Went to a friends and picked up Todd's on the way. She ordered ahead. It was ok. I grew up in a pizza shop so I'm kinda picky. The crust was good and crispy. There was just not enough cheese. It barely covered the dough. The subs were good. We had an Italian and a crispy chicken. There are just SO many good places to get pizza around here that are better. We love trying mom and pop places cuz those are typically the best pizza around. We would eat it if someone else ordered it but we probably wouldn't order it ourselves. read more

See all

We've never been here and thought we'd try this out. My wife and I idered the extra large pepperoni and cheese, and we loved it. The crust was a good, flaky style, and even the next day, the reheat level tasted great. Next time, we'll get extra topping and see how that goes. It's worth the visit. You'll enjoy it. read more

Todds Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - West Jefferson, Ohio

Just ordered a large BLT pizza and after eating my first slice I'm in love! The crust is perfectly crispy the lettuce and tomato are so fresh and large! I will certainly order from here again. Thanks for- (had to stop writing this to eat another slice)-a great pie! read more

Todds Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - West Jefferson, Ohio

I stopped here while around the area and decided to get a pepperoni pizza and overall it was good the waitress was nice and attentive. Food came out in a timely manner and the pizza tasted good , and as for cost it was reasonable . read more

See all

When I am in West Jefferson Ohio after 4pm , I have to order a large Pep and Cheese from Todd's Pizza. The Pizza is always ready on time and delicious. The crust is thin and crispy and the sauce is just right. The sweetness of the sauce is unique . I highly recommend this pizza for lovers of fresh delicious pizza. read more

Tasted like some things just dumped out of cans and baked. Not what I expected. Was told it was amazing pizza. I think some people haven't had good pizza. read more

Pepperonis are spicy. I can't eat them and wasted a pizza. I wouldn't have ordered had I known. I think they should tell you ahead of time.

The fact that I drive from Union Ky to West Jeff to get this pizza should tell you all you need to know about this place!! Hands down MY FAVORITE PIZZA! I've had pizza all over including Manhattan, little Italy in NYC and Brooklyn and this is the pizza I want the most!! Where you at Dave Portnoy ? Go review this place, you won't be disappointed read more

As of last night, Todd's is still showing to be a winner in my book. I have had hits and misses within the past year, which had me worried that this place was 'chinzing' out, but I take all those dirty thoughts away. Todd's is still superb in my books. Todd's has some really awesome deals throughout the week. My favorite is the free pitcher with any purchase of a large pizza on Saturday. It saves you a few dollars, and the desperation of awaiting refills. Another awesome deal is two small pizzas 1 topping for $10 on Mondays. My husband and I are such gluttonous ham-beasts when we come here, but the pizza is just great, which is why we find ourselves coming back again, and again. The pizza is a good midwestern square cut pizza. Close to pizza house, but in my opinion leaps and bounds better. It's amazing how one simple pepperoni and cheese pizza can cause such euphoric bliss, but then again, that's why I am probably fat as well. Health enthusiasts beware: This place is artery clogging, greasy goodness at it's best. read more

One of my favorites places for subs and pizza . It's really good food . Pizza' s is is great thin crust and sub 's are big and delicious .

Nice fast friendly service. Pretty good pizza and a unique dinning area. Pizza is similar to many other small pizza places in central ohio with thin crispy crust and edge to edge toppings. Pretty reasonably priced. Looking forward to returning! read more

Todds Pizza Restaurant - Meat Lovers Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - West Jefferson, Ohio

Todd's has the best pizza in the area. I used to own pizza shops in Hilliard/Westside and this pizza is the real deal! Subs are great as well. Recommend this shop to everyone! read more

Got a pizza & asked for extra sauce on it & not only did I didn't get extra sauce which I paid for there was hardly any sauce on it at all. Never again!!!!! read more

We have been enjoying Todds Pizza every Friday night for years! It has always been great. Last night it was the worse pizza we ever got. The crust was hard and burnt and tasted nasty! I called and told the person how nasty it was and that we did't get the banana peppers ! I asked if they changed their crust and he said yes! I said it's awful andhe said I don't know what to tell you! I hung up! Never wasting our money there again! read more

My mommy is mean but they have really good food The pizza is really good ind I love it read more

I stopped in here last weekend with a friend of mine on our way back home from a photo shoot in London. I've seen this place many times while passing through the West Jefferson area. When we walked inside, we were greeted by a gentleman behind the counter. We quickly found our seat and we were waited on. The place was empty except for a man just inside the door watching basketball by himself. We ordered the breaded mushrooms and the usual peppersoni & mushroom pizza. Our waitress was very pleasant. The mushrooms were very good and so was the pizza. The pizza had a 'cracker thin' crust which was pretty good. Quiet place for a little bit until others showed up shortly after we arrived. I'd say it was average pizza for a mom & pop place. read more

First time trying Todd's after reading some of the reviews. I'm glad I decided to give them a try. We ordered a large half cheese half pep and a large Italian sub. Both were amazing too. I live outside there delivery zone but I'm more than willing to make the 30 minute drive to get another awesome pie from them. Very friendly staff as well they were helpful polite and patient. So if you are debating whether or not to give them a try or another after a bad experience I suggest you do. read more

Todd's is the best pizza place in West Jeff! They are also taking great Covid precautions as far as seating and hygiene is concerned. We ate out on the patio, ordered pizza, mozzarella sticks and potato skins. Everything came in a timely manner, and the pizza crust is crisp and fresh. Everything was delicious! Has a real mom and pop kind of feel to it. They also serve alcohol which is a plus. If you are in the West Jeff area you must try this sweet little pizza shop! read more

The pizza is ok, if you pick it up. I have ordered from todds before. The first time was really good and enjoyed the food. Delivery the second time was cold and very late ( it's 5 minutes away from my home). As forth the staff in my opinion this time, very rude on the phone for pick up order and not friendly when I got there, plus it's very muggy in the restaurant on top of that... with flies every where. I wasn't really happy with the attitude I received from all the staff at all. Don't think I'll be going back again! read more

See all

We ordered our pizzas for carry-out. They were hot and ready on time. Our order was correct. The toppings were good from the sauce to the sausage but I was not impressed with the crust. It was saltine cracker-like and black on the bottom. read more

Todds Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - West Jefferson, Ohio

Awesome Blt pizza extra crispy. Original tasting pizza. Small town all the way. Friendly service. Also great fish sandwich.

Great pizza but please get rid of those God awful swinging doors leading into the dining room that seem to injure / bruise at least a few customers each time I'm there. read more

Delicious and super friendly. I love the extra cooked thin crust. I say if they added some salt or parm cheese to underbelly of crust then 5 stars. Highly recommend. We drove from Hilliard and would do it again. read more

The only pizza that can give Cappys in London a run for its money and it does. I give Todds the nod over Cappys because it actually has TVs that show sports aka they care about the customer. They realize that beer, delicious pizza and sports go hand in hand. The establishment is rather small which can produce long wait times during busy hours but it's worth the wait ten fold. The pizza is thin crust so if you aren't a fan of thin crust stay away from Todds. However if you can dig on thin crust then you absolutely HAVE to try this place!!! Service is always spot on and the atmosphere is relaxed. I hope everyone has a great experience with Todds! read more

We waited for 30 mins to order our drinks. The place looked like it was very busy before we got there. It is a tiny establishment but only had 1 waitress working, they needed at least another especially since it was a Saturday night, then they ran out of O2 so no more draft beer. Might try again only because they have draft beer. read more

A thin to medium thickness hard crust pizza ,with a hard crunch to it and a cracker crust flavor. a very tasty mild sauce, great cheese and toppings. A good pizza that stands out from the rest. read more