Believe it or not, tonight was our first time eating pizza from here. I've got to say, it was outstanding!!! We had the everything pizza, w/1 side having black olives on it. Everything about it was super. The crust, sauce, amount of toppings, EVERYTHING! The service behind the counter was excellent, too. Friendly, professional w/out being too much or too fakey. They DO take debit & credit FYI, as there was some question about that. Previously, they must not have. It's a little hidden gem on E.Broad st. at the end of the strip mall area. ABSOLUTELY WORTH CHECKING OUT! I'm sure you'll love it too. read more

I ordered from Joe's, 2 double meat subs, small pizza with pep, sausage and extra cheese. 40.00. I asked for my subs to be well done not burnt. I live about 8 miles from the location. Arrived home and my subs were so burnt, we could not eat them. You saw that the food was not edible and you still sold it. My family had patronized this establishment over 20 years. You lost a customer today. read more

Joe's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Excellent cracker crust, plenty of toppings and quality ingredients. Large size was enough to feed 5 adults!!! read more

Joe's Pizza - Sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

On their game tonight. We called in, they quoted 30 min. We showed up in 25 and they were pulling the pie out of the oven. Large, double cheese, half pep, half veg. $20. It was a top-notch pizza. Joe's heritage is Tommy's Pizza...from the old days. Well done repping your history. read more

Joe's Pizza - Sorry. We ate it. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This place is mediocre at best. The Italian Sub has always been good the times I ordered it. I thought at least Italian Dressing was on it. I found out tonight that is not the case. I've ordered a veggie pizza and a meatball pizza at different times. Both very Bland and No Flavor. I had to add garlic, salt, and pepper when I got home. There are too many other options. Last thought: YUCK read more

Wanted to try what was suppose to be the best pizza in Bexley (as I've been told) but was disappointed when I found them closed at 9pm on a Friday night. So I searched and found Joe's Pizza. Ordered a large pepperoni and sausage with an Italian sub. Pizza was delicious and the amount of cheese, sauce, and toppings were plentiful. Crust was a little different for me but good. My kids described it like tasting pretzel dough. The sun was delicious. Plenty of meat. I probably should has asked for more banana peppers. Nice people here. Loved seeing all the meat and toppings you get for the money. read more

Joe's Pizza - Pepperoni and sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Note: This review is strictly about the service. On 8/1/24 at around 11:19a I submitted an order via the Joe's Pizza ordering system. Their site notes they open at 10:30am on Thursdays which was the day of the week I was ordering. I received a confirmation email at 11:21a noting that my order would be ready within 24-34 minutes and that I could track my order. I went to the store to pick up and found that there was a handwritten sign on the door that said 'closed for repairs' and all the lights were off and no one was on site. I called the number to the store and got a voicemail but was unable to leave a message. Later that day I reached out to Joe's Pizza to try to get a refund via their help link. So I emailed them the details of what happened and waited for their response. On Friday 8/2/24 at 9:04p I received a response noting that 'unfortunately, we are not currently able to provide a refund for this order. We understand your frustration and will work to improve so we can provide a better experience for you next time.' And that was as much response as I got. Luckily I as able to reach out to my bank and dispute the transaction but what kind of customer service is this?! Stuff happens and that's fine but why not shut off the o line ordering system and why not make it easy for any orders that were charged for a product that was not received to be cancelled or refunded once the business found this had happened. This is shady. I won't be recommending this business. I hope they do better. read more

Joe's Pizza - Copy of email response from Joe's Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Amazing pizza!! This place is definitely worth trying. Located on the East side of Columbus, right on Broad St. They also have a great chef's salad. read more

I had a carry out experience here and yum yum yum. I ordered two pizzas a sausage and pepperoni and a plain cheese. I judge a pizza place by its cheese pizza and this place passed the test. I enjoyed this local pizza place and I will def be back soon read more

Pizza was absolutely delicious! We live in Pickerington and tried it for the first time based on reviews that it was Tommy's Pizza nephew that has continued the legacy of taste.....and he did!!!! We are hooked! Joe's Pizza is our pizza of choice from now on. So happy I stumbled across the reviews. You can believe I will pass this gem on to my family and friends. We also ordered a sub and it was equally delicious!!!!!! Try it for yourself! You will not be disappointed!!!!!! read more

Pizza was amazing, I love a locally owned pizza shop. Customer service was great, everyone was friendly and didn't mind me asking a thousand questions. Definitely will back!! read more

Covid protocols were only partly followed. There is signage posted in door and hand sanitizer immediately inside. However there were 5 working: one had mask under nose, one had mask under nose and only partly covering mouth, and one wore a very thin (and virtually useless) knit covering. The pizza was okay. Columbus style. I would give it a 3.5 star. read more

Joe's Pizza - Large - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Great pizza!! Toppings a plenty! Very fresh and delicious. I highly recommend! read more

Joe's Pizza - Large pep, half with mushrooms and onion. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Pizza was good. Tasty. A bit spicy! But was also a bit greasy. I am sure the pizza is better if it was hot (temperature)! My main issue is the delivery. DoorDash provided horrible service. I specified the order should be 'handed to me". I received a text the driver would be arriving shortly. After ten minutes, I wondered why I had not received the pizza. I went outside to look around and there was my pizza on the porch, out in the cold. read more

We newly found Joe's and are now completely hooked! They make sure to load you up with toppings and the crust is nice and crackery. We've ordered from there twice in the last month and been very happy both times! read more

Great crust and pizza sauce was delicious. Staff knowledgeable and very enjoyed the pepperoni sausage and pepper pizza we took back to our home read more

Let me start by saying that this pizza is pretty good. I liked it a lot. I'm sure you are asking yourself why not a five-star review, Mikey? Well, the reason is that I base my reviews, as do most of you, off of my overall experience. I did not have a good experience when I got there. I will give them another try in hopes of changing my review but until then, here goes. So I decided to check this place out because I love pizza, and I am trying to go to all the right spots here in central Ohio; this is on my list of places I've never been so this was a perfect opportunity for me to try it out for family pizza night. I arrived at the establishment an hour and fifteen minutes before closing; this is outside the window of time where the employees get upset with you for making them work close to closing time. Inside there are only two people, both of which had already placed their orders. Great, this meant that I shouldn't have to wait a long time to get my pizza; boy, was I ever wrong. I waited for 25 minutes before the lady who was taking orders got to me. She asked how she could help me. I told her I wanted to place an order to go. This woman threw her head back, rolled her eyes, and the lady making the pizzas to take my order. The pizza making lady tilts her head to the side and asks real low in volume for my order. After completing my request known, she mosied along to the back to make it. I return to my car for the promised 15-minute wait. While sitting in my vehicle, I observed them flipping the sign to closed, but it was 35 minutes before closing; these people wanted to go home early and seemed disgruntled about getting business during a pandemic. Time passed, and I ascended from my vehicle to acquire my pizza. There's a guy in there waiting to pick his order up; the order lady informed him their credit card machine broke and that he was to pay in cash. They were not going to give him his pizza until he settled in money! The man dug around in his pockets and finally came up with the cash to get the pizza. I was going to pay with a card and went back to the car to find some money because most places close around this time. After getting my pizza, I checked it out, and it looked good. I got it home, and before the family came downstairs, I had taken the first bite of that wonderful Ohio cut corner piece. It was delicious. The sausage had the right spice and seasoning levels. The cheese and sauce were savory the way I like it, and the crust was crispy the way it should be. I was mad because the pizza was so good, but the service was horrible. read more

Joe's Pizza - Sausage and pepperoni was pretty good. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great pies and sandwiches. Sink your teeth in and take a bite. Delish. Is this enough characters yet? Good pizza

owner Joe and his managers are rude and have no customer service skills. I have been a customer since it was Tommy's. Every Friday my coworkers and I order from Joes. several times the order was incorrect. I complained to Joe (the owner) once. the third time that there was error on our order I called and spoke to a girl who said she was the mgr. she was rude and stated we don't or need your business and hung up. I called and spoke to the owner Joe. He asked what happened. Before I could get to my complaint he yelled "I DONT HAVE TIME FOR THIS. WE DONT WANT OR NEED YOUR BUSINESS!!!! Needless to say I won't be going back. read more

OmG this place will not disappoint. The crust stays crisp with all the cheese. There's something about a little sizzle taste that keeps me coming back for more. Bad day, order Joe's, celebrating, order Joe's. So good and so fast! The only thing is that they're closed on Sunday but they deserve it! If you don't say, Dude on your 1st bite then you don't know what's good. Enjoy! read more

Joe's Pizza - OmG this place nails it every single time. The crust stays crispy even with all the cheese Large 15" - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

College Football Championship game night. For a Monday you can't too much better than Buckeye Football and a hometown favorite of ours Joe's read more

See all

Great go-to pizza place on near east side. Great thin crust Columbus style pizza. Mushroom and sausage is a must.

Outstanding. If there is such thing as a perfect pizza, this was close. Best sausage, pepperoni delicious, flavorful sauce, crispy crust. Wish they had a Joe's in Northend Columbus read more

make your tongue slap your brains out delicious!!! the italian sub tasted like it had been cooked over a campfire and i loved it. read more

Joe's Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I was raised on Joe's. My son was raised on Joe's. They aren't just a pizza place to us, they are adopted family. Phenomenal food. Thank you

Takeout that tastes great. Had a steak sub and a small pizza. Was full before it was all gone! It is a little shop in a shopping strip. read more

Taste is subjective, I realize. Honestly, no pizza is "bad"...heck, even grade school cafeteria pizza was the best-thing-ever on a Friday. My 3 star review for Joe's is based solely on the pie itself & NOT the customer service, which was FIVE STAR!! To be fair, my husband & I are from MA & NY. We, recently, moved to the Springfield, OH area, from MA, for a 5-7yr stint. You can say, we are food snobs. This is an accurate assumption. We have been spoiled for sure! I was disappointed with all the sub par chain pizza restaurants in Springfield & decided to make the trek into Columbus after scouring the web for "the best pizza in Columbus". I decided on Joe's Pizza. It's located in a small, cute plaza (4-5 other businesses). Joe's is small with a walk-up counter, one beverage cooler, a rack of potato chips, & 2-3 small tables should you choose to eat-in. The place was nothing special to look at but I was there for pizza so who cares about aesthetics. The 1 female employee took my order for a large, extra cheese, pepperoni, sausage, mushroom & onion pizza. She was great (kind & friendly). I mentioned how odd I found it, being from the east coast, that Ohioans cut round pizza in squares & not like a pie unless you request it. I requested it. I left & came back 20 min. later. The employee apologized when I returned & said it wasn't quite ready because she forgot & cut the pizza in squares so she was baking me a new one! Lol! I told her she didn't need to do that & I would've taken the square cut. I thanked her though because she went to the trouble to make it right per my request. At checkout, I noticed the "large" was smaller than what I'm used to in MA & NY. Having driven almost an hour, I decided to purchase the "accidental" square cut pie too because we like leftovers & 1 pie wouldn't have afforded us that luxury. Visually, the pizzas looked great. My toppings were very similar to what we are used to. The taste of the cheese & toppings were decent. Unfortunately, the dough & crust left little too be desired. It reminded me of Ellios frozen pizza you buy in the grocery store. Not fresh, just flat & flavorless with (almost) non-existent crust. Thin crust doesn't mean it's NY style pizza. For us, it's average. Definitely NOT the worst we've had but I pray it's not "the best pizza in Columbus". We will continue our hunt, in Ohio, for a NY style pizza that will satisfy our spoiled pallets. read more

Door dash got lost and delivered to wrong hotel room... I called restaurant to let them know. Their response is we're not responsible for door dash & we get complaints about door dash all of the time. I said , well maybe u should hire ur own drivers or find another option... they r representing ur product. He said not my problem- I said well, I'll have to give u a bad review. He said, that's fine, I'll give u a bad review. Love getting hung up on.... Where did the ability to problem solve and customer service go?!?! read more

I order this pizza almost once a week. Elizabeth is always very nice on the phones. I ordered a large pepperoni, mushroom, banana peppers, and sausage. I asked if I could get the pizza well done. This is my favorite pizza in Columbus. read more

It's not the same quality the toppings are trash now! Not worth the $17.00 for a small or large. They use little pieces of veggies now and slim pickings on the sausage. Going back to Tommy's pizza. And then I talked to Joe the owner and he was like oh well have a nice day. Joe I thought you was better than that man you'll never see me again bro. read more

I pick up a pizza from Joe's a couple times a month on average. The spot itself is no frills, but the pizza is consistently great. The sausage here is really good too, though I usually get mushroom and pepperoni here since the crust in the middle can get a lil messy when you add sausage to that combo. Highly recommended! read more

Joe's Pizza - Pepperoni & mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Just moved to the Bexley area from Florida. Have ate at rubinos, hound dogs, harvest and Donato's. By far this has been the best pizza yet and that's not a knock on rubinos (Joe's just has more cheese). The older gentleman working the oven was busting his ass, slinging the dough. We ordered the pepperoni pizza well done and crispy and it came out perfect. The pepperonis were curling up, to pool a little grease. Generous on the cheese, with a good flavor. Crust was thin and crisp. To the people saying poor customer service, the girl working the counter tonight seemed to be really trying. But the old man making the pizza is a Artist! read more

Joe's Pizza - Well done Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Well we ordered and they delivered good fresh hot pizza and it was delicious . And we had to order a Italian sub also it was yummy juicy and plenty of meat and fresh bread . We will be ordering again! read more

Joe's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Joe's Pizza is always a treat. Its thin, crispy, and loaded everytime

This was the most delicious pizza I've had in over 10 years. It had the right amount of sauce, toppings, and the cheese was the Bomb! This was a small pepperoni musheroom onion XTRA cheese, OMG! it was really good! read more

Fantastic thin crust pizza with plenty of toppings. The sausage sub and the Italian subs are amazing Reasonable prices!

I plan on giving this place another chance, but for now, it's just sort of okay for me. There's a ton of mom and pop pizza joints surrounding my work, so that means there's plenty of places to grab an Italian sub. My search for the best sandwiches around here brought me to Joe's Pizza, which I hadn't even noticed was there even though I've passed it several times. It's in a small strip mall on Broad that's really hard to see from the street. I called ahead to place a take out order, since it didn't look like there's anywhere to sit in the place (there's two small tables but not really for eating), and it was only going to take about 10 minutes. I had ordered extra meat and cheese, and it was only going to cost me about $7.25. First issue when I get there is the girl at the front forgot she was baking my sub. Whoops, does it smell like burning in here? Oh well, they threw together another one for me that only took about 5 minutes to make and didn't charge me for the extra meat and cheese. I appreciate that. I think my biggest mistake was getting extra meat, because it was almost too much. I wasn't sure how big the sandwich would be, but I should have known, since they use Auddino's bread. Points for quality bread. Unfortunately, there wasn't much flavor in the dressing to break up the massive amount of meat I had on there. Also, in the 5 minutes it took me to get back to work, the dressing had managed to cut through the bread, making it super soggy. As I said, I'm going to give them another chance, since maybe I just put too much meat on the thing. In a pinch, this is a quick place to get a sandwich that's better than your chain joints, but it's not my first pick. I hear the pizza's pretty good too, so I'll have to give that a shot some time. read more

See all

So I got to try Joe's Pizza last weekend because I was in an 8 hour class so one of the instructor's got us this for lunch. For pizza it was alright. Although I do have to admit I felt so bad for the other instructor who was a gluten-free/dairy free person. She was so hungry and this is all they had so she had to take off all the cheese and just eat the toppings. I do feel her pain though because I once was a gluten free person and it was very hard to find food like this before it became so popular. I do wish the crust was not thin crust because I grew up loving thick crust pizza. I just feel the thin crust makes it more messy. Although if this is all you have an option of eating when you are in an 8 hour class you can't complain. I've never had an instructor in my entire college career buy me food because they felt bad for us. So kuddos to him and thanks for letting me try it. read more

rude customer service on the phone 10/01/21. She hung up on us while we were trying to complete the order. Then when we called back and informed her we were not done, she replies "WHAT DO YOU WANT!" I suggest putting her out there spinning a sign outside so she doesnt have to talk to your customers. Then again if she lacks the enthusiasm she did on the phone , maybe not read more

I think this was a pretty darn good pizza, but it's just not up there with Bexley Pizza Plus. It's hard to grade, because the pizzas are very different. I'd eat here again if the hubby wanted to have it, but I prefer BPP. We got a sausage mushroom and pepperoni pizza. Good amounts of all meats (Really??? How can you have TOO MUCH pepperoni? I couldn't believe it when I read that review.) as well as mushrooms. The crust is a thin crust, not quite cracker thin, but thin. Almost cracker thin. Sauce was tasty and not too sweet. Service was quick and efficient, if not exactly cordial. read more

Joe's Pizza - Hehe. I had to giggle a little at the box. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio