First time there, pizza was burnt, and lacked cheese. " Boneless" wings were well done and just popcorn chicken.

Good pizza, try their wings too! They are pretty good and won't break the bank. They also have gluten free for those who want/need it.

Wow, wow, wow!!!! Amazing pizza. I must say this place took me by major surprise. I'd like to try something new but every time I come here, the pizza is too good to turn down. Give this place a try sometime. read more

Just tried the tacos for the first time. So good. My husband had the thick crust pizza ( you have to ask for it) which was good according to him!! We know Mike and his family they run a great business! read more

The first time here was really freakin' good. The second time here... was really freakin' bad. The pizza wasn't cooked through. The bottom was done, but the top of the crust was still doughy. What really killed it for me was that there was just WAY too much sauce. There was so much sauce this pizza could not be eaten with your hands, but seriously, after two small corner pieces of this pizza... that was enough for me. The sauce came off as really cheap... like something you can buy for your boboli pizza at Krogers. The subs were pretty boring, sub par and mostly sub bun. Terrible. The service wasn't much to write home about either. Telling me "Next time ask for light sauce." And hearing some guy in the back get all pissed, because I didn't like their pizza. Is not really helpful, or great customer service. Maybe you should address the issue with the person who's incompetent at making pizzas in the back, because this pizza tasted NO WHERE near what I expected from Mike's based on past visits. At this point.. I don't even know if I'd like the recommend the place. The people behind us had pizza that looked absolutely amazing, so why did we get the skunky-ass pizza of the night? read more

Everything I've ever gotten here has been really good! Service has always been good! I would recommend this place to anyone and everyone! Prices are pretty good. read more

I used to absolutely LOVE this place and the taco pizza is still my favorite pizza but if I could give zero stars I would because the last two weeks we have tried to call and order a taco pizza and they've told us both times they are unable to make that pizza because they don't have the ingredients they don't open until 5:00 PM and close at 10 PM when online it says they're open until 11 PM. Someone please tell me what's going on! read more

I ordered a grilled Italian sub and while the bread and construction were good, it was cold in the middle. It was as if some of the meat was added after it was done cooking. The salami was hot but the ham was cold. It was strange. I also ordered a pepperoni pizza, it had an ok taste but there was so much melted cheese that the slices started to fuse back together again, making it hard to pick up the individual slices. Our pizza looked nothing like any of the pictures posted in previous reviews. I also used the restroom while I was here and it was very dingy. There were dead bugs and also no towels or anything to dry your hands with. This was my first time here, and while I was recommended by a local, I have to say I was disappointed and I won't be back. read more

Best pizza in town! We lived in London and ordered weekly from the Choctaw Lake location. We were surprised to find West Jeff was their home store when we moved here. Hopefully, unlike the London location, this one stays open! All of their food is great! They have gotten smaller on their sides and dips, but still worth it! read more

I have to say this places pizza is amazing. I used to order bambinos all the time but they screwed up so many orders. Everytime I order from here and walk through the door when I return home all I see are smiles. Love this pizza over bambinos have never had a order get messed up. read more

Fantastic pizza, great service, and great environment, the sweet girl at the window was very kind a cooperative! Would definitely come back again read more

Average at best. Very stingy with their toppings. Cheese was almost non existent. Mushrooms were scarce. Crust was okay hot, but as it cooled became very leathery and chewy. This was my first time here. Probably won't be back. Edible but not yummy. read more

...I've never had better...Luv this Food! It's ALL Good! If these pic's don't say it all...I don't even ask for Xtra anything anymore...there's really no need to and the onion rings are "to Die for"...really nothing here I don't like! Thank You Mike & Staff for Many Years of Fabulous Food And Service...I'm Never disappointed! read more

See all

The wings are really good not like the soupy wet ones from the chain stores. The pizza is really good I recommend this place

Check this place out. I did. And I'm glad I did. It's well made. Flavor profile is very good. All the flavors go together. I got the old world pepperoni on it. It gets crispy. Creamy tasting provolone cheese and they don't work the dough to death. Somewhere between a flyers and tammy's pizza if you want to compare it to something...but it's own thing and very tasty. just for some context - I like all kinds of pizza...and consider Columbus to be pizza wasteland - because I prefer NY Style pizza. But Columbus has many different types of pizzas to choose from. You wouldn't waste your money at Mike's if you are in the area. And as a small business they need customers and I'm sure they'd appreciate it. Looking forward to trying their subs. Oh yeah, and the pizza was good and hot and not overcooked. just right. read more

First visit to Mike's Pizza tonight . Italian sub is pretty good and the price was good too. Will be back to try the pizza soon. They have coupons in the store so I will be back with one of theses for sure ! read more

Tried Mike's for the first time last night and very disappointed. I work at a large company in West Jeff and we order food pretty much every day of the week. First off, the woman who took our order over the phone was very rude. We had 3 different orders with 3 different payments and she acted like it was then end of the world. They also charged us three separate delivery fees to bring all of the food to the same place. When the delivery driver showed up, he was also very rude. I noticed that they charged the wrong cards for incorrect orders and got a "there's nothing we can do about it now". After he left, we realized they gave us extra food we didn't order, and didn't give us food that we did order (and paid for). Food was average, but not worth all that hassle. We'll stick with Bambinos. read more

I thought this place was ok at first but then I tried the thick crust with the old style pepperoni. The pizza went from average to above average! Best local place in west jeff. read more

We tried Mike's Pizza tonight for the first time. I did enjoy it but I hardly had any tomato sauce on my pizza at all. My husband said the same thing but he said he could taste it. We will try again ask for more sauce on our pizza. read more

Excellent pizza. Dough is fresh. Pizza sauce is not sweet. Crust is perfect....toppings are super fresh. The cheese is very tasty. It beats Donato's or any other Central Ohio pizza shop. I HIGHLY recommend it. read more

I have lived in WJ for over 30 years.. I absolutely LOVE Mike's Pizza! We have a business in WJ also & it's a treat that we have at least once a week. I always order the same thing..an extra large with everything..They pile the toppings high :) Good crust, Awesome sauce and lots of pep & vegies. In my opinion..the best pizza ever! read more