This place could have killed me! Ordered some subs and the only thing I asked for was no peppers because Im allergic to them. Drove 25 mins to get them get home and they had poppers all over them so I called them to have them replaced and was told "pick them off" they refused to replace them or give a refund. The audacity of this place. If I wouldn't have checked i would be in the hospital. Beware if u have any good allergies. Or if they mess up ur order chulk it up to a loss because they refuse to actually have costumer service. I recorded the man on the phone telling me to pick them off and refusing a refund or to replace. If I wasn't deathly allergic them it wouldn't be a big deal but the way they treated me on top of it!!! Yeah unexceptable! read more

Food was ok. Not great not memorable just ok Service was ok Ambiance is a take pizza place. read more

Padova's Pizza - pepperoni, cheese, and jalapenos - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The worst customer service I've ever experienced. I belittled , mocked and felt attacked by someone who claimed to be the owner. Placed an online order that was made incorrectly. Instead of correcting he insisted I placed the order wrong and told me to never order from there again. I explained how I was a loyal customer and advocated for them, he mocked me by saying they will have to close because I've decided not to do business there any longer. I have never felt so disrespected. I will no longer be doing business with them read more

This pizza is PHENOMENAL. Italian Sub was Good. Pricing is fair for portion & quality! My first time and definitely won't be my last. We got a large meat lovers and an Italian sub. Pizza is thin and cooked perfectly, hearty amount of tasty sauce, toppings are top tier with JUICY Italian sausage, fresh LEGIT bacon crumbles & pepperoni is on a DONATOS level, with pieces of ham that are not slimy or seem to have been frozen. Plenty of toppings. The sub would be top quality if it had a flavor to the bread, maybe a garlic butter on top or even cheese and be toasted. MORAL OF STORY my family will be back & we will be telling EVERYONE about this pizzeria. read more

See all

Picked up a large all meat pizza and Buffalo wings. So good. Generous toppings, Good price. Good service. Nice break from chain pizza shops read more

Best pizza in Columbus. Been coming here for 40+ years. Owner is awesome too. We also really like the Italian subs and steak subs

Good solid pizza. Fresh and hot each time. The staff was delightful to me. Parking and maneuvering can be a bit of a pain. read more

Padova's Pizza - Counter for ordering. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

No matter what you pick you can't go wrong with Padova's! Yahya and staff know your name and order by heart! Food is always consistently amazing, out fast and always hot!! read more

Padova's Pizza - Chicken Salad - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Padovas has been consistently the best pizza I've had in Columbus. Always affordable, cooked evenly, cut all the way through, and delicious! read more

Padova's Pizza - Large pep sausage xcheese Yummmm! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Decent pizza if you like your sauce thick n sweet. Pepperoni not spicy just normal. The cheese itself doesn't have a deep cheese flavor. The crust is decent. The Italian subs were not as good as the Big Don from Donato. Most of the flavor is from the Italian dressing. Just ok. read more

Padova's Pizza - You get 2 Italian sub with medium pepperoni for 17.95$ - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I called padova pizza at 9:50pm 1/5/24 to place an order for a medium pep. a lady answered the phone and was completely and blatantly disrespectful and arrogant.. she answered the phone telling me its about 10-10:30 and your trying to place an order... I said it's not even 10pm yet and you guys don't close until 11pm?? she cut me off mid sentence to say well go ahead order then.. I proceeded to order but she was so rude in her tone and how she was speaking me and my fiancé were utterly speechless because we order here all the time and never received this treatment so obviously she's new. FIRE her because she just lost you guys a frequent some customers! never eating here again. read more

If you are a thin crust pizza lover, this is one of the best. Pepperoni was just like I want it. The kind that curls up with little grease puddles. Fantastic sauce. Absolutely fantastic. Only $13.95 for xtra large pep. read more

Padova's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I used to live close now I live in reynoldsburg but I made the trip down noe Bixby and just as good as I remember I did opt for extra cheese this time YUM!!! read more

See all

So I've been doing the low carb diet for over a year now and last night I decided to have a "cheat" night. I have no regrets in choosing Padova's as my cheat meal! They have an awesome pizza recipe. The sauce has a sweetness to it and their sausage has got just the right amount of spice. I am typically not a fan of sausage on my pizza but their sausage recipe is delicious! The only reason they didn't get 5 stars was that the crust on the center pieces was not as crispy as I thought it should have been. But if crisping the center pieces means the outer pieces change texture or consistency then I would keep it as is. And as I sat in the car waiting for my husband to get the pizza... I noticed that there is a Donatos's pizzeria just 4 doors down from them. It says a lot that a mom and pop place can stay in business with a big box store only a few doors down! This is a special place and I would highly recommend them to anyone. read more

Padova's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Im still kind of new to the area and wanted to try a different pizza place for dinner . Read some reviews before deciding to order . I was pretty hesitant about ordering just because the reviews didn't seem that great. However, I decided to order anyways! The gentlemen at the counter when I picked up were really nice ! I ordered a medium pepperoni with an order of their pizza rolls. The pizza rolls are FRIED !!! I was happily surprised by this !! The sauce on the pizza was good! There was a good sauce, crust (thin crust), and topping ratio ! Overall a really good pizza! read more

Padova's Pizza - An order of the pizza rolls ! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

We just bought a house in Blacklick estates and tried Padovas pizza for the first time...so glad we did because it is my new favorite pizza place! I love the sauce and the pepperonis and it's crunchy and soooo good! This will be my go to all the time now. read more

Best pizza in Columbus!! I've been living in Columbus for 25 years, I am from New York and could not find decent pizza here it was really sad! I had Padova one day for the first time about 12 years ago and been hooked ever cents. The flavor of the pizza sauce the combination with the delicious made class was just amazing! As far as I'm concerned this is the best pizza place in Columbus hands down!!! read more

Really good pizza!Ok subs, but the pizza/ sauce is really good. They don't deliver more than a few blocks, but worth it to pick up when you're wanting great pizza! read more

I came in to order and was treated like hurry up and get out of here we are to busy to deal with your questions. They guy was argumentative which turned me off about ordering but I did order anyway like a dummy. I know I will never be back, very rude people working there. read more

We just bought our first house near here. Neighbors have repeatedly recommended this place so we gave it a try over the weekend. It's always a little scary trying a new restaurant but we absolutely loved it!! The thin crust is crunchy but not obnoxious. The sauce is so good it reminds me of my Italian grandmother's recipe and the toppings are delicious! So thrilled to be able to support a family business that's also so convenient for us. Highly recommend read more

I like to support local businesses when possible, and tonight I decided to give Padova's a try. I ate there a few times before back in early 2000's when I lived near there. Obviously it's under new ownership but still has the same great prices. I ordered a xlarge pepp pizza and 2 Italian subs. The pizza is ok, not the best I have had but for the price it's decent. The Italian subs were ok, but could have been great if they weren't soaked in Italian dressing. If I go back I may try a pizza with more toppings, and the sub minus the dressing. I will say they were super busy, so there are people who love their food. read more

Great mom and pop pizza joint on the east side! Made exactly how Midwestern style pizza should be. Plenty of cheese and tons of toppings. The crust is your thin to medium midwest style baked 'just' under being solidly crunchy if that makes sense. 5 star except for the area is a tad iffy, but kudos to the owners for staying true to their roots. read more

With donatos and anges pizza in close proximity this is definitely your best bet. Old world pepperonis that curl up. Amazing subs at a great price. Sauce is not too sweet. Not a huge delivery area but i wouldnt recommend delivery anyways because the wait time is usually long. Call in. Because it gets hot in there in the summertime. You dont want to dine in even though that is an available option. It will takr away from your experience. Pretty good prices. This is amazing pizza for carryout. Best in the area read more

Padova's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Horrible customer service and average pizza. I went to pickup my pizza last night, and the guy behind the counter gets my pizza, rings it up and tells me to "slide my card". So I do while he turns around continuing to make pizzas. The message on the credit card reader says "Processing", so I figure he needs to finish the transaction. I grab his attention by saying "Are we good?", because I believe he needs to complete the transaction and give me a receipt. He comes back to the counter and realizes he put the total for my 1 large pizza as $2.05... his mistake and I hadn't noticed. However, he seems to blame me by saying "Whoa, it's not $2.05. You didn't pay for this pizza, we aren't 'good!'". So he rings up the correct charge of $16.95. I slide my card again, it processes, he throws the receipt on my pizza box and says "Don't ever try that again buddy!". I say nothing, turn around with people behind me and he calls me a "Cock sucker" . Like I was trying to steal the pizza, when he was the one who rang it up wrong. The only thing I said to him besides my order, was "Are we good?". I'm not an aggressive person so I just walked out and said nothing else to him. Now I got 2 charges from Padova - one for a $16.95 pizza and a $2.05 charge because some guy can't do his job. And I'm the "cock sucker". Never going back. read more

I've had Padova's pizza once (picture posted) and I enjoyed it. The sauce taste sweet, but I thought there was way to much cheese and not enough pepperoni. I was impressed w/ the customer service received, they were polite and courtesy, i'll be eating here in the future. read more

Padova's Pizza - small pepperoni with sausage - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I've been going all over the place seeking a tasty pizza and little did I know, close by was a hidden gem with great service ! New year and new favorite pizza place!! read more

Padova's Pizza - Yummy large Pep with extra cheese and sauce - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Tried this today was not good... the lady at the front who took my order was very nice even tho she stated they we short staffed.... when I went to pick up the small pep I order a rude man with an accent tossed the pizza on the counter... got the pizza home opened the box it looked ok but dident taste that great why does the flavor of the sauce over power the tasteless pepperoni and the cheese was not real cheese more like the kind u get from Lil Caesar where in the world did they find TASTELESS pepperoni..1st and last time for this place!!..also the place is not to clean very dusty... I was starving and this pizza was gross and a waste of money SMH!!! read more

Awesome pizza! Second visit and have only tried the slightly sweet pizza so I suspect everything is just as great. Priced right and excellent customer service. Guy at the counter was super nice. I'll be back!! read more

My dad always always orders pizza from here and it's literally so good I could eat it everyday. My work also orders it all the time it's really the only place they order from because it's the only place we all can agree on. The staff is always kind and friendly and the delivery time is always right typically early which is amazing. read more

Hidden GEM!! I am telling you you would not expect pizza of this caliber in this part of town but it is absolutely worth the trip to eat their pies. Very reasonable priced. I learned this place has been in business for a long time. That is for a reason and it shows. They know what they're doing. It's a shame more people do not know about Padova's. Glad I made the drive from Canal to order a pizza. I will be coming here again. read more

My roommate ordered this pizza and it was my 1st time. THAT pizza was very good. I've had the pizza two more times since then and both times it has been mediocre. Apparently the quality is inconsistent. I'm not interested in wasting my money anymore @ this place. read more

One of my favorite pizza places! Must try pep, bacon and banana pepper pizza! So delicious. read more

Padova's Pizza - a slice of pizza on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

i used too live very close to this place and i move 20 min away. I still make the trip like i still live close by. The pizza is hard to beat from the crust to the toppings. It has not changed in 20 yrs. My all time favorite in Columbus and ive been all around this city to find a place better and i cant. read more

Price is good. Food is decent. Subs are the best they have to offer. The staff are friendly and keep me coming back for the subs.

New to the area and sampling pizza joints....this is by far our favorite so far. The prices are amazing and the pizza is too!! This is our new spot with convenient online ordering and fast service. read more

The pizza here is great! My wife and I tried it for the first time and we are hooked. We had a large pep and cheese! Perfect amount of pepperoni, the sauce has a slight sweetness, which we loved, and the cheese was amazing. We will definitely be adding Padova's to the list of our local favorites. read more

This is probably on of our favorite pizza places in Columbus! They are different than all the chains. Ingredients are fresh and in generous portions. They have become our Friday night tradition for supper. The sauce is extra special a bit on the sweet side and we just love it! They are super friendly too! read more

Padova's pizza has been a favorite around the area. My brother comes from Pickerington to pick up Padova's.

will never order from Padovas again!!!! i had a missed call from the shop so i called backed the person on the phone talked over me saying the pizza was on the way and they didn't call. ten minutes later another call. apparently my neighbor accepted the pizza and driver thought it was paid for by credit card. owner claims he can't control my neighbors or his driver. when asked what they would do to make this right best he could do was free 2 liter. read more

I am going to start out by saying i have eaten this pizza for years. The last few times i have observed a few things that have made me take my business elsewhere and question the quality of the food and environment. The owner is not very nice to his employees patronizing and correcting them in front of customers, if you walk to the far left of the counter you can see the girl sometimes a guy making subs without any gloves. I have also smelled a strong order of cigarette smoke twice that was so strong it overpowered the smell of pizza. Working in the food industry for quite sometime these are very concerning observations. Be careful. read more