Tried GoreMade Pizza last month for the first time & I will definitely be going back! Fittingly located in Italian Village, the service is quick, staff is friendly & vibes are on point! This is a great spot for take out, a date night, or sharing a pizza with friends! I snuck in on the last day of the month & got to try the Sweet Heat pizza of the month; it was fire!! The pineapple-Gochujang Hot Honey brought this pie to the next level; all of the toppings are great quality, and this was one of the best tasting pizzas I've had in the city! The cheese on the classic cheese was so fresh & the pizzas are cooked great in general! Make sure to get some of their awesome house made ranch too! read more

See all

It had been awhile so I gave this another shot. It keeps coming up as a Neapolitan pizza but I just don't get that impression. The crust isn't chewy at all. It's all very thin and flat. I only live a few streets over and the pizza arrived very cold. Each time my experience just gets worse. read more

GoreMade Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Great service with limited seats. Thin crispy pizzas with unique ingredients. Their 8 slice size is optimal for each person. Be aware prices are above standard chain pizza places, but totally worth it. We all loved our options. read more

See all

True neopolitan style pizza. Very kind owners who take a lot of pride in what they do. Pizza made carefully and with love. Fresh and unique seasonal toppings and thoughtful monthly specials. Very addicting pizza read more

Saw this woodfired pizza place and wanted to try it. You place your order at the counter and disposed of your own trash. They have a water station for water. Serve beer and wine. It's small. We did not encounter any rudeness referenced in other posts. It is a little pricey for what you get but we found the pizza good. It had a nice woodfired firm crust on the edge but more slim and limpy on the inside. The basic salad is mixed greens and we had the basalmic dressing. It was good but challenging to eat with plasticware. Plastic forks, glass plates, & the salad came in a brown box - odd combo. Its a nice little place. It was not busy so we really enjoyed the ambiance read more

Friendly and helpful staff, unique and tasty food fired pizza. The garlic bread was very good. We love thin crust so this was a hit for our family. read more

How cute and convenient! Made it here during the Arnold and I was able to get a gluten free pizza. You have option for menu pizzas, create your own or chefs choice! I tried a chefs choice and loved it. The pizza i had didn't fall apart and was crunchyyyy! If you're unable to deal with cross contamination with gluten, it may not be the place for you though as there is only one pizza oven read more

Food and service was great! Craig was very personable and nice. The ambiance was cool as well, definitely recommend read more

GoreMade Pizza - Porkistopheles - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Always great. Server team was on it tonight. There was a Crew game tonight so it was very busy. We arrived at 530 and got a good table. The balsamic on the salad is really great. So is The Old Fashion. The water is cold! A Top 10 pizza in the area. read more

See all

The seasonal pizza for April 2026 is unreal. A true culinarily delight & it's absolutely stunning a must visit.

We had high hopes for this place. Being local, I had read that GM had some great pizza and was eager to finally try it. I won't deny that the pizza was good but not filling. We shared the larger pizza and was still hungry after. The reason for the 2 stars is bc service was absolutely awful! These guys really seemed like we were putting them out. We had a larger group of 8 on a Tuesday evening: grandparents, cousins and a young child. We were barely acknowledged when we walked in. There was one other group of customers and a couple sitting at the bar. While I like the concept of self-serving yourself water, plates, utensils, etc. maybe staff could have told us this was the case. A casual "Hello, have you visited us before? Please order at the counter and grab your plates and napkins" would have gone a long way. The "Order Here" sign was clear but was that for take-out/walk-ins only? I might be exaggerating if I said that the two staff members said 10 words to us. And after delivering our pizzas to the table, no one asked if we needed anything else. Again, just a simple, "do you need pepper flakes or parmesan?!" Very disappointing experience as our family was visiting from Seattle and another family member just purchased a condo nearby. It must be really bad for me to leave such a review. Doubtful any of us will return or recommend. read more

The pizza is awesome Service spectacular The ambiance is perfect for a pizza shop. The only complaint is parking. You will have to find parking and it can be difficult and you may have a long walk. With that said I take a star away. 4 stars read more

See all

I was not impressed with goremade and honestly sad about it. I've heard so many good things and finally wanted to give it a try. We ordered a large pizza and a garlic bread. When we went to pick it up, it was around 8:30 on a Saturday. Their site says they don't close till 10, but when we got there they were out of ranch. That's fine, but they offered us some jalapeño sauce? It wasn't what I would eat pepperoni pizza with. We went home and opened up the garlic bread. The bottom of the crust was charred and burnt. It's all we could taste. I was super bummed because it wasn't cheap either. Our pizza was fine, but tiny. I would've rather gone to Borgota or the truck outside seventh son. I sadly will not be back. Too expensive for not good pizza. read more

GoreMade Pizza - Burnt garlic bread - not good - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Sometimes I want a good wood fired pizza. It's a unique and great taste. Went to GoreMade pizza on N. 4th Street near downtown. Excellent pie. Got the 12" Porkistopheles pizza. Great flavor, fresh mozzarella, Ezzo pepperoni, sausage and bacon. Very thin and light. Not greasy. The crust is bubbly and perfectly cooked. Toasted but not burnt. They use an old pizza oven from Naples Italy and make each pizza by hand one at a time. The wood fired flavor really comes through. You can eat there or take out. Friendly staff. Reasonably priced for such great pizza. read more

GoreMade Pizza - Undercarriage is toasted but not burnt. Soft and bubbly. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Excellent, excellent pizza! My daughter has been raving about this place, and I was skeptical. But geez. This was so delicious! We got a Clintonvillain subbing the mushrooms for olives, and a Chef 's Choice Pizza -- also delicious!! Great crust, amazing toppings! A small pizza joint with a small bar and 6 or so tables. I'm sure they do a robust carry-out business but we sat at a table by the window. Helpful employees, who are clearly proud of their product. Street parking. We'll be back! read more

GoreMade Pizza - Chef's Choice at top and Clintonvillain (with olives instead of mushrooms) - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This place never fails to make a perfect thin crust pizza every single time. This time we ordered a bacon, mushroom and roasted onions, red sauce pizza. Sooo delicious and the staff is always helpful. Seating is okay but much more space outside in the back, weather permitting. Definitely will be back!!!!! Always!!! read more

One of the best Neapolitan pizzas I've ever tasted. Customer service is excellent! I spoke with the owner and he graciously offered me a tour. You get an old world vibe from this place and if you like Neapolitan pizza, this is definitely a stop you should make more than once. Even though I was surprised by the quantity of the pizza; which due to the size of the mouth of the oven cannot be altered, the quality of the pizza far surpassed my expectations which more than made up for it time and again. I'll definitely be back to try my hand at a different take of this passionately made artisan style masterpiece. I highly recommend getting it well done if you're getting delivery. You'll thank me later. read more

The side salad was $5 and life changing I loved it so much! Pizza was light and super easy to eat, restaurant was adorable, and the service was very friendly! The outdoor dining was also super cool! read more

GoreMade Pizza - Car in outdoor dining section. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Outstanding pizzas that are fairly lesser known throughout town. I love this place - truly well made (or should I say "gore-made") pizzas with a personalized flare. Everytime I go here, I leave with a smile - I wish I also left with leftovers, but the pizzas are just too good. Great service, fun decor, everything is just so fun. read more

See all

I had my fiancée order a meat lover's pizza to go. When I arrived to get the pizza I was met like I lived in the neighborhood and had been there before. It small but clean with a bar and a few places to dine in. Once I picked up the and drove an hour home. I heated the pizza up in the air fryer and it was amazing. read more

The pizza was great and the restaurant is small and cozy. Wood fired, which I didn't know and was great. Deducting a star because when I ordered, it would've been nice to know I was going to sit there for over an hour to get my food. Restaurant's typically give you the courtesy of telling you it's looking like 60-70 min until we get to your order. Told me there were 9 more pizzas infront of us after I had been waiting for 30 minutes and asked about the order. read more

The owner was there, he was nice and helpful. His service was great. Once he left, the other 2 guys working basically didn't talk to us until we had to pay. It was odd and the one guy seemed annoyed to be there. The pizza was decent. Prices were what most places seem to charge. The overall place is a little small. There was a third guy in the back kitchen cutting onions and my eyes started to burn & water. Glad we were paying to leave at that point. read more

Discovered this awesome small local business thanks to Yelp! The pizza is so yummy and I have been wanting to take my partner, Chris, so he could try it. Today was the perfect day for pizza and for him to try some pies! We ordered the Annie Social and the Clintonvillain Pizza and we have leftovers for tomorrow. The Annie Social Pizza ($16) has bacon, red onion and feta with the olive oil base. The Clintonvillain Pizza ($16) is my favorite with roasted mushrooms, smoked salt, truffle oil, and grated cheese with an the olive oil base. It's a nice laid back shop with seating inside and outside on the patio. There is even an art car on the patio. Definitely recommend and can't wait to come back! Next visit count with the chef's choice. read more

See all

Great pizza owner really nice good service and great drinks loved the patio cool old car with toys on it and lots of cool lights read more

GoreMade Pizza - Wood oven - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Didn't know this place existed until recently, and it's right down the street from my place. The cheesy garlic bread is amazing - a must try! The pizzas come in a round 12" or you can get the pizza boat, which is half sized. I really enjoy thin-crust pizza and I think this place is my favorite in Columbus so far. They definitely have some unique toppings to choose from. I went with a basic pizza, but will have to try their pesto next time I'm there. There is an outdoor area available with decent amount of seating, which I did not know at first! read more

GoreMade Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Visited on pizza tour. WOW the pizza texture and flavors were phenomenal. Owner was extremely personal with tons of information read more

I first came here with my father just cause we were in the area and wanted some quick pizza, but it tasted so good that we've been coming back every other week for the past year read more

Finally made it to GoreMade for the first time and it did not disappoint. The inside of the restaurant is small and intimate; the chef even cooks the pizza right at the bar for all to see. It was a really cool concept! The staff was super helpful in navigating you through the menu and making recommendations. We ultimately wound up building our own pizza, although the chef's choice (chef surprises you) was tempting. We sat on their back patio which was perfect for a nice fall afternoon. The pizza was INCREDIBLE. The crust was perfectly thin, the red sauce was sweet and tangy, and the toppings were all fresh. I'm already excited to go back! read more

GoreMade Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

My first time here. Ordered a small chef's choice and it was basically 3 slices with barely any toppings. The person that took my order was very nice. read more

Food was perfect, the dough cooked wth the perfect char rustic basic tomato sauce and fresh local ingredients. Will definitely be back and went to my top 5 list of cbus pizzas read more

An order at the bar kind of place that has both a small indoor seating area and a rather charming backyard. They pride themselves on local ingredients, and yet I didn't see as many local vegetables as I wanted, given how much farmland I drove through to get here. Nonetheless, the mushrooms were, and I got them on my pizza, along with some carmelized onions that didn't add much. The crust here is very thin; it does have a bit of spring to it and a hint of char, but clearly the star of the show is the sauce, which is a pretty pure tomato flavor without a lot of spices. Toppings were generous. I'm skeptical that it's the best pizza in town, but it was good. A tulsi cardamom soda delivered an intriguing flavor hit, and I liked the salad options enough to order one with fixins. read more

See all

Food gets a 4 read on for the 3.5 First thought...be prepared to find parking and you'll pay for parking. It's on a fairly busy street so be patient and park as you find a spot, even if you have to walk a bit. We came on a Friday afternoon and found parking fast but then had to figure out the parking app. No wings here but salad or cheesey bread for appetizers. The only dressing they have is balsamic and housemade ranch. We opted out of either simply because of the lack of choices on dressing, no biggie for us but remember that coming in. They also only have locally brewed and canned beers but a pretty big variety. Unfortunately no frosted glasses and sitting on the patio the beer got to room temperature pretty quickly. We ordered the 12" pork...something or other pizza and added roasted mushrooms. Delicious!! And enough for us to share. The wood fired pizza is great and the crust is especially thin... yummy! Pizza and two beers was $30 but we left the tab open for more beers Then seen to be short staffed so we had to go get our own beers, not an issue but would have been nice to be told that instead of having our beer sit on the counter. Great little place for delicious pizza and if you can, sit out on the patio. read more

GoreMade Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Snuggle up to the bar and watch the pizza professionals work their magic on your wood fired pies. Such a warm and inviting atmosphere in this little "Gormade" pizza shop with super friendly staff. My Old Fashioned was yummy & the (three!) pizzas we tried were divine. Before you leave stop and enjoy the fungi themed bathroom! read more

See all

Great wood fired pizza. Took it to go and they got cold fast. Next time will eat there to get them piping hot out of the oven. Tried the mushroom white pizza and the pepperoni, sausage and bacon, really good flavors on both with just the right amount of char on the crust. read more

I hate giving out my haunts though I will make an exception this time...Nicholas G and Goremade one of the best Neo Italian style pizzas I have had in Columbus outside of Rome, Italy! The $19 Clintonvillan is packed with shrooms, garlic, and white sauce/cheese to temper a hungry vegetarian! There are options galore to choose from under $20 and I suggest you get good service and watch you pizza being made- that is the true charm of the place. The interaction with the pizza oven and the chefs! Don't be lame and ask for a different size- they are all 12" or half as a boat...or ask for a different type of pizza...like the guy after us trying to impress his date!?!! Square all around when the pizza is round. Check out the menu before coming to get your barrings and grab a brew or glass of wine while you are at it. One of the only places where $55 dollars can get you a nice date dinner! read more

The Good: Good crust, slightly reminiscent of the flavor of Dominos. Pizza oven gives it a distinct texture. Fresh tasting cheese, sauce, and a unique flavored pepperoni that's definitely not Hormel Pepperoni from Krogers. The Bad: Crappy Parking, the pizza is real dainty and pricey for what they give you. If you want to use this pizza for a Super Bowl party then I suggest you buy 50 of em because this pie will leave you hungry and your guests will fly through them because there's no girth and they're not substantial at all. I doubt you'll have leftovers. They're RAZOR thin crusts. Think even thinner than Donatos thin crust. The cheese and toppings don't fully cover the pizza and are sparse so you'll definitely see like areas of just crust with a little bit of sauce and no cheese or toppings. It's an artisan pizza I guess and they're catering to that whole Italian village area with the $4,000 a month apartments and the feel that your eating "fresh," "clean," "exclusive" with "premium" ingredients but it's not satiating or satisfying at all leaving you with a feeling you didn't get your money or time worth. read more

GoreMade Pizza - Porkistopheles - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

OMG!!!!!!!!!! Excellent pizza & awesome service!!! Excellent pizza & awesome service!!! Excellent pizza & awesome service!!! Excellent pizza & awesome service!!! read more

Dave Portnoy gives this place a rating of 7.4. Yelp only has a maximum of 5, so I'm going to go with 3-4 stars. Don't get me wrong, the pizza itself is pretty good, especially if you're a fan of thin crust. The wood fired oven does a great job of toasting the bottom yet keeping the toppings nice and crispy. However, they have limited pre-made pizza choices on the menu -- only offering 4 specialty pizzas, in addition to one appetizer. There is an extra 'chef's choice' where, according to the menu, whoever's making the pizza pretty much decides whatever toppings they want to add. I went with the 'porkistopheles,' the quintessential meat lovers pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon. Like I mentioned, the pizza had great flavor and the wood fired crust gave it a good crunch. However, the largest size is only 12" (8 slices), which is equivalent to a medium at most pizza joints. In addition, the $16.50 price tag for all but a generic cheese pizza had me gritting my teeth a bit. Overall, the pizza is tasty but limited menu and higher than average prices have me rating this place around 3.5 stars, and for the sake of Yelp, I tend to round up. read more

GoreMade Pizza - 12" Porkistopheles - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I had passed by this please many times seeing its sign on the side of the building. I don't know what to say except you need to eat it to believe it. I don't know how to do this pizza justice, you need to ask for the staff pick/ chef special, whatever it is. They will blow your taste buds' mind like you wouldn't believe. Sorry no pic of my food, it went down to quick. read more

GoreMade Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This was our first time here. Cute enough. We sat on the patio and it was nice. I had a Cardomon soda and hubby had house red wine. Also fine. We each had the fixings side salad with balsamic vinegrette. It was a very good salad and the salad dressing was delicious. Pizza- my husband ordered a pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms and two kinds of olives. It was gorgeous and covered with toppings. He said it was very good. I ordered a gluten-free clintonvillain. It was awful . I posted a picture of it. It is advertised as having roasted mushrooms, smoked salt, truffle oil, and a delicious grated cheese with an olive oil base. The problem was that the toppings were lacking and there were giant patches where there were no topping at all. Perhaps, if they had spread the olive oil base across the whole pizza, it would have been better. But the didn't. So the pizza was super dry. I went into ask if they had any dipping sauce or something that I could use. The guy at the cash register (he was very nice) asked ,"olive oil"? And I said okay. Then as he was getting it, I saw a squeeze bottle of the pesto and I asked about that. He got a soufflé cup and put about a tablespoon of pesto in it. Then, he said he had to charge me for it. I was a bit taken aback because we just spent 60 bucks plus tip and now you want me to pay extra for a tablespoon of sauce? So I said, never mind, I'd just take the olive oil. A person I perceived as possibly the manager (big guy with a beard) said something along the lines about a "lot of work going into it" and thanked me for my "opinion". Then he just tossed the pesto into the trash. So...I definitely won't be going back. Honestly, we love little places like this. It would have taken very little to have turned this around and had a repeat customer. read more

GoreMade Pizza - Gluten-free Clintonvillain - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio