A new to us pizza place near Graceland. The pizza is a little thicker than your usual Columbus-style pie, but not too thick. There was just enough char on ours. Pepperoni with good cupping. My only suggestion is that the sauce is a bit on the sweet side. Service was friendly. Price seemed reasonable for a plain pepperoni pizza (under "custom"). It wasn't busy at all at 6:30 on a weeknight. I hope they stick around! read more

I was on search of something different and came across the Real Dill at Brenz. I LOVE pickles so I thought this was a perfect choice. The crust was delicious and the toppings were great! Only issue was the chips on top were soggy and no longer crunchy. Otherwise the flavor was good, the server behind the counter was nice and it was very quick for a Friday evening! Not a lot of seating if you want to stay and eat but perfect for takeout! read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - The Real Dill. - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

It was a miserable weather night, I'm new to Columbus and am still unpacking, so I ordered delivery from Brenz. All I can say is the moment I opened the box and saw this pizza I was in awe! Now that's a pizza!! Loaded edge to edge, the crust was the right amount of chew and crunch, the hot honey left a nice spicy heat on my tongue and complimented every topping. If all of the pizzas at Brenz are like this one I'll order more! The order, even with delivery, took less than 30 minutes (I live 0.5 miles from Brenz). It was piping hot and delicious! I highly recommend Brenz! read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - Heritage Honey - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I've ordered from Brenz Pizza multiple times and EVERY pizza ordered, has LITTLE TO NO CHEESE. Even when I pay for double cheese, I NEVER get it. No more. read more

See all

Pepperoni 'za for dinner last night for a full-on Friday night comfort food/nostalgia throwback. I normally get one of their delish fancier pizza options, but this simple pep did not disappoint! Next time I might go with extra toasted or a pizza triangle cut because the middle squares were a bit floppy (but I'm an outside/crust lover myself). 20 mins tops for a pickup order around 6pm and it was almost too hot to eat when we got it home. Legit such good pizza! Always friendly, too. read more

See all

What a fantastic way to end our night. My friends wanted to see Beetlejuice and then get pizza after the movie. We never knew of this place, and when it popped up, we agreed to check it out. Their pizza was amazingly delicious. My friends got a veggie pizza, one got pepperoni and cheese, and I got easy on the cheese with double pepperoni. I highly recommend this place. Great staff and great food. read more

See all

Excellent pizza. Definitely recommend Try their different combinations Located off olentangy rd with entrance and parking behind building read more

The hot honey and sausage marry together so well to make the perfect combo on a pizza. Delivery is available! read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - Heritage Honey Pizza - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Two distinct pizzas but one happy camper! In trying the spinach artichoke pizza (olive oil base; chicken) and the heartland pizza (red sauce; pepperoni/bacon), I can say that Brenz is a Jack of All Trades in the pizza game. 22 pizzas + a build your own option means that you're bound to find something that you like. Good crust and generous toppings. The only downside might be from a value perspective. At the 12 inch size, a lot of the selections were $19. If that doesn't intimidate you, a good pizza awaits. read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - Sometimes people want to dig in so fast that you can't get a clean pic of the Spinach Artichoke Pizza. - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

First timer, last timer. Ordered 12 in Classic, toppings skimpy not covering outer slices, 2-3 slices of pepperoni per large slice, heck, I thought they forgot the sausage until having one of the center slices, and that was skimpy at best read more

Pretty darn good. I thought it was one of those fast-fired pizza places and it's not, so there was a short wait while they cooked it. It's small, and handy to the Lennox mall, and has quite a menu plus build your owns. No kid's menu, but there is cheese bread and cinnamon bites, so Baby K was covered. She said the bread wasn't as good as Jet's, but the cinnamon things were better. She spilled her drink, and the staff were super good about cleanup, plus patient with her in general. Smaller cups might be nice, for kids. My rustic pizza (pepp, sausage, onions, etc.) was quite good. Good crust, good sauce, good toppings. Better than some "gourmet" places. We'll be back. read more

What? Only 5 stars? Brenz goes above and beyond to get you the pizza of your dreams, whether it's a basic pepperoni or a fabulous gourmet pie. Delivery is great. A couple of times I've experienced a snafu, and they bent over backwards to make it right. The team is great, the pizza is great. What's not to love? read more

Bomb!!!!!!!!!! So amazing and the pizza is more than pizza. It's magic in slices!!! The lord knows what he was doing!!!! read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The first thing to know is that Brenz is the best pizza in Columbus. High quality ingredients on the kind of delicious, actual crust which is almost impossible to find around here. And that would be enough, but I'm delighted to also add that their customer service is just excellent. They worked with me to feel a large group of community members really affordably and much to everyone's delight. Thank you, Brenz! read more

Holy pizza!!! This was so delicious. So cheesy and saucy. Toppings to pizza were the perfect ratio and the sauce was sweeter without going over board. I'll be making this a regular stop!! read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - 12" pizza - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Wow!! I was deciding between the soup shop two doors down and this pizza shop and I'm sooooo happy with my choice. I'm sure soup would have been delicious but holy cats was this salad and pizza satisfying! And the customer service here is super. The staff are genuine, attentive, and enthusiastic. I loved my House salad with an incredibly good fresh Italian dressing, which I'm told is made in house. Even the small size was so generous! Loaded with fresh greens, veggies, and croutons. Only $3.99! I also ordered an 8-inch specialty pizza, which I'm loving. I'll take half home. These are 4 specialty options that are vegetarian, plus you can build your own with the 30+ topping options!! Loved this place!! read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - Rustic Pizza - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

In the search to find my favorite pizza joint in Columbus, I gave Brenz a try. They are currently delivery or take out only, so I called ahead and placed an order for take out. The online menu offers a good selection of specialty pizzas, and at the bottom talks about a seasonal pizza deemed 'The Local'. The Local is no longer a seasonal pizza, but rather two additional pizzas, called 'The Heartland' and 'Midwest Special' that are now permanent selections on the menu (although not listed on the website). I ended up ordering an 8" Heartland pizza -- red sauce, cheese, pepperoni, bacon, balsamic caramelized onions, roasted red peppers topped with shaved parmesan and fresh basil. Interestingly, the prices are as follows: 8" ($7.99), 12" ($15.79), 14" ($19.49), 16" ($23.49). I did a double take when I first saw this -- you can get two 8" pizzas for essentially the same price as one 12". Not sure how that makes sense, but alright! Anyways, after I placed my order I was told it would be ready in 15-20 minutes. I showed up right at 20 minutes to find that my pizza hadn't even been started yet -- talk about disappointing. I understand restaurants are short staffed, but I would have been fine if they told me it would take 35-40 minutes -- I would have just stayed at home longer. So after paying and waiting for another 15 minutes in the store, I finally had my take out pizza. Now on to the pizza. The toppings gave it a good flavor, especially the balsamic onions. However, I was not a fan of the crust and that's strictly personal preference. I tend to favor a thinner crust, and Brenz crust is a bit thicker than a traditional hand tossed pie. During my wait, I watched the pizzas run through the conveyer oven and noticed that during cooking, the crust rises so much that the employees have a tool (think gardening hand rake attached to a long wooden pole) that they stick in through the side of the conveyer to prick at the crust and let the air out so that is falls. Overall, average pizza combined with the extra wait time gives this joint 2 stars in my book. read more

See all

Easy to order online and they had a lot of staff working! Cheese pizza and cheese bread was good. Ranch was made in house and our daughter thought it was the best! I also bought a peanut butter cookie while I was waiting. Cookies are big, soft, and yummy. Location is just off the Hamilton exit of 161. There are a few stools along the front window, but no other seating. Will definitely be back. read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - Menu - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

First time trying this place. Staff was very friendly and helpful. I got a personal pan size (6 pieces) bruschetta pizza. Very tasty and fresh. I wish the pizza dough had been cooked a bit longer but aside from that everything was great. Also inexpensive. read more

I ordered online and it says 20 minutes for takeout. I arrived at 20 minutes exactly and it was all ready to go! Ordering online was very easy around 1pm. I ordered 2 of the 8 inch cheese pizzas and they tasted great! The sauce, crust, and cheese all combines together for a great pizza. Each 8 inch was around $7.50 which seems fair ... but I felt like I was not completely full after an 8 inch so that's why I think I wish it were more filling or the 8 inch costed less. If I upgrade to the 12 inch for $13, I'm curious if I'd be full / if it's more financially worth it. All in, the pizza did taste wonderful and it's up there in favorite pizzas in the area! The only reason I'm not at 5 stars is the bank for your buck but still a quality pizza and I will definitely return. read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - 8 inch cheese pizza - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

So glad I decided to try this spot. The pizzas and wings are always fresh and delicious and ingredients are quality! The crust is super yummy and they have always followed any notes and included extra sauces which I appreciate. I recommend trying their pepperoni or a white pizza with ranch or garlic butter base. They haven't missed yet for me! read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Brenz has been on my list for a while now and I'm so glad I finally made it in! Tried a little bit of everything and loved. The pizza is great -- doughier than traditional Columbus style with a respectable ratio of toppings and dough. The pizza is wonderful but then the CinnaBrenz... that'll have you hooked. After being quite full, my husband and I finished this entire tub. Savory and sweet perfection. In total we tried the greek salad, mushroom trio pizza, spicy Hawaiian pizza, cinnabrenz, and a couple cookies!! Firm believer that jalapeño should be on every Hawaiian pizza now! So good and would definitely return. read more

See all

This is one of my favorite places to just chill get my personal size pizza the customer Service is amazing they remember my name and it's just overall chill definitely 10/10 highly recommended read more

Hands down. The best pizza I have ever had. They make it so the pizza is crunchy, soft, doughy all at the same time. Normally im a well done crunchy pizza guy but this is the exception this is the best pizza place in THE Columbus area, if you haven't tried it already please do and try the breadsticks. The breadsticks are to die for as the top layer is soft and still doughy but still cooked and as you go down it's cooked and yet still doughy, highly recommend and and I can guarantee I will be returning. I would rate 10 out of 10 if I could read more

Awesome pizza! Their Rustic Pizza is one of my favorites if not my most favorite pizza! It's amazing it's not more popular! read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - 1/2 Rustic Pizza, 1/2 veg Vegetable Out Pizza - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I've had Brenz before and loved it! Their ranch is so good and the crust is buttery. On my most recent trip, I was let down. The service was fast and kind, but my pizza was drenched in hot honey. I ordered the heritage honey. This was a new pizza for me to try, and I loved all the toppings so I was excited. I knew there was hot honey, and I like hot honey. When I got home and opened the box, I was shocked at the amount of hot honey on my pizza. It was pooling across the top and had started to seep into the bottom of the box. The flavor of the pizza was fine, but I couldn't finish it due to the amount of sweetness it had. I tried with all my power to dab it up, but then it would take the ricotta with my napkin! I was sad because this was my birthday month pizza and I had been saving it for my actual birthday. While I've had good pizza, this one just grossed me out for some reason and isn't motivating me to come back anytime soon, read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - Heritage Honey Pizza - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

One of the best pizzas I've had in a very long time. Nothing to say other than great topping choices, specialty pizzas, and very friendly service that helped me with my choice. read more

I was not impressed with Brenz Pizza Co. It was more the experience than the food that will be the result in me not returning. First time customer and they lost my future business and I doubt they care. On Sept. 23rd around 3:30pm we stopped in for a meal. Party of two. Two separate order of wings and side salads (no croutons). Two checks. First order salad arrived with croutons. Then first order wings came out. Then my salad (with croutons again). I kept waiting for my wings. My other party finished their meal and finally the staff came back out and apologized and went to check on my wings. Then more waiting. Basically a catering order came in and they forgot the rest of the second order. I asked after waiting over 30 minutes if they could put it in a box to go at this point. When they came out, he stated "sorry for the miscommunication". There was no miscommunication, you just missed the order. Not even any sort of compensation or 10% off or on your next order or anything. It was just not a good experience. I gave some time before writing this review. The person taking the order was great, went out of her way, and you could tell she felt terrible. The second time she came out I felt bad for her for having to explain to us the croutons and orders, etc. Manager I am guessing is the one that made eye contact and sent another person over at the end (the miscommunication guy). To be fair I did take my wings home and toss them in the oven a little later and they were delicious. If you do go there I can say the garlic parm wings are good but not good enough for me to return. I was so excited about trying this place out. Actually had looked at 4 different menus and chose Brenz Pizza over the others. That's my story and my overall experience is why I am not rating higher. No reason to. read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - Brenz Pizza Co. - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Damn good pizza. They are great with big orders for catering. Kind caring and helpful staff.

Awesome pizza! Fast service. Few places to sit but I'd get the pizza and sit in the parking lot. Will be back as often as I am in Columbus.

Best Pizza Ever sometimes I drive from Dayton just to come and get their pizza. I love it just that much.

Good pizza and salad. Way too much trash. If dining in they should give you a salad in a real bowl with a real fork, or at least not put the plastic lid on the cardboard bowl after they already asked if it was dine in or takeout. I also wish restaurants would stop putting salad dressing in plastic cups. Just put it on the salad! There is way too much plastic waste in this world. Employees were very nice. read more

Im kind of a pizza snob and this was pretty good pizza. The crust was crisp on the outside but pillowy on the top. Loaded pep and cheese toppings were great. Tasty sauce. Would be 5 stars, but thought $19 (including tip) for a 12" was a little steep. Pizza was good enough for a return visit. read more

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus - Loaded pep and cheese 12" - Salad Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Online ordering was easy, and my order only took a few minutes to pack up for carryout after the quoted time, despite them being short-staffed. The garlic parm wings were meaty and good, the spinach salad was nice and fresh, but the pizza was just okay. We got the Heartland - I was craving the balsamic caramelized onions, but they were overpowered by the pepperoni. Thought there was a bit too much going on. read more

Pizza is delicious! Customer service is among the worst I have ever experienced. They don't give a crap if they messed up. Aligned with other reviews, it's like pulling teeth to get a semblance of an apology. I'll be thinking twice before ordering from them again. If customer service improves, it will be an easy decision. Of note- this has NOTHING to do with with COVID. It doesn't take much to be a decent human. read more

While on a business trip, eight of us went to Brenz Pizza in Columbus OH. We called ahead and they suggested we get the: Tres Amigos, BBQ, and the Classic. We did. And - wow, this pizza was amazingly good. I am a pizza snob and this place passes with flying colors. While we were there, we saw people coming in and out, it was a happenin' place to be. Everyone had a smile on their face as they ate their choice of pie. Additionally they have breadsticks, wings, salads, sub and wraps. We did not try them. However, we did get a couple orders of CinnaBrenz (dough covered in butter, cinnamon, sugar and a side of icing). They came fresh out of the oven and were great! 5 stars all the way! Yum, Yum, Extra Yum! read more

See all

The first time I had this pizza was at a work meeting in Grandview. I loved the bruschetta pizza. It was truly memorable. I kept meaning to go into the shop to get this pizza again, but it actually took several months. I did on Saturday and it was spur-of-the-moment because it is next door to Nothing But Bundt, where I was headed to use a Groupon before it expired. First I stopped in to order a pizza and salad for carryout. After picking up the cake, I waited for my order. The place is small, but has a decent dining area, with 2 tv's. The register gal was very nice, and when ready, she brought my order to me. I took it home to share with my husband and the bruschetta pizza was every bit as good as the first time I tasted it. The house salad was really tasty too, with a great selection of vegs and shaved parm. This is my new favorite. read more

The people are very friendly, the pizza is always delicious, and the salads are well made!

My co-workers and I were looking for a good place for lunch and decided to try Brenz Pizza, as we saw on Yelp their pizza looked good! I was not disappointed or maybe I was just very hungry since the pizza tasted so good for the original and pepperoni. We did half of both and was able to share with the whole office that pizza. In addition, we ordered the house salad and that was very good. With a side of cinna bunz, let me tell you those cinna bunz are as good as the Yelp picture posts. I literally had my co-workers wanting to remember this place so we can go back and get more pizza and cinna bunz again! I literally had to bookmark them to help me remember to review them and tell the Yelp community how amazing this pizza establishment is. It's comparable to Pizza Cucinova. If your looking for a good pizza place in town and happen to be near the Lennox area stop by Brenz! You will not be disappointed! read more

I have never visited this restaurant. I ordered from door dash. The 5 piece wings I ordered were really good. I decided to try the sweet heat sauce and it was sooo good. The wings were cooked well and weren't too soggy or crispy. The sauce was a little spicy but also sweet which is perfect. I usually get Buffalo or spicy garlic, but I'm happy I tried the sweet heat sauce. They also give you a big side of ranch which is nice. If you're craving quality wings you should try Brenz! read more