Been meaning to try this place. I love mom and pop pizza places. This place did not disappoint. The drinks selection is great. The specialty pizzas all sounded delicious. The cluckin loaded fries were delicious. We got the sweet heat sauce and it was really good. The bbq white meatball pizza was amazing. I will absolutely get that again. The all the way was your classic supreme. It was really good too. Almost edge to edge toppings but left just enough crispy crust which I love. We will definitely be back. read more

See all

I cannot attest to the service or ambiance since this was a takeout order but the pizza was great! I tried their "all the way" and my husband did their "pigs pizza". The all the way is their version of a supreme pizza and is heavily loaded with toppings - banana peppers, onions, pepperoni, sausage, ham, mushrooms, and green peppers. The crust has a good texture- chewy but not in a gross way. The pork pizza was a meaty version- pepperoni, ham, bacon, and sausage. Both were great! read more

Shirkys Pizza Zone - Pork pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carroll, Ohio

See all

Was originally going to try a nearby establishment, but chose this instead. Inside is deceivingly large, two bars, multiple sitting spaces with a variety of booths, tables and hightops. Service was good. Our server was quick to recommend food options, and kept constant check on us. We had the cheeses fries a salad with their home made blue cheese dressing and the Bbq meatball pizza. The fries were soggy and lacked the crunch that I love, the cheese and bacon bits atop were okay. The salad was pretty standard. Annoyingly, I found large chunks of lettuce stem in mine. The pizza was different, but grew on you. The meatballs were flavorful and surprisingly moist. The bbq sauce was the right amount. The crust was a cracker style, thin and had an overtake on it. Very crisp and crunchy. Some folks are into that. read more

See all

If you enjoy slightly thicker than a typical thin Columbus pizza crust you'll enjoy Shirkey's Pizza. We enjoy the short ride to Shirkey's for a change of pace pizza. Try the twice baked or well done version for a crispier crust. Delicious! The service is always friendly though we have always ordered carry out. read more

We visited Shirkys last night for the first time. The pizza is delicious, honestly right up there with Tommy's, Emilio's, Pizza House and Teritas! The service was spectacular, fast and friendly. And speaking of friendly, our server(whose name I do not remember), and the owner(I believe), both recognized that we were new to Shirkys, and gave us a warm welcome. 10/10, no notes read more

Pizza was as always on spot. Pep& cheese, pork pizza and pep, mushroom & cheese. Very good!

Pizza perfection when you are in the mood for that crispy thin crust and LOADED toppings. I'm pretty sure every time we have dined here, the manager stops by to say hi. Doesn't get much more inviting than that. Great friendly place with a variety of seating. It's on the must stop list when we are in the area for athletics and on the occasion we just want some hot-the-spot pizza. read more

Shirkys Pizza Zone - Cinna-bombs - do not leave without an order! - Pizza Near Me - Carroll, Ohio

See all

Always great food and service. Some of the best pizza in the area. Plenty of seating including a private party room.

Picked up three large pies for a ball team. Order was fulfilled quickly. Pizzas were packed with toppings and the crust was thin and crispy. Can't beat the price either! read more

Great little place! It is well run, clean and comfortable with DELICIOUS pizza! We go whenever in the area

Best pizza in the Lancaster area. I was raised on the original Tommy's in Columbus and it's hard to find I pizza that compares. This is the closet I have found since I have lived in Lancaster read more

Delicious!! Did I say delicious?!? Hubby and I stopped in here last night with some friends for dinner. Never knew about this place until our friends invited us to join them for dinner at the last minute. We all ordered pizzas and appetizers. One of the owners came around to check on us including our waitress that was very tentative to our table. Everyone's pizzas looked delicious! Great atmosphere too! We will definitely be back again!! read more

Awesome pizza and great service. The Shirk brothers do it right. Great local spot!!! Great service and people.

I visited Shirkys last night and was very disappointed with the service, specifically from "Tyler". When I spoke up to her about being unsatisfied with my cheesy fries (the cheese was burnt, not melted like it mentioned on the menu), she offered me zero solutions when she looked at me and said, "well, what do you want me to do?" She was distasteful and incredibly rude to say the least. I feel bad for anyone that works with her or receives """customer service""" from her. read more

Shirley's Pizza Zone is a Home town classic. The pizza isn't as good as I remember but maybe that's because when you're in high school everything taste different than when you're an adult read more

This place is amazing! Great pizza we love the meatball and the dessert cinnamon bons are amazing! If your looking a great beer the tangerine beer is great too read more

Shirkys Pizza Zone - Meatball pizza so delicious - Pizza Near Me - Carroll, Ohio

See all

Outstanding thin crust pizza, great atmosphere, terrific service, what more can you ask for? We were in the area and asked the pizza connoisseur group on Facebook for advice and this was highly recommended, and for good reason. We love it and will definitely make the drive from west Columbus to come back! read more

Shirkys Pizza Zone - Large All the way minus onions - Pizza Near Me - Carroll, Ohio

Pretty good food . Price are not bad . Good cold beer . Plenty of servers . Owners are top notch .

Shirlky's pizza is one of our families favorite. The atmosphere is fine but with three kids it is crowded. They have a nice option to go through a sides door and grab all pick up orders. read more

Pizza is good but very expensive. They were busy the last time we ordered almost an hour and a half wait. $76 for two pizzas and wings is too much. read more

Take out Italian subs were just okay. Flavor okay. Couldn't really notice Italian dressing. All ingredients but bun was pretty skimpy. Was really looking forward to these too as they had good reviews. Did we just get them on an off evening? read more

One of my favorite places to eat!!! Great small business that also supports the community and the schools!

Always great food a great service. We love Shirkys. If you are in the Carroll area I recommend you stop in and get yourself some good food.

Heard that this place serves a great pie but had to experience it myself- and it was a very good pizza. Got the pepperoni sausage and banana peppers. Loaded with the toppings and the sauce was excellent. It did not disappoint. Nice crispy crust and washed it down with a cold brew. Thumbs up!! read more

First time trying this place over the weekend. It did not disappoint!! I liked the sweeter sauce and the crispy crust. The curled up old world pepperonis were yummy as well. The garlic bread was a bit of a letdown. It seemed a bit soggy, but that may have be caused by it being in my pizza bag on the way home. The mac n cheese bites had a nice crisp and were full of cheese. I would recommend dining in at this place so the food is more fresh. Overall was very good and I will be back. Parking spots right outside the building. read more

See all

Just love this place! The food is excellent and is a great family oriented restaurant. While all the pizza is 1st class, my favorite is the Buffalo Chicken Dip Pizza (not to be confused with the BBQ Chicken pizza). read more

My first try of Shirky's was a pick-up order. Thus, I can only comment on the phone conversation and the end product. Called and put my order in with a gentleman. He was polite. I had a few questions I wanted clarified first (What's the red sauce's profile - sweet or zesty? Does the Chicken Bacon Ranch (CBR) have sauce on it? What kind of crust - thicker or thin?). Got a personal-size CBR and a large pepperoni/mushroom/black olives for the other mouths. He informed me they were out of pepperoni for the evening, so I asked about their sausage. Not spicy. Cool. Substitution complete. This was an awesome first-try. My CBR was absolutely loaded with grilled chicken and bacon! The crust was chewy - in a great way. The drizzle of Ranch on top was just enough, but was not overkill (a very important quality). They use a crumbled sausage. And, man, this place used the largest amount of sausage I've ever seen - nomnommmm! Great flavor! The red sauce on the SMGO melded well. And it wasn't seeping out of every opening in the cheese. I'll most assuredly remember this place. Perfect pick when not feeling like cooking on a Sunday night. read more

Shirkys Pizza Zone - Chicken Bacon Ranch! - Pizza Near Me - Carroll, Ohio

See all

Small business in a small town. It has "OUTSTANGING" pizza. It is definitely a place to check out and enjoy.

One of the best places in Fairfield county to get a pizza. My wife and I love thin crust pepperoni pizza. The crust is very tasty and crispy. I really like the pepperoni. They get it crispy and it has a good flavor. The selection of beers rotate and they have a good selection of craft beers. The owners (twin brothers) are super nice and they stop by your table to make sure your experience is awesome. The spaghetti and subs are good as well. It is an ideal location for large groups, as long as it isn't at a time when Bloom Carroll sports are playing. They get very busy at those times. Outdoor seating is plentiful during the warm weather season. Their parking lot is rather small, but there is plenty of parking if you are willing to walk down the street. read more

Always love coming to this place when i'm in the area. They have the best buffalo chicken dip around!! They also have really great pizza. Very nice staff and owners from what I've seen. read more

See all

Shirkys is great! They have the best wings around! Well worth eating inside. Excellent pizza, friendly staff, great prices.

Great place to hang out and have a great pie and a cold brew. The two brothers that own the place our great people to. Love the place.

Stopped there last night with some friends from the church on the hill (Shalom UMC) and everything was great! We had a couple of the Lost Coast Tangerine Wheat Ales and a sampler platter (chicken was really good). The server was attentive and friendly. One of the owners/brothers (Kerry) came by and greeted us. Very good vibe and the place was hopping on a Tuesday night. Highly recommend this spot for folks to visit and make a regular stop! read more

This is by far the best pizza place around. The subs are phenomenal. Just sitting outside waiting for our food, the aroma was making me hungry. Can't get the hang of dining in yet, so we order pick up. read more

Enjoyed this place. Even as a Spartan Fan I liked the vibe of this Buckeye Pizza restaurant. Good food and friendly staff read more

Shirkys Pizza Zone - a picture of a poster - Pizza Near Me - Carroll, Ohio

I am originally from Ohio but live in Nashville TN now and friends recommended Shirky's to me. ...Let me just say I travel all over the country, I love my Ohio pizza and I have to say this is some of the best pizza I have ever had... period ! They make their crust , sauces and most everything from scratch fresh every day .... I ordered three smaller versions of pizzas so I could try some of the different specialty pizzas.... Well...normally I am not a huge fan of chicken on a pizza BUT their buffalo chicken dip pizza is out of this world ....in fact I would go as far to say it's almost addictive!! The white pizza was amazing and the classic pepperoni/ sausage was fantastic ( they put lots of pepperoni on and it gets crispy around the edges ...the best way to have pepperoni) ...I really can't say enough good things about this place- i've never been in there before yesterday but the staff and the owners make you feel like family- you would've thought that I had been going in there for years.... and they are genuinely that nice, care that much about their customers , their restaurant and their pizza / food! Bravo Shirky's I will be back every time I drive from Columbus to my hospital clients in Charleston WV !! read more

See all

This place reminds me of my favorite pizza place in Wisconsin. My family truly enjoyed the pizza and the atmosphere. One of the owners was walking around and checking on everyone making sure their customers are satisfied. We will be back for sure! read more

This place is AmazeBalls! Don't believe me, come and check it out! Wondering what the definition of AmazeBalls is.....come and check it out. Well worth your time! read more

When they get it right, it is fantastic food. Unfortunately the last few times we picked up, our order was incorrect in one way or another. In addition, there isn't always consistency in the amount or placement of toppings. Would recommend dining in as opposed to picking up for these reasons. Again, when they get it right, it's fantastic! The gluten free crust and subs are great. It is the thickest gluten free crust you can get at a pizza joint and being able to order a gluten free sub is a rarity. read more

Lunch today was my first visit here. The buffalo chicken dip pizza and the BLT pizza were both great at lunch and cold tonight for dinner. Bonus- if you play Pokemon go, you can pick up a nearby Pokemon stop from inside the restaurant!:-) read more