Cristy&#x27;s Pizza

Treehouse Treats and Treasures is a quaint little shop that we stopped into after spending some…read moretime browsing the antique and consignment shops nearby. We originally went in for ice cream, but discovered they also had books and souvenirs. My wife found a book she wanted, and I picked up a few souvenirs for my children. We actually made three separate purchases at the same counter -- first the souvenirs, then my wife's book, and finally two ice cream cones. I took receipts for the first two purchases, but unfortunately declined one for the ice cream. I really wish I hadn't. After we left, I realized we had been charged $23 for two double-scoop ice cream cones. The ice cream itself was very good, but the amount we were charged simply did not seem to match the prices posted where the ice cream was being served. Based on what I remember seeing on the menu, it appeared we were significantly overcharged. Without the receipt, I can't say exactly what happened or whether it was simply an innocent mistake, and I wish I had noticed the amount while we were still there so I could have asked about it. But it bothered me enough that I was still thinking about it several hours later. It's unfortunate because otherwise this was a charming little shop with some fun things to browse, and we enjoyed the ice cream. But paying $23 for two relatively ordinary double-scoop cones left a disappointing impression and took away from what otherwise would have been a very pleasant stop.

Who doesn't like a treat. I know I do. The location of this place is easy to find. The staff…read morewere very friendly. The selection was decent. I will be back. And I will enjoy it some more.

See all

Mini library with a few tables

Oasis 2.0

4.2(23 reviews)

1.1 mi

Came across this place going to Lake Logan. Hidden gem. Large selection of drinks and coffees. I'm…read moreglad I tried their chocolate chip cookies. Best I have ever had in my life. Great outdoor seating area with a well thought out balcony on top of seating area. Great Pick

Great spot if you have time to sit and hangout! We grabbed drinks this morning and my friend got a…read morecinnamon roll. I enjoyed the iced vanilla latte I ordered. I tried a bit of the cinnamon roll and it was delicious - it has maple icing on it. They definitely forgot she ordered the cinnamon roll, but they were on it when she reminded them we were waiting on it. Great space and atmosphere, all outdoor seating, with some covered areas.

See all

Outside

Hocking Hills Frozen Yogurt

4.1(19 reviews)

1.1 mi

Nice variety of froyo flavors, toppings, and sauces. Boba was good. Kind staff. Plenty of space to…read moresit inside. Nice patio out front to also sit. No bathrooms.

Great stop if you are vacationing in Hocking Hills. Lots of options. The yogurt was great. It's…read moreself-serve so you can make your own mix and add toppings. They also have hand-dipped ice cream, açaí bowls, boba tea and more. Cute little shop with friendly staff and plenty of outdoor seating.

Sign

See all

Shorty's Ice Cream Parlor

4.0(10 reviews)

1.0 mi

Delicious ice cream! The girl who greeted us was very friendly, energetic, and helpful. We sampled…read morea few flavors. In my group of 4 we had the Biscoff Cookie, Buckey Blitz, and Chocolate Black Out. All were really really good! Also appreciated that they have junior size scoops. The price was just right and the tables by the window were great.

Ice cream was delicious. And the washboard display was such fun to look at! The young ladies…read moreserving ice cream and were eager to help us choose our flavors.

If we'd had a bit more time we would have loved to explore the washboards in the store.

All good choices!

See all

Hocking Hills Inn and Coffee Emporium

4.4(115 reviews)

2.2 mi

Fantastic place to stay and enjoy the beauty of Hocking Hills. Centrally located to Old Man's…read moreCave, Cedar Falls and numerous other scenic sites, the accommodations are very comfortable and private. The coffee is excellent and the staff charming.

Cute and cozy with small B&B. Great photo spots, ground, lower& second floor outdoor seating as…read morewell as indoor seating. Coffee Emporium souvenirs as well as Hocking Hills souvenirs. Ordered carrot cake, strawberry cake and nitro cold brew. Cakes are tasty, light and perfectly sweet. Nitro cold brew was crisp, bitter and perfectly caffeinated. Service was impeccable and very sweet. Must try.

Exterior

See all

Olde Dutch Ice Cream & Candy

2.0(2 reviews)

0.5 mi

Very stingy scoops for price! 1 scoop they didn't even fill the scoop bowl! Lavender dream ice…read morecream had a good flavor but definitely serving up a good serving size for the money.

Don't come here just for ice cream. Ordered and took 10 minutes for them to bring it to us. They…read moreweren't busy at all either.

One scoop serving very stingy for $4.99 for 1 scoop lavender dream was good but disappointed value for the money!

Chocolate pie and mint chocolate chip ice cream

See all

Goats ...you can feed

58 West

4.1(161 reviews)

1.0 mi

•$$$

In for the weekend and definitely coming back before we head back! Live music, Food and service was…read moregreat!

Amazing food Good…read moreservice Lots of drink options We will go there again for sure if we can

See all

Berry Cobbler ala mode

Oasis Coffee Shop Hocking Hills

4.2(64 reviews)

5.4 mi

Popped in here to grab an iced matcha this afternoon while out shopping. Service was friendly and…read morequick. Grabbed a back of coffee while I was waiting to order, looking forward to trying that soon!

Roger welcomed me with a great smile. I drove three hours to find this place. The only thing I…read moreregret was not finding this place years earlier. We ordered a flight and enjoyed every one of the flavors. The staff and owner were very welcoming. And very quick at their job. I took my drink upstairs to enjoy. The building is really well laid out. And comfortable as well. I will make the three hour trip again. Soon.

Iced coffee and cheesecake flights

See all

Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

2.5(24 reviews)

0.3 mi

Maddy at the register was very helpful and had amazing recommendations. She made my experience…read moreworth the overpriced menu. Food was okay, but expensive. Maddy made the atmosphere all better though.

Very poorly run Dairy Queen. We waited in the drive though for a half hour. Very slow and very…read moreinefficient.

See all

Hocking Hills Winery

4.0(193 reviews)

1.4 mi

•$$$

We didn't eat food…read more We went for wine tasting. I walked up to the hostess and said "HI, we've not be here before. Is there a certain area for just drinking wine?" Hostess, mind you, no hi, "Do you know if you're buying bottles?" Me: "No, we've not tried it. I guess probably not at this point." Hostess: "Everything is table service." I said okay and went and told my family in the car. She walked us back to a table. No conversation was had. It is a very pretty area, BTW. It was pretty quiet. It was Friday at 4 so not dinner time yet. We sat for 15 minutes, watching waitress socialize, play with dogs, etc. My husband stood up to find out about a server, and our waitress came. I dont know what her name was, but she said "Sorry no one told me you were here, hope you haven't been waiting long." She served us our flight very quickly. She came to check on us once and then disappeared. After waiting longer to try to pay, we went inside to pay. We were going to buy a bottle of the Chardonnay, but everything took forever, we gave up.

We stopped here on a rainy Monday to try their wine slushes. Even though the place wasn't packed,…read morewe had to wait 20 minutes to get a table. We sat outside on their covered patio. The slushes were great- I had peach and my boyfriend had the sangria. We also each tried a glass of wine. The service was great and the ambiance was very nice. This is a cute little winery tucked away in Hocking Hills!

Inside

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Cheyenne C.

7 years ago

I've tried a couple other pizza places around town, but I think Cristy's Pizza is truly the best. The service is great, the employees are polite, and the food is INCREDIBLE!! The waiting time for delivery is very reasonable and the food is always delivered hot. I ordered the "New York Pepperoni Pizza" and the "Grilled Chicken Salad." The pizza was cut into traditional triangles, the crust was thin, the sauce tasted amazing, and the cheese was gooey and absolutely delicious! The salad tasted very fresh and light. I absolutely love this place! read more

Lynette L.

3 years ago

My husband and I were visiting Hocking Hills for a mini weekend getaway. He got hurt while hiking so we decided to "order in" instead of attempting to go out to eat for dinner. Our pizzas were prepared quickly and tasted amazing! Also, when I picked up our dinner, I was greeted by the kindest worker. Highly recommend! read more

Jess P.

1 year ago

I love Christy's Logan oh there calzones there really good always have hot food when deli it to us the works are so kind make sure everybodys food is great and hit Im ready read more

Trinity S.

3 years ago

varyyy rude to us and all we wanted was a pizza and she was being really rude BAD COSTUMERS SERVICE!!!!!!!!

Jennifer P.

10 years ago

Great service, delicious food, and clean environment.

Cristy's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Logan, Ohio Restaurants near Cristy's Pizza

BEST of Logan, Ohio Coffee near Cristy's Pizza

BEST of Logan, Ohio Desserts near Cristy's Pizza

BEST of Logan, Ohio Things to Do near Cristy's Pizza

BEST of Logan, Ohio Breakfast near Cristy's Pizza

BEST of Logan, Ohio Dinner near Cristy's Pizza

BEST of Logan, Ohio Burgers near Cristy's Pizza

BEST of Logan, Ohio Shopping near Cristy's Pizza

BEST of Logan, Ohio Movie Theatre near Cristy's Pizza

Best of Logan

Things to do in Logan

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Cristy's Pizza also viewed

K&C Restaurants

4.2

(206 reviews)

Out of towner looking for a sit down pizza restaurant and we found good one…read more We ordered a medium pepperoni, a mini BBQ chicken, side of ranch and two drinks. Both pizza's were cooked well with some crisp on the edges which is heavenly. I was surprised on how big the restaurant was and the service was really good. Everyone had a responsibility and seemed to work flawlessly. Go Blue!

We ordered a couple of pizzas for carry out while camping nearby…read more The pizzas were hot and fresh. Just out of the oven when we came to pick them up. We ordered a veggie pizza and a supreme meat pizza. Toppings were extremely generous on both pizzas. Garlic bread with cheese was delicious. A great place for lunch or dinner when visiting Hocking Hills.

Papa Dino's Pizzeria

4.5

(36 reviews)

We got a pepperoni pizza and a side of French fries. Let me just say that the reviews about the…read morepizza being good are correct, BUT the pizza with their ranch makes it an 11/10! There is one place I rave about that has the best pizza in Arizona and I had not found the best in Ohio until I tried this place. But listen to me when I say you have to try it with the ranch because that takes it over the top. The French fries are the perfect amount of crispy and recommend them too.

Super nice patio and food. I can imagine this would be amazing on cool summer nights to hang out as…read morewe were here in November. Good drink selections as well. The margarita pizza was tasty well cooked. Will be back next time we are camping for sure!!

Avalanche Pizza

3.9

(186 reviews)

Easily the best pizza in southern Ohio. Very creative menu…read more We've had the super mushroom (my fave), the Philly, pepperoni, and the skeletonwitch (spicy). Their crust is phenomenal. Try the green chili jam!!! Service is fast. Only outdoor seating which with Ohio weather can be a pain. There's a speedway down a bit so order pizza then go grab drinks. By he time you get back - pizza done! They also have take & bake. We found it by accident first time then drive an hour back to have it again. It's that good. Full menu is not posted in the store so make sure you check the website.

As a college town, Athens has a plethora of pizza options. Avalanche stands out among this sea of…read moreslices. It leads for its creativity of combos, it leads for local sourcing of ingredients, it leads for its stall at the Saturday Farmer's Market with numerous bread options, and it leads for local ownership with deep commitment to investing in the community. The Super Mushrooms with diverse fresh mushroom types and ricotta and asiago cheese is always my go to even with lots of other tempting combos available in regular, gluten free, and cauliflower crust options in 10" and 14" size options. There is a table in the tiny parking lot for eating at the restaurant, but really this is for takeout or delivery. They do have NY Style and regular cheese and pepperoni slices available by the slice on walk in plus some to go salads and cannoli in the small pick up area.

Little Italy Pizza - New Straitsville

4.2

(5 reviews)

This pizza place is our go to choice for delicious and affordable pizza. Good Customer service and…read morehave never been disappointed with anything we have ordered- pizza, wings, subs, appetizers.

Placed my order for two subs at 4:27 pm for delivery and the order did not arrive until over two &…read morea half hours later & the subs were almost cold. I will not be giving this company any more of my business, this is extremely poor service and not how you retain your customer base.

Pink Cricket Restaurant

3.9

(50 reviews)

If you want fresh hot made to your order then this is the place along with on tap beer. Pizza and…read moreBeer what could go better together! And you don't have to clean up the kitchen. The service is friendly too. The ambiance is like a 1950's classic pizza place. Take a chance and you will love it.

First time here, I had heard many good things, so we decided to try it out. We arrived shortly…read moreafter 5, it seat yourself so we chose a booth. It's looks rather vintage inside, very much a local bar feel. We browsed the menu in addition to the specials, and decided. I had a beer which was served in a frosted mug, talk about nostalgia. Pretzel bites were good and hot when they arrived. It was served with a cheese dip. The wings were very large, crisp and had plenty of sauce. We tried the bbq and the mild both were good. I personally didn't like the bbq as it was a vinegar base. Lastly I had the "famous" pizza. I kept it simple, pep and cheese. It was a very thin crisp crust. Had a good crunch to it. Lots of cheese and plenty of pepperoni. The sauce had a bit of a sweet taste to it, very good, glad we decided to try this place!

Crosstown Creamery & Diner

4.3

(39 reviews)

Great food. Everything is made fresh and great quality! Will definitely eat here again!read more

Delicious food!!! Their sausage gravy tastes like home! Nothing pasty about this!! And Lovely…read morefluffy biscuits. The Brussel sprouts were so delicious I'd could eat them several times a week!! Great service! Give it a go sometime.

Creno's Pizza

5.0

(2 reviews)

Awesome pizza and friendly staff! Greeted at the door upon delivery with smiles. Family friendly…read morefor dine in.

Pizza and breadsticks with cheese was amazing. The staff was very friendly highly recommendread more

Giovanni's Pizza

4.1

(16 reviews)