In the area for work and apparently this is a go to place. Took the recommendation and went. This place was hopping. It was very busy. The locals said it wasn't usually like this but it was busy. Our party started as 5 and then grew to 7. This could have added to the slowness issue. Typical local pub interior with a great bar area in the center. I had the Hawaiian pizza with shrooms and there were several other pizza at the table. Very good just took a while which is to be expected. The fellow next to me had the wings. Wow they were huge. He was unable to eat the 10 he got. I was unable to finish my 10" pizza. Love the popcorn they give you while you wait. Awesome just a bit slow but they were very busy. Sorry Jo pix as it was a business meal. read more

Just had another Kingy's All the Way and it rocks it!! The drive thru window makes it so easy to pick up my favorite pizza. I love this place! read more

Kingy's Pizza Pub - Kingy's medium All The Way! - Pizza Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

GREAT VIBES!! My best friend had her surprise birthday party there recently and the food came out fresh and it was all very delicious. Didn't get any pictures of the food, but just know it was amazing. We will be back. read more

Kingys Pizza Pub never disappoints! Great food, friendly staff, and a fun atmosphere every time we visit. The pizza is always fresh and loaded with toppings, and the service makes you feel right at home. The wings are amazing also! Definitely one of our favorite spots to take the family! read more

Kingy's Pizza Pub - Breadsticks filled with cheese - Pizza Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

See all

So I just tried calling Kingys to place an order for pickup. It's 5:45 pm. Yes I am sure it's busy. Right off when the phone is answered I hear, "Kingys, please hold", and I'm immediately transferred to a hold line. The system puts my call through again after a few minutes, and the girl does the exact same thing again - immediate to hold. Three times. I tried calling back and tried to stop her, but she is on auto function, and unwilling to be polite to customers, by answering the phone properly. This is not good service. No wonder their ratings aren't better. Their staff aren't trained properly, or perhaps don't care. No spaghetti tonight. read more

Heard so much much about this local dive, I had to bring the fam out and check this place out. Every time I drive past this place in the evening, the parking lot is full. I always look at cleanliness first, which is so huge for me. A+ for that, no question. We were seated right away, basket of popcorn right off the bat, service is tip top. Very friendly, very fun vibe inside, love the scent of food in this joint, just has the aroma of that old school pizza parlor in the air. Wings were sauced very generously, probably on par with the top 3 wings I've had, very plump in size, plenty meat on the bone. Not easy to find a dive that has great wings. The thin crust of the pizza was very delicious, we're big thin crust fans, and this pizza was on point. My wife had the turkey club, and do they pack that deli slice turkey in this sandwich, yes they do. We brought food home, but snacked on it later that night, and it was just as good. If you're wanting to beat the rush, I recommend you come around 5ish. This place has a family feel to it, which is a plus for me, this may be our family night spot going forward. read more

See all

A great time amid the confusion at what appears to be a premier pizza/ burger dive on a Monday night. The pizza was great. The boneless wings very good but the honey bbq sauce wasn't for me. PRO TIP: You may want to avoid meal times. They do get jammin' We show at 5:45. Just a glass of water until we can get a handle on their wonderful menu. Ten minutes to get water sucks and sadly, we can't get our s*#^ straight so we need a minute. Don't do that. Twenty minutes later I walk over and ask this older lady, that looks to be in charge, if we've offended the server. She ghosted us. Now the server appears and apologizes. Claims she's hopping, but it's her bad, still she's sorry. I told her to let it go, no harm, here's my order. That takes thirty minutes to come out, but in the meantime at least the boss lady has stepped in to refill water and the complimentary popcorn. The server is also updating us on our order, up to that point. This joint is a wildly fun hangout. Very loud. With a very robust atmosphere. Ironically, we spent almost 90 minutes in there just eating and yucking it up with the boss and the server. A very funny pair. I really believe our next visit (under calmer circumstances) will yield 5-stars! 7/24 read more

Update of Kingy's Pizza Pub, I think my first mistake was getting takeout. The food quality is much better inside. Service is good, large seating areas ans decent outdoor seating area. Service is good, and spacious interior. Spaghetti is a home run, comes with a salad, and bread. Buffalo chips are fantastic with a touch of spice! read more

See all

Tried to order pizza. On line is down and when I called I was placed on hold 3 times, then hung up on. Tried to call 3 times with constant answer "Please Hold" to never have anyone ever pick up to place an order. Horrible experience trying to order pizza. Evening busy customer service would say three attempts to respond should put me in rhe queue to place the order rather than rotate over and over into no response. Will be a while before, if ever, that I will use this business. read more

I ordered the chicken wings and they were amazing!!!! I did not add any sauce just the naked crispy tender wings! They accommodated my request for all flats which I appreciated. Thank you to Kingy's and the amazing chef who prepared my dinner read more

We love Kingys pizza. We have been going there for many years. The food, atmosphere and staff are great. They have great ribs too. Give them a try!! read more

Been here a few times on our friends side of town and always enjoy it. Never remembered to do a review haha. So here we go. It's a pizza joint. But it has a lot more. We haven't had anything we didn't like. Great drink specials. Great food specials. Lots of choose from. Great appetizers. We started with loaded tots and chips. Both delicious. My friend and I split the rueben because it's ginormous. Our husbands split the Buffalo chicken pizza. Both were sooooo good!! read more

See all

Likes: - Super awesome staff. - The indoor and outdoors areas (very spacious) - we love the patio! - The cold beverages (alcohol). - The indoor area has a game area for the kids. - They serve popcorn as a complimentary appetizer. - The pizza is always good - plenty of fresh toppings! - They are within walking distance of Whit's! Dislike: - Some of the food is hit or miss. I recently ordered the chicken quesadilla and the quesadilla was filled with more cheese than chicken AND the cheese was as hard as a rock. It was as if the quesadilla had been sitting out for a while and the cheese had cooled down. The tortilla for the quesadilla was burnt as well. From now on, we only go for the pizza and drinks! read more

See all

I got there for our UYE a little early and man, was I super hungry! Thankfully the server quickly brought over a generous bowl of freshly popped popcorn and got me a pint of their Kingy's Ale. (Pretty good brew, btw.) Upon arrival of my co-diners, Gwen W., Gail R. and Marlena L. things got rolling. Now do yourself a favor and get yourself a basket of their deep fried breaded mushrooms as an appetizer. They are crispy, golden brown nuggets of fungus-y goodness and frankly, were probably the best part of my dinner. And speaking of dinner, they have a big menu. My eyes focused on one of my favorite pizzas, their White Pizza and theirs was good, but not great. If you're not familiar, it's a no sauce pizza where you get two toppings of your choice (mushrooms and onion, just so you know, Mr/Ms nosy). It comes on a crackery Central Ohio style crust and there's a good amount of toppings but then again, it all seemed to lack flavor. A couple shakes of salt helped... Gail R. seemed to be the big winner with her 1/2 rack of ribs. They were moist, tender and that meat just fell off the bone. She seemed to be totally pleased with her order. Keep that in mind, folks. Kingy's is a good, casual place and it's a busy place so come early as they can really get popped after about 5:30. The service was good and the food came out pretty fast for how busy they were. I'd give them another shot sometime. You might want to too. 4 Stars read more

Kingy's Pizza Pub - 10" White Pizza With Mushrooms And Onions. (~$12.50) Good But Not Great. - Pizza Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

The food was excellent and priced accordingly. Waitress was attentive and the atmosphere was as expected

Consistency in good food and good times. Kingy's is the neighborhood hangout that the world need to know. read more

Kingy's Pizza Pub - Potatoe Skins. Bacon on side. - Pizza Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

See all

We have visited twice pre-covid lockdown and twice again post covid. I've written a lot of restaurant reviews that I felt obligated to mention they were written during the Pandemic. However, this is one of the first reviews I have done in 2023 where I think everything was the same before and after. We mainly have ordered pizza, wings, and beer on our several visits, so I will branch out soon, but each time it was excellent and the service has been great. We have went during peak and off times and they have had plenty of staff who seem happy to be there and give great service. The pizza is your typical Columbus style, or sometimes called Party Cut, it has always been hot and tasty. I'm more of a wing expert and these buffalo wings are very good! I believe they are fresh not frozen, and this is close to an Anchor Bar tasting sauce. Both have been served quick and hot each visit! I haven't tracked prices, but it appears to me they have raised theirs less than some other places. When we visit again I will expand our menu choices. read more

Great pizza! When my family goes here we always get something different from each other. My pizza is always super good. I'm not sure about their food cause I'm too busy enjoying mine, but they haven't thrown up or died yet. It's a little noisy but it's to be expected in these types of restaurants. read more

Food was really nothing special, at minimum it was about a 5 out of 10. We had a leg pepp, hot wings and that's all. When we arrived to get a seat, the teenage girl, yes, teenage girl asked "how can I help you?" Well, that was weird, maybe you could seat us? Clearly we needed to be seated. Our pizza and wings took close to 50 minutes to arrive. Our server never gave us an update after about 25 mins, yes that long. She stated the drive thru was really busy. How that affects me I don't know. All the while you get to watch the teenage girls play on their phones and not even help the servers or clean up the trash on the tables and floor. They were enjoying their coffee drinks and phones! I get trying to introduce a job to a teenager, but they acted like it was lunchtime social hour at school rather then actually working. Never going back. The teenage girls in the front of the establishment is not a good look! I will spend my money elsewhere where there is professionalism when you enter the establishment! read more

The servers are always amazing and polite. Even the drive-thru they are so quick and they smile. Bonus they all SPEAK. I've gone to other Mcfast places and they don't say anything except the total amount of money owed. No thank you, no pull forward, nothing. Just back to their phone. So well done Kingys! Keep up the friend family atmosphere. read more

Disappointed is an understatement. I've always heard how "Great" their pizza was and I never thought so but it had been 10 years since I had it last. ANYWAYS, was at the Diley Hill Animal Emergency which is right next door to kingeys and we were hungry. We ordered a large 2 1/2 topping pizza and it was $25.00. I thought that was a little expensive but I'll pay almost anything for a good pie. We ordered half pepperoni bannana peppers and the other half pickles, onion and sausage. I always specify LITE CHEESE AND EXTRA SAUCE...ALWAYS. and I make sure they repeat the order back to me. When I opened up the box all I saw was CHEEEEEEESE....and lots of it. Now for most people they would be in Seventh Heaven, me however was not...nor was my family. We are a plant based family and try to limit our dairy intake to as little as possible. I know some of you are saying "if you don't like dairy don't order pizza". Thats not the point here...the point is my order is WRONG and EXPENSIVE. I hate to be that guy but I was just really let down. Thanks for listening read more

Kingy's Pizza Pub - Kingeys $25.00 Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

The pizza is super good. Toppings all the way to the edge. The crust is thin but not too thin. The sauce is unlike any I've had. Not sure how to describe it but I am craving it now the day after visiting. It's a little more on the sweet side but not as sweet as others I've had. Service was a little slow but it's understandable given lots of places need more staff. Definitely check it out if you're in the area. It's a local fave. read more

Having moved to Canal Winchester, we are trying new places. We sat outside on the patio. Morgan was our server and was very helpful in making recommendations for food favorites. Morgan was upbeat and friendly. We will return based upon the service we received. The Italian sandwich was flavorful as was the spaghetti and meatballs. read more

Food is good service was slow but we had a new waitress. We sat outside away from everyone

All the pizzas come in till crest. The one we ordered came in somewhat over baked crust was brown. The only thing decent was the beer! Lol. I don't recommend for pizza here if you're looking for quality. read more

Always great food and service. Some of the best pizza in the area. Done in gets popcorn with your menus too.

I will say that my eyes were bigger than my stomach this day LOL. This place is super divey. They give you a basket of popcorn for starters. I always heard that they had fantastic spaghetti so I decided to try it. The spaghetti dinner was great and all that comes with it. I also had the chicken wings and Buffalo chicken pizza both of which were very good. I also had the Ruebert sandwich, which was very subpar. I'm a big Reuben connoisseur and I can say that I would never get it again. I would recommend this place for the spaghetti dinner, chicken wings and pizza, only if you are in the Canal Winchester area, it's nothing to rave about or drive far to try, but it is good. read more

See all

We frequent Kingy's every so often. The past three times have been disappointing. We ordered Buckeye Balls as an appetizer and were given regular pretzel bites without asking if we wanted the substitution and still charged us for the price of the one we had ordered, which was a little more expensive. The girl just shrugged at us when we asked why we weren't notified of the switch. We also never get ranch with the loaded fries that we order. One time we were told she would have to charge us... ummm the menu description says ranch is included? The most recent time, we ordered a calzone that is basically only cheese and plain bread. There are two pepperonis in one side of the calzone. It also barely has any seasoning on top. So I paid for a calzone of plain bread and cheese. Frustrating. We won't be back. read more

Kingy's Pizza Pub - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

The food is great, but nothing insane. Better than other sports bars I've been to for sure. Definitely get the wings, bone-in trust. The vibes are great. And service was good. A recommend for sure. read more

This place is hopping on a Saturday evening both inside and with the drive-thru wrapped around the building. There is a reason for this...... because this place is FANTASTIC! Not only is their pizza some of the best in Central Ohio, but their customer service is amazing. I've never had bad service on any of my visits here. During this most recent visit, our waitress took great care of our large party and had the assistance of the manager on duty who was also busting his butt to ensure every table was running smoothly. Even while they were slammed, our drinks stayed filled and all our orders came out expeditiently. I tried the rubert for the first time which is Kingys spin on the reuben... might be my favorite item on the menu now. Keep up the great work! read more

I've been meaning to come here for a long time, but the location and hours conspired against me. Today we happened to be in Canal Winchester, so figured we would try it out. Heck, it's even a haul from CW. It is way out of the way even when you're down this way. It's a nice place though: big, with a nice patio, and a welcoming interior. Very much a sports bar feel. The starter was a letdown: stale popcorn. But service was great, and the rest of the meal was pretty good. We talked about the BLT pizza, an apparent regional specialty, but passed this time. I was there for the ribs, and Sweetie had a personal pepperoni pizza. Her pizza was fine overall, but both of us thought that while the pepperonis were great the crust was very bland. My half slab came with good coleslaw and decent fries. The ribs were of the saucy, "fall off the bone" type, but among the best example of it that I have had. The sauce was quite good, flavorful and slightly spicy. The meat itself actually had good smoky flavor. And while eating meat that barely stays on the bone is difficult and even more messy than with most ribs, this was still "toothsome" as I call it, with a bit of resistance to it. I enjoyed them and would have them again. Prices are good, as are portions. If I lived nearby I'd come once in awhile. As it is, maybe on a visit to the Hocking Hills or something; it's a heck of a haul. read more

Kingy's Pizza Pub - Half rack - Pizza Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

See all

The food was great!! The Service was terrible!!! We ordered online and on the phone for pickup. We picked up the food and paid. We drove home and one persons food wasn't in the bag. We called and they let us drive back and pick up the pizza they had made for us. They said we are sorry........ No Coupon for future discount no current discount. Gas prices are very high and no consideration given for this.. We wanted to sit down with our children and grandchildren but one grandchild didn't have her food. So they are no better than McDonald's drive through... Wait a minuet, McDonald's gives us coupons for free food when they make a mistake. So Kingy;s Pizza Pub Drive though is NOT as good as McDonald's.... read more

I've been to Kingy's a handful of times but this was the first time they cooked our pizza perfectly! I usually have issues with crust that is too crispy, however, I'm happy to report that the pizza was amazingly chewy with a slight crunch on the outside. The Cajun Garlic chicken wings (cooked well done) were delicious as well. Also I love their convenient pick up window! read more

Kingy's Pizza Pub - Pep and cheese! - Pizza Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

See all

The trophies say it all!! Food is amazingly delicious, service is fantastic, the owners are outstanding, prices are incredible, and the view of the sunset from the patio is phenomenal!! 10/10 recommend!!! read more

Took advantage of a groupon to take the in-laws to Kingy's since they live in Pickerington. It's set up like a sports bar, but it's relatively quiet so family friendly. Plenty of TVs but they're too small, so you can't really see the scores of the games. The beer list is so-so. Could use more microbrew. We ordered the pretzel bites, Mexican pizza, Kingy's Special Pizza, and Kingy's All the Way pizza. The pizza toppings are good, but the crust and sauce are relatively low on flavor. I thought they skimped on the cheese as well. So if you get a fully loaded pizza like the Kingy's All the Way, you'll like it. But if you got a plain cheese pizza, you might not be as satisfied. I thought the pretzel bites were good, but my wife was disappointed that the nacho cheese is the artificial store bought type... Overall though, the food here is very reasonably priced, so I can see why this place is relatively popular among the locals in Pickerington. read more

Kingy's Pizza Pub - Medium "King's all the way" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

I don't get down to Canal Winchester much now days but when I do I try to always stop at Kingy's. Great pizza, salads and you must try the ribs. One of my favorites read more

Haven't been there in years but was in town and couldn't not go grab a pizza. And man it was great only person I recognize there was the owner Mr. Reynolds but my buddies and myself used to go there literally every day. It was nice to go back just wish I had more time there. read more

Kingy's Pizza Pub - Kingy's pepperoni pizza and Pepsi what else do you need in life? - Pizza Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

Always good food and service when I go there. I've dined in and went through the drive though and always super accommodating.

Love this place, Kingy's. It's not the closest pizza joint to me but I make the trek down here nonetheless. Their pizza is one of my favorites in the world. Their pep is great, but their Hawaiian is excellent! Just ordered ribs for the first time tonight and I am impressed. The service is always efficient, there is a drive-thru beverage carryout and ice cream parlor adjacent to the restaurant (I use the drive-thru carryout all the time!), and the service is always very pleasant. I am a happy and repeat customer of this restaurant. read more

Kingy's Pizza Pub - Half rack of ribs platter - Pizza Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

The food is yummy, and service is usually pretty fast. It's a pretty chill place for pizzas.