Stopped in after running a few errands, and left questioning every other pizza I've ever eaten. Four Points looks like your typical small pizza joint with a bar--but don't be fooled. The pies here come fully loaded, like they were built by an overachieving Italian grandma who refuses to accept "light toppings" as a concept. I grabbed a Supreme and a Carnivore, because balance is important--veggies for the soul, meats for the heart (and cholesterol). Both were cooked perfectly: crisp crust, cheesy layers of happiness, and toppings stacked so high they needed their own building permit. Had a couple of local microbrews while I waited--because what's pizza without beer? The bartender was friendly and clearly knew their stuff. Bonus points for serving up brews that didn't taste like they were filtered through regret. Took the pies home and--no surprise--they were a hit. Everyone's inner food critic went quiet after the first bite. Verdict: Four Points Pizza is the kind of place that makes "errands" sound like code for "pizza mission." Come hungry read more

Four Points Pizza & Grill - Supreme pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

See all

Not my first time here, but tonight was not a good night. I will say, the actual food was good and did not have any problem with it. Our problem was speed. There were 4 of us. Our food was ordered at 5:45 PM. We had a sandwich, 2 calzones, 6 honey BBQ wings and cheese garlic bread. Wings and bread requested as a meal, not app. 35 minutes later the sandwich is delivered along with the bread. Nothing else. We asked twice about our food and were told sorry and that the kitchen is backed up. Another 20 minutes and watching others get served at the bar that appeared to be friends with the bartender and order well after us, the calzones come. The wings came right after but were wrong. Not to mention the first beer was brought out and rudely slammed on the table and it was wrong. The bartender seemed to have an attitude when told this and asked for a glass. Never an apology for anyone in authority. No offers to make it right after telling the order taker twice. Sorry to say this sold your fate, doubt we will be back. The whole experience took well over an hour. Too long. Willing to allow anyone to have a bad night but admit it and try to make it right. $65 spent at the table. read more

This is by far, the best pizza i have had since i have been in ohio. My wife and I arrived right when they opened. Was nice and quiet. The wings we ordered were delicious, the garlic bread was fantastic. The pizza crust was thing and crunchy. Toppings were fresh. Will definitely be returning, if i could give it a higher rating i would . The service was great as well. read more

Four Points Pizza & Grill - 14" Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

Can't say enough good things about this food! staff is friendly . Been eating at Four Points weekly for years. A MUST TRY!

Wow! We've been in Delaware over 2 years and never been here. Great pizza, the Italian sub was also excellent. Very friendly service. We'll definitely be back! read more

Very good pizza. We will be back! Both service and food were good. It was an all-around good experience.

We ordered food for twenty and they delivered at lunch. The order was organized,correct and well labeled which is amazing for 20 orders! I got the pork tacos and a small antipasto salad. I should've just gotten the pork tacos because I couldn't even finish them. I ended up having to antipasto salad for dinner and it was fabulous as well. The portion sizes are huge! I found the menu so unique that you could get pulled pork tacos, and a calzone all together on one menu. The flavor and quality of all of the food was top-notch. I would highly recommend this place read more

Four Points Pizza & Grill - Pork tacos - Pizza Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

Why isn't this place crowded?? Great pizza, friendly staff and owner!! Talked to the owner, after we were stuffed with pizza. Found out they smoke their chicken wings and serve house made cheesecake... we are gonna definitely be back!! read more

Moved to the area last March and finally got around to trying Four Points. I'm a fool for waiting so long. Called and verified that I was in the delivery zone and the girl who answered the phone was very helpful and polite. Ordered a 12" half cheese half pep and the club sub. Was quoted 45-50 minutes and it arrived a little early and piping hot! They do a Columbus style pie and appears they use Auddino's rolls for their subs. The pie had great pep coverage and was cooked perfectly. Plenty of sauce and cheese. Great flavor. The sub have a good amount of meat and fixings. It was wonderful. I'm looking forward to trying the Italian sub next. Next time I will be dining in as it looks like they have a nice bar area. Couldn't recommend more. read more

Just know that if you go there to eat, it's not really a restaurant, in other words, you don't really get service like you would expect at a restaurant. Plan on going to the counter to get the attention of one of the teenagers to get off their phone for a minute to take care of you and get what you need but if you're unwilling to do that then forget it I wouldn't even bother going in there despite the fact that the food is great. read more

So glad we stopped here after driving by so many times. Veteran -Owned restaurant. They have a good selection of food. Their pizzas and desserts are absolutely amazing. The Gawaii Five-O is delicious and so is the Carnivore pizza. They even smoke their own ham, which is absolutely the best in the area as far as I am concerned. The subs are wonderful too. The staff is nice and polite. And it's absolutely touching that they have a Special area on the walls for Honoring Military and First Responders. This is good spot to drop in for good food and to relax. read more

See all

Been to this place twice because its close to me both times service slow I think food is average and over priced. And no egg in chef salad WTH. Wont be back Too many other places have better pizza and better wings and service. read more

This has quickly become my family's favorite pizza place! We love the pizza, subs, and garlic bread. There is a small dining room, which has been mostly empty when we do carry out. We dined in yesterday and were so glad we did! Eating the food as soon as it was ready did not disappoint. Friendly staff as well! Will definitely be our go to spot from now on! read more

This place is a hidden gem. On top of the good food... they have thee best cheesecake in town!!! They have different flavors each week. Bury me with this cheesecake... seriously. Staff is so friendly and attentive. I've had the meatball sub, calzone, chef salad, cheesy bread & all phenomenal. read more

Four Points Pizza & Grill - Maple Bacon Cheesecake - Pizza Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

See all

We loved it. Dropped in with my family on a Friday evening. Pizza was absolutely delicious. (We are self proclaimed pizza critics) we also got a veggie sub that was so good. We live in the area and this place is now at the top of our list for pizza night. You can tell they put a lot of care and excellence in their food. read more

Our first visit to the 4 points. One of the best pizzas we've ever had. Our 14" veggie with sausage crumbles was loaded with veggies. Check my photo. Delicious We also got a small Italian salad which filled a medium size stainless bowl when my wife took it out of the clam shell package. We will be back. read more

Four Points Pizza & Grill - Italian salad - Pizza Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

See all

I have been ordering from here for many years and I have seen some of the reviews and wanted to clear up some misconceptions. These pizzas are cooked in a stone bottom pizza oven, not a conveyer belt one. This is how pizza SHOULD be cooked. I have gotten some with hard crusts but it will be crisp being it was cooked on a stone. Sauces are good too. I have eaten many places for pizza and I think Four Points has the best sauce of all them. If people have heartburn then take your meds. There is nothing wrong with this sauce. I have never gotten a pizza with short or burnt toppings and I have ordered well over 100 times from this place. Pizza's are properly cooked, taste great, and generally so hot you have to wait for it to cool down before eating! If you love hot pizzas with plenty of toppings and great tastes then you need to come here. Staff is very friendly and the building is top notch clean! You will not be disappointed. Now I'm off to order a pizza from them! read more

This pizza was amazing! The crust was thin and delicious and the toppings were great, especially the banana pepper rings that were surprisingly spicy on the deluxe pizza. This was great pizza and a must stop if in the area. Dare I say, I would drive the hour from my home to eat this pizza! The garlic bread is also awesome! read more

Online order for pickup 3/20/20 Large pepperoni pizza Large house salad w ranch This place used to be called The Pizza Cabin, and was located just a few minutes south of this location. Recently they moved to a bigger location with a large dining room but also changed their name. However because of COVID-19 and the quarantine we could only do carry out. I called ahead and placed an order and the food was ready in 15 minutes. When I arrived I was greeted promptly when I entered. My order was ready, I paid and headed back home. Dinner was excellent, but would prefer eating there next time so the pizza is a little more hot, and fresh. The pizza still had the same taste and quality as the previous location. I appreciated that they kept their recipe and didn't completely change what they were doing. The salad was rather bland and was not any good. It was just iceberg lettuce, diced cheese, a few tomatoes, a couple cucumbers and red onion. It was a cheap, tasteless salad that I would not recommend ordering. read more

See all

We finally got to try this from the new location. If you don't know, it used to be The Pizza Cabin, but they moved out of the cabin and changed the name. I hope they don't lose business by doing that. We like to eat in, but did take out since we're all supposed to stay home right now. They had a coupon for a large pizza and house salad. I would probably skip the salad, as it's just iceberg lettuce with some standard toppings. The pizza is really good. The slightly crisped pepperonis are somewhat of a signature here. A little on the spicy side for me, but still yummy. read more

Four Points Pizza & Grill - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

See all

Ordered for the first time on a Thursday evening, wait time was only 20-25 minutes for pickup. Pizza was over cooked and very crispy, like really crispy. Cheese was burnt and hardly there at all. Sauce had good flavor though. read more

Four Points Pizza & Grill - 12" half pepperoni half Carnivore - Pizza Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

I was surprised how much I enjoyed their pepperoni pizza. Crispy and simple. Very enjoyable! Will return for sure. One of those places you pass on highway often and never stop. Give them a try! read more

Ordered several times and had no delivery, Waited 1.5 hours and more.... Poor staff and frequent turn over of staff. Very frustrating! I am done. read more

Ok, nothing special. Had a sausage, onion and I had a hard time distinguishing between ingredients. Friends had their own and enjoyed them. Go back yes read more

Consistently good pizza! Subs are one of my top two favorites in the Columbus/Delaware area. Reasonably priced and always good on time promised. read more

This pizza was just ok. It was a very thin crust. Not cracker like Donatos. But crackly? Hard to describe. Very tomato-y sauce which gave the hubs heartburn. Bummer. Pretty light on the toppings. The cheese was good. Overall, 3/10. I wouldn't go out of my way to order it again but if I was driving by on my way back from Menards, I would support the locals. Hubs loved the garlic bread, for what it's worth. read more

This place was great. I had always wanted to try the pizza at the pizza cabin and never got to. When I found out this was them just in a new location I was jazzed. Pleased with the pizza. Pepperoni was nice and crisp, bottom was crispy, sauce wasn't sweet or bitter. The cheese was a bit meh, but it was ok with everything else on it. I was enticed when I was told about the dessert so I bought a slice of chocolate cake, and a slice of cheesecake. The chocolate cake was very Rich with the chocolate fudge as well but the cake was dry. Really needed something to drink with both how dry and how sweet it was. The cheesecake seemed over baked and undermixed. The cheesecake was crumbly and not creamy and there were pockets of granules where the sugar had not incorporated into the batter. Overall I would go back for the pizza, I would give the cheesecake another shot since I've been told that's not their norm. Also $4.50 for the slice of cake you get seems like a steal. read more

Great food, stellar service, kind people. Awesome deal on quality wings!! $12 for 12 well cooked well seasoned wings.

Awesome food, consistent and pretty great service! I have only ever done carry out but it's been whT I need.

The pizza is great - they even have gluten free crust available. My son prefers the cauliflower crust! The wings are the best we've had anywhere- they are smoked and then sauced. read more

Four Points Pizza & Grill - Me and my fav daughter - Pizza Near Me - Lewis Center, Ohio

See all

Remember that time when you had a great pizza then followed up with a big piece of cheesecake? Yeah. It was awesome pairing!

Best wings we have had since moving to Columbus. Big and saucy with lots of different flavors. We will be back!

Smoked wings were excellent. Pizza with spicy sausage was delicious as well. And, very affordable. Great spot.

We tried Four Points recently and have found our new favorite pizza place. Quality ingredients (Ezzo Pepperoni, Auddino Sub Buns) and great service at a reasonable price. We will definitely be back! read more

Absolutely the best cheesecake I have ever had. Amazing. It is definitely a great place to eat and the service was great. A nice quaint little spot. I recommend you stop in and try their delicious cheesecake, the pulled pork sandwich the subs and the pizza. Just fantastic. read more

Delivery of pizza and subs costs are too high thin crust pizza was over cooked (burnt) .It was very close to closing time and they sounded agitated that I was ordering. read more

Been looking for "the pizza" ever since moving to the area. This is it. Fantastic pizza. Very crispy crust. Great taste with that little bit of char on the crust and pepperoni. Prices are very reasonable as well. This will be a weekly staple going forward I'm sure. read more

If you're a ranch person- this is your place-ha! Their pizza is okay. Delivery has always been consistent and reliable which is great when you want to have something delivered that isn't a chain and isn't through Grubhub. Not the best pizza in the world, but it's good enough. read more

Came for an impromptu late lunch on our way to Lake Erie. We had pizza last night, so we sampled orange-sriracha smoked wings, a meatball, chicken tenders and a chef salad. I can't say enough about how fresh and tasty everything was! Salad crisp and cold, homemade meatball, SMOKED wings with a nice sticky sauce. (My husband says TOP 2 of all time) So impressed and will definitely be back next time we're in town! read more

Some of the best pizza in the area, especially delivered. Always hot, crispy and fresh toppings.