespected. I will no longer be doing business with them