Used to eat at Cristy's 30 years ago growing up and our family always loved them. Moved away and no longer had a location near us. Well, last month my husband, kids, and I went to Hocking Hills. We saw there was a location in Logan and I told everyone we had to try it. When I say this pizza did not disappoint even my East Coast husband. He told me yesterday he keeps thinking about it and wants to go back. Seriously amazing. We got three pizzas; a double pepperoni, a cauliflower crust cheese, pizza, and a salami, green pepper. All three were phenomenal. read more

We ordered a few pizzas, two Italian sandwiches, wings, and cheesy bread - and the consensus was everything was delicious!

Excellent pizza. It has been a few years since I have been out here but I really love the taste of this pizza. Really friendly service and the pizza was ready within 10-15 min. The restaurant was clean and it is great to be able to stop into Cristy's again on my trip through Ohio. read more

After a whole day of hiking, we were ready to eat something carb-y and pizza sounded perfect. The person manning the counter was very nice and patient with our indecisiveness and told us it could take 30 mins. Since we didnt want to drive back and forth, we decided to wait there. We ordered a small custom toppings pizza, a small cheese pizza and a medium "The italian" pizza. We also ordered the garlic 4 cheese bread. Well our order was ready in less than 20 mins! The guy said he would rather overestimate time than make people wait longer, nicely done! Back at our rental, we dove into the pizza and cheese bread. Unfortunately the cheese bread was too hard and dry. The pizza however was SO good - perfectly crispy crust but hardy enough to hold heavy toppings. We enjoyed each of those pizzas so much and yet had leftovers for another dinner. read more

Quick pickup in their drive through. What an incredible pizza. Every aspect was perfect: Sauce, crust, cheese, topping. I want one in Canton. read more

The family and I stopped in for a pizza and garlic bread after a long day hiking. Before we could get the food back to the hotel the kids attacked the garlic bread and almost finished it! My kids were begging for the cheap pizza place across the street but we were glad we stopped in at Cristy's instead. read more

Cristy's Pizza - Medium pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

Not a fan of the square cut pizza (the toppings kept falling off when we bit in) but otherwise very tasty and VERY fast!

Don't waste your money on a salad. Just a small box of lettuce and very little else. A complete waste of money. The gluten free pizza was good which is the only reason I gave it 3 stars read more

We decided on Cristy's pizza after stopping by the "#1 pizza in Hocking Hills" place and they didn't have a counter to order at, so my husband and I decided to try Cristy's to take back to our Airbnb. It was delicious! We split the pepperoni snackers and a medium 4 cheese pizza with salami. The crust was crispy, but pillowy. An abundance of cheese and flavor and salami! We were impressed. And every time we opened the fridge, we could smell our leftovers and it made our mouth water. We also ordered two brownies that they make in house and they were slightly fudgey with chocolate pieces scattered throughout. We will definitely be returning. read more

We went to Cristy's pizza. Crust was thin, crispy, and well done. The sauce was flavorful . We had an 18" pizza and had plenty of leftovers for the two of us. It took about 25 minutes for the pizza to come out. Service was friendly. read more

I love live live Cristy's pizza. Their sauce is just the right amount of sweet. I grew up on Cristy's and when I moved away my mom would pick up a pizza and bring it to me when she was coming. Now anytime I'm back in Ohio my fam will usually order some pizzas. It's become a Christmas tradition to have Cristy's while opening gifts (no we aren't weirdos that have pizza for breakfast, our fam meets couple days before 25th after work to exchange gifts lol) read more

We were visiting Brewery 33 and had Cristy's delivered. We ordered a salad and a pizza. The salad wasn't anything special, but the pizza was very good. We liked the sauce, the delivery was fast and the pizza arrived hot and fresh. Would order again. read more

We got a large cheese pizza after a long day of touring Hocking Hills. Our pizza was very very good. On the Dave Portnoy scale I give it a 7.4/10. "One bite everyone knows the rules". read more

My boy toy and I came to Hocking for a quick get away. Hiking and such, you will work up an appetite! This pizza will blow your socks off! They didn't deliver to where we were staying, but it is certainly worth the drive!! Spicy sauce, quality toppings! read more

We were in town for the weekend and ordered Cristy's to take back to our cabin after visiting the local brewery. Absolutely, hands down, the BEST pizza we've had in the area. We ordered the large Italian. The crust was perfect and the sauce was sweet with a hint of spice, toppings were abundant. We are adding this to our must haves visits when visiting Hocking Hills. Service was fast and friendly too. read more

Cristys is the best pizza in town. They never get my order wrong. The sauce and cheese combination is delicious!

Great pizza! Tastes like good old fashioned East coast pizza. Well seasoned and tasty. App was easy to use and follow.

The best Hawaiian pizza I've ever had. Nice crust topped with all the toppings, plus an amazing sprinkle of cinnamon to top it off! I would highly recommend it, the bread sticks were also delicious! read more

Surprisingly there's some great pizza places in Southeastern Ohio. I suspect if your making only average pizza these "great" places will put you out of business in short order. Christy's pizza is one of those great places. Their "Classic" is a loaded supreme and is wonderful. The crust is crispy and not too thick or thin and it's loaded with toppings. Their pizza is not cheap, but our family of 4 can't quite finish an Xtra large so I think it's still a great value. read more

Best pizza I've ever had, hands down ! The cheese nibblers were amazing!!! The Christy's signature pizza was absolutely delicious. We ordered delivery. They were 20 minutes earlier than promised. That never happens. The delivery guy was very nice and made a point to to thank me for the tip. We'll be ordering again next time we vacation here, for sure! read more

Not very good. I was staying in a cabin in Hocking Hills and came across a Christy's Pizza brochure--it looked really good. My boyfriend and I were sure to try there mega cheese pizza and cluckers (basically popcorn chicken). The pizza reminded us of something you would get at a bowling alley or arcade. The cluckers did not look like the crispy chicken bites displayed on the brochure. They sure did not taste very good either. They were almost all breading and the very little chicken in them was very chewy and had a weird texture. We were disappointed but did not have much of an option for anything else to eat. We threw away the leftovers and were saying that we wished we would had just ordered from Pizza Hut. read more

Great pizza! We are from out of town and we were starving. Stopped in to order and came back a little later to pick up our food. They are heavy on the toppings and the large was sliced in squares which I prefer. We had bacon, pepperoni, & sausage pizza and it was delicious! The garlic cheesy bread was a let down because it was super dry. We totally should have opted for one of their fun breadstick options. Staff was friendly and seemed shocked that we left a tip so give those friendly guys some love if you stop in! read more

We were staying in the Logan area for a weekend getaway and got in the mood for pizza on a Saturday night. Cristy's was conveniently close and sounded as good as anything. We ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza with extra onion at the counter. The place was really clean and the lady who rang us up was friendly. We drove around the town while the pizza was being made but when we showed up at the pick-up window, our order wasn't quite ready. We chose to park to wait, and as soon as our order was up, somebody ran it to our car. The pizza was delicious, I really liked the crispy crust, and it was also possibly the best pizza ever for eating the cold leftovers the next morning. read more

Best pizza I've had here so far. The sauce has a unique taste that I can't place but I love it. The texture of the dough was perfect providing just the right amount of soft, chewy and crunch. read more

After hiking all day we were craving Mexican, decided to give this place a try based on the mostly positive reviews. I was really surprised how long it took to get our drinks, chips and salsa, and orders taken but overlooked it. After ordering our food we had to wait 43 minutes. There were only two other tables occupied in the restaurant and it wasn't busy. The food was okay, not the best but certainly not the worst. read more

Good pizza, fresh ingredients (except for the mushrooms), plenty of sauce, nice crust. our order was carryout so i have no idea about the inside of restaurant. My only complaint would be the use of can mushrooms on the salad. Epic FAIL, nasty & yuck! Gordan Ramsey would loose his mind. read more